Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Cooperstown
6 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
"The Italian sausage pizza I had was amazing. I past at least 3 other pizza shops on the drive there and it was so freaking worth..."
Carlton Gamble
"Stopped in after son played at Cooperstown dream park. Not being from New York, but hearing how great the pizza is, they did not..."
Marianne Lowe
"Stopped by while in town to see the Hall of Fame. This place did not disappoint. Pizza was by far one of the best I've ever had! Friendly staff..."
Sara Carter
"Delicious! I finally understand why NY pizza is the very best..."
Crystal Walters Lane
"Great pizza (loved the gluten free option) and friendly..."
Sara Erickson Baker
"Stopped in to eat after visiting Baseball Hall of Fame. Had the Veal parmigiana. Service was friendly and helpful. Food was hot, fresh and excellent...."
Richelle Lightfoot
"Stopped by close to 8PM yesterday after visiting the Baseball HOF. There were plenty of seats. We ordered a large pizza and it was fantastic. Price..."
Paul Prohaska
"This place is a "must visit" place.. one of our favorite places to..."
Todd Fowlston
"Great place, good food, nice people! I've been living on their food for a month and I'm picky...."
Kristan Campbell
"Planning my recent trip to Cooperstown, I found out about New York Pizzeria and planned to come here for dinner after a fun day. And the verdict was,..."
Dwight Davis
"Excellent Pizza and service. Being from the big easy in new Orleans. Pizza definitely did not..."
Kerry Chanson
"Great pizza...cheesy and greasy, just the way I like it! A little warm upstairs..."
Anthony Ginter
"The pizza was fantastic! The A/C could have been turned on..."
Kathy Ginter
"Chicken riggie and the most ginormous delicious pizza. We ate well in..."
Dayna Thompson
"Fantastic! Friendly. Great pizza!!
Will come back next time we are in..."
Mick White
"Food was good. Pizza was a little greasy but not bad. Dough and sauce were good. Garlic knots were also..."
Alfredo A.
"Clearly a busy day! They are quick at taking the orders! Affordable pricing! Fast service!! I ordered a Small Buffalo Wing Pizza !! Most importantly..."
Ariel
"We’re in town, visiting. Fridays are pizza days. We decided on New York Pizzeria. It was AMAZING! My son is picky about his pizza and he LOVED..."
Liesel Miller
"Last year we discovered this place and we made sure to stop again this year. During our visit to Cooperstown, we must have eaten here 3 times!! The..."
C Medrano
"I was blown away by how delicious the chicken parmigiana hero was! Chicken was so soft and tender, the bread was delicious, and the pizza was pretty..."
Chris6d
"This place hit the spot after a long morning on the baseball field. I would highly recommend it! The food was..."
Scott Tolar
"My partner and I often get lunch here as he works at Bassett and has 30 minutes for lunch. Those who work the register are super polite with us. We..."
Crystal Hamm
"I got a Calzone with Ham and GF got a Pasta Dinner. The food was hot, fresh and delicious. The staff were extremely pleasant and very..."
Richard Schneider
"I stopped in for a bite while visiting my father at Bassett. I ordered a plain cheese slice. It was the best pizza I have had since moving to Western..."
William Hanley
"Diligent and friendly staff with fantastic pizza.
I grabbed a couple of slices for lunch. They had my favorite crust; a nice crunch into a warm,..."
Kevin Troy
"Cooperstown-Being local, we often order a couple large pizza’s to go.
Always ready on time, delicious, and everyone likes them. Service is also..."
Carl
"Delicious pizza and mozzarella sticks. Sticky tables and high chairs,, but yummo I haven't had pizza this good in I can't remember when. 5 stars if..."
A. LeDuc
"Great Pizza. Very nice..."
Tammy Gage
"We devoured a pizza and garlic knots. Our only complaint is that we didn't order more knots! This pizza was..."
"We were all wicked hungry after kayaking on Lake Otsego, and we decided to get dinner here after driving by here so many times before. The food was..."
Regina Riem
"I was passing through Cooperstown, I Googled something up and saw this pop up as a suggestion so I drove five minutes to get there. Really glad I..."
Kitty Couture
"Came here for dinner with a group and found the food to be amazing and the service excellent. We ordered multiple items like chicken riggies, lobster..."
Ajay Bansal
"Wow! We've been here a couple times for lunch and this is our first time here for dinner. I can honestly say, every single thing was AMAZING!!! You..."
Joe Sweet
"Hand made pasta .. warm bread beautiful ambience. Loved the food. Outdoor sitting was good and warm. Their service could be improved. And btw they do..."
Mary Britto
"What a nice little restaurant. Everything is cooked to order. The greens (Verdura) were great as well as the meatballs and Caprese salad. My..."
david gutowski
"Unbelievable!! The spaghetti carbonara was so good I could cry. I asked for the espresso martini recipe because it was so tasty. And the..."
Catherine Bryden
"Probably the best experience dining experience we've ever had! Fresh, delicious, and a smiling staff. We went a couple of weeks ago while driving..."
Kathy
"Delicious Italian food with a great staff, especially our waitress Rachel. She was very nice, extremely personable, informative and..."
Paul Vetrano
"Every single dish was amazing!!! Loved that the greens were crunchy and not soggy as well as flavorful. The mussels in wine, butter, and garlic sauce..."
"Very good food, decent prices and great sized portion for the pasta and veal parmigiana. Feel like this is a must when visiting Cooperstown. The..."
Pawan
"Great service, amazing food and fantastic atmosphere! Took a quick trip to Cooperstown and picked here out of a bunch of options. We got the octopus..."
Brooke Clayton
"We wanted to find a nice restaurant near our hotel and we hit the jackpot at Toscana. Lobster Ravioli and Chicken Parmesan….delicious. Nice..."
Lucy Dee
"If I could give this place more than five stars, I would. My wife and I walked in and asked for a table. Though they were clearly busy and backed up..."
Whiskey Plays
"Amazing dining experience for my husband & I who were celebrating our wedding anniversary by visiting the beautiful cozy town of Cooperstown, NY. We..."
MaryBeth Jewell
"I live roughly five hours away and still make sure I can find away to come past here once a year for my birthday dinner in July. This is by far the..."
D “Shellsabub” H
"3 of us went to the hall of fame and saw this place across the street. We are so glad we did!!!! Liz was the best!! All and I mean all our needs were..."
Steve Cherry
"I’ve been a few times now. Sea bass special is delicious. Calamari done right. Very busy for good reason. Great staff, especially considering how..."
Stacey Mae
"Fantastic food. The Haddock was a large filet that tasted excellent. The cheese ravioli in vodka sauce was wonderful. Service was spot on. And..."
John Daum
"Came here for our anniversary dinner and really enjoyed our meal. The cozy, warm Italian vibes were romantic and charming. The service was..."
"I was pleasantly surprised!
I was not expecting much for Italian food upstate, however…Great prices, Nice menu and the customer service was..."
D B
"Very romantic place to have dinner! My boyfriend and I came here after the baseball hall of fame. The food was delicious. Highly..."
Brenna Fisher
"Excellent food, generous portions and very reasonable prices, what's not to like? Highly recommended. Dinner for two, with 1 appetizer, 2 entrees..."
Bruce Huttner
"My friend and I decided to do the Starfield Hiking Trail, and headed to Cooperstown afterward for dinner. We quickly searched using Yelp, and found..."
George Wheeler (Wheelercub)
"Ran through the rain tonight to enjoy a dinner here! We didn’t have a reservation but were seated promptly. Isaiah was our server and did a..."
Maria Ball
"One of the joys of being on vacation is finding a really great restaurant. That's exactly what we found when we discovered Nicoletta's while walking..."
Matt Ellsworth
"We had a wonderful dinner at Nicolette’s in Cooperstown on a Tuesday evening after the Glimmerglass Opera performance . The restaurant is lovely..."
Carol “cbell” Bellinghausen
"Love the food ! Friendly staff, good prices !
Everytime my wife and I visit Cooperstown, we come here for..."
Ryan Cunningham
"We had a fantastic experience. The atmosphere and service were really nice. I had the Tortellini and it was wonderful. We will definitely be..."
Tom Williams
"This gem of a restaurant is open on Mondays!
The service was excellent, the meal was fabulous from start to finish. I had the salmon and it was..."
Linda Thomas
"Fantastic cuisine and..."
Scooter Racing
"Had the blackened salmon for dinner which was beautiful. The flourless chocolate torte is lovely. Servings are huge. Prices reasonable and service..."
Kathy
"Great Bolognese spaghetti and ravioli dishes. A very relaxed dinner in a beautiful room. The wine list is quite good with a number of excellent..."
Tom Maguire
"Nicoletta's is a cozy and unpretentious Italian eatery which serves typical fare at reasonable prices. The space is well appointed with nice table..."
Jerry Ridder
"Nicoletta's was wonderful! My wife and I went for dinner and loved it. The antipasto salad for 2 is big enough for 4 and delicious. My wife had the..."
Jeffrey Nienstedt
"Food was delicious. We got the calamari, sausage for appetizer, chicken Alfredo, chicken parm and the clam linguine. Absolutely delicious. Wine list..."
Natalie Bafus
"Such a beautiful place, the food was delicious and service..."
"Please stop in and try the best pizza in Cooperstown!! This is the best crust, sauce and mozzarella have ever tasted in this area. I recommend it...."
Bonnie Chapman-Van Alstine
"The man who runs this place is amazing! He honored a coupon I had that he gets nothing for in return, just to be an honorable guy. He greeted me with..."
Jennifer Moore
"Phenomenal crust on their pizza. If you are in Cooperstown, this is the place to..."
Lorianne Rawson
"Great service friendly owner. Plus they have ice cream and all sorts of other foods to dive..."
Robert Anderson
"Friendly owner & great pizza. Very clean..."
Joe Kidwell Jr.
"At one of the very busiest times...the staff was absolutely very courteous and efficient despite the chaos. Food was delicious..."
Karen Andela
"Pizza was awesome. Loved the Reuben pizza..."
Christina Hess
"Had a slice of cheese---excellent ingredients and baked to..."
Barbara Kane
"Awesome garlic Parmesan..."
April Bernhardt
"I grew up in this town. The owner has a huge heart and invited me in when he saw me walking by. I was amazed to see the operation he has going on..."
Stephen L. Guarneri, Jr
"Nice place- eat here often. Not far from Hall Of..."
"Hi, it was second visit to Upstate New York for my and my friends. We we stopped
in Cooperstown for the first time for a quick bite to eat. We went..."
Rena
"My experience was a quick dinner with a meatball & ricotta slice, accompanied by a local amber (beer). Both very enjoyable quality. Staffer kindly..."
Sarah McCaghren
"Great food. The workers were friendly and the beer was delicious. Definitely stop by when your..."
Jennifer Lauck
"I was hungry and about to go into the Hall of Fame across the street. I think I ordered, paid, and ate two slices of pretty good pizza and a garlic..."
Brian Princer
"Coming from Minnesota to check out b.ball hall of fame, I really wanted some real NY pizza.
My wife and daughter also was with me and all agreed..."
Scott Jermstad
"Stopped in for a late lunch with my family after visiting the Hall for most of the day. The place was packed! Even so, the staff was holding their..."
Vincent Kearney
"Delicious NY pizza thats a short walk from the National Baseball Hall of Fame. You can buy a whole pie or choose from the large variety of pizza by..."
T L
"Solid @ss pizza still. Very consistent and great service. Pizza has a great flavor and good..."
Joe
"The New York Style Slicers were amazing. The chew on the crust was outstanding. The line out the door didn't move very fast. Definitely a New York..."
Jared Krekelberg
"Pizza was pretty good, unfortunately not like NYC. Service is excellent and the atmosphere is alright. The eat in tables are not big people friendly..."
Jose Angel Tollens
"Visiting the HOF, my wife and I were looking for a quick bite. I told her any place in NYS named Sals has a reputation to live up too and they did..."
singingchef23
"Pizza was 4/5 but the service was great and garlic knots were amazing. Great food and experience so I rated 5/5
Highly..."
Alfredo A.
"This is hands down the best pizza I’ve ever had. I’m 4 hours away from here, and I seriously would drive here just to get this pizza..."
Dianne Wright
"Had good pizza enjoyed the atmosphere wasn't crazy expensive kids enjoyed eating..."
christopher freund
"Stopped in for a slice after visiting the hall. Got me a proper piece of pie that you can fold in half, just the way it's supposed to be!..."
Shawn Mobley
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes