The best Restaurants in Bellefontaine ranking of March 2025
73 restaurant menus in Bellefontaine, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"I was very happy with our experience. There was no eating in due to the pandemic, but we didn't mind.
We got our food to go, and ate out in our..."
Charity's Ghost
"I used a code from their app to get a free medium fry and free medium drink with the purchase of a quarter pounder with cheese. I did have to pull up..."
Jodi Patrick
"There are 2 ways to order which is nice but the food is only made right half of the time. (Like when you ask for no pickles they'll put pickles)...."
Sophie Fosnot
"The restaurant is less than 5 minutes from where I live. Also, I love using the app! It certainly comes in..."
"First time being able to go inside, order and dine in at this location in over 2 years. One thing DEFINITELY missing was the buffet, which the guy..."
Gerald Brown
"Friendly staff, great food and very fast drive through! One of the better KFC restaurants I've..."
Nathan Motter
"The drive through girl with braces sorry didn’t get to catch her name but she was very very helpful and very kind even after I forgot my drink and..."
William Shields
"Food order was correct and timely. Ordering process was slightly more difficult than needed but overall was just..."
Jaron Schmelzer
"Shortest wait time of any fast food place in town. Food is always fresh and crew is always friendly. On the negative- stay FAR away from KFC sauce..."
Joshua & Rachael Richards
"The food was good and the people at the window was..."
Earl Coffee
"The night manager was so nice here great place to..."
James Neeld
"These are the friendliest people I’ve had the pleasure of ordering from! Always polite and my order is always hot fast and..."
"People will often tell you a place has the best pizza it's great. or it is really really good. It really is as good as I was told it would be. I..."
Alan Doll
"Loved the garlic knots. All bread are very soft and fresh. Worth the drive from Columbus. Excellent ambience and friendly service staff. Location is..."
Mukul Pai
"Delicious pizza. We got the Montana with the Detroit crust and the garlic knots. Highly recommend both. We had a local wine from Dragon Fly winery...."
Tom T
"Man, I thought I had had good pizza before but I had never had pizza this good. Wide expansive menu and something for anyone’s taste. Pizza is..."
Lucas Keeran
"I have heard so many people rave about this restaurant, but today was the first I had the opportunity to try in. The pizza crust and knots tastes..."
Lisa Mead
"Ordered the Americana Detroit style pizza for date night , and let me tell you this is about as close to perfection Detroit style pizza can come...."
Tony Rea
"Yummy food and fun atmosphere. A little dark in the back eating area, though. One server jumped in when ours went missing for a bit, helped us, was..."
"Cheap pizza if you need a bunch in a pinch. Another restaurant forgot our catering order for a funeral dinner, so I called them for 10 pizzas. Got..."
"Delicious food.
They mopped the floor while people were coming in to order. It might be a little slippery for some older folks.
But I appreciate it..."
Judith Vassar
"I go to this Subway quite a bit. It is farther for me but the one on Main Street doesn't allow customers inside. I like to watch my subs being made...."
Brent Byrd
"Very good service and one of the cleanest Subways I've been to in a long..."
Jonathan Neeld
"Nice that it has the ability to dine in. Always prefer this Subway over the one on main St. Food was excellent and got through the line in a fair..."
Jordan Walker
"The subs here are fast and yummy! The inside is open luckily and the cookies are..."
Sophie Fosnot
"So I was refused service at Subway because I didn't have a mask on. Anyone that knows me knows I usually always have my mask on. Well this was a spur..."
"Always loved the Asian Chicken Salad. Was REALLY craving it tonight. . . For some reason, they didn’t grill the chicken like usual (looks broasted)..."
Johanna Bowsher
"Enjoyed a great dinner on the patio! Pictured here is a cucumber collins with vodka and a fried bologna sandwich with a warm pretzel bun!..."
Mark
"Ordered the French Dip Au Jus ( Prime Rib Meat). It was incredibly delicious. Comes with a huge pickle spear and chips. I can't wait to go back again..."
Dave223
"This place is super cool! Came memorial weekend with my boyfriend and we stopped in Sunday afternoon for early dinner…our waitress (Aubrey!) was..."
Katelyn Clark
"Decided to take a little road trip for lunch over the long Labor Day weekend. Hopped on Google and found this place, picked it based on reviews and..."
Linda
"Love the atmosphere, awesome for events, beer is like rolling dice. Always something new to try if your into craft beer. Menu is good not a whole lot..."
Nick Dyer
"Great place! Drinks are pretty expensive and small but delicious. Food is fantastic. The pickles are amazing. Definitely would go there..."
Morgan Benoit
"Nice plce..we stopped in for lunch...had some business at Ben Logan HS. Best Fried Bologna Sandwich..."
"This DQ is exceptionally better than the one at the Lake. They have friendly employees and even though they are busy all the time no matter if you go..."
J Fizz
"A great DQ with friendly employees and speedy service! I have been here dozens of times and cannot recall a poor experience. If a mistake is made,..."
Caleb Burkey
"Every time I go the food is always fresh and the best employee attitudes I have ever experienced. Even though the line is always long, it moves..."
Cara gaines
"Great, very friendly staff and really..."
scott wheeler
"Fast service for always being busy. For the price of blizzards a little more toppings would be..."
Preston Rowley
"I got the carmal brown cheesecake blizzard it was too good very fast friendly..."
"Food was good (catfish chunks, sweet potato fries and fried mushrooms), service was good. Really enjoyed the Christian music in the background. Will..."
Cassandra Elliott
"Outstanding BBQ joint! Ribs were exactly as described, fall of the bone and they meant it! The Smoke flavor was so rich I didn’t even use the BBQ..."
andre spivey
"Thought it was just average when I went a couple if times 4 to 6 years ago , but friends encouraged me to give it another try, before a Holland..."
Jean Wright
"I had the catfish chunks, deep fried okra, deep fried mushrooms, and a pulled pork taco for lunch today...and I'm still full. The catfish was..."
Jodi Patrick
"Ordered 2 pork tacos and 1 rib. Everything was good, but I’m not a fan of all the lettuce on the taco. I think that good pork shoulder (which it..."
Logan Rowe
"I got take out ribs and catfish. Both excellent. My sides were Mac and cheese and baked beans. Very good Everything was hot and very good. I would..."
Patricia Ross
"Best catfish I have ever eaten. Their Mac and cheese is yummy and corn bread is delicious too. I've never had anything there I didn't..."
"Hands down the best fish Sandwich at any fast food joint. I’d put it up against some sit downs as well.
Staff is always..."
Ben K
"Food has always been great. Horrible drive thru service seems MUCH improved! Hope I didn't just happen to catch them at a "good time". I shall..."
highwayhua
"Tried their Deluxe Wagyu Burger. It was really tasty and juicy. Service was quite slow due to apparently short..."
Jeff Sammons
"I don't like a lot of the food here but the turkey sliders, chicken tenders and mozzarella sticks are very yummy. Their inside is always busy but the..."
Sophie Fosnot
"Big sandwich, curly fries, and a drink. Everything I've tried here has been..."
"I had the pulled pork meal with grilled veggies and a loaded baked potato for my two sides. I like to do that so I can take the potato home and make..."
Jodi Patrick
"Service was spot on. The beef burrito deluxe was good and finishing it queso gave the dish a bit of heat. The salsa could use a bit more..."
Gary Bishop
"Havent been to tumbleweed in years since the shutdown of my local one. This store more than made up for missed experiences. Family like service. Even..."
justin ginter
"Years ago, it was astounding that a chain sit down restaurant was going to Bellefontaine but this one has done well over the years. The food has..."
"Good pizza but have to pay for red pepper and parm, cheese extra were it should be free on the..."
Kenneth Patak
"The pizza was hot and fresh and got here in under 30 mins. There was toppings in every bite. Cayden Z. Was professional when delivering the pizza...."
brian mcpherson
"Always have loved pizza hut. Not sure how my orders get done so quick but they are always..."
Kevin Henry
"Professional and friendly young man! Suggestive items yes I bought😋 super great service and..."
Kathleen Mikes
"I ordered our pizzas 2 hours ahead of time to be ready at 4:30 and they were not ready till 4:37. Normally it would be no big deal but there was a..."
Texan Salad with Crispy Chicken Tenders It's Fantastic
Wedge Salad
Burger
Buckeye Pretzel Bites
Kids Chicken Tenders
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Tater Tots
Chicken and Waffles
Wings
Buffalo Wing
Pulled Pork
Quesadilla
Fries
Beef burger
Bar
Pub
American
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Gift Cards Available
Takeout
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Great local sports bar. Plenty of TV's with your favorite games on. Good music, healthy bar, good food. Was not there on a buckeye game day but could..."
Joe Kaufman
"I enjoyed my dinner at Irish City. The food was good, promptly served hot. The wait staff was friendly and attentive. I highly..."
Rodney Schilling
"They needed to have some more floor help. Especially since it was trivia night. It took awhile for thr waitress to take our order. The food was..."
Stacy Vance
"Awesome food and drinks. I enjoy coming here with family and friends. My favorite food is the Buckeye Bites and The Mac Attack burger.
Get it every..."
Chantelle
"Amazing burgers. I am particularly choosey when it comes to a burger. The ground beef was lean, full of flavor and perfectly grilled. Tots were an..."
"The ladies servicing our requests are really great, worked together, helped us. Now between the baked spaghetti or raviolis, the raviolis are way..."
Stephanie Jay
"Food is always hot, fresh and tasty. Service is ok but the window workers aren't very cheerful but I probably wouldn't be either with all the rude..."
Brian Phillips
"Purchased 2 Chicken Bacon Ranch Salads. And underneath the toppings was nothing but brown, old Lettuce. So, thanks for taking our money and..."
Sonya Mckee
"Excellent food and customer service. The staff was courteous and adjusted the meal, so my wife could eat.
Keep up the good..."
Eugene Duran
"Lizzie took our order and was super sweet and helpful. Then she brought our food out very fast, and it was excellent..."
"Limited, but TRUCK PARKING in back! The service was great, the Food was DELICIOUS! Even purchased a couple garden statues!! Family friendly, room for..."
Buddo Hood
"Really nice people. The food is good. Typical mom and pop menu. Homemade..."
KR M (KRM)
"The country fried steak and real mashed potatoes were amazing. The waitress was so fun and efficient were so glad we stopped. If you haven't tried..."
Becca Creque
"We had a really good meal here for lunch today. Staff was nice, it was quick and found homestyle items, I haven't seen forever. Kids meal portion was..."
Danielle McDonald
"The waitress was very nice and attentive. The food was blah and could have been cooked a little longer. I got the salmon patties and they were gooshy..."
"Great food, fast friendly service. Have driven to Bellefontaine on many occasions, simply to go to Waffle House. Those waitresses work their butts..."
Barbara Baum
"Andy ?can fry th best bacon at btown waffle house and th food is always great n it stays open 24/7always very welcome to sit n get a good..."
Lori Bray
"Ate at this restaurant Saturday morning. Was absolutely the greatest breakfast food and service we’ve ever received from a Waffle House. Gabrielle..."
Colt Blair
"This was our 2nd time at this location and both times the staff on duty was friendly and the food was served warm and good. Coming from Atlanta I..."
DJ Ron Burt
"It’s Waffle House, Food is Good, Staff Will Get You..."
Ben K
"Friendly staff. Great service. Prices are very good 👍. Food is very..."
"Going back home my daughter and I were hungry so we stopped in. Had a whopper Jr and some onion rings. Sure hit the spot. Thank you for being open..."
Lois Lowe
"Have had many average or below experiences eating in and/or driving thru this.. But tonite, it was EXCELLENT! I chose the drive-thru for dinner. The..."
"Best coffee.. Just wish Bellefontaine, Oh. Store was like it use to. I wish it was open later..And they had workers that cared more and wish the..."
Angel Early
"If you're in a hurry around 7am through the week just plan on sitting in line for 15 minutes for coffee. Most employees are great but a couple seem..."
Kevin Henry
"I love Tim hortons and I love their coffee, but I feel like it is hit-or-miss With this location and and the food and drinks. Every time I go there,..."
"Got the Three Alarm Burger, there has to be 1/2 lbs of beef on the bun. The meat was sweet and cooked perfectly. The added jalapeño, pepper jack..."
FGee
"Great burgers. Stopped by here for lunch while skiing at Mad River. The hamburger was a bit over cooked in my opinion, but still very good and I'd..."
10153015663092630
"Great hamburgers! We were in Bellefountaine anyway but would make the trip again just for..."
Carrie
"Great food. Love their burgers, salads and peanut butter..."
Pete G
"2nd time I have been here and I will return. Hamburgers are amazing. Fresh cut shoe string fries. Homemade shakes. Totally amazing. This time I..."
Pamela Johnson
"Hands down the best ribs and burger we have had since moving to Indian lake
The prices were well worth it the service was fantastic.
If you haven't ..."
Classic_ Peanuts
"Went today to check out furniture at Francis in Bellefontaine then my husband ask weres a good mom/pop to eat
Don's Downtown Diner you will not be..."
Deb Lycans
"Stopped in for lunch today. Decided to split the tenderloin sandwich with onion rings. The onion rings are huge, crispy on the outside with sweet..."
David Snyder
"Delightful visit! Bustling place and the food smelled so good and tasted even better!! I had the portobello burger. Honestly, the best hamburger I've..."
Cheryl Turner
"Great food. I even got a straw with my coffee and they have .05 cent hamburgers on sunday and..."
David Lawson
"Great service. Great food. I had the BLT and the hubby had the..."
Zandra Cox
"Best burger I've had in a long time! First time here, and was VERY impressed. Will definitely be coming back. They were very busy, but the servers..."
"This was our first time here since the move. We decided to get hamburgers and fries and shared an order if mushrooms. We also ordered a pizza and..."
Chelsea Chapman
"It really doesn't get better than this. All time favorite pizza place. Plus there's something for everyone. New location is super nice! This the one..."
James Mabry
"I had the large pepperoni pizza with the sweet sauce and the pizza was amazing as usual! I travel to Bellefontaine in order to get this pizza. It’s..."
Jayla Neal
"This by far my favorite pizza place. I love their sweet sauce. Anytime I am in Bellefontaine, it is a must that I stop at Vicarios’ Pizza.
Love the..."
Adrianne
"Really the best pizza of all-time. I've prolly had over 100 pizzas in my life (different styles, places, frozen, fresh). Nothing beats that sweet..."
"One of the best pizza places in Bellefontaine. We ordered 2 large pizzas and they were ready and waiting when I went to pick them up. If you get..."
Jodi Patrick
"I have always loved Donatos pizza. However I can no longer eat a traditional pizza crust. I ordered the cauliflower crust and it was fantastic. Great..."
andrea christenson
"The man over there don't pick up the phone no more I don't want to post this but I have to I like to order from this shop but get it..."
thariq aljahmi
"Been visiting this Donatos for a few years. Never a bad..."
David Milobar
"Nice group of people. Very polite , quick welcoming from the cashier. I ordered Big Don's sub. Ex meat and cheese and an Antapasta Salad , ten..."
"Love this place!!! I'll definitely go again! If you love a good biker bar dive like I do then go here! We were greeted at the door by the patrons of..."
Deron Martin
"We went to dinner & were pleasantly surprised with the food. The place looked very outdated & there were not many people there. The meals turned out..."
Sharon Doyle
"Best little restaurant EVER!!!! I took my 12 year old. It was our fisrt time going. I like the fact one side is the bar and the other side is the..."
Ariana Busbin
"First time here. Very good. All food was good. We had a sirloin steak, spaghetti, and a salad. Steak was cooked just right. Spaghetti had their..."
Jeffrey Himler
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes