"Came today while visiting the cute quaint downtown of Zionsville for the first time today and stumbled upon this gem. Sugar cream pie is a childhood..."
Amy Hineman
"I "happened" in to this little shop due to being in town for a wedding. Can I just say WOWZER!! The pie (sugar and dutch apple) were just..."
Terri Guisewite
"The absolute best Sugar Pie you'll ever eat. Filling is sweet and creamy, crust is perfectly baked. Make sure you order way in advance for..."
Debbie Gibson Kauffman
"The best pies I’ve ever had! We especially love the sugar cream pie!..."
Allison Anderson
"This is my favorite place in Indiana. Happened to stop in here one day by chance, now I am always looking for an opportunity to go or get a pie!! The..."
Heather Scover
"The Dutch Blueberry pie is amazing! The crumb topping is to die for! I definitely recommend My Sugar Pie. It is worth the splurge-in calories and..."
Abigail White
"Best cherry � pie we have ever..."
Krista McNeely
"Wow. Amazing!!! The Sugar Pie is unbelievable!!! Moms Original Apple Pie..."
Jennifer G Samelson Lehman
"Incredible! Best pie I've ever had. I have to mention the kindness of the employees too. It was my first time there and the service was..."
Brittney Gardner Paterson
"Keeps us coming back time and again. They are the best..."
Matt Scott
"Guaranteed the best pie you'll ever have! Don't miss out on the sugar..."
Carol Guthridge Banta
"I would like to thank the staff at My Sugar Pie for being friendly and very helpful, as I had brought my residents from The Hearth at Tudor Gardens..."
Kimberly Tedrow - Freitag
"the dutch apple & mixed berry are fabulous~ best pie around, hands down~..."
Shelli Norman Alter
"OH.MY.LANTA. NEVER had a better pie-not even grandmas! Simply amazing apple pie (and this is coming from a chocolate lover). I can't wait to try..."
Dori Gomes
"Had my first lattice strawberry pie as a birthday surprise today from my son and daughter in law. Beyond good! Off scale delicious! I had been..."
Debbie Reeves
"Stopped in today to order holiday pies. They were so busy, but so very kind! I also took two pieces to go, Hoosier Sugar Cream and Blueberry! We just..."
Stephenie Winn Franco
"We stopped to try out the pies since we saw it on the Food Network.
The raspberry pie was overly sweet, the chocolate chip pie was much better.
The..."
M A
"Ordered a banana cream pie. The best pie ever! Hands down next to commercial store bought. Fresh tasting, long lasting, and no soggy bottom after 4..."
Pamela Babbitt
"While in Indianapolis for a conference I wanted to try something local. Sugar Cream pie came up as a great option. During my research I came across..."
Stanley Lawrence Jr
"Went today for the first time and I have no regrets! Not only were the pies delicious(I got a slice of the sugar cream and a slice of the key lime),..."
Jas Am
"Easily the best Key Lime Pie ever, got it for my wife’s birthday! She’s from Florida and not easy to impress when it comes to key lime flavored..."
Wade Morgan
"Whenever family or friends are visiting from out of town, or for any special occasion really, we always bring home a pie from My Sugar Pie. Our..."
John Kosloskey
"I have tried almost every single pie here. All of them are delicious and they have a huge variety! When we decided that we wanted My Sugar Pie to..."
Casey Davidson
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes