"Sad by how much prices were raised from last year, but at least the ice cream always tastes good! I only wish they would keep some flavors around..."
Tori Hadinger
"The best ice cream I have had in quite some time. Very flavorful. Polite and friendly..."
Mickey Wicks
"Service is fast and efficient. Homemade ice cream is incredible. Kids have a great..."
Kim Bright
"Love New Baltimore ice cream!! Had an amazing turtle sundae, I recommend this place to everyone!!
Update: Got the banana chip ice cream and it was..."
Liv S.
"They have locations on rt 44 and rt 619, which is the one I usually visit. It's a cash only business so don't expect to use your debit card there...."
Dan Stefancik
"Ice cream was great, need to come back and try the put put..."
Roy Montan
"We live about 45-60 minutes away, but we put New Baltimore Ice Cream on our summer bucket list year after year. Great place, delicious ice cream,..."
Kim Bell
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes