"Ate dinner here for the first time last night. They have the best pizza ever so when I ordered I expected nothing less, and they didn't disappoint. ..."
Charles Hagemeyer
"By far this is the best pizzeria place ever. Great prices and great service. Everyone is so friendly.. I love..."
Chris Plume
"Always the best pizza and more! Don’t underestimate CG..."
Lloyd DesBrisay
"By far the Best place to eat on the grove. Good food and reasonable prices to say the..."
Joe Poggiogalle-Poggs
"The best pizza on Fire Island. The Eggplant Rolitini slice is my favorite and also the chicken parm slice
The heros are delish. The specials are..."
Susie Tmay
"This little gem never disappoints. Great food service & outdoor dining. Frank is a sweetheart always giving & doing for the community. I crave their..."
Stella Anna
"Best food on the island. Great service. You will not be..."
Irma Ruiz
"Excellent food, from slices to weekly speciality entrees, you can't go wrong. The staff is like a part of your extended Italian family - all are ..."
"A staple of Cherry Grove food spots. Open late for great pizza and other italian fare. (The spaghetti was exactly what my over-partied body..."
Ian James Roberts
"Always good pizza. We were so hungry we forgot to take pictures od the food. They have great spealcials all..."
Gregory Barbera
"There is something very comforting about this place. The casual atmosphere and plastic utensils are almost nostalgic. The pizza and food were really..."
Luke Miller
"BEST pizza on fire island hands down. It’s worth it to go to cherry grove for this pizza over the pizza in the pines. I love the triple chocolate..."
Wall Fish
"Our server Michael is so attentive and kind. I the pizza is amazing every single time without fail whether you sit down or take it to go or even..."
Jeame Marroquin (Jm21photo)
"Pizza was amazing. Generous portions and topping. Meatballs where great. Staff is very attentive and fun/nice. Ate here..."
mike north
"Me and my gf LOVE the pizza rolls – fresh, garlicky spinach and pepperoni, seasoned to perfection, with a tangy, sweet, and scrumptious marinara..."
Sammy Grob
"If your at Cherry Grove ocean walk in Fire Island, Cherry Grove Pizza is the place to go. I greeted by the really nice waitress, who had a smile the..."
Giovanni Amador
"The waitress was very nice and the service was excellent. We had a great time as there was a wide variety of food to choose from. It was a great..."
David Gest
"Amazing pizza! The garlic knot crust was very good. Will definitely come..."
Kristina Garcia
"Everyone was very friendly and kind will come back with..."
Panda Asterfield
"Bacon cheeseburger pizza is it!! Also AJ was a great worker , very fun and respectful!! Can’t wait to come..."
Billy TheBanned
"Cozy pizza shop with great service and delicious pizza! Definitely recommend the garlic knot pizza..."
Darya Ivanova
"This is the best pizza in NY! I go here every trip to fire..."
Angela C
"Great spot in the heart of the Grove. You can see and hear all the 'goings on'.
Service is..."
John Galluzzi
"They sell by the slice if you don't want a whole pizza. It was very good and was thin crust..."
jay VB
"The food was amazing & our waiter Michael gave us fantastic service! I highly recommend this..."
Kenneth De Jesus
"The food was great and our server Mike was friendly and really knew how to handle a large group of..."
Matthew Incardona
"Tastiest meatball hero on Fire Island. Had greta service from..."
photohustler official
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes