2 restaurant menus in Wheeling, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"I absolutely love that place...i don't get over there as much as I'd like, but when i do its always a great experience...good food and nice..."
Melinda PatselCooper
"Coleman's has always been my favorite place to eat and shop. Would love to win the lobster dinner for my husband and I for our 45th anniversary..."
Candy Stein
"Best place to eat in wheeling. We eat there all the times. The food is always hot and fresh the taste is amazing we love colemans fish..."
Mary Wells
"This place is amazing. I haven't had fresh seafood since we moved to Ohio. I will be..."
Tammie Fluharty-Mulhern
"Best fish sandwich ever!! Highly recommend this place also call..."
John Hall
"The best fish sandwich & soft shell crab‼️😊 Go there whenever we ars in Wheeling..."
Clark McKee
"This place is awesome. I love all the food and fast..."
Lindsay Warren
"Ordered a clam boat and they must have lost the ticket because after 20 minutes, I still didn't get it yet. When I brought it to their attention,..."
Jasmin Russell Ilovar
"Fish Sandwich. Canadian white is..."
Facebook User
"Coleman's Fish Is Decent. O here it is...... The review that you need! Coleman's is a Wheeling tradition that has been around for 100 years. They..."
Nittany
"Very nice.. Been there several times to get take-out seafood orders, plus eat-in once or twice. Now I have to warn you, it is kind of like the Soup..."
GeoLynch
"Enough Fish in One Sandwich for Two. Some people say it smells fishy. Well, it's a fish store that also sells sandwiches and other..."
CatGuy
"Local Icon. Coleman's is an acquired taste usually from birth for most folks from the Ohio Valley. You get in line and order the sandwich , the bread..."
Georgie
"I have never had a bad meal here. It's always fresh and always..."
Crys Weiss
"Coleman's Fish. I have grown up in Wheeling and I love Coleman's fish. Sometimes I wish it was still a true open air market with a fruit stand at the..."
Ruey
"Best Fish Sandwich. Coleman's never disappoints. Some whine about the Wonder Bread. The bread's only job is to keep your hands from burning while..."
Mike Sengewalt
"Just Plain Good. Work nearby, and the smell on Fridays is absurdly awesome. Went to try it. No fuss - fish on wonder bread. But the best you'll ever..."
Kurt Acker
"Its OK. I was hungry. I got the fish sandwich. It was on store bough bread. I ate it. Don't get me wrong, it was good, but I don't see what the fuss..."
JimPGH
"I love there fish they have great fish and..."
Debbie Darlene Tidrick
"I loveColeman's. My husband and I eat Coleman's about once a week, and always order the same thing: two fish sandwiches, bread separate (you get more..."
Kate
"Great fish !. The best fish sandwich you can get! Comes ultra plain on white bread, but don't let that fool you. Alligator soup, too! My wife, kids,..."
Braden Parker
"I love it, I miss it so!. I grew up on Wheeling Island and Coleman's fish. You can't get a better fish sandwich anywhere for any price. When I get..."
Debi
"The Three Things You'll Miss. A wise man once told me that there were three things that I would miss when I moved away from Wheeling. Number One was..."
Town Hill Tavern
"The Best.... I don't even like seafood all that much but this is the BEST fish sandwich I've ever eaten. I grew up eating Coleman's fish and still..."
Tara Novick
"Eating at Coleman's from Birth!!. Coleman's Fish Market is the staple of Center Wheeling, it's not the fish or the oil that makes it the best for an..."
Der Herzog
"This is a hometown favorite, anyone that is a fan of wheeling, is a fan of the fish market, yes they serve their generous portions of golden fried..."
Lori
"Local favorite. Best fish sandwich in Wheeling. They also have really good egg rolls, deviled crabs, slaw, and fries. Very affordable. They do get..."
Gianine Nelson
"We did a quick stop to pick up their fresh whiting fish for the Holiday weekend. As usual it cooked up so wonderful.
You can't go wrong with..."
Renée Gamble
"Great fish sandwiches and great service. We stop in every time we're in..."
Terry Cooper
"Alwayse delicious! The classic fish sandwich is the best around. The other menue items are also great. Very efficient at providing quick delivery of..."
Tyler Jones
"Great place to eat.Fish is excellent, service is personal and excellent..."
ynotcreations webb
"Fish sandwich was excellent, make sure you have it put on a bun, they put on slices of bread makes it to soft.tryed the crab cake not a fan of it, it..."
Ross Desimone
"The fish sandwiches are always super good and they give you more than one piece on it. The gator soup was alright but it only had 3-4 pieces of meat..."
"Really great restaurant in Northwest suburbs. If you like seafood you won't be disappointed here. I haven't been there in a while but if they have..."
Jack Malisz
"I'm happy that they opened again. Some tables are not used to allow proper social distancing. The food was amazing. I tried the Copper Rover..."
Ronnie OB
"100% GREAT FOOD!! The place definitely takes you to a vacation moment feeling. From waiters dressing shorts and Hawaiian style shirts to a blue water..."
Best Analyzer
"I've heard about this place for years and finally went and it was worth all the hype I've heard. The lobster tasted fresh and had good flavor,..."
Nick Kupinski
"Best clam chowder that I have had outside of New England! Lobster was cooked perfectly; very tender and flaky. (It is very easy to overcook lobster..."
Elizabeth D'Elia
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes