Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Westerville
22 restaurant menus in Westerville, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"I gotta say this is the best pizza I have enjoyed in a very long time!
Lovely casual service and great hospitality from CEO (Chief Entertaining..."
Brenton Quirini
"First visit to celebrate my 50th birthday. We had pizza, chicken parmesan, and lasagna. Food was awesome. Great taste and generous portions. Very..."
Michele McGinnis Lockard
"This was the best pizza I have enjoyed in a long time. Plus it’s a family business which is a plus for me! The staff was friendly and very..."
Pamela Leach Shelnut
"Unfortunately, it doesn't seem like the restaurant read any of the notes on my ubereats order. I ordered the Antipasto salad and I noted that I..."
HMM31
"Haven’t had good pizza in so long, I swore it off but this was redemption. The marinara that came with the garlic twists was amazing. Pizza was..."
Sequoia Holmes
"We had gnocchi with meatballs and a pepperoni and jalapeno pizza for takeout. Gnocchi was pillowy and soft. The marinara was great as we're the..."
Mike Royer
"Great family owned biz! We always get great dine in service, my office is close by. The pizza dough is fresh and addicting! Don't forget to get some..."
Nick Gabbard
"Our first time here. My husband got the 14in supreme pizza he absolutely loved it! I went with their House made Lasagna omgoodness to die for really..."
Linda M.
"Pizza was delicious with crispy crust. Also ordered a peanut butter and chocolate sandwich..."
"Yohans is a true staple to the polaris area... truly the best pizza shop and always on time.. Yohan runs a great crew and never let's us..."
Tyler Butterfield
"The is by far the best pizza I have ever had. We drive from Hilliard just to eat it!! Need a location closer..."
Lori Hunziker
"The best pizza on the planet!!! I love that this pizza is just like we got in the old days!!! Anyone remember Tommy's Pizza? Yohan's you are the..."
Brenda Lynn Ferko
"Having lived in the Polaris area for awhile, I've had most of the pizza places around. Yohan's is hands down the best. Pepperoni and extra cheese,..."
L.j. Hayner
"They make a good pizza...the pepperoni scoops up too...the subs are very good as well...always like supporting local businesses....Yohan has been..."
Michael R. Laughlin
"Had it for the first time today and yummy! Tried the wings and pizza today and it was soooo good! I will be coming..."
Amanda Castle
"I love this place! Not only is it next door to my local bar they have gluten free pizza crust with all their amazing toppings! Love that I can have..."
Kate Gardner
"Best pizza and sub place in Central..."
Erin Temple
"More like a mom and paw place, not those chain restaurants...."
JP Bentz
"go independent pie guy!! usually make my own from scratch, but when i need to order out these guys are the best !
Thanks Always
Matt..."
Matt Shanks
"THEY COVER THE PIZZA IN PEPPERONIS AND THEY CURL UP AND THE GREASE SITS INSIDE THE PEPPERONI LIKE A TINY PUDDLE OF JOY RENDERING MY TASTE BUDS AND..."
Jared Bender
"Yohan Pizza has been my favorite pizza place in Columbus for a good few years now. IMO crust and sauce are the key to having a great pizza, and Yohan..."
Nick Yates
"Tried Yohan for the first time yesterday, and it’s probably my favorite Columbus style pizza. The crust is airy (I hate the snappy cracker crust at..."
Clayton Kohut
"One of the best pizza places I’ve been. Sauce isn’t too sweet, crust is crisp, toppings are quality and service is always top..."
Chris Worthen
"Consistently good pizza and super friendly employees. It’s my go to spot in the Polaris area. It’s also very affordable for the quality of the..."
Kimsey Kelsik
"Awesome pizza spot ! We will be back! They really load the toppings on here. I enjoyed the thinner crust, my boyfriend did too. The staff was super..."
Chelsea
"One of my favorites! Nice crispy, flakey crust. Very good sauce and they put a lot on.. too much for my wife but she barely likes.
Ive went twice now..."
Sam St
"Amazing pizza! Their pepperonis are very good and the sauce has zing and pep. The staff is very..."
"Love, love, love Cucinova pizza, pasta and salads. Love the Westerville location and the atmosphere is like a touch of Italy.
Love the white sauce,..."
John Scardina
"Love the concept with wonderful ingredients! Would recommend for sure! Make the pizza or salad your own and/or go with their own..."
Heidi Mueller Vallie
"Today for one hot 4th of July parade, my family sat outside of Pizza Cucinova in Westerville. The same space we’ve sat for years. This year,..."
Lena Smith
"Great, friendly service. Great food. Clean. All things the easton location is lacking. Definitely recommend this..."
Karen Stiffler
"As a Jersey born girl, I have high expectations of what I want my pizza to be! Cucinova is the best that I've had in a long time. The amount of..."
Bev Carlton Pancoast
"I’m a big sauce person when it comes to pizza and the classic tomato was soooo..."
Johanna Slomovitz
"The food is great and the staff is wonderful! It’s always super clean as..."
Missy Dougherty Shardy
"My family has been in twice and we have had the pizza and pasta. Each time was excellent. Would definitely..."
"Solid selection of toppings, pizza is ready in just a few minutes, and most importantly it tastes..."
Chris Bobb
"Voodoo pizza handmade in front of you & ready in less than..."
Michael Wharton
"Amazing! Will road trip back to Westerville just to eat! (And visit the..."
Penny Tharp Vick
"We own a business in Westerville so my husband picked up food to bring home tonight. Wonderful!!! So fresh and thank you for the healthy options :) I..."
Laurie Kinnear
"Wow, Cucinova blew me away tonight. Just one minute before closing at 10pm, an employee welcomed me in to grab something to eat. It was quick and..."
Terry Miller
"Good food & service at a good price! My husband and I enjoyed dinner after an event in Uptown Westerville. I had a customized salad while my husband..."
"Good good and tons of options. Friendly staff!.
Price is also very nominal for the..."
Raj K
"Individually made pizza at a good price. This place is perfect for people who can't agree on the same toppings on a pizza. Fun to see them make the..."
Anne Nguyen
"Love this place. You get to pick all your own fresh toppings for pasta, pizza, or salad. The stone bake is delicious. The staff had always been..."
COUPLE vs FOOD
"Been here a few times, great place for a quick bite. Nice staff and good food. Our family loves this place!
One suggestion if you get a pizza would..."
"Was looking for a place to hold a small celebration (20+ people). Picked Antonio's to do this and it was amazing. The food was excellent and the..."
Anna Marie Calo-Batt
"Excellent pizza especially the Buffalo Chicken Pizza. The best ranch dressing in the whole state. Friendly staff! It is a small dining room so there..."
Karena Somerville
"We love Antonio's! Great food! Their pizza is amazing. The staff treats you like family! Highly recommend it for a spot to..."
Julie Beirne Apsey
"Had a late dinner here night before last! I can honestly say the homemade pasta and sauce was better than GMarcos. The service was ten times better..."
Kathy Walston
"We were looking for some take out so we could picnic at Hoover Dam. I found Antonio's Pizza and decided to give it a try. I took one bite and told my..."
Richard Ivory
"Love Antonio’s now, loved it back in the day. Great food, great..."
Karen Wood
"Best pizza ever! Friendly family run place where you have to wait but it's so worth it..."
Wendy Landis
"Great pizza and friendly staff. The family size salad was big enough for 4 adults and 2 kids. We'll go back..."
Camilla Kehoe
"As always...pizza was..."
Marty Chitwood
"Don and I love the food as well as friendly..."
Phyllis Ritter Nobile
"Food was Really great, timely and friendly service, we will return and tell our..."
David Chapman
"We go once a week! Excellent food and service, and such wonderful people. I couldn't recommend it more..."
Bridgett York Simmerman
"Great food, great atmosphere, great staff! Thank you for the years of great..."
Margo Leinheuser
"The waitress is Fabulous ;) but seriously the pizza's are great and we are a big family come once as a guest stop by a second time as family!! My..."
Lauri Jones
"Wonderful family atmosphere. The staff was very attentive. My husband ordered the all the way pizza and the rest of us ordered the Italian subs. We..."
Jennifer
"Great little casual pizza stop! Food was pretty quick and service was top notch. We really enjoyed all of the pizza and sides. Crust is a little bit..."
Andrew Lather
"First off the ingredients are top tier, no joke. Second, the family atmosphere you feel when you’re there is second to none. Now to the most..."
Tyler Mautz
"Absolutely delicious! Laid back atmosphere with extremely nice staff. We got pizza, pepperoni rolls, and kids pasta and all of it was amazing. Will..."
Nicole Lather
"Very good food. The pizza has lots of toppings on a medium thin crust. It is not the super thin "cracker" crust like Donatos, but a bit closer to a..."
J
"Great Food! Great Service! We live in Marietta and will be making the trip back to this magical pizza shop that is so much more. The garlic bread is..."
Kevin Haught
"Antonio's was #1 of 4 in a friendly pizza competition with some friends. We all picked a different place and brought 4 pies to my house for the..."
tim ault
"We really enjoy Antonio’s! Pizza, salads, and sandwiches are always good. Prices are good, staff is great! We order at least once per..."
"Just returned from dinner, what great service, fast friendly. The food excellent, love the Veal Parm, spaghetti with salad and roll, but the pizza..."
Larry D. Acheson
"Every thing I have eaten here has been great ! The service has been good and the wait time..."
Gregg Barb Adams
"Great food and menu. Nice new location. Service was fast yet..."
Mary Kay Forster
"We are there almost every Friday- for many years. Good food - fun..."
David Huddle
"Excellent Lasagna meal. Great atmosphere and good..."
Jim Doyle
"We waited a long time for Minico's to open at their new location. But it's the same great food and we're so glad they are..."
Cece Bancroft
"So glad you reopened!! Best around. Cooked just right, love to have your pizza on my Friday evenings..."
Lee Ann Gleason-Dietrich
"Our first pizza in over a year was awesome!!! Welcome back Minico's. Thank..."
Mark Barrett
"Great local restaurant. We stopped in for a quick bite and were very pleased. Italian sub was delicious! Service was very good and prices were..."
Cbj Fan
"Im not a big fan of pizza , but their pizza is good & their garlic bread as..."
Alaina Alderman
"Nice neighborhood Italian restaurant. Perfect balance of quality and cost. I had a ~$14 baked ziti, and it was really tasty, good quantity, and came..."
Harry Cardillo
"The pizza is the best. The sauce is so good. The wait staff are quick and friendly. Just a nice little neighborhood..."
Cynthia Mygrant
"The pizza was awesome...sauce was perfect! Loved the pepperoni and perfect amount of cheese! The garlic bread with cheese...I couldn't stop myself..."
Dianne Herman
"The food is great! The pizza, subs and and baked ziti was..."
"Everyone needs their own nearby go-to pizza joint. I've been on the look out for mine for too long considering there's a several competitors in my..."
V-Man
"A very good place to have Pizza if you are in and around Polaris or Westerville area. I tried their Deep Dish Pizza with my own toppings. It was so..."
christopher sam
"Pizza is consistently delicious. We get the Cuban pizza and regular pepperoni and it’s great every time. I love that we can go any day of the week..."
Bevin Kallmerten
"Delicious...yummy....tasty.....crispy and crunch crust. I had a Calzone here. This is my first visit to this place. Nice small place with pleasant..."
Sri surya shankar Neerukonda
"Holy cow, the Cuban pizza is the best pizza I’ve ever had. Pro tip: add sesame seeds as the crust..."
Matt Downey
"It’s great pizza place with traditional pizza. They have wide variety of pizza including create your own. I am being vegetarian tried Mediterranean..."
Mallanagouda Patil
"Outstanding pizza, prices are extremely worth it for the quality that comes with it. I would recommend the buffalo ranch base with bacon with garlic..."
Cameo Telcoma
"Just tried the place for the first time yesterday after being told to go here from a gas station attendant who said I would not regret it.
Good was..."
Wedding Soup with Meatballs Carrots Chicken and Pasta Beads
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Meatball Sliders
Pepperoni Pizza
Italian Sub
Red wine
Fish and Chips
Pasta Rosa
Italian Fries
Spaghetti & Marinara
Personal Calzone
Wings 1 lb
Carsonie's Ultimate Loaded Fries
Wedding Soup Cup
Chicken Carsonie
Millie's Meatball Hoagie
Salad
Frankie's Fried Pickle Spears -New
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I went on a Sunday evening by myself around 7pm. It wasn't too busy and I had excellent service. The waitress was very friendly and I appreciate not..."
Cyrelia J
"Chicken stromboli was so good. The waitress was very attentive and took care of everything we asked for. We'll be back to try pizza next..."
Antionnette Jackson
"Food was really good. Sat at the bar and had an excellent old fashioned. Didn't have a to wait that long for my takeout order
My lasagna was..."
Aaron Gaspard (Big double A)
"Although we’ve lived in the area for a very long time, this was our first experience with Carsonie’s. We have a new favorite!! My husband had a..."
Anne Carter
"Funky, fun, casual Italian joint with a great menu and beers. They're most famous for their calzones, which are fantastic, but I also like their 8"..."
"Great Thai food hiding in pizza shop! This is the second time trying this restaurant and the food is great. We got the grilled pork broken rice and a..."
Rosie Rings
"Noticed that this place had finally reopened under new management. Ordered a large pepperoni pizza and some garlic bread. New owner (Thai) has 5..."
MRBARBQ 1
"Vietnamese food was incredible. Pizza is great for the price. Highly recommend you stop..."
Anand Patel
"went there this past Saturday to try and find a good place to eat near the college campus. the food was delicious and the service was excellent. I..."
Geneva Smith
"This place has delicious Vietnamese food and Pizza! I ordered the short ribs with rice and the taste was just amazing. The sauce had just the right..."
Daclaud Lee
"Nice restaurant. I advise. The pizza's bread was different, I liked it..."
Enes Furkan DENİZ
"Very friendly establishment. Pho was ok. Spring roll is best in the city. Vermicelli is..."
"It has been a minute....
I can't remember the last time I was in Giammarco's but wifey was in the mood for Italian. The decor is your typical..."
Michael Koehler
"We were first timers, and it did not disappoint! The enormous Arancini had a little zip stuffed inside the risotto. Oh - and 1/2 priced apps on..."
Jacque Spurlock
"We really enjoyed our visit to Giamarcos. We had no idea they had brunch on Sundays. Food was outstanding...good sized portions and prices were in..."
Cbj Fan
"We ordered 3 Penne Giammaro Pasta all different protein (blackened shrimp, blackened salmon and chicken. We enjoyed our meals. They come made with..."
Anitra S
"We sat outside in a nice comfortable patio area and had great spaghetti. Prices are on the high side but quality is very..."
Norm Bour -Travel Younger
"1st time customers. Our server, Maria was super patient and cool even though she was busy. Food was delicious. I ordered a $9 glass of wine but..."
"My husband, myself and two kids have become frequent fliers at T&C! I've probably had most everything on the menu at this point and keep coming back-..."
Samantha Vargo
"Great pizza and best gluten free crust around. My husband loves all the..."
Megan Owdom-Weitz
"Great service, awesome food, friendly staff! This place is bigger than it looks from the outside. House food and drink specialties are great and..."
Matt Palmer
"Friendly folks with awesome food! Always great whether eating in or taking out! Best gluten free pizza..."
Kelli Krantz
"The food is GREAT!! Have never had anything I didn’t love on the menu. The bartenders and staff are fantastic..."
Chad Baxendale
"Very friendly atmosphere with excellent service. The food is very unique and tasteful. There is a wide variety on the..."
Austin Hunt
"T&C has quickly become one of our favorites! Back for some veggie pizza....freshest veggies and very good! Gotta mention the best waitress, Ashley as..."
Sandra Trzcinski
"Time and Change is the best neighborhood bar in Westerville!!! People working there are great....food is really good, especially the Italian sub and..."
Mark Molnar
"My favorite eats are the bacon jalapeno dip, and any of their pizzas. Service is always..."
Amy L Gossard
"Great neighborhood place. The food is always good. Pizza is awesome!!
The staff is always friendly and amazing...."
Will Eadie
"Really great food and on Wednesday night they have..."
Helen Clark McCandlish
"One of our favorite places to go! Wonderful staff! Feels like family! Great..."
Kristy Worthington Seevers
"Great atmosphere, amazing food, excellent..."
Frank Green
"Genuinely great pizza. Friendly and efficient staff. Cold beer. What more could you..."
Alan Slocum
"We always have a great time at Time and Change. The food is on point and what you would expect from a neighborhood place. Whether we get carry out or..."
kelli k
"They actually have quite a nice and extensive menu. Their prices are reasonable, everyone enjoyed their food, and our server was very good even given..."
Beth Rock
"Time & Change - a great little Resturaunt and Bar. Great food and atmosphere. We love to stop here after a busy..."
Jeffrey Jones
"Awesome little hometown sporty bad and restaurant. They have a very friendly staff and a "local" vibe. I get the wings and they are great. Sandwiches..."
Joseph Bannon
"It was great! It always is! The food is amazing( I love the spinach and artichoke dip) and I love coming..."
Allana Scutt
"Fun neighborhood sports bar with decent food and an ok beer..."
Tod Bowen
"The best Buckeye bar around! The pizza is great and the sandwiches are awesome as well! If you go on Sundays, they put something different on the..."
"I Love that I can get Vegan pizza here. Also, I love that I can pizza for my friends that arent vegan!!! So many choices!!! Friendly staff!!!! 5..."
H Mo
"Kiara is amazing and should be a shift lead or manager if she isn't. She was fast pasted and quick to assist customers and be sure to get exactly..."
Samantha Ohlemacher
"This was my first time there. We did Pizza and Painting. Jamie the owner was ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS. Our Meetup group enjoyed the..."
Mochap 70
"We have tried all the different fast pizza shops in town and we like the selection at rapid fired Pizza. We especially like the garlic cheese sticks..."
Bill Konves
"This is the Chipotle of pizza! They have craft pizzas and build your own!!! They are super friendly and have amazing sauces and..."
Chesney Devine
"Options on crust include pan, thin and "no-doh" (my wife's preference) which is a cheese "crust" base. Several types of red sauce range from..."
"Great cheese pizza! Always on point. Some of the best steak subs a pizza place can offer. Reminds me of steak subs back in the 1980's. I ask for Mayo..."
kelli k
"Tried Classic Pizza on Sunbury last night with my family, it was mine and boyfriends (who especially loved it) first time there and we will..."
amber dishman
"I love this place. Small business with only a couple locations. I only ever get their pizza, but it is top notch and their service is usually..."
Stephen Sadurski
"Just started going there glad I did the pizzais awesome haven't had a chance yet to try there other products but based on the pizza I think I would..."
Steven Nutt
"Exclent pizza... Cracker thin and crispy, lots of crisp..."
David Brown
"Classic Pizza delivered 14 hot pizzas for a party I hosted. All employees were professional and fun. The pizza, price and service was..."
"We had the chicken bacon barbecue pizza... And the taco fiesta pizza... The taco fiesta pizza is the best taco pizza I've ever had in my life and I..."
Carey Marie
"I was looking for a place to take my celiac (gluten free) daughter for dinner, so we stopped in and she got one of their gluten free pizzas. I had..."
Andrew Pitonyak
"I Love Massey's, wonderful food, it is really nice to have a family owned restaurant around, don't get me wrong, the chain restaurants are nice too,..."
Angela Henry
"Best pizza in Ohio! I try to get it once a year while visiting. @masseyspizza The small pepperonis, thin crust, and good sauce really make this..."
"The food is ALWAYS hot and fresh!! There has not been a single order that didn't taste like it was straight from the oven! Good job..."
Amanda Burgess
"Absolutely nothing bad about the Westerville Glengarry location but the discontinuing of Ham from toppings may very well make this one of the VERY..."
David Edward Norris
"Nice and great service! I just hate when price jump when I change the toping or choose checking which is more costly than beef. I wish if they make..."
"It was the best pizzas I've ever had. I highly recommend..."
Michael Madhatter Phillips
"My family and I dine at this Westerville location regularly. The pizza, breads, subs, wings... everything tastes very good. The restaurant is always..."
Doug Lane
"I'm from Florida and Donatos chicken mariachi pizza is the best pizza I have ever tasted in my life. My wife put me on to it and every time I visit..."
kaiden playz
"After driving 1000 miles for one of the best pizza's, I had to stop in Westerville. I was not let down in anyway. Had a large pep, the new garlic..."
"The shrock road pizza hut is surprisingly good. After going through a lot of the other chains around like Donatos and Dominos I ended up preferring..."
Yippy Coyote
"Always courteous and polite staff, hot delicious food, clearly prepared with care. I order carryout from this location because it's SO much better..."
Heather Tombleson
"Food came speedy, hot, and delicious. Our delivery driver was courteous, friendly, and took pride in his work which is always..."
"Great staff! Great service! Pizza is fantastic! The stuffed spinach and feta bread is to die..."
Stephen Coy
"I've always had nothing but good experiences with this location, unlike a certain recent reviewer, this place actually DOES take care of you and will..."
David Pietrzak
"Domino's is really stepping it up! Easiest App to use. The Deep Dish is amazing. Everything they've done adapting to distribution methods, just..."
Keith McCaslin
"I have been at Heartland Of Uptown Westerville nursing Facility since February 2014. I have placed several orders and I am very pleased at the..."
"Best & most delicious gluten free pizza. They get busy and it is far easier to order on the ap & pick it up yourself. We like the cauliflower pizza..."
M A
"Fantastic Pizza!!
Got the large veggie deluxe with traditional crust.
Full of toppings. Sweet, but not overly sweet sauce.
Picked it up it was hot..."
Chuck Losch
"I ordered two pizzas from Romeos last week and ours was not good. There was about an inch of crust on the outside of the pizza and it was dry.I..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes