Reviews Brooklyn Pizza Co.

4
JD_WB _8888
+4
The four stars for the food is for the lasagna, calzone, wings and sausage pizza. The lasagna is some of the best in Wilmington. It is as good or better than the more fancy restaurants in the area. The calzone is delicious. I usually get a ham calzone. The wings are big and the honey BBQ is very tasty. The sausage they use on the pizzas is cut thin and very good. The problem I have had is any pizza with pepperoni. It makes the pizza so greasy it is not edible. I complained and I was told that the manager told the person I talked to on the phone that it is normal for the pizza to be greasy from pepperoni. That was it. They did not care that I paid for a pizza I could not eat and was throwing away. The grease as you can see in the picture went through the dough and through the pizza box. Crazy. I understand pepperoni can cause grease but thousands of other pizza places have pepperoni and you can eat the pizza so what ever they are using probably needs to be changed. I hesitated for a while to do this review because I really do like their food outside of the pepperoni. The service one star is for how I was treated when I called about the pepperoni and the atmosphere could use a deep cleaning and or a remodel but it does not affect me because I always get the food to go. With all that said I still recommend this restaurant as a must try if you are visiting or live in the area.
4
Jessroo444
+4
Pizza is Excellent! I love a nice stretchy cheese on a pizza. Hot and delicious. They also sell by the slice until 4pm. I would only ask that they try to wipe down the tables more often. It’s a small place and only a few tables. More than 1/2 of them still had crumbs on them from previous customers. But maybe they just finished a rush and did not have a chance to wipe them down yet.
5
Larrie
+5
Been here for over two years and just now trying this place out. Fantastic NY style pizza. Also had the fried raviolis, and chicken parm sandwich (not pictured).
4
Andrew Holter
+4
Full disclosure. I'm from Northeast Pennsylvania, grew up in a small town with ten family owned pizza places all good to amazing. When we first moved here a few years ago we struggled to find good to great pizza places. But it's safe to put this on your list. It's good. Just tried it for the first time and it's not my favorite in Wilmington but I would certainly get it from here again. I did order it well done and it came out perfect.
5
RJ Autrey
+5
The pizza was excellent. I've had some of the best pizza NYC has to offer, and this definitely is in the same vain are those places and captures that same vibe of a pizza joint in NYC. The crust on the regular slices is excellent, not doughy at all, and the sauce has that nice tang that a good homemade sauce will have. My only suggestion for improvement would be maybe experimenting with a combo of cheeses to get the best possible flattering contrasts in richness and saltiness. The Sicilian pizza was the BOMB. A great crust, a sweeter sauce than the NY style, and that sweet sauce combined with the hearty tomatoes on top of a rich cheese along with a zesty seasoning made it a very satisfying slice. The service was good, the guy running the counter was very approachable.
5
J Y
+5
Sicilian slices or the entire pie. Need I say more? The entire pie will take 20 mins to cook.
5
Kenny Stwo
+5
Small little pizza place, I was in town for work and pizza is my go too. I read the reviews but I had good pizza and good service. I picked my food up thought. Easy to find.
4
Justin Goode
+4
Update: Tried em again recently and it was much better. The cheese kinda slid off the pizza during delivery, but I was able to save it. It was less greasy, and the flavor was a lot better. Original Review: Pretty standard "New York Style" pizza. Sometimes it's good, sometimes it's meh. My main complaint is that it just tastes like grease most of the time.
4
Stephanie Rains
+4
The food was excellent. It's so nice that they are open for dine in again, but the girl who delivered our pizza to our table had a terrible attitude. She just kind of slung our pizza on our table and walked away. Throughout our entire meal we got to hear about what a terrible day she was having and how she didn't want to be there. Other than her unpleasant demeanor it was a vary good meal.
5
Charles Lienhop
+5
Always quality products, best New York style pizza in Wilmington. Take it from me I tried them all, no comparison. Over 30 years here their the best. Eating pizza over 70 years.
5
MJ Hellmann
+5
Absolutely the best pizza I have ever had. I get the Margherita and it’s incredibly tasty. I had to go twice in order to get a photo of a whole one because they go so fast. Today I tried the Chicken Marsala & it is wonderful also. The folks who work there are friendly and hardworking!
5
Bryan Weckel
+5
It really is great pizza. Everyone here in Wilmington already knows it. You don't need me to tell you. This review is for the tourists.
5
jerryfarley
+5
What a great little pizza shop!! This place was busy on a Thursday evening but still only took 15 minutes for a pie. A few tables to dine in like we did. Most people were picking up orders. Pizza was delicious and affordable. When back in the area... I will be back.
5
adam hoing
+5
Some of our favorite pizza in all of Wilmington! They are busy, but for good reason. Consistent. Fresh. Lots of options.
5
NuclearGemini
+5
Has anyone else ordered The Frank-Oooh Pie? We're naming it that because every time my boyfriend Frank takes a bite, he yells & screams...Oooh, Oooh, Oooh, Oooh YES! YES! YES! Ladies...wanna make your boyfriend scream saying, Oooh, Oooh, Oooh YES! YES! YES! It is so delicious!!! ...order him a :::well done::: :::fresh mozzarell::: :::roasted red pepper::: :::fresh basil::: :::thinly sliced sausage::: :::spinach::: pizza pie from Brooklyn Pizza Co.in Wilmington, NC...since moving down south in 2019, this is the 1st legitimate pizzeria I found to be worthy of making the claim they serve NY-style pizza... touché my friends, touché ...Brooklyn Pizza Co. does it right!!!...(further fyi: thinking to add ricotta to the next pie...we'll call it the Frank-Oooh-Oooh-pie!!!...much love from Frank's girl from Queens, NY.
5
Patrice Harms
+5
Hands down, the best pizza in Wilmington! You only have to try it once to be hooked! I typically go for lunch and order a mushroom slice, extra crispy! So good!!!
5
Zuriel Daher
+5
Last night past around 9:00 pm my dad bought a takeout order of a pepperoni pizza with additional toppings, it was very good. However the year before last I believe we bought pizza from them or am not quite sure but it was good as well. The dough on the pizza we ate the previous day reminded me of good Italian bread from New York specifically the end crust. I recommend buying pizza from them considering that the distance is about 4-5 miles away from our home around Eastwood although it’s not the closest pizzeria, but it’s an option. I was curious about their menu seeing that they have Vodka pizza, I was wondering if the Vodka Pizza sauce would taste the same as Aldi’s sauce since it was the first time for me trying it
Clicca per espandere