My review will be a bit "out of date", as I remember best the Caradaro Club as a bar on Erie St. I was a small boy then, and my dad worked across the street from the Caradaro Club. He brought their pizzas home at times, or he would take me into the bar to watch them being made.
But sadly we moved from Milwaukee in the mid '60s. In the late '80s, I was in the 757th TC Army Reserve at the old Allis Chalmers site. And again had Caradaro pizza, it was as good as my childhood memories.
Now I seldom get to Milwaukee, but to me their pizza is HOLY, as in
the same yesterday, today, and forever.
The only authentic pizza in West Allis. The crust, the sauce, the toppings, they can’t be beat. Stone fired pizza, as close as you can get to Italia from 70th street.
Love their pizza! Cracker thin crust. Looks like a hole in wall but food is fantastic! Only carry out or delivery options.
Love the pizza here. Always nice go to.
Ordered my pizza at 9:00 and was ready by 9:15. Can't complain
It's a good pizza. If your ordering for delivery, they only accept cash. Nice thin cracker crust.
Been eating their pizza for 25 yrs.
Love u guy's really know how to make a authentic Italian pizza.
Good Pizza not the best though Lisa's or Ann's are the best
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes