The best Restaurants in Cicero ranking of January 2025
252 restaurant menus in Cicero, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"This is one of the most convenient locations for me. It’s on the corner of S. Bay and Circle Drive. I like that there are two entrances and exits...."
Christopher Demetrick
"I have been there twice in the last 4 days and both times they did a great job. Greeted immediately as I approached the Deli counter both Employees..."
K B
"Byrne Dairy a Syracuse legend, Sense 1933. A local store, hometown store whatever you want to call it, it's top notch all day and night, 5 stars. The..."
Timothy Mahyna
"Very clean gas station with great chocolate milkshakes! Whenever I visit NY, I go here to gas up and grab a..."
Spinner’s Reviews
"I always stop here for gas or quick groceries because its convenient and well stocked. Their sandwiches are really tasty as is the ice cream. Only..."
Alyssa Work
"Stopped at this location to use bathroom, get gas, snacks, & drinks while on a recent road trip. Store & bathrooms were nice and clean, gas prices..."
Virginia “Gin” Monaghan
"I love their breakfast pizza though it is inconsistent, sometimes you get way too much crust. I haven't really ordered other food from this location...."
Dan Chizz
"This is my local Byrne dairy. It is brand new. It is always very clean and well stocked. The byrne products are always great. The milk and coffee..."
Andrew Tousaw
"Greetings once again from stocked travelers.
Great friendly staff, dairy products, pizza and ice cream too with coffee.
Look forward to visit area..."
Irina Mockute
"If you're looking for a satisfying lunch the sandwiches, pizza, garlic knots are delicious. Coffee is great. Ice cream is refreshing on a warm summer..."
Dee
"I go here almost daily. Staff is friendly and pleasant. Four stars only because if its busy you can wait a while in line due to only one person on..."
S.M.
"This is my go to stop now. After the renovations the store is nice. Turning in and out is a little bit of a pain during busy hours but if you go down..."
"Love this place!! We went NYD and my partner got the Italian combo while I had a Buffalo Chicken sub with blue cheese and American (recommended by..."
Wolf
"On vacation, we were looking for something for lunch. We decided on subs, and JRECK popped up in our search. We're glad we went! The staff were..."
Rachel Anderson
"I love the freshness of the ingredients and that I could make adjustments as my order was being made. They don't try to hide anything. Very..."
Shelly Webster
"Jreck Subs is out place a steak sandwich. My wife and I go when we have an urge for a steak sandwich. Rolls are exceptional, soft and flavorful...."
Grandpa Jimmy
"Excellent experience at this location! I was greeted immediately by the friendly staff. I also had all my questions answered promptly and kindly,..."
Wil Collins
"Hit or miss. Depends who you get.
We went 1 week on Tuesday and they made our subs phenomenal.
Due to the delicious sub, we went back the next..."
Jean S
"I've always had a very good experience at this location. The staff has always been kind, friendly and very good. I recently used the new online..."
Andrew Witherell
"The secret really is in the roll as they say. I really like Jrecks..."
Alan Smith
"Understaffed as always, young dark haired girl, very good at her job and very easy on the eyes.. she is definitely a rock..."
Jesse James
"Love that I was able to find a Jreck Subs! The staff was very..."
A Mulvaney
"Delish sub, the hot pepper relish was..."
Ronnie “Ron” Marston
"The staff is friendly and helpful, and the restaurant is clean. Jreck Subs is one of my favorite sub places to go. Their bread is always fresh here..."
Bill Robinson
"I got the steak and onion peppers sub, an it was AWESOME!! I love them girls they did a amazing job an it was my first time eating there. 5..."
Krystal Burchard
"Man, I just LOVE Jreck subs. Its nothing fancy, its kind of a stark environment and they ALL look the same. No BS, no nonsense, just really good subs..."
Corey C
"Drex is a number one fast food sub sandwich family oriented best service in necessarily everyone should..."
"This location (Cicero) does their best every time! They are fast, courteous, and accommodating. The inside is clean and comfortable. Nice spot to..."
S Jobin
"As great a Dunkin’ as you could ask for. Food and drinks are on par for Dunkin. Easy on/off the highway and always fast, regardless of the..."
Renata Porter
"What can I say? I love Dunkin'! The staff are great! This location actually know how to make a iced latte. Hope they keep the cold foams and butter..."
Tmoney
"Decent Dunkin. I’ve had pretty good and fast..."
Scott Evans
"I ordered just a plain coffee this morning and Debby was the sweetest woman I had ever spoken to. She made me feel special, even though it was 5:30..."
Kayla Miller
"Mariah at this location did a fantastic job! During my visit you could tell things were getting fustrating. She handled it very well while wearing a..."
Kaitlyn Lambert
"Every time I have came in this week. Arry has made my coffee perfectly everytime! She does it with a smile and is very kind and professional. Thank..."
Cody Voll
"This place is great other than crabby MC crab cake that works the drive-thru she's the older lady that seems to have an attitude with everybody now..."
Ron Casselman
"Small, quiet with an interestingly accessible inside dining area. Close to the highway for easy pitstops. Crew is hard working and stays upbeat even..."
"Very taste treats and food. The natural juices are always enlightening. Wish they can have a more specific menu. There's alot of pictured items I..."
Danny Aguilera
"This place always seems to amaze me the delicious and authentic Mexican food and the daily fresh yogurts with fruits it's always a pleasure to take a..."
The Freight Genius
"Love the place! Very tasty and creamy ice creams. Churros are nice too! It's a fun place, with all their exciting flavors and..."
Srinath Kuntipuram
"Staff is on top of everything here
Fast pace
Food is good
They are nice 👌
Decent space to sit and enjoy
But lose points for the area
Shady..."
"This location (Cicero) does their best every time! They are fast, courteous, and accommodating. The inside is clean and comfortable. Nice spot to..."
S Jobin
"As great a Dunkin’ as you could ask for. Food and drinks are on par for Dunkin. Easy on/off the highway and always fast, regardless of the..."
Renata Porter
"What can I say? I love Dunkin'! The staff are great! This location actually know how to make a iced latte. Hope they keep the cold foams and butter..."
Tmoney
"Decent Dunkin. I’ve had pretty good and fast..."
Scott Evans
"I ordered just a plain coffee this morning and Debby was the sweetest woman I had ever spoken to. She made me feel special, even though it was 5:30..."
Kayla Miller
"Mariah at this location did a fantastic job! During my visit you could tell things were getting fustrating. She handled it very well while wearing a..."
Kaitlyn Lambert
"Every time I have came in this week. Arry has made my coffee perfectly everytime! She does it with a smile and is very kind and professional. Thank..."
Cody Voll
"This place is great other than crabby MC crab cake that works the drive-thru she's the older lady that seems to have an attitude with everybody now..."
Ron Casselman
"Small, quiet with an interestingly accessible inside dining area. Close to the highway for easy pitstops. Crew is hard working and stays upbeat even..."
"They have great pizza at very reasonable prices. You can’t go wrong with a party size for your gathering. Great customer service..."
Edwin Arcos
"Pizza was good for the price better then other ones nearby, it was hot and fresh as it should. Got the 2 mediums and my soda for free so go for it..."
Jassie Jay
"Good pizza, reasonable..."
Jellybean
"This is a really good pizza..."
Tizoc Garcia
"Great pizza.. Customer service has also improved!..."
"good delicious food the b3st i have taste in cicero berwing and litle village in chicago...just be careful when you order to go,check all you order..."
"I love this place it very friendly the stuff are so kind the food was delicious. The service was so amazing and so professional with their service...."
Dominique Hermida
"Food tasted like it was just rushed to be cooked. A very, very noisy..."
Danielle Sr.
"My Wife and I had lunch with my Parents at this new location. It was a pretty good time. The restaurant was clean and neat. Staff was professional,..."
Raymond Ramirez
"Better quality than even my fondest memories as a fat kid at Old Country Buffet. Surprisingly good buffet-quality beef stew, shrimp, catfish, mac and..."
Jesse Wu
"Everything was clean good best one I have been too yet the wait staff that gets the drinks and clears the tables wasn't great but that was ok cause I..."
"Beautiful lakefront restaurant with fast friendly service. Seating can be indoor or outdoor and when we went, they even had live entertainment. I had..."
bobbie manns
"A friend from work turned me on to this place. I ordered the riggies and was not disappointed. The quality of the service is really good for the..."
Bhalinder Singh (Balwin)
"Best view around, really can't beat it. We had Melissa as our server, she was very good. I'd definitely recommend asking for her.
We got the..."
Jeff Brown
"Former Borio’s, but new management and name. Great location on the water, I imagine it’s beautiful in the summer. It was cold and rainy out but..."
Keith H
"A great place to go to have a good deal and enjoy a beautiful view. We've been at many weddings or parties here, and they do a fantastic job. You..."
Marshall
"Went for first time, dinner was very good. Husband had riggies and I had clams linguine. Both were very good. Lemon cake and peanut butter chocolate..."
"Our family was on the way to lights on the lake. We decided to grab some coffee and donuts while enjoying some Christmas lights. It was 20 minutes..."
Christopher Bohm
"I prefer this Dunkin, close to home and they always get my order..."
Dan Martin
"The cashier was amazing! We were confused on a drink and she took the time to explain and then even offered us a discount for being confused. She..."
Tanya Siddle
"One of the more comfortable dunkins. Would be awesome if they had a fireplace like..."
Shane Sloan
"I usually got to this location on the way to work with my wife and I got to say, the morning staff never misses a beat! The oder is always right and..."
L Cruz
"I would like to give a shout-out to Derek at this location. He’s always on top of his game and making sure the customers are satisfied. Including..."
Nicole C
"Even though I love Dunkin the breakfast tacos aren't worth getting but the pic advertised makes you want it .And I've seen people get upset over it..."
Walter Edwin Vanderzee Jr
"Well they got the orders correct on the first go round,so that's really saying something! Dunkin Donuts is still in my opinion very over priced. $13..."
Jessi Conley
"Most of the morning guys are amazing, I don’t think Naomi should be on the drive thru in the morning rush the wait when she does is absolutely..."
S S
"Good late. Nice girl prepared..."
Mar T
"We frequent this store at least 3 times a week. usually early afternoons Tony greets my wife! & I at drive thru with energy & clarity! The ofder is..."
"This place is so fun! Lots of flavors to choose from both for the bulk tins and the individual specialty bags. Very friendly staff who let us try..."
Emily Seabrook
"Good selection of flavored popcorn. There was also a selection of pre-bagged drizzles and such, but I opted for my tried-and-true caramel corn, which..."
Ernest Pergrem
"Such a hidden gem! Wandered in and fell in love. The popcorn is so fresh and delicious with an amazing variety. We tried a couple and all had our..."
Shannon Renckens
"Lots of choices of popcorn, even basic popcorns like carmel corn have a few verities. Staff was friendly and knowledgeable about their products. Bit..."
Mews Snep
"Everyone there is very helpful and friendly. The popcorn flavors are unique and fun. For a baby shower game we played "Looks who's ready to POP"..."
Jill Welsh
"This is where I come for the best gourmet popcorn for gifts. They even give samples to wet your..."
Gary Woodward
"I went there with my daughters and we bought the small bags of the gourmet popcorn. So yummy! My hubby loved it and wants more. When I'm out that way..."
Mary Bliss
"What a gem of a novelty popcorn company! We received a lovely gift basket with three different bags of Kandied Kernel popcorn. The flavors are..."
Linda K
"I don't live in NY anymore, but my mom facetimes me and picks out popcorn to send (I know there's a website but this is more fun.) The employees are..."
Tatiana G
"First I need to say that I am not a huge popcorn fan. To me it is just too bland of a snack.... but that being said, I LOVE THIS PLACE! I never knew..."
Amy Fox
"Kandied Kernel, best popcorn in CNY and now they carry CBD infused pretzels, popcorn as well as various tinctures and salves. A great place for pain..."
Elizabeth Moldenhauer
"Wonderful shop!!! So many flavors to choose from and all were very fresh. I'm so glad I was told about this place. I will for sure be going..."
Melissa Maciejko
"Great selection of gourmet popcorn. Always new flavors to try. One of our favorite places to visit for a snack. Love the "Kuse..."
Gary Hatashita
"I admit, i go here often! Trust me....youll like it. Buffalo Blue, White Chedder, Chedder, Dill and tons of other flavors. Great place to go before a..."
Mike Deapo
"Amazing homemade ice cream.
Incredible selection of gourmet popcorn.
Very limited hours. 5 stars if they were open..."
Mark Noble
"Amazing selections and taste is absolutely amazing as well. Went to buy some on a Tuesday, they are open until 6:00 and I was there at 5:30 but they..."
Abby Medve
"Best popcorn place ever!! Awesome staff and so many yummy..."
Matteo Russo
"Love love my neighborhood popcorn spot..So many unique flavors!! I ordered Cheddar popcorn Ale..."
"Love this place! This is my son's favorite pizza place and hang out! Great food and great staff! Couldn't ask for a better place to get your pizza!!!..."
Jennifer Repko DelPriore
"Pizza and wings were great! Recently moved to Cicero and have tried all the pizza places around the area. Lakeshore pizza is hands down the best!!..."
Marlayna Catanzarite-Salz
"Definitely the best pizza in the area. The staff is great and the owner is a solid..."
Laurie Burlingame
"Easily the best pizza in cicero. And better than most of..."
AJ Marrone
"Just moved near to this pizza place we had wings and pizzas it as delicious my family enjoyed it its gonna be a regular spot I can even walk to..."
Tanica Greene
"My favorite is pepperoni but the white pizza is great too! Now I'm..."
Bill Nickal
"Delicious! Thanks for letting us sit at your picnic table, it was a beautiful night to eat..."
Tracy Zimmer
"Absolutely amazing service and food! Never disappointed. Great work..."
Stephanie Lynne Warner
"Just had med pizza ... Mushrooms, sausage, onion with extra crispy med wings THE BEST all of it THANK..."
Peggy Hewitt Phinney
"Awesommme Pizza...!
Perfect Wings...!
The Best Staff Ever...!
Top Shelf Home Made at Neighborhood Prices...!
These are Good People making Excellent..."
Damian Roberts
"Really awesome pizza and wings this place is really..."
Jordan Jaeger
"Stopped by there last night for the first time since we moved away from Cicero a few months ago.... it was INCREDIBLE as always. If you live in..."
Laura Nelson
"Great pizza & Fast delivery..."
Laura Hulsizer
"Meat lovers pie was incredible..."
Michael Anderson
"Absolutely the best pizza I have ever had. The staff is great! Only place I will order..."
Jennifer Town
"Great pizza, Great wings, Great place to eat in Cicero..."
Chad
"The best pizza in Cicero. 'nuff..."
Josh
"We went on recommendations from a friend. The owner and staff were very friendly. I was impressed, I called before they even opened. They took my..."
Maryel Briggs
"We moved to Cicero about two and a half years ago. I've known about Lakeshore pizza close to 10 years as my friend has lived in Cicero for many..."
Joshua Dunham
"Delicious....a New York style Pizza local. The crust was perfect, lightly salted and just thin enough to hold up the cheese and toppings. This place..."
Thomas Hayduk
"Excellent pizza and wings. Great service and delivery is..."
tripwire
"One of my favorite pizza joints. I enjoy just about every kind of pizza from here. The wings are also very tasty. I will say that you get what you..."
Noah Poirier
"Pizza was good and unlike any sardos pizzeria near you their chicken wings were cooked PERFECTLY. Had a great special for 3 pizzas and 48 wings for..."
George Samson
"A hidden gem. The pizza is amazing and great service. Prices are also very..."
Regina Petrera-chiarizia
"This place is unreal ! I love to go to Buffalo for pizza logs and I have been trying to find something equivalent to Buffalo and I finally found it!..."
Lourese Davis
"Stopped by and ordered for the first time ever tonight. Definitely will be going back. Great pizza and the wings were cooked perfectly. Wings were..."
Chad Ryan
"Best pizza ever! Order almost every day and been ordering since it..."
SiimplyOcto
"Super friendly, and super yummy! Love that Lakeshore pizza is around the corner...we love it, and are lucky they're so close! My husband loves the..."
Blythe Gaming
"Best pizza in Cicero, hands..."
Rob Colvin
"We order often from Lakeshore...tonight there was a mix up...my order was for a pick up and when I got home I was missing my salad. I called and..."
Michele Perrin
"Have ordered at least half a dozen times now, and we are never disappointed. Theres hardly any grease to this pizza, which is a HUGE plus. Great..."
Daniel Andersen
"We ordered from Lakeshore Pizza tonight, our first time.... and man o man.....this is the best Pizza I have had in a long time!!! We were told the..."
CHERYL MEMORY
"Some of the best pizza in CNY. I order from there on a regular basis and it’s always on point. Every time I call the employees are polite and on..."
brian hammond
"Even though we have lived in the area for years this was our first experience. Great pizza and service. Will definitely order..."
Michele Rochkind
"I grew on Lakeshore road for me ist home no matter how far away I live the pizza is the best feels great to be home and have awsome food to, you will..."
"This is the BEST pizza king pizza we have ever had! The pizza is light and the crust tastes like real dough - proofed and airy! The breadsticks are..."
g burton
"Always excellent. Manager Joyce has her staff all on the same page and their service is very consistently too notch. Best Pizza King of those we have..."
Mike Major
"ONLY buy twice a year, prices crazy for thin pizza. We actually went to CICERO PIZZA KING, better deal from mgr, she was sweet! She hoped for our..."
Angie Bardwell
"I love pizza king! Been coming here since I was young and it still tastes just as great as..."
Jordyn Beck
"Awesome! There were 22 of us, 'each and everyone seasoned'. One waitress. She was fantastic! Always had a smiling face, didn't make us feel rushed...."
Sharon Starkey
"This Pizza King is wonderful! Joyce and her team always go the extra mile to ensure quality food and excellent customer..."
Stephanie Bramel
"Awesome staff and food. Always friendly and accommodating. Location is a quality pizza..."
Quinton Camp
"So the noblesville pizza king nearly ruined the brand for me. The pizza I had from there, more than once, was atrocious. For whatever reason, I..."
Jerry Mosbaugh
"Pizza was perfectly made. Hot and ready when I arrived for pickup. Pleasant cashier...."
David Pagel
"Best pizza king ever, manager really cares about her..."
Rookie Cookies
"Food was great - but the service was even better. The young man who took our order and the delivery guy were fantastic - polite and..."
Tasha LeMasters
"Just a chilly in here but food was great and service was great. And I will be..."
tim buckner
"Solid PK location. I will always be loyal to my hometown Marion Pizza King, but this is a very good location. Great service and a good amount of..."
David Culley
"Joyce is the best. Always friendly and remembers customers even though she’s..."
David Toll
"UPDATE 2023: Still the BEST pizza in CICERO!!! My girl Joyce still makes mine just PERFECT. ❤️❤️ I'll ALWAYS continue to order from y'all..."
ARKANJEL
"Absolutely love Pizza King. The "Washburn" is our go to. Washburn is a meat feast pizza with BBQ sauce instead of pizza sauce, highly recommend it...."
logan Blackford
"It’s hard to find good help right now. Every time I call in they are so kind on the phone. When I arrive I am greeted right away. Pizza is always..."
"This place has great food! I really love Italian Beefs, so if you are tired of Portillos, Pete's, Al's or any other place that sells beefs........."
LaShunda Shelby
"My first time going here I had the Italian sub and when I say it's delicious I mean it's deeeelicious I get one to eat there and one to go ........"
Markeley d Welds
"Had the italian sausage and fries....very good sandwich. Local resturant vibe very friendly..."
Chris Pacifico
"I have been ordering from Sarno's for 12 years. What I order most is the soup. I love the soup. I will always remember during the Pandemic they took..."
Patrick Woods
"Man I see why they close the kitchen at 3:30 Monday thru Friday afternoon. I got the philly cheese steak it was delicious 😋😋😋. The service..."
Charles Huoson
"Wonderful pasta and soups, great staff, reasonably priced and a neighborhood institution. Big thumbs..."
Zach Abel
"Delicious! Flavorful! Wonderful!
This place makes some of the best food around. They treat everyone like family. One of the best lunch restaurants..."
"this place has usually been good to me. hit or miss, but usually a hit. get extra sauce or the pizzas is just to dry. I wish they would just charge..."
Mike B
"We order online from here all the time. The kids love the Dominoes Tracker that shows the status of the order. The pizza is always hot and the order..."
Jeanette Jones
"This was the first time I did my order online. Was very impressed with the online ordering. Really love the step display where my order is and..."
Tina Clark
"1st time in nearly 20 years when order was cooked to WELL DONE or should I say over done. Called the store, they apologized, problem with the oven...."
Rose Stoller
"I'm not a big fan of chain pizzas, but this particular Domino's is probably better than the rest of the chain stores as this place has a incredible..."
TJ Tryon
"What wonderful and helpful service I received for our Christmas Eve gathering earlier today. I called and ordered last night. It was a BIG order...."
Debbs Leo
"I personally have had no Issues really worthy of mentioning. i've enjoyed every pizza i've gotten. Speedy even on busy Fridays, I commend them. Will..."
Eric Craig
"Yum. Yum. This is great pizza. I ordered online, and it was easy and efficient. I did pick-up and it was ready when I arrived. I've not had..."
Beth Copeland
"Every pizza I have ordered from this Domino's has been delicious. The phone staff is always happy to tell me about specials, and I have not..."
James Snapp
"They make a very good pie, and every delivery member of the staff we have met has been a great representation of the Domino's name.
We appreciate..."
Buck Bailey
"The food was made very fast and tasted great. I got the carry out option and by the time I got there they were all ready to give my order. The..."
"Great friendly atmosphere, people are very personable. Food is very good. Some food items very different, some great, some like minestrone soup are..."
Charlie Jackson
"Great location, great food, and great music!!! Nice family friendly spot, with a bistro air. My pick for best burger in town. Always cooked..."
Christopher Bloome
"I always try and get something different everytime i am here and I have never been disappointed! Steak Marsala and Chicken Francaise are favorites. ..."
Nicole Hansen
"GREAT FOOD, live music and an amazing atmosphere! One of my favorite places for a healthy meal and a night out! Highly recommend giving this place a..."
Scott Phillips
"Great atmosphere. Great food. Friendly..."
Sean Conway
"Great atmosphere, food is outstanding, great..."
Suzy
"Great atmosphere.
Good food great music. Has a wonderful neighborhood feel. Well go..."
Jody McDougall
"Very nice meal! Fried & broiled haddock. Love the pasta sauce. Great place with friendly..."
Denise Smith
"Great food and relaxing..."
Sam Galster
"Sammy is a good friend of mine he's done very well there food is great very friendly atmosphere
His wife is a sweet..."
James Pudney
"Came on a night with a string quartet whom played a little bit of everything. The atmosphere here was phenomenal as well. Really enjoyed..."
Shawn Brummett
"Good food reasonable prices..great atmosphere
Found out today that they have live music on..."
Margo Cavelos
"Hosted a private event for us and were very accommodating and kind. Worked with us on every aspect to make the day special for our..."
Ryan O'Donnell
"Nice Location 👍, best for live music. Food's are so delicious...."
Shazzadul Islam Tushar
"Excellent food, friendly, great..."
Julie Clark
"Great place for food and drinks and great..."
Lisa Cayea
"Nice place to hang out, inside or outside. Friendly staff and great..."
Ron Mirizio
"Great atmosphere Great food worth the..."
Todd Germain
"Great atmosphere. Live music is amazing. And the food, out of this..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes