Everything we got was delicious. Our fish and chips portions were huge. Of course we had to have some authentic NY pizza while we were here and Peter’s did not disappoint. The sauce and crust were to perfection, very fresh tasting cheese.
We took our pizza to the bluffs for an anniversary sunset that was just our style 🥰
We love Peter's Pizza! We come into town about once per month and we always make sure we get our dinner from here. Every time we order we are greeted with a friendly voice over the phone and at pick up we are greeted with friendly conversations and smiles. The wings are also delicious and the onion rings are crispy and addicting! Can't wait to order again (tonight)!
Very friendly environment. I stopped there on a business trip last weekend and got their meat lovers calzone. It was huge! And it was so good! I will definitely go out of my way to stop by again.
Absolutely phenomenal pizza & garlic rolls! Truly reminds me of NYC style. Everything tasted super fresh & homemade and the prices are great! The staff are super friendly as well. Highly recommend!
Extremely friendly, the garlic honey wings were amazing, so yummy. Pizza is also very good, nice and saucy. We have found our new pizza spot for sure!
Went to ray rays originally, walked in and got very rude responses, walked over to Peters ny pizzeria and got excellent customer service! The food was great! Very polite and respectful! Highly recommend
Peter's has the best pizza in the area, hands down! I've been a customer for more than 20 years. Fresh ingredients, homemade sauce and dough. You won't be disappointed.
I came here on a very hot day to get food. The food is great! The owner/workers are very friendly, and we had my dog with us. He just brought out water for the pup and even folded the tin bowl so my pup wouldn't get cut!
We tried this pizza shop while staying in nearby Port Bay, and it is amazing! The crust is absolutely perfect, and it's the best pizza I've had on vacation.
Had a really amazing time! My friend brought her dog and he was given some water because of the weather, we had a really good interaction and general overall experience! Not to mention the food is really really good! Amazing on a nice day
Great service, good prices and amazing food! Such nice people!
I live in Rochester and travel frequently around the nation for work, so this place isn't always the easiest for me to get to. But I do my best to get in as much as I can because this is hands down the best pizza anywhere I've been. I've yet to have a bad slice here. Even the crust is amazing - I usually give my crusts from other places to the dogs, but not from here. I've haven't tried everything on the menu but I'm making my way through it every chance I get. Definitely recommend this place, even if you have to go out of the way to get it. Worth it, I promise.
We were looking for a good spot to get dinner on our way from Lake Placid to Rochester. After looking at the reviews we decided this was the place and we were not disappointed. The portions are generous, the prices fair and the atmosphere unbeatable. The owner treated us like we were friends stopping by and we had a great chat about the Yankees. The food tasted just like New York City and if I am ever this way again I will be coming by for more!
This is the best pizza I ever had. We all loved this place. Will be stopping by every time we come to town.
I’ve been coming here since I was a little kid and Joey and Sal always treat me as well as anyone I bring along as family. They’re always willing to talk and brighten your day.
friendly service. great food!!! awesome personalities. love this place!!!
It is all great here. They make the best pizza. LOVE :)
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes