Sluurpy
Reset

6 restaurant menus in %{citta}, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

The best Restaurants in Cherry Grove ranking of December 2024

6 restaurant menus in Cherry Grove, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Cherry's On The Bay
77/100 (496 ratings)
Browse the menu
Restaurants
Pub
American
American
Bar
Pub
Bar
Dinner
Lunch
American
Bar
Pub
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Just go. Especially for the drag show. Its never not a good time at cherrys!!! We had the best waiter Mo this past weekend and he made our experience..."
Amanda Terp
"Cherry's on the Bay ,On any boring day, it's just a ridiculously overpriced bar ... but go during a Drag show or a weekend night, and you'll have a..."
Numbahz
"What is there to say about Cherry's other than it is a long-standing Cherry Grove tradition and hot spot. From drag shows to great djs, there is..."
Ian James Roberts
"Love this place- all servers are amazing. Vibes are good. Very accommodating. Get the breakfast bowl. Only thing i would say is I wish they had more..."
Kay La
"Fun cocktails ! And their seafood bucket with linguine was incredible - definitely coming back for that..."
Géraldine Pettineo
"I can't say enough about the service. We had a large party with one small child. They did everything possible to make my niece feel welcome. The..."
Kenneth Clayton
"We ate there July 3, and were served by Greg, the Sexiest Man Alive! Shrimp were perfectly cooked. Salmon was delightful. Wine was great. Open air..."
Marian Plummer
"Regis was a fantastic server! And the food was..."
Timothy Smith
"5 stars ALL around for cherry’s and most of all for the FABULOUS Mo who took the best care of us!!! He truly made this experience above and beyond...."
Megan Linebarger
"After relaxing on the beach for an hour or so; we decided to take a walk to Cherry grove. We met two 4 legged cuties from Rochester and hit it off..."
Nilda “Esther” Nassauer
"It’s def a fun atmosphere. Good place to hang out with friends or for a bachelorette party. I had a rocket fuel which wasn’t the greatest and..."
Lynsey Smith
"Egg on a burger is the best thing after a night out. My party had it twice the whole week we were there & it was good both times. Drinks were great,..."
Deanna Calvacca (PumpkinPoet)
"We LOVE Cherry's on the bay. The food is always good, staff is friendly and kind, the atmosphere. What can I say..it's on the bay we watch the sunset..."
cathy fitzgerald
"Had a great time with friends and my wife for her birthday. Drinks were great! Food was mediocre but good for bar..."
Nathan Webb
"This place is a very gay place in summer. You combine a drug performance at night with the food. Take burger, chicken dinner or chicken palliard -..."
Sergii Starostin
Island Breeze
85/100 (358 ratings)
Browse the menu
Restaurants
American
American
Bar
Pub
Bar
Pub
Seafood
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Burger
Sit down
Bar
Pub
American
Seafood
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Outdoor Seating
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"The service was good and the views even better . Great outdoor and indoor space . Food was delicious. Will eat here again. The staff was friendly and..."
Chad Millard
"I was pleasantly surprised with food. Huge portions and very yummy, given the prices. Service was great and we had a great time with the mango..."
RAM IMAGERY
"Excellent Sunset View, Friendly Staff, we have eaten many times and have we've had just about every item on the menu, always a good meal. Danny and..."
John Steadman
"The view from this restaurant was excellent. We were seated right by the water. The food was really delicious and our waiter was exceptional. He went..."
nasha nicole
"What an amazing experience. I've eaten dinner there on many many occasions. All the menu items are absolutely delicious. The staff is super friendly..."
Michael Edward
"Had an incredible experience with wonderful service from a super nice dude (long gorgeous curly hair) while watching the sun set...."
Noam Landor
Cherry Grove Pizza
91/100 (223 ratings)
Browse the menu
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Pesto
Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza
Lasagna
Extra Cheese
Pasta with White Clam Sauce
Garlic Knots Pizza Slice
Pasta
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Late Night
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Ate dinner here for the first time last night. They have the best pizza ever so when I ordered I expected nothing less, and they didn't disappoint. ..."
Charles Hagemeyer
"By far this is the best pizzeria place ever. Great prices and great service. Everyone is so friendly.. I love..."
Chris Plume
"Always the best pizza and more! Don’t underestimate CG..."
Lloyd DesBrisay
"By far the Best place to eat on the grove. Good food and reasonable prices to say the..."
Joe Poggiogalle-Poggs
"The best pizza on Fire Island. The Eggplant Rolitini slice is my favorite and also the chicken parm slice The heros are delish. The specials are..."
Susie Tmay
"This little gem never disappoints. Great food service & outdoor dining. Frank is a sweetheart always giving & doing for the community. I crave their..."
Stella Anna
"Best food on the island. Great service. You will not be..."
Irma Ruiz
"Excellent food, from slices to weekly speciality entrees, you can't go wrong. The staff is like a part of your extended Italian family - all are ..."
Todd Michael Catanzano
"Best here or on the..."
Anthony Joseph
"Great Pizza , nice location, Staff esp. A.J. ,The..."
Stephen A Leonardo
"A staple of Cherry Grove food spots. Open late for great pizza and other italian fare. (The spaghetti was exactly what my over-partied body..."
Ian James Roberts
"Always good pizza. We were so hungry we forgot to take pictures od the food. They have great spealcials all..."
Gregory Barbera
"There is something very comforting about this place. The casual atmosphere and plastic utensils are almost nostalgic. The pizza and food were really..."
Luke Miller
"BEST pizza on fire island hands down. It’s worth it to go to cherry grove for this pizza over the pizza in the pines. I love the triple chocolate..."
Wall Fish
"Our server Michael is so attentive and kind. I the pizza is amazing every single time without fail whether you sit down or take it to go or even..."
Jeame Marroquin (Jm21photo)
"Pizza was amazing. Generous portions and topping. Meatballs where great. Staff is very attentive and fun/nice. Ate here..."
mike north
"Me and my gf LOVE the pizza rolls – fresh, garlicky spinach and pepperoni, seasoned to perfection, with a tangy, sweet, and scrumptious marinara..."
Sammy Grob
"If your at Cherry Grove ocean walk in Fire Island, Cherry Grove Pizza is the place to go. I greeted by the really nice waitress, who had a smile the..."
Giovanni Amador
"The waitress was very nice and the service was excellent. We had a great time as there was a wide variety of food to choose from. It was a great..."
David Gest
"Amazing pizza! The garlic knot crust was very good. Will definitely come..."
Kristina Garcia
"Everyone was very friendly and kind will come back with..."
Panda Asterfield
"Bacon cheeseburger pizza is it!! Also AJ was a great worker , very fun and respectful!! Can’t wait to come..."
Billy TheBanned
"Cozy pizza shop with great service and delicious pizza! Definitely recommend the garlic knot pizza..."
Darya Ivanova
"This is the best pizza in NY! I go here every trip to fire..."
Angela C
"Great spot in the heart of the Grove. You can see and hear all the 'goings on'. Service is..."
John Galluzzi
"They sell by the slice if you don't want a whole pizza. It was very good and was thin crust..."
jay VB
"The food was amazing & our waiter Michael gave us fantastic service! I highly recommend this..."
Kenneth De Jesus
"The food was great and our server Mike was friendly and really knew how to handle a large group of..."
Matthew Incardona
"Tastiest meatball hero on Fire Island. Had greta service from..."
photohustler official
Sand Castle On The Ocean
85/100 (222 ratings)
Browse the menu
Restaurants
Seafood
Seafood
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Clams
Tuna
Lobster Roll
Burger
Lobster
Salad
Sit down
Seafood
American
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Exceedingly, the preeminent place to dine on Fire Island! Executive Chef Noelle Grant exquisitely prepares each delectable dish with enthusiasm,..."
Karen Miletic
"I had a great experience with friends, staff (Ben) was on point and the bartender makes a mean dirty martini. The duck is a must have, delicious and..."
Joseph Flee Leechak Rodriguez
"Chef Noell returns with an all new menu and it is amazing! The staff is almost entirely new and they had it going on! Delicious! We enjoyed..."
Michael Manhattan Moran
"The creative and delicious menu by chef Noelle Grant is an amazing dining experience. Couple that with a staff that makes you feel like royalty and..."
Stella Anna
"Had the Fish SPECIAL on the separate menu. I think it was salmon with rosotto. Delicious and the wine selection paired perfect with our..."
Susie Tmay
"Amazing food & the best hospitality! 10 stars! A favorite! A must..."
Caroline Loevner
"The Sand Castle is all about Friday nights with the one and only Dan Daly....oh and the drinks, the view and the friendly staff...."
Arleen Kuzneski Farina
"Food and service was awesome!!! Lobster salad was amazing, view was astounding, and James our waiter was..."
Laura Anne O'Shea
"The staff is wonderful! Friendly people and delicious food. Also the view is..."
Brian Benjamin
"Friendly waiter. Dog-friendly. Right on the beach. Good food. Try the "Fire Island" frozen marguarita. Fun with..."
Gene Sower
"Tasty food. Fun drinks. Excellent service. Beautiful..."
Wil Schweigert
"The dining and bar experience have been very delightful this season. The food was delicious and Charlie and Rodrigo were courteous and professional...."
Julia Lydia
"Was an excellent dinner and view and host and waiter above..."
Christine Adrian-Paradee
"Bianco Donna'sThe Sand Castle on the Ocean had the most incredible Porterhouse Steak special this evening. Beautiful prepared by Chef Noelle Grant,..."
Micheál ScarpaBurnett
"Phenomenal service and Amazing Food. If your in the Grove you HAVE to go to sand castle for dinner. Drinks are strong but not too strong and the food..."
Nathaniel Larson
"A lovely place on the beach in Cherry Grove. I had halibut which was delicious. Nice views of the ocean. Attentive and friendly service. If you're in..."
Michael Lehrman
"Reliable place with good menu choices. Excellent service and atmosphere. The margarita was somewhat shy of alcohol, so the better bet is wine or..."
Janice F
"A solid place. My family enjoyed a nice lunch here. The burgers, fries, kale salad and tuna melt were good. Our waiter Brandon was wonderful. Also..."
Paul Vetrano
"Fabulous lunch and perfect cocktails!!!! We'll be..."
Thom Fogarty
"It’s a very cute sit down restaurant. The only restaurant that is right on the beach. For that alone it’s worth going to. The drinks were nice..."
Luke Miller
"My friend and I went for lunch yesterday. We both had the lobster roll and hummus appetizer. It was fresh and delicious. Extremely plentiful. I had a..."
Lisa Oddo
"Food so great!!! Wow yummy in my..."
Wall Fish
"The clams were just adequate. The service...ridiculous. The Pina colada....missing something. My expectations were low. They lived up to it. I..."
Todd Everett
"Awesome staff!!! Molly, PJ, Erin and Dan ROCK!!! The vibe is perfect (oceanfront), the food and drinks are spot on. A must when visiting the Grove..."
Steve Ostrowski
Top Of The Bay
82/100 (157 ratings)
Browse the menu
Restaurants
International
American
American
International
Dinner
Salmon
Ribs
Burger
Shrimp
Salad
Scallops
Sit down
American
International
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Dinner
Fine Dining
"We were there recently on June 30th and we had a superb dinner. It was a birthday celebration for myself and my boyfriend and I thoroughly enjoyed..."
Willam F Rasschaert
"Wow, wow, wow! The entire experience was spectacular! We got to see a gorgeous sunset over the bay right from our table. Our drinks (Blue Cheese..."
Erica Malave
"Honestly, one of the top 10 best meals I’ve had in my life, and it takes a lot for me to say that! Food was fresh, delicious, and an appropriate..."
Emily Larson
"Great restaurant! They are super accommodating for dairy and gluten allergies without compromising the taste for anything! Sooo delicious and the..."
Gabriela Ulin-Mejia
"We were very impressed. The quality of the food and drinks were top notch and the service was great. We got the truffle lobster Mac and cheese, beet..."
Luke Miller
"Cozy bistro with decent food great drinks and an unbelievable view. It's a bit of a splurge but treat yourself you'll enjoy..."
James B.
"Outstanding barkeep and waiters. Looking forward to returning soon. The food and drinks were quite good. Upon returning for the 5th or 6th time,..."
Kirsten Beck
"We’ve eaten at Top of the Bay for years. In fact, my husband and I met there on a quasi blind date 19 years ago. This past week we spent our first..."
John Langan
"Excellent staff, food, drinks. What more can I say. A *****..."
Scotty D
"Is it the finest dining experience ever? No. Is it overpriced for no good reason. Duh. But I don't know a better place to have a nice dinner in the..."
Michele Hamparian
"The best place for a cocktail and sunset viewing. They have a nice, if short, happy hour (buy one get one half off) from 5-6pm and if you stick..."
Er mo
"Great food, service and..."
Jared Henderson
"Wonderful ambiance and great option for fine dining on fire island. We had the rock shrimp, sea scallops, and roasted chicken. Everything was..."
Andrea Guerrero
"If u can get a table, this is the place you want to meet to..."
John Galluzzi
"The Braised Short Rib is absolutely on point.. fabulous service, fantastic view..."
William L Jones Jr
"Great atmosphere. Beautiful! Best meal I have had in years! Excellent service...."
Kelly Cutillo (KellyandJimmy)
Floyd's
91/100 (95 ratings)
Browse the menu
Restaurants
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Wheelchair Accessible
Seating
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Mid-range
"This is by far my favorite place for coffee/breakfast! Amazing Staff!..."
Cb Kirby
"I seriously come here EVERY morning when I am in Cherry Grove. I can't think of a better place to eat..."
Neil Chamberlain
"Fresh, good quality food served with a smile. Best way to start the..."
Tom Reidy
"Loved the food. Loved the staff. A great way to start my day in Cherry..."
Ray Santos
"Love it here my fav breakfast fresh and..."
Sandrye Matero
"Great hearty breakfast is Floyd's specialty. Fresh and wholesome ingredients... Owner takes pride in his cooking and quality. From $10 and up...."
Todd NYCity
"An enjoyable place to hang with friends/lover(s) to get some food to cure the hangover from last night. Also a good place to meet people of the..."
C Van Order
"I've been half way around the world and this is still my favorite breakfast and spot anywhere. Just a great relaxing place with great food and..."
Sean Colton
"Excellent place for Breakfast, Lunch - muffins & Cinnamon Rolls are the 'move'. Outdoor..."
John Galluzzi
"Busy, bustling, charming breakfast spot in the heart of town and a Cherry Grove institution for more than a decade! The signature Floyd’s..."
Ry
"Floyd's is the best place for breakfast by far. The service is great the people are great. My favorite is the breakfast sandwich which is the Floyd..."
Robin Byrd
"Outdoor seating to watch the world go by, and excellent food, make Floyd's a place not to be missed when visiting Cherry Grove. Try Floyd's Famous..."
Jill Navarra
"Great place for breakfast. The atmosphere is friendly and relaxed and the food is good. A little automation in the ordering process wouldn't hurt..."
Mike Dallas
"Their egg sandwich was very yummy. They ran out of muffins but they made more and held two for us to pick up..."
jay VB
"Brett and Stas work well together to make this a favorite breakfast stop. Creative menu with tasty items. Best is Floyd's Famous breakfast..."
Irma Ruiz
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use