American cuisine: the best places to taste it in Edgartown
36 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Our first time at Seafood Shanty and we were quite pleased. The restaurant was a bit empty on Thursday in October, which I feel may have made the..."
Patrick
"Great service! Amazing food. Our server Kosal S was so attentive. I just had the best pan seared tuna sandwich ever! We also had the Shanty's..."
Yamilet Gonzalez
"I love this place. If it’s nice outside this is the go to place in Edgartown to dine and drink and enjoy views of the water. The food was so good...."
Adam Kotzman
"On a glorious sunny day in late September we sat out on the deck and enjoyed the views of the harbor. The portions were more than adequate, and the..."
Robert Golenbock
"Having read multiple reviews and having looked at a number of menus while walking around Edgartown, we decided on the Seafood Shanty for..."
Steve in NEPA
"Really loved this place! The service was top notch. I got the cold lobster roll and a few pieces were pretty fishy. It was a really good size though...."
Samantha Mackowitz
"Fantastic view! Get there when they open at 11 AM - people were already lining up. We tried the oysters, 1/2 lb lobster, fish tacos, and tuna steak..."
Emma Johns
"This place was incredible!! The warm lobster roll with butter is the best I've ever had. A MUST on the..."
Lovesexxee Love
"Fast service. Kind staff. Good food. Ninety minutes for a table, but you didn’t even need that long with how quickly the food came out.
The Bloody..."
Natalie Caldwell
"Fried calamari and lobster roll were large and delicious. The fish taco was overcooked. Service was friendly and super fast. Make sure you dine..."
Ruibing Wang
"First up, Louis the manager is good man and made everyone that walked in feel welcomed and at home. He takes tremendous pride in his restaurant and..."
Gene Waxman
"What a great place, fantastic views, great service and really good pub grub. The calamari starter with a tangy side sauce was fantastic. Our waiter..."
B MORENO
"Fresh, delicious, and fun place!! Loved getting to watch the boats in the marina while eating outside. The food was..."
Michelle Carmeli
"Amazing experience. Excellent view of the boats moving in and out. Wife and I ordered way too much, but lived it all. Drinks were delicious and..."
Wilson Good
"Absolutely a must visit! We came in October, and noticed the hours the restaurant was open weren't dinner friendly (11am-5pm) so we stopped in for a..."
Katie Boudreau
"Always a go to during the summer. The only sand beach bar on island. Great menu for all including the kids. From fine lobster rolls to the food to..."
Brian “Bmanpitt” Pitcher
"Favorite lunch spot on the vineyard! Amazing views, great cocktails and fabulous food! I ordered the hot lobster roll and my husband ordered the fish..."
"Amazing breakfast sandwiches and the coffee can't be beat. Oh, did I mention they are ALL happy to be here? A+ on service with a smile. Thank you..."
Douglas Karma
"Amazing lobster..."
Alicia Fitzpatrick
"A theme I found in Martha’s Vineyard was the feeling of being rushed. I ordered their lobster roll. The cashier rung me up. I wanted to add a soda...."
NY chinchilla
"Best and LARGEST lobster roll on the island. Hefty warm roll filled with chilled, large chunks of lobster salad. So amazing I wanted to go back for..."
Natalie Caldwell
"We had a really good lunch here last week. Lovely friendly staff and food made to order quickly. The veggie burger and egg sandwich were delish!..."
Angie Honey
"Nice place .
Delicious lobster roll and cheeseburger..."
W.S. JEE
"Was looking for a quick bite to eat to tide me over before a late dinner and very happy I walked in here. Food was made fresh and very quickly..."
Alexander Kantor
"Egg and cheese on an everything bagel was incredible. We got it twice for breakfast on our trip. The bagel was soft and sweet and toasted well...."
Josh Biggs
"The Lobster Rolls are..."
Felicia Royster
"Lovely location. lovely Indoor sitting area and outdoor patio with many tables. Good macchiato. Friendly..."
Henry Katz
"Great staff, positive, friendly.
Food is always fresh .
I've made several trips there
Always..."
Jimmy Keough
"Breakfast sandwiches are good. Great quick breakfast stop with great frozen Arnold Palmers and breakfast burritos and sandwiches. The sausage and..."
Todd Stewart
"Very good food but it is pricey. I would reccomend the French fries and popcorn..."
"poached eggs. such simple fare. yet so exquisite when done correctly. how i have missed my poached eggs for breakfast. yet, as anyone who is a..."
MaryAnn Cahill
"It's the best breakfast and dinner place. They use a lot of local ingredients. The atmosphere in the restaurant is very casual and makes you feel..."
Mila Lowe
"One of my favorite restaurants on island. Aside from the gluten free bread, cozy setting, easy parking, friendly staff, the food is outrageously..."
Helen K Neumann
"The food was delicious and worth the price i enjoyed every bite and ending on a pie is the best way to end a..."
Victor Lion Leon
"Delicious Food! A must to eat at! We all ordered different breakfast dishes and everyone was very satisfied! Thank you Lucky..."
Lynn Ann Averill
"Wonderful little spot in Edgartown. Great for breakfast & lunch. Dinner has a casual feel with an innovative, delicious menu. The farm share -..."
Ruth McDermott Levy
"The lobster mac n cheese was excellent! 5 star customer service! I will definitely visit this restaurant..."
Michael McGee
"Cod Cakes were fabulous - Very friendly and attentive staff. I will definitely go back and highly..."
Jeanie R Carter
"Excellent food! Best lobster Mac n cheese and the lobster deviled eggs were amazing. The bread and honey butter were so good but they were skimpy..."
Janis Gochoco Mulrooney
"Lobster eggs Benedict and whole wheat toast on the side with fresh mimosa...perfection. Nice quirky atmosphere as well. Would highly recommend their..."
Elizabeth Clausen
"Great menu and wonderful atmosphere! Staff is delightful and knowledgeable about their craft! Try the homemade sausage patties. I have had just about..."
Rob Topp
"I so miss you guys--especially the lobster deviled eggs, to die..."
Stephanie Ann Smith
"Staff was great. Food and drink were delicious. Our first visit, but will definitely..."
Nidia Johnson
"Absolutely delicious and staff is amazingly..."
Kendall Robinson
"Thanks for a fresh and delicious breakfast. Our daughter has a gluten and dairy allergy and we really appreciated that you had almond milk & gluten..."
Debra Dorsey Shuman
"The flavors and presentation were awesome. Such a fantastic meal. The crab cakes and scallops were off the..."
Ned Casey
"With brunch themed cocktails and Eggs Benedict on the menu, this was my kind of breakfast. With only two tables in front of the restaurant, I chose..."
Greecian Koukla
"We went to Lucky Hank's for our anniversary and it was the coziest breakfast spot we've ever been to. The food was delicious, the staff was kind, and..."
Evan Shaw-Mumford
"This is very overdue - we've been going to the Vineyard for 12 years, and Hank's always serves the best meal(s) of our trip. I usually get the Farm..."
Angela
"Lucky Hank's is unassuming. Don't pass it by! The food was top notch and the atmosphere was lovely. I had the lobster salad...amazing! Even the table..."
Erika DeShay Lowenkron
"Nice sized restaurant. They didn’t have the cod cakes but substituted with salmon cakes. Tasty, but was looking forward to trying the cod. The..."
Michael Peterson
"Excellent local and farm fresh American fare located conveniently across from the stop and shop in Edgartown. Except typical “vineyard” prices..."
Kate Avruch
"I had the 3 egg omelet + the beef brisket eggs Benedict too! Tasty, hot and timely service. Kudos to thus..."
Jan Nixon
"As usual Lucky Hanks does not disappoint for breakfast! The French toasts are out of this world! And the omelets, although not the massive American..."
Lauren E. Galinsky
"We went for breakfast on a rainy weekday morning. The food was delicious, and the menu had some enticing options! I opted for the French toast and..."
Libby Chernouski
"We were recommended Lucky Hank’s by our B&B Jade House host. LH’s didn’t disappoint. The food was scrumptious and very fresh. The servers were..."
Angela Marquis
"The cutest place I have ever seen. They have really nice outdoor and indoor screened porch seating (only issue - quite a lot of bees). Great food and..."
Sumaya Khan
"Amazing food. The servers were a bit rushed but the food more than made up for that. Cute little spot for breakfast or..."
Vinay Kapoor
"Everything here is fresh, delicious and healthy. I ate the lobster mac and cheese. It's topped with crunchy baked kale for the perfect topping. The..."
Maria Eileen Duncan
"We had a great experience. So accommodating. The Farm Fresh special was on point. We sat at the table out front with our..."
Seth Andrea McCoy
"Great tasting French toast. We ate on the back porch and it was a nice quiet..."
Dan Kellett
"Loved that we could get a brunch cocktail and loved the vegetable options- the veggie breakfast sandwich was very good! We had a little mishap with..."
Lisa Neefe
"The breakfast sandwiches are to die for! But seriously, it's so..."
A.J. H
"We went last minute because the other place we wanted couldn't actually accommodate dogs. Very pleasantly surprised. Meatloaf was out of this world...."
"The food was excellent and worth the wait. Even in the off season it was busy for lunch (always a good sign) and food took a bit longer than..."
Patti Wakefield
"Best lobstah roll on the island, no comparison. A regular stop when I'm in..."
Jim Jingozian
"We had the Bangers and a Reubrn. Great meal. We've been fans since day one, never a..."
Larry Nuesch
"My experience at the Kelley House was the absolute perfect end to our stay on island. Very rarely would I say that I would plan a trip around a..."
Renee Hirschberg
"Worth the 360 mile drive! Great food and great..."
Nick Persons
"Loved the food and atmosphere! Had the fish and chips and husband had the pasta bolognaaise. It was a chilly rainy day so this was a great..."
Leslie Frye
"We love being greeted by Ester!
Service was great food..."
Heidi Matthews Cantin
"I loved our waitress and the hostess Esther has such a great personality, she makes you want to go back just to say hello. She makes all customers..."
Sandy Mcnamee Bruscino
"Have loved The Newes for years and years. Love seeing Esther too....took a selfie with this amazing woman too. Keep being Great! Be back..."
Greg H. Goodman
"Great place for a spot of luncheon during our day on the Island during our trip from London to Boston and Cape..."
David Hastings
"Always a favorite spot. Doug is a great bar tender! ..."
Meghan Gravander Lavetsky
"Consistantly delicious food and service! Love the French Dip and Beer..."
Lauren Giglio
"Love the News! The food, atmosphere and the wait staff. So glad they are back open for..."
Janet Scott
"Great cozy decor and vibe. Very attentive service and adorable waiters. Fish and chips were yum but pass on the overpriced tomato bisque and wedge..."
Dominique Callimanopulos
"Great service. The food was good, but the salad tasted like water, no salad dressing on it. The atmosphere was good. It just needs better lighting...."
Amanda Bettencourt
"Amazing food! I had the best fish and chips on the island! The staff was..."
Emma Bainbridge
"Great spot to have dinner. The Maple ale was great too. I had the fish and chips and it was great. We had about 10 people with us and they..."
J. Jackson
"Open year round, the Newes is just such a cozy spot, with a fireplace for those cold, snowy days. And the perfect meal? A bowl of their French Onion..."
Marnely Murray
"Sat outside on a warm summer day. Beer selection was excellent and typical but delicious pub food. Highly..."
Alison Moon
"A classic for Martha's vineyard not to be missed. It is one of the few reasonably priced restaurants on the..."
Michael Teiger
"We stopped here for lunch and my wife and I both had excellent salads. the garden salad was good but very basic while to the Caesar salad with..."
Rich Hardie
"We are so passionate about every costumer service. We always love to see smiles on their faces when every they come in to eat for lunch or..."
cassandra edwards
"I love the atmosphere. You feel like you are in an English pub. The food is Fab. Truffle fries outstanding. Lobster Mac and cheese decadent and..."
"poached eggs. such simple fare. yet so exquisite when done correctly. how i have missed my poached eggs for breakfast. yet, as anyone who is a..."
MaryAnn Cahill
"It's the best breakfast and dinner place. They use a lot of local ingredients. The atmosphere in the restaurant is very casual and makes you feel..."
Mila Lowe
"One of my favorite restaurants on island. Aside from the gluten free bread, cozy setting, easy parking, friendly staff, the food is outrageously..."
Helen K Neumann
"The food was delicious and worth the price i enjoyed every bite and ending on a pie is the best way to end a..."
Victor Lion Leon
"Delicious Food! A must to eat at! We all ordered different breakfast dishes and everyone was very satisfied! Thank you Lucky..."
Lynn Ann Averill
"Wonderful little spot in Edgartown. Great for breakfast & lunch. Dinner has a casual feel with an innovative, delicious menu. The farm share -..."
Ruth McDermott Levy
"The lobster mac n cheese was excellent! 5 star customer service! I will definitely visit this restaurant..."
Michael McGee
"Cod Cakes were fabulous - Very friendly and attentive staff. I will definitely go back and highly..."
Jeanie R Carter
"Excellent food! Best lobster Mac n cheese and the lobster deviled eggs were amazing. The bread and honey butter were so good but they were skimpy..."
Janis Gochoco Mulrooney
"Lobster eggs Benedict and whole wheat toast on the side with fresh mimosa...perfection. Nice quirky atmosphere as well. Would highly recommend their..."
Elizabeth Clausen
"Great menu and wonderful atmosphere! Staff is delightful and knowledgeable about their craft! Try the homemade sausage patties. I have had just about..."
Rob Topp
"I so miss you guys--especially the lobster deviled eggs, to die..."
Stephanie Ann Smith
"Staff was great. Food and drink were delicious. Our first visit, but will definitely..."
Nidia Johnson
"Absolutely delicious and staff is amazingly..."
Kendall Robinson
"Thanks for a fresh and delicious breakfast. Our daughter has a gluten and dairy allergy and we really appreciated that you had almond milk & gluten..."
Debra Dorsey Shuman
"The flavors and presentation were awesome. Such a fantastic meal. The crab cakes and scallops were off the..."
Ned Casey
"We checked out this local no frills breakfast spot during our trip to the vineyard this week after looking for places that were reasonably priced and..."
Katie Boudreau
"A hidden gem in Edgartown and where nothing is over $9. A great classic breakfast menu and some delicious sandwiches, I love their Cuban sandwich the..."
Marnely Murray
"Admittedly, after reading all of the poor reviews, we really wanted to go here. Expecting rude customer service and to be verbally abused, we were..."
Deborah Belisle
"Great work food. Very plain decor, and the only menu is the chalk board. But the food is great, excellent prices for the Vineyard, and serving sizes..."
John Dolza
"Recommended by a work colleague, definitely your locals only spot that's remained under the radar. Prices are great, quality is great, interactions..."
Dillon Nachbar
"Wonderful breakfast! FOUR blueberry pancakes ( I NEVER eat 4!). Bacon cooked just right, not flabby or burnt. Decent coffee. Tables spaced apart,..."
Betty Smith
"If you want your ego stroked with your lunch go to downtown edgartown and pay for it. If you want a really good Turkey Gobbler, BLT, Pasta salad,..."
Annie Bryan
"Best lunch place on island, way cheaper than anything you will find on island and on top of that the food is actually really good. Awesome staff..."
jermaciel15
"Great food low prices for the vineyard they have a nice steak and cheese with frys or a side of your choice for under $9 bucks can not beat that..."
GrandmazC00kies
"Friendly service and good food at good prices...order at the counter, seat yourselves and super friendly counter gal will bring it to ur table and..."
Jennifer Cotty
"Great food.. if you come to Marthas VineYard and want quick easy delicous food this si the place to..."
Robert Singleton
"They're open even when the tourists leave and the money is gone. And they don't make me pay for it.
Can't ask for more..."
bejamoro skull
"Fantastic food at really good prices. Give it a try for lunch or..."
"I recently had lunch at The Quarterdeck in Edgartown, and it was an absolute delight. The picturesque setting on Memorial Wharf, with views..."
Marnely Murray
"the best fried clam strip we've had, the clam chowder was comfy and tasty, the fish and ships was nice but not crispy as it should, like the place,..."
A H
"Super friendly person behind the counter. Yes, it's cash only, but there's an ATM there if needed (though the fee for cash at a bank ATM is likely..."
Steve in NEPA
"Judy was our waitress and made excellent menu suggestions. Midwesterners need help! Glad we..."
p browne
"Best cheeseburgers in Edgartown. Totally hit the spot and I could have eaten three of them for the price of a burger anywhere else in town. If you..."
Henry Gwazda
"Recently, on my first trip to Martha’s Vineyard, I wandered through the streets of Edgartown one soft summer night hoping to find a walk-up cafe..."
Barbara Perry
"Stopped here for lunch with my family and we all enjoyed the food so much we came back the next day for more. The food is fantastic and the wait time..."
Shellcode
"This is the BEST lobster roll I have ever had. Not to mention the prices were fantastic! I’ve lived in New England all my life and my favorite food..."
Ivy O'Brien
"We had cheeseburgers and they really hit the spot. At $6 a pop, they’re an excellent deal. Toppings tasted fresh (LTP: lettuce tomato pickle) and..."
Thomas Lynn
"Lobster rolls were packed with meat and not a lot of mayonnaise. We grabbed three to go and ate them on South..."
Light Breeze Cruisin'
"Delicious! Lobster roll, beyond burger and chicken finger platter. All exceeded expectations. Good..."
Liz Libson (Liz Etherington)
"Wow!!! Super good fresh seafood! I could not skip the lobster burger, and wow So good. Don't miss out on this little place plus there open to 1..."
Elvin Chacón
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes