We always come here for the Buffalo chicken rolls! This pizza place stands out from all the others in Tyler. They hand toss their pizzas fresh, right in front of you behind the counter. I love their garlic knots with the marinara sauce. They have the good soda that’s so carbonated it makes you hiccup :) (my Dr Pepper lovers know). Please take the time to bring your family to this little diner! Don’t make our mistake we made this last time and SAVE ROOM FOR DESSERT lol! Their dessert case has my mouth watering every time.
Just moved to town and my kiddo wanted pizza so we decided to give this place a try. The food was really good but I was beyond impressed with how friendly and accommodating the staff were to me and my little one. You ever have those crazy, bordering on a bad, day, and you run into people that are kind and give you renewed faith...yeah, they were those kind of people. The pizza was an added bonus! Would recommend for sure!
Best Veggie Pizza in town! I have had almost every Veggie Pizza in Tyler, and nothing comes close to Top It Off Pizza. Fresh veggies, delicious crust! Pizza sauce was seasoned just right. Finally found my new Pizza Place! Thank you guys!
Best pizza in the area! And locally owned! Family friendly, super friendly staff made us truely enjoy our meal! Best of all we had left overs and they were just as delicious as they were fresh. And I have to add that is was really cool that they used pizza boxes with pictures drawn on them as decor. We will definitely be back for more!
Update 1/13/2020 - This place is only getting better! The owner has some new offerings that are just as spectacular as the pizza. This is the best, the best, pizza in Tyler. Don't wait! Visit this place now!
Original review - I can't speak highly enough about this place! The staff is friendly and you can tell they really have a love for the stuff they make. The ingredients are fresh, the toppings plentiful and flavorful, and the crust and sauce just spot on. The prices are really reasonable also. This is, hands down, the BEST New York pizza place in Tyler, IMO. Please, check this place out!
This place is a 30 minute drive from where we live....and I will keep making that drive. Not your run of the mill pizza place. Light, flaky crust. No bulk-bought, generic meats and cheeses here...apparently some housemade or fresh, near-sourced toppings...fresh, delicious, and specialty made with care. I can think of only one other in town that remotely compares...and I'll be passing it on my way here most of the time now.
The pizza was amazing but Wendy made it even better!!! We will definitely be back! If you haven’t been here, it is a definite must! The best pizza in Tyler by far and the staff takes the experience over the top!
Amazing pizza! Owner was hustling making those pizzas! Amazing ingredients and great local find
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes