Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Wantagh
9 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Great pizza, always fresh and cooked perfectly. Staff is friendly and service is fast. Will continue to come here for my pizza and would highly..."
Mike Palazzolo
"This is one of my favorite local pizzerias, and I order from them regularly. The employees are always friendly, especially the owner. He knows my..."
Ryan Walpole
"Stopped in for the first time for a quick slice because I was in the area and I was pleasantly surprised! The owner Joe was super friendly and..."
MIkey BagAdonuts
"Great food, fast delivery, and the best homemade fresh zeppoles on Long..."
Ron Pagliarulo
"Friendly service, above average food quality.
I went to Jones Beach on Sunday with family. We got there at around 10 but we didn't bring lunch. We..."
Gavin Lee
"Not only is there pizza as good as New York Pizza but the best on the Island! Had them catering a party for me and everything I choose was fantastic..."
Gina Senatore
"Our favorite pizzeria and they only pizzaria willing to accomodate a dairy free request for a vegitable slice with no cheese. Go anywhere else and..."
Sandi Vega
"With so many other good pizza places in the neighborhood it took us a while to try this place. Glad we did. We didn't have the regular pizza, we..."
Rob Fiumara
"Went for dinner with several friends and all ate in. The food and service were outstanding. We tried several different appetizers from the Calamari..."
Len Kunzig
"We endet up going there after a day at the beach because it seemed like the closest and how lucky we where!
This was the most delicious pizza we have..."
"Positively a place to go for incredible pizza. I recommend coming here for great food, but don't pass on the..."
William Dambra
"You guys are the best! We love your pizza. Arrived last night after driving from Saratoga and you guys were closed. Instead of sending us away you..."
Cindy Gougler Crowe
"Best pizza ever I will recommend to everyone. Nice staff..."
Hernan Ospina
"Excellent pizza and service, quality ingredients! Always satisfied, great place to have..."
Vincent Trent
"The food is delicious and the wait staff are very attentive to their diner's..."
Helene Axelrod
"Lived here 30 years and no place better then..."
Gina Senatore
"Whenever I go there I usually order Penne Ala Vodka and chicken rollatino
Yummy. The service has always been great and it's best to make..."
Joannie Tipping
"The food & staff are very good here. I can honestly say I never had a bad..."
Charles Smith
"Food is always delicious and the service is excellent...my husband and I love this..."
Nancy Truzzolino
"My family used to go here all the time until we moved away 10 years ago. But being back in town for a few days, I had to stop here for dinner with my..."
Robyn Schwartz
"Umberto”s of Wantagh is the best restaurant!! Everything on the menu tastes fabulous! They have the most amazing food from pizza to pasta one of my..."
Maury Myar
"Great place to take your family and loved ones. Very good food and..."
nikhil sinha
"Solid pizza and great food. Can’t go wrong. Nice sit down restaurant too. Family friendly. Lots of options for all. The salads are..."
Phil P.
"Food is good but my expectations fell a little short just because of the hype around Umberto's name. It's a pizza and restaurant as good as most..."
Joe Giaimo
"Came here a few days ago for dinner was craving Italian food so heck why not, wasn’t very busy for dinner around 7pm, overall food was good enjoyed..."
Christopher B
"Service was excellent, food was done perfectly and delicious..."
Rafeena Sinha
"Every time I get together with my cousin we always go to Umberto's, the food is amazing, never disappointing in any way, the service and atmosphere..."
Michael P. D'Elia
"The other day at 1600 hours my stomach started talking to me and said hey Mike can we get a slice at Umbertos to hold us over!? I said of course a..."
michael lapadula
"Food is usually always very good. Of course they are famous for their pizza. Prices are a little high but you get a very good meal. We go to the New..."
John Jaronczyk
"For a neighborhood pizza/restaraunt it’s great. Service good. Plenty of breads on the table. You will be happy with any dish you order. And take..."
michael forte
"I have to inform everyone that this place is amazing.. Im such a selective person when it comes to pizza 🍕 but I dare say these folks have the..."
Cha cha Alston (Cha cha)
"I go there (Wantagh) for the deep dish pizza; I.e., the Pazzo pizza. Full dining in the back with pizzaria in the front; full bar with tap beer. The..."
jj Mawek
"First of all a whole fight broke out which was understandably wasn't the workers fault but still disrupted the atmosphere. Secondly, the pizza is..."
"Another amazing meal at Tavolo the Thai calamari was out of this world! Lobster ravioli was delicious as well as the veal sorrentino. Always on point..."
Angela Moon Ardito
"What can I say but 5 stars.... new Italian restaurant and pizzeria in Wantagh. We went with 6 adults and 11 kids. The garlic knots actually had real..."
Randy Katakofsky
"Yumm...they have thee best food! Everything is delicious we eat here all the time now. Even the kids love it and they are so picky. Not only is the..."
Jen Palmisano
"Quite busy on Saturday night so we decided to eat at the bar rather than go elsewhere. The service was friendly, dining space comfortable, and the..."
Louise Soukup-Radzicki
"Wonderful food and atmosphere. Am currently obsessed with the lobster ravioli. And Jess is a great waitress who always provides great..."
Amy Fleming
"..wonderful experience serving delish food...good selection of appetizers and entrees...very attentive wait staff as well..overall way above average..."
Anthony Luzzi
"We have been here about 6 times in the last two months...hubby and I are always looking for that great place near home ...we found it ...there is..."
Sandy Boucher Baranello
"I'm impressed with this place., the menu sets itself apart from other restaurants around the area.. Tavolo has a trendy feel, more health conscious..."
Uri Berkowitz
"Visited Tavolo for the first time tonight at the recommendation of my daughter. Tavolo is a newly remodeled, spacious restaurant serving excellent..."
Donna Riccardi
"We were there for my granddaughters Christening! The food was delicious and staff was attentive and courteous! Definitely will return. Thank you..."
Cynthia Marciano
"Every time I eat here I am very pleased with Whatever I get !!!! I Have had a different entree every time and so has anyone I have gone with !! No..."
Doreen Boucher Barnett
"Absolutely excellent experience there tonight. Delicious, delicious pizza, excellent service and really great live music! We will definitely be..."
Elizabeth Kristin
"Just got back from Sunday brunch. It was AMAZING!! I went with my mom and grandma. We got 3 meals to share, and each one was delicious. Our favorites..."
Kali Balducci Rapp
"Ate here tonight with my family and friends- delicious! Kids had pizza and French fries and loved it! We also had two dinner salads which were so..."
Jennie Riccardi Igneri
"Service was friendly and quick. The drinks I had were great as well. I got Bolognese and it was so rich I couldn't eat it all in one go ☺️. Would..."
K Dooley
"Family and I went to celebrate my mother's birthday for brunch (she loves brunch!) and everyone LOVED the food. It was all so delicious and the..."
Awilda
"Really surprised at how good the food is here. It is easily overlooked as a simple pizzeria with a few tasty slices available in the front. However,..."
Ron Abbate
"Tavolo hosted a friends bridal shower and it was FABULOUS! Excellent food & service. This is truly a hidden gem! The restaurant itself is stunning,..."
Melissa Culp
"This is really an excellent restaurant. Been twice and tried a few great dishes. All fresh and the homemade tortellini is a hidden gem on the menu...."
David Kurman
"I had my sisters bridal shower at tavolos and I've eaten there many of times! All I can say is the food is amazing the space was perfect, the staff..."
Maria Aguilar
"Consistency is key here, after 3 visits over the past year I have yet to be disappointed. Great value, quality and service. A wonderful selection of..."
Mike L
"Nice family style eating with terrific service...not much not to like; bring your family and..."
eric j
"I went to tavolo for dinner and got chicken Parmesan with angel hair pasta and let me tell you BEST TOMATO SAUCE EVER!!!! Not to mention the chicken..."
Mike Chaparro
"From the bread to the desserts, I have got to say, this restaurant delivers great Italian food to its customers. The staff is also amazing with great..."
Ryan Boswell
"Pretty good food, I wouldn't recommend their Veal Parmigiana. Meat was too thick (but who complains about extra meat lol) the chicken francese was..."
Mr Mrs Aulov
"Best specialty pizzas anywhere!! Their veggie pizza is outstanding with just the right mix of flavors. Their chicken parm pizza is awesome. White..."
"Ok we have gone 2 other locations particuly Farmingdale and Commack was not impressed. But wow this location is the best the service is impeccable...."
Audrey Faldich
"I ordered this pizza for the first time tonight from Uber Eats and the delivery unfortunately wasn’t great... Uber is a third party and took way..."
Heather Ivy
"We go to Anthony's about once a week. I am very much a foodie as I have my own cooking page on FB where I cook and give recipes. Its called cooking..."
Michael Sgroi
"Great Pizza and apps, had the square margarita and it was excellent. Good drinks and Beer selection..."
Rhys Whalen
"Best personal pizza's you can get. Crispy, well done to perfection, good selection of draft beers. Nice atmosphere, friendly..."
Nick DiFabrizio
"Never dissatisfied. Place is second to none.
Excellent service. The best wings we've ever..."
Joe Stainkamp
"Awesome salad & wings. Pizza is good to. Have the best French..."
Patricia Northrop Connelly
"Went there late Saturday
Great service pizza was perfect .we will be..."
Steve Micoretti
"Kudos to manager Greg for taking care of us tonight. Anthony's coal fired and Greg know how to do the right thing for their customers. They have..."
Ann Visconti
"Everything is always fresh and delicious!great drinks & specials, Place is clean Services is..."
Mikey Geraldi
"Love..."
Barbara Cianciaruso DeRita
"I saw some negative comments about the pizza being burnt and what not but I gave it a shot anyway and this is the best pizza I’ve tasted so far. ..."
Pedro Luis
"I like their pizza but I go there for the wings...by far my fave. But even better than the wings is the service. My server, Destiny, is the shining..."
Seth Flax
"Great Anthony’s salad, very affordable prices, good service, social distancing and famous chicken wings. For me personally it was a little bit..."
Elana S
"Not only is the pizza amazing but they have a honey margarita that pleasantly surprised me. I can't wait to go to this restaurant again to try more..."
ronald howard
"Amazing food and great service, i bring my 85 year old mom and the daytime help especially is so patient and..."
D Blatt
"Stopped at Anthony's after a movie night, and the food was delicious!!
We had the jumbo wings, and meatball pizza, and it was great!
Friendly and..."
Sharon Gordon
"Nice place to go for a drink and a bite by yourself, friends or a couple. Bar - customers are friendly, wait staff and bartenders are friendly. ..."
Pauli T
"This is a great place to enjoy awesome food with family and friends..
. Their service is really top-notch and their staff are obviously well-trained..."
Florence Masseyfu
"Delicious food and great service. We went on Sunday in the early afternoon and we had the whole restaurant to ourselves. The waitress brought us two..."
Luke Carlson
"Prices are very good. Food is also good. They used to have a better beer selection. We eat here..."
Andrew Cohen
"Not the Best pizza but good on the Wednesday special*
Love the Eggplant
Nice sause *
Oh and garlic ..."
Robert
"You can't miss this place! It's right in your face and angled on the street so it can be easily seen. Access to ample parking is available from both..."
GC Browne
"The pizza was cooked nice and crisp with thin crust the way we like it. Everything was fast and fresh. My only gripe is I think the portion size is a..."
Jason Lazarus
"Good pizza, good salad, the manager went out of her way to try to make us cappuccino, but the machine was broken... very..."
Ellen Holland
"Good food for a decent price. Pizza and wings are really good. The Italian Tuna Salad is really good. Staff was nice too. They only have cheesecake..."
"The best pizza in Long Island. come and visit..."
Dominick Pedone
"Excellent food. Sal and Nino are always so welcoming and offer great..."
Erica Silhan
"Loveeeee This pizza. Everyone is so nice. I went in for a chicken roll and they made t for me fresh. Sooo delicious! Service is awesome. Gotta love..."
Lauren Muldowney
"Excellent food and service! My go-to for pizza, heroes and sides...."
Anna Razza
"This place is great!! The best food I've had in a long time everyone's gotta give it a try you'll love..."
Coleen Flynn Maresca
"The food is delish!! Portions are huge the owners and staff are wonderful, you must check it..."
Sheri Cali Nicoletti
"I stopped in there today for the first time, I ordered a Meatball parm hero it was Delicious!!!! Best meatballs around..� & the people who work..."
Rosemary Winter
"Welcome to Wantagh!
Awesome Food & Awesome Staff = Awesomeness
You have got to go and check it out or get take..."
Nancy Camlin Sedacca
"Amazing..."
Zak Allen
"Finally found amazing pizza here in Nassau County that is comparable to Rosa's in Queens! I'm so happy! If I could give them 10 stars I would! We got..."
Dani GS
"Phil's is a local pizzeria restaurant in Wantagh. The staff are friendly and the premises is clean and is decorated lovely!
There is a wide variety..."
Thomas Thornton
"I've been going to Phil's Pizza for years, and I've never been disappointed. The food is always delicious and the service is excellent. My daughter..."
Matthew Thompson
"Ordered a Pie and two orders of fried calamari.
Excellent excellent food was great
Well done..."
John Portanova
"Great specialty slices and their entrées are always great. They have weekday specials with very big portions. My go to pizza..."
Dan Drucker
"We frequent Phil’s often and always loved their pizza and takeout. When we needed our daughter’s graduation party catered we considered Phil’s..."
ABode c
"spectacular food. the drunken sicilian is great and the delivery was right on..."
Jordan Deitch
"Found Phil’s pizzeria ad in my mailbox, went to the place for dinner and loved it. That same night we placed a catering order for 2 parties (..."
Rosie Tzimas
"We have many Pizzerias in Wantagh, but Phil’s is the only one we are overall aways pleased and satisfied overall..."
Ruth Ann Demeri
"Great experience all around with this place. Absolutely true don't judge a book by its cover. Rather unassuming from the outside, and even. With a..."
rick verga
"I highly recommend this restaurant great food and service
From Chef..."
"My favorite local pizza spot. Their pizzas and creamy chicken soup is to die for. I always ask for penne pasta to be added to the soup and it’s..."
JML
"Party of 8, food took a while to come out, however it was very good, worth the..."
Eric Coners
"Such a great place to eat! The workers are all so nice and cater to your every need. The food is absolutely delicious and the pizza here is like a..."
Kelly Cassidy
"Brick oven pizza spot that is awesome. Try the grandma ala vodka slice! The house pasta dishes and chicken parmesan is also great. Mary's is my go to..."
Jake Schaefer
"One of the best restaurants I've eaten at in my life. The pizza was delicious with no grease on it. The bread was divine. Lastly, fried Mac n cheese..."
Jarrod Worley
"Very attentive service, good food, big portions at reasonable prices. I ate half my meal and was stuffed, so I took half home for another..."
Mary Slaughter
"Mary’s Pizza is delicious and their dinners are even better. They take their time preparing the meals, in 5 years eating there haven’t had a bad..."
Peter Brasile
"Always great food that is quite plentyful for the price. Shared a meal a few times on my less hungry..."
Thomas Lang
"we went on a thursday nite place was packed. food was excellent, gets a bit chilly if seated by door was my only complaint otherwise everything was..."
Lisa Santagata
"Great place. Good food..and They have specials..chicken wed...seafood thursday...can't beat the..."
Buster
"Very good pizza, great experience, and they offer a small selection of wine and..."
Daniel Higgins
"Food and service is great. Love their pizza..."
Victor Siles
"Delicious, fresh homemade tasting pizza...Sesame crust makes it even..."
Viktoria “Drummermomof2”
"Any time they order pizza at my job we go to Mary's! Good pizza and fast delivery...garlic knots are..."
Ace Tool
"Good pizza, very tasty. I enjoyed the spinach..."
"Wonderful establishment one block from train station, nice ride outside NYC, was blown away by the fried shrimp appetizer, drinks were fantastic,..."
Vinnie Cozzi
"Overall this place is amazing.
Food is so delicious, service is exceptional and the environment is so classy and relaxing, live music is really a..."
Danilo Rubio
"We were there last night for our daughter's birthday we had 5 young teens and 8 adults they gave us a semi private room. Our server Andrea was..."
Carol Horne
"My filet mignon was cooked just as I asked it to be.
Nice attentive staff.
It's a well kept clean place too.
The friendly hostess was cleaning the..."
Sabrina
"I've been here several times for business lunch, great option if you need a nice place for lunch in Wantagh. I liked it so much I decided to try it..."
G DeF
"We really enjoyed the great tasting steaks. Went back couple of days later for burgers. Excellent food all the..."
Nick Giglio
"I had a great time with my partner here tonight! My server was Frank; he offered fantastic service. I took him up on his recommendation (stuffed..."
Lesley Ann
"Thank goodness for Restaurant Week because I may not have found Vincent's Steakhouse otherwise. The food was amazing and the friendly service was..."
J Beatty
"The owner was very friendly, the staff was attendant and the food was delicious! Highly..."
Clair Awad
"A MUST!! Food is incredible! Owner and Staff are very friendly. It was my first time and we will be..."
Ruth Ann Demeri
"I order takeout and the food is consistently ready on time and the staff is alway pleasant and..."
M M
"My fiancé and I held our engagement dinner at Vincent’s. Vincent was extremely personable and worked with us every step of the way! We we able to..."
Dominique Norwood
"Went there for the first time on restaurant week. Loved every plate that came out of that kitchen! We ordered beer cheddar soup, Caesar salad, burger..."
"The service and food at this location is very good! The manager and staff are nice and accommodating and the food is cooked very..."
Angelina D'Rozario
"Have ordered twice from this location and both times, my order was ready when I walked in the door. They do not forget your extra requested sauce..."
A
"The food was ready quickly and tasted great when we got..."
Lil R
"First of all, it’s rare I review something anymore because who thinks of reviewing unless it’s negative or outstanding? Maybe some people but not..."
Richie McManus
"The pizza is great! The service was EVEN better. Provided us with garlic buttery crust and sauce and asked us when we wanted our sodas which was very..."
Becks Loo
"Ordered here 2x already in past 3 months and pizza was very good, good..."
Javier Flores
"Cashier was kind considerate and patient and the food was GREAT! Honestly - I could go to another location but dont because I always have good..."
Heather Wilkinson
"They always get my order..."
Abhijeet Singh
"Would have given 5 stars however, the kids working there need better customer service. The app said my order was ready but when I got there, one of..."
Stacey Kelly
"Very pleasant and extremely..."
Margie Fauci
"Experience was awesome, Three workers caught my attention the most. Their names were Emir, Kathrine and Arielle. One of the three nicest people I..."
Mighty Tube
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes