Excellent establishment. The service provided by Sydney was wonderful, informative and prompt. She recommended the calzone and I tried it. It.is.amazing. Wallet friendly and a great atmosphere. Definitely family friendly. I ordered Santas Little Helper cocktail and it is refreshing and pretty. Thank you Sydney! You are awesome!
So good, I came back twice. Call ahead and make sure the seafood lasagna is in stock. You are going to want to get that for sure. And you can't go wrong with any place that has a "meatball sundae" as an appetizer. James the bartender will take care of you! Though I never met Fat Tony, I feel all who eat here have a little of his spirit in each of us.
Bestie and Buds ordered 2 amazing fresh to order pizza's in this interesting historic building and pub. Great vibe, great service and the pizza was delish with ample toppings! Fat Tony's is a must try if your visiting!
Good meal! Waitress was great!
Whiskey drink was a bit lacking the whiskey.
No oyster crackers with chowder? That was a massive let down!
Also it was end of night so chowder was a bit....... underwhelming.
Really enjoyed our meal there Great fish and chips and diverse menu options. Staff was very helpful and very nice.
Absolutely delicious food! Love the atmosphere. Unique taste profiles on every dish!
After reading reviews i had to try it but now that we did we weren't impressed the pizza was the best thing. Chicken parm dinner needed more sauce the meatball sundae had too much cheese on top
Fat Tony's is one of my personal favorites my husband and I went on our 1st date there. Never been disappointed in the food or service. I was sad when the Pizza Fries away ha ha!!
We stopped in our first night in Wilmington for pizza and some drinks. So glad we did. The pizza was awesome but it was the service that really made our night. Matt was our server and was efficient and attentive. Noah made my drinks and seemed to really enjoy taking the time to make them extra special. He actually told me he was glad I ordered a pineapple upside down cake because he really enjoys making them and nobody ever orders them. It really started our trip off on a high note. The atmosphere is great too.
Needs more lighting, but the service and server was amazing. Also the food was very, very, good! My pizza was very tasteful especially the Italian style sausage and pepperoni. Overall experience i would give it a 10 out of 10! Great job everyone working there, especially our server he remembered everyone order without pen and paper. The blue crab dip is a definite must to get when you go here! Let me know what you all think of this place?
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes