Went for lunch on Monday and there was no wait. Several people were eating on the patio with heaters running. We ordered tossed organic greens with Ranch dressing and a pepperoni pizza. The salad was cold and fresh and arrived quickly. The pizza was perfect! Delicious thin, chewy crust, mild sauce and zesty pepperoni! Restroom was clean! Our server was excellent!
So good! I would wager to bet that this is one of the best pizza places in the state of Arizona. I randomly stopped in here while charging my car nearby and I ordered two pizza specials. And they were SO GOOD! The wood fired pizza was cooked to perfection. Crispy crunch, perfect layer of cheese, and just the right tang in the tomato sauce. Cannot say enough good things about this place!
Highly recommend. We walked in and ordered a pizza to-go and only waited 15 minutes for it to be ready. We got the pesto chicken pizza and it was fantastic. Not too heavy, not too pesto-y, not too greasy. It was exactly what we needed after a 6 mile trail run. We will be back next time we're in the area.
Rotten Johnny’s is the ONLY pizza you should be eating while in Sedona. From the extremely welcoming and friendly staff to the truly authentic and mouth watering pizza at and affordable price, I highly recommend this place! Miss Ellen ensured we were satisfied with the food and was a fantastic conversationalist. Will be coming back here next time I visit!!
Went on a Friday night, ordered the wood fired wings and the Buffalo mozzarella and they were both very delicious! We also ordered a meat lovers pizza that had amazing flavor and the outer crust was so good. The center of the pizza was just a little bit soggy but over all very good tasting food. The staff was super nice and polite too.
Amazing pizza, and great service by Miss Ellen! She gave us all kinds of background on how the pizza is made and where they source their ingredients. Would recommend and come back next visit and it’s right at the start of town off the 179.
The whole atmosphere and experience was great. The garlic bread, wings, and pepperoni pizza were all delicious and highly recommended. Our server, Mario, was also very attentive and gave great recommendations for food since it was our first time. I will definitely visit again when I'm in Sedona.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes