If you're coming to Oneonta and playing in the Cooperstown tournaments this is one of the few places that you could rent out for the whole team and their family members.
The owners knew exactly what they were doing and have it down to a science. All the food orders were taken ahead of time, placed on their own separate table, and everybody was able to serve themselves. True family style as it should be. At the end of the meals each family is then given their own separate check which certainly helps avoid any conflicts come bill time.
Highly recommend.
We came here with our baseball team. Pizza was good, great atmosphere and service was friendly.
Absolutely best pizza 🍕 and phenomenal service, hidden jewel that everyone should know about it. Huge portions at a reasonable price. Recommend to all
The Pizza here was delicious. I felt like I was back in NYC , having real NY style pizza ! The service was great. The young staff was so pleasant & attentive. We were there with a rather large party of 25-30 . Our kids were there for a baseball tournament at Cooperstown Village . The owners were wonderful in assisting us with a team dinner & cupcakes for dessert. GreT service & good food
Amazing staff, great place for a team party while visiting Cooperstown. Penny was so organized that we ended up doing the pizza party package delivery the night of opening ceremonies too! Would definitely recommend this place!
Been here twice and both times dinner was delicious. Garlic knots are the best I've ever had. Pizza is perfectly cooked, and even better the second time! Salads are super fresh. Next time we are going to try subs...
Coming from I did not think I would see Grandma's Pizza again go there really just for that must try them for dinner I am looking and no one none of the three prime Italian restaurants up here and yes 23 West is one of the best of the three also makes gnocchi now I understand no one could make it like my uncle in Whitestone but come on give it a try have it as a special or something I bet you it will be good because your sauce is phenomenal
The Grandma's Pizza is the BEST pizza I have ever eaten! The dough is superb, made by Rich who has made pizza all his life. Nice people!
![5]( "Recensione")
Ordered 2 Large pies night before July 4th. (Plain & Pepperoni.) The pizza tasted amazing... U can tell they use very high quality ingredients.
The ONLY constructive criticism I would mention, was that the dough was a little overworked with specific this batch we had, so made it a tad tough, which was okay... (bc it had so much flavor)
& lastly, very light in the sauce department, (which seemed to have a great taste)... but would have LOVED more.
Overall, the flavor was their strong point! Definitely not some basic bland pizza, like some of the other local pizzerias.
The staff were so sweet & so were the hard working owners. They remain open on major holiday's & 6 days a week, even past the closing times of other pizzerias & were kind enough to take us pizza, last min. The pepperoni btw, was like no other, not greasy & packed with natural herbal flavor! & made us 🤤 the very moment we smelled our pizza.
Definitely genuine place & very happy we had the pleasure to find this pizzeria!!! A hidden gem for sure!
Great atmosphere! Great service! Family owned and run.. very friendly... and the pizza was terrific!! So good fresh out the oven!!
Nice Italian food in Oneonta. I had a sausage, pepper and onion roll with marinara sauce. Loved the marinara and the combination roll. Seating is closed temporarily for COVID-19 but takeout/pickup is available.
Fantastic place for a team party!! We loved everything about it!
My friends and I went there for a lunch takeout. I had a mushroom and meatball calzone. It was sooo big that I only ate half of it!!! It was very good, nice and cheesy!!! The lady that took my order was very pleasant, in spite of all of my friends talking all at once.
I hope to return to the area next year.
Best pizza I’ve ever had in my entire life. Family atmosphere, kind people. Garlic knots are a must. BEST food.
We got delivery here twice while the boys were playing at Allstar village. The service was great. Food was excellent and very affordable. The staff made ordering so easy and delivery was right on time. Food was hot and the boys loved every bite. Even a couple that are really picky. I would highly recommend them and will definitely return when in the area.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes