Best Sandwiches in Washington Island

6 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Jackson Harbor Soup & Sandwiches
Jackson Harbor Soup & Sandwiches
93/100 (601 ratings)
Quick Bites
Vegan Options
American
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Cafe
Gluten Free Options
Soups
Soups
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Reuben Sandwich
French Dip
Shrimp Bisque
Grown Up Grilled Cheese
Paninis
The Jen
Sandwiches
Quesadilla
Creamy Jalapeño Soup with a Side of Warm Bread
Dogwood Sandwich
Beer Cheese Soup in a Bread Bowl
Bumble Berry Pie and Chocolate Cream Pie
Carrot Ginger Soup Kettle
Fresh Baked Pie
Salad
1 2 Cubano Sandwich 1 2 the Jens Bowl of Lobster Bisque
The Stella
Artichoke Dip
1 2 Dagwood and Salad Combo
Chowder
Roast Beef Sandwich
Apple Lavender Cider
Lobster Bisque Soup
French Onion Soup
Café
American
Café
Soups
Highchairs Available
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Seating
Accepts Visa
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Discover
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"When a place says half the adventure is finding us, well, i usually take that challenge. Located just a few steps from the Rock Island departure..."
Joel Paylor
"A diverse menu, scenic location, and excellent food. I had the Jen (essentially a turkey Rueben) and the French onion soup in a bread bowl. Both..."
Luke
"Eat here! Wonderfully delicious soup and sandwiches. Everything is fresh, filling, and presented nicely. The outdoor seating is lovely to catch some..."
Ashley A
"Beautiful tucked away place. Soup and sandwiches are wonderful. Staff was so kind even tho they had non stop orders. There are limited tables inside,..."
Kristine S
"The specialty pizza was great! Service is a bit slow, but for the popularity and the beautiful location, it makes sense. Lots of options for pies,..."
Katie Brister
"Very busy place but the staff worked their butts off to make fresh food and deliver it all over their place. Staff was young and they handled..."
Kara Thomas
"What a hidden gem! Some of our clan wasn’t too excited at first because they thought it would only be soup! They ended up loving their meals!..."
Kristie Rust
"The folks that own and operate this place grew up in the hospitality industry, So it means something when I say that their even-temperament Goes a..."
J H (Kirjava)
"The soup and sandwiches my husband and I got were extremely good: French onion soup, Grammy's potato soup, wreck of the Iris sandwich, and French dip..."
Kristina Reuber
"This place was great! I had a tuscan bean soup with pesto and tomatoes, my husband had the beer cheese soup in a steaming, warmed bread bowl. I stole..."
Julie Swenson
"Super delicious sandwiches and soup!!!! The carrot cake is Enormous and Amazing too! A beautiful location to sit outside on the various decks and..."
Deborah
"Best food and service on the island! Cherry pie is to die..."
Joe Kasanay
"Very good food and plentiful. Loved the very casual seating outside. Staff is friendly and helpful. Do plan plenty of time. It is a small kitchen,..."
Jon Holcomb
"Recently had a vacation on Washington Island. We ate at several restaurants and this was the best. There were two soups available one was vegetarian..."
Stephen Miller
"What a place to have coup of soup...beef vegetable one! Great selection of sweets and ciders.Beautifull view of Rock Island. Now when COVID is gone..."
I D
"Great little spot on the water. I had their version of the Cubano sandwich, it was very tasty. Other selections were delicious as well, the chicken..."
D R
"BEST French onion soup I've EVER had! ..."
Tammie Dickerson
"Food was great, staff was friendly. Took a while to get through the long line to order and get our food but we weren't in a rush. Nice outdoor..."
Abigail Bosco
Nelsen's Hall Bitters Pub
Nelsen's Hall Bitters Pub
91/100 (642 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
Pub
Bar
Pub
American
Dinner
Lunch
Sandwiches
Burger
Salad
Fish Sandwich
Fish
American
Bar
Pub
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Always renew my bitters card when I visit here. Friendly services, good food and spotted cow on tap. Love coming here when on the..."
Erin Green
"Good drinks, food, and the service was awesome....we will return....the motel that they also run was better than your fancy motels....large room,..."
Debby Bublitz
"Awesome Food. I joined the Bitters Club, l highly recommend you ask and get the story (history) of Bitters. Please try it was very nice. Ps soup and..."
William Stalfa
"The experience itself alone was great. Great service and food. Our bartender was helpful , friendly, and informative about the business's history. ..."
Brenda Heritz
"We stopped in here just on a whim on my Birthday adventure. It was the first time my husband and I had been to door county. We were told to check out..."
Janet Patten Hillier
"Stopped by there today. Outstanding meal and friendly..."
Michael Amidzich
"Great to see a piece of Wisconsin history!! The bitter shot was the nastiest thing I have ever drank, but so worth it!!! Will be..."
Michael Wright
"Only the best bar in the northern hemisphere...just..."
Erika Gonzalez
"Joined the bitters club! Very busy, felt bad for the only bartender. Brandy Old Fashion was OK. Building is really cool and atmosphere was great...."
steven sorenson
"We had a great visit. Wife had a shot of Bitters for a 3 time club member. Sad to see it is up for sale. Some ppl need to have patience and less self..."
David Fannon
"We had a great Island experience! Good food, good service, good atmosphere. Be sure to join the..."
Eve Wimpffen
"My wife and I had such a wonderful time here! The food, drinks, atmosphere and service (you are a rock star, Ella!) were all exceptional! We will..."
Jesse Worf
"At this point if you aren’t stopping at this place. You didn’t visit Washingtons island. This place is a town favotite and I can see why. The..."
Lucio Vergara
"Love coming here! The service by Ella bartending was outstanding! The New York Strip with mushrooms was great I have never had a bad meal here. This..."
Paul S
"Yes, we did the bitters shot and are now members for a year. Great bar. Christian was a great..."
Judi Cimuchowski
"Those had to be the best Brandy Old Fashioned Sweets we have ever had. I joined the Bitter's Club too. This is a must stop on Washington..."
Troy Roberts
"Neat little stop with old time atmosphere. Food was very delicious, but a bit expensive for a quick burger and fries. BEST Brandy Old-fashioned I've..."
Robert Haggerty
"The food and drinks were so good! Ella makes one of the best mojitos I've ever had. We had a great experience and recommend..."
Tori Worf
"Must visit when on the island. Great history, stories and..."
Sara Bella
"Visited Nelsen's on our honeymoon on 8/7, and try to go every time we are in Door. The vibe is chill and fun, the BLT is tasty AF and the petite,..."
Kimberly Bacik
"Conquered becoming a member of “The Bitter’s Club”! Cool local history. The building is fascinating inside & out. Very good selection of beers,..."
Deb Halbach
"A classic old tavern, the place serving alcohol for the longest continuous period in the United States. I stopped in out of curiosity and surprised..."
Leonard Grossman
"You MUST stop in and have a shot of bitters and get your official bitters club membership card! Once you down your shot, stick your thumb in the ..."
Stephanie Diggs
"What a fun place. My boys, wife, and I enjoyed our short time here while touring the island. After many tries, one of my boys were able to get his..."
Mike Solt
Island Cafe And Bread Company
Island Cafe And Bread Company
90/100 (172 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Chowder
Toasts
"Awesome little gem on the island! Stopped for breakfast and they had great food and drink—the sourdough flapjacks are a..."
Kate McFadzen
"Our family of 4 visited Washington Island this past weekend. The food we had was nothing short of amazing! My husband is an extremely picky eater and..."
Carmen Geier-Fortun
"Our first visit there yesterday. Very good food...the coffee cake was awesome..my friends had the omlette...they were very pleased...my hubby had..."
Karen Sheahan Prue
"Fantastic breakfast and owner beautiful spot loved..."
Terry Tr Hansen
"Food is excellent ! Some recipes are very unique but delicious , all home made, with fresh locally grown ingredients. Coffee is the best, freshly..."
Bobbi Wiberg Rabideau
"Fresh, delicious and creative food. Went for lunch and breakfast; both meals were amazing. Highly..."
Diane Hope
"Delicious breads, loved the toast menu and the smoked whitefish chowder was..."
Betsy King Breaker
"The best place for specialty homemade sandwiches with great..."
Chirag Chavda
"Such an asset to the food world of Washington Island! Great food with fantastic intentions, never had a meal I didn't..."
Holly Frank
"Love this place, food and beverages are so delicious and the service is very friendly..."
Kathrin Judd
"We were just delighted with every drink, every amazing meal, and all the smiles. Thank..."
Tim Eddy
"WOW! Never have I had a better, more tastier breakfast! The tartine - every bite was a magical explosion of taste in my mouth. I want to sit here all..."
Laura Fry
"Heidi's creative twist on classic menu items is so refreshing! She uses world class and locally farmed/raised ingredients and the flavors in her..."
Angela Lindemann
"Great food .. great staff! Loved the lavender..."
Lori Steen
"Great breakfast and friendly staff. What a nice addition to restaurant choices on the..."
Dawn Chier
"Stopped for breakfast and coffee at the start of our island visit. The breakfast Sammy was terrific. Even better we’re the lavender scones. The..."
karen moriello
"Stopped here for lunch and the food was delicious. This is a farm to table type place where the food is fresh and made to order. As a result, we had..."
J L
"Stopped at the Island Cafe and Bread Company for lunch while I was on the island. It was delicious! I had the green machine (added bacon) and it was..."
Amanda Hyttel
"We had stopped there for breakfast I got a smoothie which was good and a French toast and eggs on the side. French toast was not sweet enough and it..."
Rhea Williams
"This is the place to stop on Restaurant Row on Main Street in town. My walnut veggie sandwich was so yummy. It was a perfect combination of bread,..."
Candace Person
"We had the daily soup today...a smoked whitefish chowder. Probably one of the best soups we've ever had anywhere. Lots of fish and beautiful veggies..."
Cynthia Nelson
"I had a great breakfast there: fresh locally caught fish and eggs with potatoes and bird seed toast. The fish was lawyer fish, a fresh water cod,..."
James Rose
"Reading some of the other reviews leaves me confused because this is literally the best breakfast I have ever had. My group shared the waffles, eggs..."
Hayley Grace
"Lunched here with a group of four and while the wait was long, it was worth it. Pork tacos were delicious and wait staff was friendly. Purchased a..."
Dennis Horn
"Island Cafe is a delightful and charming place with amazing bread, coffee, and food. We always pre-order our bread and pick it up the next day. The..."
Theresa B
"Food was incredible, farm to table, and local. Staff was very kind and truly enjoyed the food that they made. A must visit if exploring Washington..."
Alex Konen
"Power toast was Bomb! Prices were very affordable and staff was friendly. I recommend having a coffee and power toast to start your day..."
Luke Tull
"We had awesome turkey sandwiches. The lavender lemonade was something new and we really enjoyed..."
Toni Dickmann
Fiddlers Green
Fiddlers Green
84/100 (494 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegan Options
Bar
Bar
Pub
Pub
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Salmon
Hummus
Pretzel
Sandwiches
Baguette
Gyros
Guinness
Roast Beef Sandwich
Beef
Salade Verte
Vegetarian Gyro
Duck Breast Sandwich
Salad
Roasted Vegetable Sandwich and Couscous
Duck
IPA Green Chop
Sit down
American
Bar
Pub
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Live Music
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Late Night
Dinner
Mid-range
"Wonderful experience! I was thrilled to find this gem. I loved the vibe, it felt very welcoming and comfortable. Enjoyed a cold Guinness on the patio..."
Adrienne Hartman
"We stopped in here on a whim yesterday to grab a beer before heading back to the mainland. Guinness on tap,and a good variety of other craft beers..."
Claire Steckel
"Exceptional Eats, Special Space This restaurant is a real stand-out on Washington Island. Waiting for the Rock Island Karfi we picked up the special..."
Colleen Jornlin
"Wonderful lunch. We ordered the beef tenderloin medallion with caramelized onions and horseradish Brie and the Duck breast with spiced cherry sauce..."
Peg Joseph
"Kate does an amazing job and runs a top notch eclectic eatery and pub!! We've eaten here on every trip to Washington Island and too day her Salmon..."
Mike Schmitz
"I’ll be honest and say it wasn’t our first choice, but I’m so glad we found it! It is such a cute and eclectic restaurant. The ambiance is so..."
jennifer morris
"Favorite place on the island -salmon wellington is SO GOOD, wine selection is unique and the band was so fun! NO DOUBT why they were so packed! Can't..."
Tammy Schmitz
"A definite destination when visiting Washington Island. The decor is vintage eclectic, from the brass tile ceiling to the bar fashioned like a boat..."
Patrick Wilson
"Love the atmosphere here! The gyro might be the best I've ever had. Will definitely be returning next time we are on the..."
Angel Gaikwad-Burkey
"The food was absolutely amazing I had the roast duck sandwich and I'm not a big sandwich guy but that was the best sandwich I've ever had it does..."
The Chicken Rising
Kk Fiske Restaurant & The Granary
Kk Fiske Restaurant & The Granary
80/100 (478 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
Seafood
American
Dinner
Lunch
Sandwiches
Cod
Fish Sandwich
Fish
Sit down
American
Seafood
Bar
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"This place is one of the hidden gems of door county. It is an adventure just to get over to Washington island, and it's so worth the trip. Home..."
Lori Jorgensen
"Great place and not just for fish! I hardly ever eat fish, but there is always some awesome stuff on the menu. The bread appears to be homemade, nice..."
Will Morrison
"Top 5 fish fry in Wisconsin. Hands down great food and drinks. The service was amazing. Veggies perfect. Highly..."
Chad Kofler
"Been an island visitor for all my years, and it's always amazing service here! Igor did a fantastic job and was a great..."
Alden James Dewey
"Friendly folks who serve great food at fair prices! Get the Lawyer fish if they have it... you will not be..."
Steve Ehlers
"The broiled whitefish and fried Lawyers are THE BEST!! Caught by owner and commercial fisherman Ken Koyen, then cooked to perfection by his son..."
Melanie Joy Bauer
"Great food and good people!! The Broasted Chicken is..."
Helene Rodgers
"Had the greatest time here between the outdoor bar at the coop and the fishboil at the k.k. Fiske restaurant We came back the next day just for the..."
Yada Dykstra
"The lawyers are awesome! And the lawyers livers are even..."
Kay Stiefel
"A very warm cozy atmosphere, and staff that treat you like family! Or maybe even better in some cases :) LOL FOOD: fresh, delicious and prepared..."
Curtis E Harrison
"My favorite restaurant on Washington island. My wife and I ate here twice while staying on the island. This place was always open while some other..."
L
"If you are looking for fresh delicious fish, this is the place on Washington Island to go. The last remaining local commercial fisherman brings in..."
Lindsey Roddy
"Firecracker chicken and parm fries were fabulous!!!!! We received warm service and crafty recommendations from Jeremiah and Hans. Larry at the bar..."
Faith Barrett
"The food was delicious. Not your typical bar food quality. The coleslaw was yummy, the chicken was juicy, the cheese curds were good and served w/ a..."
Kristina Reuber
"Whitefish caught in the morning by the only commercial fisherman left on Washington Island was my dinner last night. Bf had the parm fries. Both..."
Bonita Rae
"The best fish I've probably ever had! My boyfriend and I were on the Island for our 2 year anniversary. When we got up on Friday, we tried to go to a..."
Monica O.
"Excellent food. Some of the best fish we've ever had! The lawyers are worth the drive! Even though they were extremely busy and seriously short..."
Nicole Phalin
"This definitely seemed like the best option for lunch on the island. The fish sandwich I had was great, my families food was good too. I think the..."
Chase Nelson
"If you don't try the fresh caught parmesan white fish dinner......shame on you! Awesome meal,fish was well cooked and along with garlic green beans..."
Del Parson
"Stopped here in August (2023) during our honeymoon in Door, and was greeted warmly by the owner's son. He mixed a few delicious cocktails, poured a..."
Kimberly Bacik
"We have a home on the Island and my wife grew up here. So been to K.K. many times. Tonight we met a couple friends and sat at the bar to have a..."
Steven Wold
"This place is amazing! I have dreams about the perfectly cooked whitefish (caught fresh daily), squeaky fresh cheese curds with homemade ranch, and ..."
Krista Townsend
"***The place to get fish!*** Had the white fish sandwich and it was impressive. Mr. Hans knows what he's doing in the kitchen! All the whitefish is..."
Eric Bieniewski
"Kenny's classic restaurant and saloon is an iconic piece of Washington Island. Saturday night they had live karaoke presented by an islander. It was..."
b j
"Our 2nd time this year. We went in July and came back in September. We loved the food but this time they only have walleyes. The service was good and..."
Road to 50
"The main fish on the menu are. fish, walleye, and lawyer. The lawyer name, according to fishermen, is owed to the location of the fish’s heart,..."
Wayne terry
"Only place on the island still serving food at 10:30pm. They offer a very small late night menu until 12am on Fridays, and I was thankful for real..."
Sweetlea
"We’ve been here several time and it’s consistently excellent. Best restaurant on the island. I love the server who always brings our two year old..."
James Kennemer
"Great spot to grab a bite to eat & have an old fashioned! Lots of history, stop in and enjoy..."
Bob White
Bread And Water
Bread And Water
75/100 (187 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Cafe
Cafe
Lunch
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Salad
Sit down
American
Café
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Breakfast
Mid-range
"I have been to this place 2 times now. Really appreciated that they let their light shine for Jesus🙌 First time the cherry bbq bacon burger was a..."
Meggie Wasik
"Quirky interior was mismatched and cozy...think Grandma's house if she shopped thrift stores. No one else there when we walked in. Staff felt..."
Jen Rhodes
"I felt like we stepped back in time! Many antiques and knickknacks. Service was slow, only 1 waitress and 1 cook. But the food was exquisite! Gravy..."
Diane Kestner
"Honestly I was a little wary due to the Christian slant of the business, when I am in fact a demon. However, the breakfast was delicious and filling!..."
Rebecca Mergen
"This place has amazing food. It was run by a sweet little lady. When you go you need to make sure you are not in a rush because it does take awhile..."
Angie Allison
"We ate at this great little restaurant for lunch while staying on the island. I had the very best BLT that I have ever had, and I make them all the..."
Robin Sesko
"This place has awesome affordable rooms. Didn't get to eat since we arrived late. Awesome kayak history. Didn't get to meet the kyak history maker,..."
Terry Doxtator
"Took a spur of the moment trip up to the Island, expecting it to be pretty tourist-free this late in mid-week September. Turns out every ferry was..."
Elle Harrer
"Very unique dining experience, had a burger and it was excellent, side portions were somewhat small. But was satisfied and would likely stop..."
pat fagan
"We split a 1/2 pound burger. It was very good. The beans that came with it were cold and such a small portion I wonder why they bothered. The..."
Adam Burge
"Our group rented 2 double kayaks for roughly 6 hours (half day) at the price of $70 each, + tax. The proprietor, Valerie, is incredibly sweet and..."
Cassie
"What a pleasure to eat here. These woman and the cook had their hands full but they kept it moving and efficient. As an avid kayaker it was awesome..."
Jason Paszkowski