The best Restaurants in Harvey Cedars ranking of February 2025
8 restaurant menus in Harvey Cedars, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Bucatini Accio E Pepe Spring Peas Parmesan Reggiano Pecorino
Oyster
Broccoli rabe
Pesto
Cornmeal Fried Calamari
Calamari
Octopus Salad
Fish
Mussels
Ricotta
Pork
Tuna Tartare
Tuna
Shrimp Cocktail
Scallop
Hummus and Pita
Chicken breast
Spring Pizza
Crab Cake
Steak Tartare
Shrimp
Foie gras
French Fries
Bread Pudding
Sit down
Seafood
Pizza
American
Reservations
Private Dining
Street Parking
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Dinner
Drinks
Fine Dining
"Delicious!! From the moment we opened the door the staff was welcoming. Loved the cozy vibe and warm fireplace. Nikki was our attentive and friendly..."
Kimberly Giang
"Incredible experience ~ drinks, appetizers & entrees were wonderful but most of all the service received was one for the books. We are new to this..."
Melinda Lloyd
"This restaurant was exactly what our family was looking for on a great beach weekend.
The apps were satisfactory 👍🏼
The mains were perfect..."
Brent Herrig
"No doubt the best high end bar/restaurant in the Island. They go above and beyond in all the details.
A short but sweet menĂş, lovely wine picks,..."
Angella Vecchione
"This absolutely one of the best restaurants on LBI!! You will not find a more friendly staff, service is incredible, food is more than delicious...."
Dan Petrozelli
"What an amazing venue for a small wedding! The food was delicious. Thank you to the chef and kitchen! From the charcuterie table, appetizers and sour..."
C L
"Fast service on a Saturday night. This is definitely a trendy spot. I got the chicken with blackened garlic aioli sauce...."
Sarah
"Ate here with some family members on an off season Fri night. Our table was ready on time. The food was good and the service was exceptional. Our..."
Curt Weller
"Wow! That was a great dinner. Went for a final family meal on the island, and found ourselves impressed. Between our party of 6 we tried a bit of..."
Dillon Browne
"Walked in Fourth of July weekend around 8 and they accommodated us inside no problem. Friendly service and good food and drinks. Angry crab pizza is..."
"This was our first time at the Neptune Market and my family was highly impressed. I was surprised that there was a full service grill here so it's..."
Kevin Kasper
"Enter as Strangers…Leave as Friends is the sign posted in the Neptune Market. My husband, son and I walked in 17 years ago as Strangers but as we..."
Kristy Carruba
"Neptune Market has been our go to for 20+ years. IMO it’s only gotten better and better. Amy just made me the absolute BEST Cuban sandwich I’ve..."
laura bair
"Been visiting this place for 30+ years and it keeps getting better and better! These folks not only fly the best food from their griddle, grill and..."
Steve Gould
"Great spot, sit at the counter, and you'll be watching them cook your burger right in front of you with all those great swells. They have much more,..."
Troy Giorgio
"Cool little market on the way to the Barnegate lighthouse. Grill with bar service has all of the breakfast staples (try the porkroll). Small attached..."
Daniel
"Neptune Market is a great grocery store with an amazing selection of everything you are looking for! This is also a fantastic place to sit and have a..."
Asher Puth
"We recently stayed on LBI for spring break with our three kids ages 3-10. We went to many restaurants that week, but we all agreed Neptune Market was..."
Anna Kasper
"Nice little place to do a little grocery shopping, and you can even sit down and grab something to..."
Jamie Gonzalez
"Great sandwiches and service! Loved the lunch counter and the..."
Trina F
"Great breakfast and lunch menu.
We were on the Island when the remnants of hurricane Ian came through. They were open and we got a great meal..."
C Bo
"Family owned, family run and if you don’t “see it” out front, ask, they’ll have it in the back for their culinary menu. They have an..."
AJ James
"Neptune Grill expanded 2020 across the street in Harvey Cedars from market. Great fries with crispy coating, cheesesteak good..."
T C Kearns
"Love the convenient nature of the store that also makes great hot food. It’s one of the few restaurants that stay open months after the end of..."
Jack Blattner
"Can’t say enough about this place. Not only do they have everything you need from groceries to bbq with a great meat selection, the grill is one..."
Ken Lagana
"Spent my childhood summers on LBI and Neptune Market was our go to place for nearly everything. When I walked inside, the atmosphere brought back..."
Janette Jones
"Looking for groceries on the north side of the island? Neptune probably has it! Looking for a place open year round? Neptune has you covered too!..."
"Great upscale restaurant. Appetizers were on point, tuna was prepared perfectly.as well as the other dinners. Bartender not only helped with the..."
Trailer Commander
"Wonderful restaurant and bar to go to for both happy hours on my own and for dinner with family and friends. Management (victor) and bartenders (Kim,..."
Patty Robinson
"This is a great option for large groups. It’s very family friendly but still a solid restaurant. They’ve got one of the few liquor licenses in..."
Brooke Young
"Food was all pretty good but nothing too spectacular. The cheese curds were awesome and I got the local scallops but wasn't too impressed with the..."
Jake Reilly
"Took my wife here as a surprise one night and boy what a surprise it was. The food was fantastic! Very nice inside and everyone was friendly. The..."
brian stark
"Great food & service. Beautiful inside and out. Prices are very..."
Steven Wilk
"Absolutely incredible! We had GREAT service (thank you Holly), and the food was delicious. We had the cheese curds to start, Barnegat scallops, and..."
Jourdan Travers
"Fantastic food, very nice decor. We were there in the off season so it wasn't crowded. Prices are fair for what you get. It was one of the best..."
R. Andrew “KonigKrieg” Springer
"W heaven heard great things about this place for years. The good and the drinks were even better than we expected! Great cocktails, lively..."
Amy Dahl
"Great food, best clam chowder I've had in a long time. All dishes were excellent. Our bartender Adam was terrific. Will make sure to return more..."
"My wife and I shared a grilled shrimp over arugula salad, and a grilled swordfish. We made several special requests for each dish. Everything was..."
Clifford Ehrlich
"First the food was delicious, fresh and well prepared. The sword fish was prepared with care for the main ingredient. The rating of not being a 5..."
John Ferguson
"amazing staff- so welcoming and eager to help! food is delicious and consistently so fresh. the calamari vera cruz is one of my favorite dishes...."
Caroline Friedman
"Great, fresh seafood. Lobsters still crawling on display. You can get a meal or carryout raw seafood to cook @ home. BYOB (liq./beer store on corner)..."
David Szagola
"Best scallops I’ve ever had. Everything was so fresh and..."
liz houck
"This is one of my absolute favorite restaurants in the world. Everything is delicious. My personal favorite is the sauteed mussels in the white wine..."
Sarah Narburgh
"This has got to be the best seafood on Long Beach Island!!! Nothing on the menu is bad!! Some recommendations are the tomatoes, old bay fries,..."
Kieran B.
"This is definitely undoubtedly one of my own choice beach locations! Simply being within a short distance of the ocean relaxes me along, and then I..."
Claire Rana
"A seasonal regular for us. Serving seafood favorites as well as some different takes on classics. Casual dining where you can show up in flip flops..."
Paul Delport
"Best restaurant in lbi hands down! Huge portions of amazing food. Make sure you order the Vera..."
Teddy Friedman
"Harvey Cedars Shellfish is by far the best restaurant on the island! The food is unbeatable and the staff is amazing. 10/10 can’t wait to go..."
Madeline Hughes
"Love this place! Great..."
Chris Bitting
"Delicious food and service. Always busy and BYOB. NO RESERVATIONS. We dined outside on picnic..."
Elise Medenbach
"If you're looking for an all around great seafood joint - this is it! Ordered a bunch of platters, a 1lb of shrimp and 1lb of scallops. The kitchen..."
Erica Metzger
"The best fresh seafood spot around!!
You can sense the family fun business the moment you arrive - welcome and genuine service, great atmosphere and..."
Jennifer Shin
"Do you even go to LBI if you don't get the seafood broiler plate & Calamari Veracruz from Harvey Cedar shellfish Co? I say no!
This place is as..."
"Delicious homemade ice cream! Gluten free cones. Assorted sprinkle colors, which is a hit with the kids. Worth the wait in line (and there is always..."
Meredith Mitchell
"Harvey Cedars is a great ice cream shop! Love all their unique selections and my favorite is the chocolate chip cookie bowl! Will definitely be back..."
Lynn Adkisson Staudt
"Awesome! Great parking and flavor..."
Miriam Berkowitz Blue
"Excellent ice cream and the best chocolate chip cookie bowl ever!! Love the selection is amazing! Can't wait to get back there this..."
Kathy Cantwell Greer
"A must visit on LBI. The toughest thing is deciding what to order. Great selection of ice cream flavors, and non dairy options as well. Gluten free..."
Elaine Aronoff
"Love going here when family comes for a visit. Not only is the ice cream good, you also get 2 little chocolate chip cookies with your order! : 0..."
Marietta Avallone Iacouzzi
"So..."
Jennifer Kalka-King
"Stop by and have the Best ice cream on the whole..."
Judy Krasner Singer
"Harvey Cedars Ice Cream is the BEST! Love the Mint Chip and Mocha..."
Jodie Rothman
"Came here with my fiance while visiting from South Carolina. Amazing soft served ice cream, I got peanut butter sauce added onto it. Really great..."
Sean Hogan
"Avery helped me and my family with a big order and absolutely crushed it! She went above and beyond and was so sweet the entire time. Definitely a..."
Conor Humphrey (Chumps)
"Great selection for ice cream lovers and people with dietary restrictions (vegan, gluten..."
Amanda G
"Order Online! This place is fantastic, several in-house flavors and additional jack & Jill fresh ice creams. The system of ordering to the excellent..."
Steven Singer
"Our favorite ice cream shop on the island! Everything is super..."
Alyssa Nelson
"One of the best off the beaten path. Had a spill with a cone and they were so nice to help replace. Good sundaes for kids such as cookie bowl and..."
Jon Caputo
"A+ establishment!!! My car was hit pretty hard by someone right outside this place. My 4 year old son was in the car at the time - fortunately he..."
Dave Keller
"Great spot for ice cream! Lots of flavors and..."
Scott Lunden
"We had a great experience. We got two complimentary chocolate chip cookies. For two of us, it was $11.50. I didn't mind paying that because service..."
Amber Thaden
"This was such an adorable, clean, and affordable little shop. The girls that worked there summer 19' were so sweet. Our orders were out quick, and..."
Erin Casey
"Good ice cream and friendly..."
Hannah Gray
"So many flavors! Perfect island feel. You get a cookie with every ice cream! Been going here for over 30 in years and it's always the..."
Jonathan Wilkof
"Great ice cream, cash only, long line worth the wait. But please get with the times, still serving styrofoam and straws served at the beach? Most..."
E Walkley
"Go to this ice cream place all the time. Workers there are kind and while the lines are usually long it's worth the wait! They also give a..."
Conor O'Mara
"It is worth the wait. Nothing can compare to what this ice cream parlor has. Always a favorite place to get ice cream! Love it..."
"Fantastic pizza! you can taste the fresh basil in the pizza sauce and the crust is thin and..."
Bobby Hofmann
"Best Pizza in LBI. Huge pies and XL slices with the right balance of sauce and cheese. Possibly the best pizza in..."
Charles Verdi
"Delicious fresh baked...made from scratch...nothing frozen here! Crispy,thin crust...scrumptious toppings...friendly service...the best Pizza on..."
Tess Harnick
"Amazing people, yummy food!! Go, eat here! You will love..."
Alissa Willette
"Great Italian hoagie on a phenomenal roll. I'll be..."
Sam Nemroff
"Best pizza..."
Colette NSeth Manheim
"Best pizza around..."
Joel A. Schecter
"The Eggplant Parm. was delicious.
The owner was friendly.
I would have given a 5 star for food if it wasn't $14 without the fries.
The Google menu..."
Jeff Rittweger
"I’m ve ordered pizza from Rays multiple times and always so good. My son had his two year old birthday and Ray went out of his way to give him a..."
Mr. Alan Murphy
"Came to LBI for the day and while driving out happened upon Rays Sunset Pizza! What luck, it was the perfect pizza!! Thin extra crispy and so..."
kara bernetich
"Food was so tasty and quick and they were so nice! Will definitely come back! Inside was cute and we sat outside and ate.
Overall great..."
Gillian Alexander
"Amazing service, very kind employees. Went above and beyond to ensure we had the best experience. Very welcoming + delicious pizza. Big slices..."
Shea Conboy
"I had the crispy chicken sandwich, and highly recommend it. My friends vouch for the eggplant parm and Grandma's pizza too. Good little place for..."
Micah Burtchell
"Pizza was meh but I’ll give them points for having coconut juice and being open off..."
Alex Sprague
"I hate to make this place more crowded, but it is the best pizza on LBI! Give them time for your order. Try the grandma and..."
Joe F
"The large slices are a plus and the pizza overall tastes great. I go here often with my folks and we love it. They also serve delicious ice cream and..."
Mathew Cipriano
"I love Ray's Sunset Pizza! By far the best slice you can get on the island! Employees are the sweetest, love the owner Ray! He always goes above and..."
Jessica Mulligan
"The Legacy Continues…Best Pizza on LBI!
- Outstanding Customer Service
- Reasonable Prices
- Convenient Location
- Down to Earth and Family Run
-..."
RG
"This place is amazing!! The food is delicious and the staff is super friendly. Ray (the new owner) has made the place look great, keeps it super..."
Sage Tonnesen
"Very good food for a reasonable price. Owner is very..."
Christian Haffner
"The crust was so thin and delicious! Great slice of pizza and kind..."
Eric Gapco
"Im pizzeria tha makes good 🍕 pizza and good people i recommend a good service and the owners is a very good person who is always grateful to his..."
"Holly Trump and her team catered a nearly week long family reunion for us in my Harvey Cedars home. We were a large group from toddlers to teens to..."
J M
"Best gazpacho. Everything we have tried has been delicious. We need more places like this on..."
Susan Jacobson
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes