Best Ice Cream in Williamsville

5 restaurant menus in Williamsville, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Anderson's Frozen Custard
Anderson's Frozen Custard
91/100 (1193 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Fast food
American
American
Fast Food
Lunch
Dinner
Curly Que Fries
Vanilla Custard with Sprinkles
Coconut Cream Pie Coffee Bean and Peanut Butter Chocolate at World Famous Anderson's
Chocolate Soft Serve with Peanut Butter
Beef
Small Chicken Tender Basket with Fries
Strawberry Cheesecake and Butter Pecan
Roast Beef
Cinnamon Soft Serve on a Sugar Cone
Ice Cream
Apricot Mango Fruit Whip
Double Cheeseburger
Hot Fudge Sundae
Beef on Weck
Frozen Yogurt
Onion rings
Chicken Tender Sandwich
Banana split
Beef on Weck
Baked potato
Angus Cheeseburger
Hard IC Shake
All Natural Chicken Caesar Wrap
All Natural Roast Beef Sandwich
Sit down
American
Fast food
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Seating
Lunch
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"I had forgotten to share this wonderful experience and just remembered in commenting about it. Andersons in Williamsville was amazing! They had..."
Katie Spoth
"I just love the homemade Coffee Toffee Crunch. Anderson's is the only place to make this delicious treat. I always buy a quart to enjoy later. Keep..."
Bonnie Fedele
"I love Andersons. Their turkey sandwich is delicious & generous & also love their salmon burger. Of course their soft ice cream is..."
Sylvia Stachura
"Love that there is a sign in the front window telling me what the flavor of the day is. Thanks for doing..."
Claudia Stachura
"The Beef on Week was so amazing and I'd eat that every day if I lived here. The Logan berry milk shake and fries were also the best!! Kudos to you..."
Cindy Belyeu Smith
"Great food and great service. The roast beef is amazing and the custard is second to none. I call Anderson's the Chickfila of Buffalo. These are..."
Jason Beedon
"Having grown up with Anderson's, I can't find a place with better custard. Love the beef on 'weck, too!!! Here's to all the..."
Gretchen Ludwig
"Everytime I come to to Buffalo, it's a must. My childhood favorite place is still my favorite as an adult!!! No other place like it. This trip was..."
Lori Covert
"My brother and I stopped in just to have an ice cream treat. He had the Mexican sundae; I had the 🐢 turtle sundae. Each was around $6 - taxable..."
Eva Mae Earley
"We love going here. I usually always get their custard of the day. The turkey sandwiches are so good. The service is always top notch with super nice..."
Stephanie Gary
"I never get disappointed here. I've never had a problem with any of the cashiers nor have I had any issues with my orders being wrong. It's a nice..."
SpcCrawford1246
"The only reason Andersons (in general) shouldn't get a five star review is that I've had too many experiences with burned burgers or slow orders even..."
Jaxxy Frost
"one of our regular places for desserts. tried the food here first time. baked potato was pretty good. mac n cheese could have been a lot better. no..."
Ram Agarwal
"Took my son here for his first time. We got the loaded fries and added bacon, and a chocolate custard in a waffle bowl. The food was delicious and..."
Alex Rosenberg
"They have a vegan coconut chocolate ice cream and a almond chicken wrap that is 💣. Everything is always good.a little expensive but Worthwhile..."
April Chatmon
Yotality
Yotality
83/100 (293 ratings)
Dessert
American
American
Ice Cream
Frozen Yogurt
Non-Dairy Variety
Yogurt Sundae
Frozen Yogurt with Lots of Toppings
Boba Frozen Yogurt
Sit down
American
"Great place with the best of the best in toppings, flavors and friendly staff. The place is spotless with and inviting, warm and pleasant..."
Eric Torbeck
"The best I've ever had! Even have Boba for topping! Yum yum yum, but you do pay for what you get, ie, expensive! Great treat! Glad I don't live next..."
K O
"I like the frozen yogurt that they have here. I come here with my friends from time to time and just shoot the breeze. It's nice to come here..."
SpcCrawford1246
"I went here last Thursday and enjoyed my time for the most part. Unfortunately, it was very hot inside. Which either meant that they didn't have air..."
Aua H
"Love the variety of flavors of yogurt, custard and toppings. I was a fan pre-covid and they never disappoint. Always clean. If I was a teen or..."
Antoinette
"The yogurt is always phenomenal. Love the vibrant atmosphere. Very hip and modern. The magazines they have out to read is great too. The decor is so..."
Brittany Maxwell
"The selection is phenomenal but sometimes you get there and there's only four flavors of yogurt and nothing..."
Becca
Friendly's
Friendly's
82/100 (536 ratings)
Dessert
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Burger
Pancakes
Salad
Ice Cream
"Fantastic Burger Shop! Friendly's is a wonderful mom and pop burger shop with a cozy setting. This place really reminds me of what you imagine..."
John Lazo
"Good visit. Seems like prices have gone down a bit from before. Still solid food and good ice..."
Michael Price
"Fantastic service! The food is fresh and delicious. Great place for the..."
Maria Medeiros
"Good food and service here, although they seem to have cut back on their portion sizes as of..."
Amy Pollinger
"Good place to eat if you like burgers and ice cream. Lots of selection on ice cream..."
Erik G
"Great service and good food! Everything came out fat after waiting a little long for a server at..."
Alexis Maida
"I went here with the family for dinner. I had a good time. The staff was friendly, patient, and helpful. I ordered a chicken buffalo wrap with fries..."
Jeffrey OHara
Sweet Jenny's Ice Cream
Sweet Jenny's Ice Cream
79/100 (804 ratings)
Dessert
Ice Cream
Café
Seating
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Cheap Eats
Alethea’s Chocolates
Alethea’s Chocolates
76/100 (535 ratings)
Dessert
Ice Cream
Seating
Takeout
Mid-range
"We love this adorable ice cream parlor and chocolate shop. The sundaes are delicious and the sponge candy is the best in Western New..."
Renee Harris
"Delicious! Friendly helpful staff. My only disappointment was they do not have cold drinks or ice to make my warm drink cold. I survived , but would..."
Patti Cuddy
"By far the best chocolate shop around! Their sponge candy is like no other. Not only is the chocolate amazing, but the shop itself is so beautiful...."
Hannah Goldsmith
"Alethea's make the best decadent chocolates & candies! When I am in the area, it is a must that I stop by and get their milk chocolate orange sponge..."
Judith Bellinger
"Ice cream sundaes, orange milk chocolate sponge candy and very friendly staff ! Highly recommend a visit to Alethea's..."
Donna McLaughlin
"Very friendly workers.. Love the ice cream parlor chocolate to die for. Favorite item.. Sea..."
Elizabeth Frost
"Omg the best chocolate in the world!! It's like chocolate..."
Cynthia Marie
"Simply the best sponge candy in the 716. Great blend of chocolate and the lightest sponge..."
Bill Pavone
"I had the sponge candy crazy sundae and it was amazing!! You guys have the best sponge candy..."
Angelica James
"I had the Almond Toffee sundae! My sister and her husband had the cherry chocolate sundae! The best chocolate I have had in a long time! Went home..."
Jeanie Miller
"PECAN PRALINE PERFECTION, Cinnamon Ice Cream, Hot Fudge & Pecans with whipped cream, the perfect combination for a hot summer day, its delish..."
Diane Helinski
"The best milk chocolate and milk sponge candy..."
Ryan Madigan
"Fabulous chocolates! We love the hockey chocolates best if all!! Thanks for shipping them so quick for..."
Alethea Goodman
"It has been 1 year since my last visit and these folks were GREAT... Thanks for the good Ice Cream and the GREAT chocolate... Hope to see you again..."
Mark Koeppel
"Drove by hundreds of times and finally stopped in. Very cool like a step back in time. Very classy, clean and smells to make your mouth water. A..."
M. Klein
"There's two parts to the shop. One on side is a cafe that serves ice cream, pies, cakes and sweets. On the other side is a candy store selling all..."
Marc Albert
"A wonderful and special place, you can not imagine the flavors that you will find in this chocolate shop, you will find a cafe that has great..."
Pushra M
"Best chocolate I ever ate in my life. My parents brought me here when I was 7 and 30 years later I still make it a point to stop in if I'm ever in..."
Dan Thomas
"I absolutely love Alethea's! Growing up I used to go with my family, but this was my first time back after moving away. It lived up to my memories as..."
Emily M
"Thank you so much from not only myself but everyone in the office out here in Indiana. I have turned them into sponge monsters. The order you guys..."
Timothy Berry
"One of the best places in Buffalo to get a hot fudge sundae or a milkshake. The girls working were very accommodating to my peanut allergy and the..."
Robert Laino
"Buffalo has a lot of candy stores, but this one is my favorite. Sponge candy, chocolates, fudge, fruit slices, they are all excellent. Everyone that..."
Kate B