The best Restaurants in Canisteo ranking of January 2025

7 restaurant menus in Canisteo, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Annie's
Annie's
88/100 (232 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
American
"First visit to Annie’s. Nice little place, on a busy corner. The food was good, they had some interesting specials. For dessert, Perry’s ice..."
Ana Lynn
"Looks and sounds like a good place!! May try it soon! 8/9/22 just tried this place, very delicious food!! I'm sad I didn't try this sooner..but will..."
Lindsey's videos Czworka
"Absolutely amazing place to eat with your family. They are very nice and friendly. Fast service and some if the best food around. A must to go back..."
Bucky's House
"Food is good. The visual of the restaurant is welcoming. Staff busy so perhaps that's the reason they aren't very talkative as I've never seen ore..."
DELICIA AMBROSINO
"This little hole in the wall is becoming a favorite! Their soups and asian dishes are amazing considering this isn't an area known for diversity in..."
Mark Guinan
"Amazing food, the best burger I’ve ever had, hands down. Different daily specials, Annie is a top notch chef. Beautiful dishes, highly recommended...."
Z C (Fae)
"Food is reasonably priced with great portion size. However I mostly go here for ice cream and so far I or the kids have never had any complaints or..."
Tommi Bragge
"I am OBESSED with Annies Sriracha Chicken Sanwhich and Garlic Parm Fries!! Any chance I get I always go there to get it. I'm hooked! Staff is always..."
Miranda Ann
"What a find. Best tacos I had in a long time. Quick service. Place is so clean it sparkles. I will be back for more Tacos and to try the delish..."
Ulrike Koehler
"Great place to eat! We order take out regularly and they never..."
Emily Evingham
"Annie's is a great place to eat at, takeout, or have delivery from. Everyone that works there is extremely nice. The food has always been spot on...."
Bryan Gamache
"Food is fresh and delicious, staff very friendly. Garlic parmesan ff yum! First time there will be back. Not fancy just..."
Sharon Green
"The Tom's Top Dog is great. First of all it's a quality meat dog, then there's cheese and hot peppers layered on top. But the best is the addition of..."
Lorna Fernandez
"Annie has incredible food!! Great variety on the menu and fresh, home cooked meals! Great choices for breakfast, lunch and..."
Lydia Sweatt
"Great little spot. Good combination of traditional diner food and chef's creations. Prices are very reasonable and the food is delicious. Try the..."
Brendan Ceglia
Nikk L Brew
Nikk L Brew
87/100 (146 ratings)
Restaurants
Dinner
Lunch
Dinner
Lunch
"This place is my go to for wing night. Always on point and cooked to..."
TheChad
"Great place to go. Good food. Good..."
Jason Aultman
"Great fish fry. The fish was soft and great tasting. Fries were better than most places now a days. Service was very friendly and quick. I'm..."
Dawn Shattuck
"5 Stars because the 1 star comment from “Savannah” below was only made because her friend tried using a fake ID in this establishment. Great..."
Kerrigan Lisi
"I had my birthday dinner here,,tha kyou Christine one great..."
Crystal Hilton
"Great food and service. I had a reuben skillet that was excellent! Returned for dinner. Food is..."
Valerie Nixon
"Good food good..."
Terry Billings
"Good food, decent prices and..."
Paul Adams
"Our family had a large group go to dinner on a Wednesday night. The service and food was..."
Tara Soesbee
"This is a great place to meet up with friends and share a meal. Book a party. Have a drink and quick bite to eat. Love the owners. Bring the..."
Brad & Kim Herrington
Big Papa's Restaurant
Big Papa's Restaurant
88/100 (137 ratings)
Restaurants
Dinner
Lunch
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Got fish fry, which was absolutely awesome. Also got few different burgers for rest of the family and they were absolutely amazing. Even the kids..."
Tommi Bragge
"Food was very tasty and delivered in a timely manner. Service was a little slow but we did go as a group of 20+ people all at once and only one..."
Patrick Meagher
"Its not the honest conversations with the staff. Its not Big Papa's owner Chris's delicious signature beer battered haddock. Its the feeling you get..."
Le Icon
"Fish fry was well above average, they were great about all our special orders...didn't have time for dessert as it was so close to close, but..."
Seana Gloss
"Haddock fish fry was incredible. Restaurant was clean, staff was..."
MaryBeth Fuhrman
"Excellent food awesome service great..."
james howard
"The food is still as I remember it 20 year's ago...mmmm..."
Matthew Hodge
"Great food. Friendly staff. Awesome prices. Definitely worth the..."
Matthew Lamb
"Ver good food, friendly waitress, didn't have to wait long for food, coffee great and was hot, not luke..."
Beverly Risley
"Had the Buffalo chicken wrap today with some blue cheese dressing. Outstanding! Wonderful service, too...."
Tim Allen, Sr.
"Not much to choose from up there but this place is always good. It's small and only a few people run it but I always..."
Mike M
"Great food allways service excellent best fish fry in..."
Ray Ciche
"Excellent food service,great..."
Matthew Hodge
"Food is great and the staff is..."
Matt Stillman
"Food was good and showed up..."
schuyler becker
"Best food around,friendly..."
randy carl
Subway
Subway
77/100 (73 ratings)
Restaurants
Deli
American
Deli
American
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
American
Deli
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
"This Subway has come a long way in customer satisfaction and service. Their food is always fresh and the bin’s displayed are full of ingredients...."
Robert David Patton
"For a franchise, I don't think I could ask for a better store. The staff are helpful, friendly, and a sense of humor to boot. I stop in here..."
jeff watkins
"Service was fast and accurate. Gentleman was friendly. Yummy ham and cheese sub. Oooh I want another..."
Karen M
"Depending on what you get if you're looking to save money...but the subs and ciabattas are delicious!! 😋😋 and also, if you get coupons you can..."
Lindsey's videos Czworka
"Overall great service... even better than the same name in local..."
Tabitha Emo
"The place was clean and the tables. The guy that made my subs he did..."
Bonnie Dubois
"This gas station always has everything I need before I go anywhere so no issues there for..."
Alix Simmons
"Chicken back ranch sub with some chipotle and ranch is amazing definitely get it toasted. Service is amazing. Always a great..."
Angel Hargrave
"Food was good. Staff was..."
Paul Adams
"They have changed the menu, it's even better than..."
Tom Jarus
"Love subway breakfast sandwiches. Steak egg and cheese on flatbread with onions jalapenos and extra..."
Tim Decker
"It's in a gas station but there are tables you can sit down to eat at. Crew isn't attentive but they're all..."
Mike M
"I couldn't say which was better the food or the service, and I don't get the say either one about fast food very..."
Granny Monster
"Stopped here on the way to see..."
Marion Howard
"Love Subway subs, great people and great subs & you make it your..."
Linda Potter
"Friendly staff and food is always..."
Michael Mcintyre
"..."
James P Schieder
"Friendly staff. And good..."
Jake C
The Corner Cafe
The Corner Cafe
81/100 (44 ratings)
Restaurants
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
"Had a pretty good meal having lunch with a friend this past week. The service was friendly and on point. If I am in the area again I will be sure to..."
Mark Lewis
"This is no longer called The Corner Cafe. It is called Annie's now and it is the best burger and fries in..."
Robert David Patton
"I love the creativity of the Taco Tuesday specials...."
TracyLyn Smith
"Super friendly service and excellent I've..."
Scarlett Kernan
"Annie's is the best food..."
Robert Damato
"Always a good meal and good..."
Scott Hassan
"Okay, good service and..."
Randy Rugenstein
"Good little..."
Shane Jackson
""
Charley Boyd
""
Howard Kemp
""
Acrj81
""
kilbrew
""
Joe Haner
""
Darrell York
Canisteo Pizzeria
Canisteo Pizzeria
70/100 (35 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Pizza
"We are from out of town and got in to Canisteo just before they closed. They stayed open a little later than they planned to make dinner for us after..."
Jeff Loucks
"Was passing through on the job and someone mentioned this place, so I stopped. The pepperoni and the chicken wing pizza was delicious. Best pizza /..."
Jared Bennett
"Awesome pizza and salads. Antipasto with house dressing is absolutely awesome. Chicken wing pizza was pretty much perfect. Pizza crust was cooked..."
Tommi Bragge
"Had a really nice time with some friends in a cozy atmosphere. The food was good, would definitely..."
Daniel Meese
"Went there for lunch before going to an appointment and the slices I had were delicious, the bleu cheese I dipped my chicken wing pizza slice in was..."
Rocky Drew
"Absolutely love their food service is excellent food is amazing and price is excellent definitely recommend them glad we have another pizza 🍕 shop..."
mary brewer
"Pizza is delicious! The establishment is clean! The price is right and we've always had service with a..."
Susan
"Great food and service. Happy to hear they travel to hornell. I haven’t had anything that wasn’t delicious..."
Lynn White
"I can't speak on all the food here, but the calzones are the best around...."
Adam Freberg
"Great People and great service - crew enjoyed the pizza and wings. TY and keep up the good..."
Jason Krenichyn
"Food and service are excellent. They promptly delivered wings, pizza and subs. Everything was..."
Bob Nixon
"I love the house dressing,the pizza and wings are spectacular,thankyou..."
Crystal Hilton
"Awesome pizza &..."
Dennis Ennis
"Great pizza. Great..."
Israel Carpenter
"The pepperoni pizza was..."
Fred Greenthal
"Old fashioned pepperoni is the..."
Robert David Patton
"Excellent food and..."
Nikita Gee
"..."
Tyler G23 Grove
"Yummy..."
Karen Dinan