Best Manhattan in Indianapolis

2 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
St. Elmo Steak House
St. Elmo Steak House
93/100 (9870 ratings)
Restaurants
Steakhouse
American
Gluten Free Options
American
Steakhouse
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Drinks
Pasta
Bourbon Butter Cake
Chocolate cake
Salad
King Crab Mac 'N Cheese
Mac and cheese
St Elmo Cola
Double Chocolate Mousse Pie
Crème Brulée
Crab
World Famous Shrimp Cocktail
Wedge Salad with Vinaigrette Blue Cheese & Bacon
White Chocolate Blueberry Bread Pudding
Loaded Baked Potato
Cheesecake
Tomato Juice
Filet Mignon
Manhattan
Surf And Turf
Surf N Turf
New York Strip
Cheesecakes
Bearnaise Sauce
Creme Brulee
Cocktail Sauce
Bread Pudding
Shrimp
St Elmo Shrimp Cocktail
Lamb
Beef
Lobster
Navy Bean Soup
Fish
St Elmo Crème Brûlée
Pork
Sit down
Steakhouse
American
Accepts Discover
Valet Parking
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Serves Alcohol
Accepts Mastercard
Wine and Beer
Accepts Visa
Gift Cards Available
Private Dining
Full Bar
Accepts American Express
Live Music
Accepts Credit Cards
Drinks
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Fine Dining
"Beautiful restaurant, My steak was cooked perfectly. Their signature shrimp cocktail was an extraordinary cocktail sauce presented very nicely but..."
Joshua Landau
"St. Elmo's is a staple and it lives up to the hype! Many in the group I went with had gone before and gave great tips and convinced me to try their..."
Dawson Brunswick
"Everything about this place was fantastic. It’s definitely worth the $$. It was on our “bucket list” for our trip to Indy. Our waiter was super..."
Gemma Smith
"Visiting my son and his family in Indiana. We decided to go for an early Thanksgiving dinner and we chose this amazing restaurant. Undoubtedly one of..."
Eddy Prieto
"Arguably the best meal I’ve had in my life. From start to finish, everything was fabulous. It’s hard to impress me with top tier service and..."
Heather S.
"We visited here on a Monday evening for my sister’s birthday. We both are born and raised in Indiana, and had never visited St. Elmo prior to this..."
Erin Wood
"Visited the restaurant during Devour Indy Week (Restaurant Week) and had a 3 course meal at an amazing price ($60). Food was delicious and our..."
Bessie Gessner
"St Elmo always has excellent steak selections. The three of us agreed our steaks were cooked to our preference - medium & medium rare. Side sides of..."
Ken Hasseler
"In downtown's heart, a beacon bright, St. Elmo's shines with dining light. No reservation? Have no care, The bar invites, a feast to share. Spicy..."
Stephen de Man
"Cmon, this place wouldn’t be world famous if they were a bunch of slouches ! Scratch that, this ain’t Pats or Gino’s garbage, this is world..."
Jon Kelly
The Vanguard
The Vanguard
79/100 (538 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Strawberry Lemon Cake
Salmon and Spinach
Pineapple Spritzer
Summer Cobb Salad
Shrimp Scampi w Broccoli
Pimento Cheese and Bread
mocktail
Manhattan
Cucumber
Tequila Sunrise
Spinach Salad
Salad
Vegan Options Available
popcorn
Chicken Wings
Fried chicken
Mousse Au Chocolat
Quinoa
Filet steak
Buttered Noodles
Coconut Cauliflower
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Mid-range
"Ate the first meal ever at this restaurant last Friday with my parents sister and wife. Everyone loved the food. The burrata was insane. Smoked..."
Sean Griffin
"What a delicious meal we had here! We started with two small plates - the grilled shrimp and the zucchini with the charred lemon yogurt --then..."
Mary Jane Hislip Mitchell
"Loved the cocktails & the food, we had oysters, pimento toast, duck confit & Mussels - as well as an absolutely delicious dessert! Great food,..."
Kelly Kay
"I had dinner at The Vanguard with my husband this evening to celebrate our 2nd wedding anniversary. Everything was perfect - the ambiance, the staff..."
Caitlin Greenwald Garcia
"This is the absolutely best restaurant in Broad Ripple, if not all of indy. I love the always changing menu and STEVE SLAYS behind the bar! Love this..."
Jordan Seifrig
"Just had dinner at The Vanguard with our supper club - the food was wonderful, service was great! Citrus Salad was the bomb and the Mediterranean..."
Becki Walters Roach
"Excellent food, beverages and top notch service. A must try anyday of the..."
Michael Bilodeau
"The food and service are wonderful! Daniel our service was amazing. I would highly..."
Donette Cassman
"The Vanguard was pretty darn awesome. I wasn't planning on going there. I was actually looking for a place to park. I'm so glad I went inside. The..."
Launda Bolden
"One of my favorite places, the staff is wonderful too. Great people, great place. Best new restaurant in..."
Phillip Powers
"Great establishment! Overall, great food, atmosphere and and service! The braised short rib is amazing and the bread pudding is off the charts!!..."
Eric Johnson
"Probably one of the best kept secrets in Indy. Creatively delicious dishes & drinks, well priced & right sized plates with something for..."
Bill Crouch
"The Cajun shrimp appetizer and butter-smoked chicken entree were both amazing! My husband says the ribs were good, too, and that the meat was so..."
Jill Ebert McQueeney
"Started with a masterfully crafted Bulleit Rye Manhattan. The appetizer special was a Chinese tamale wrapped in spinach leaves which was delicious...."
Greg Miller
"The new look is perfect! I love the openness of the bar and restaurant. I'm glad they kept some of the favorite spirits and the food menu offers a..."
Steven D'angelo Dickerson
"Excellent meal at an event here last week. The ribs were off the hook amazing! Craving more..."
Colleen Fanning
"Walked into the Vanguard, and got that WOW affect.Service was fantastic and the food was wonderful!!! I will be back..."
Jim Krier
"Fried chicken: 9/10 stars. Almost as good as grandma's. Best in the city. This is not an opinion. It's a..."
John McConnell
"Really really good...way better than we..."
Josh Akers
"Celebrating my sons birthday ! Our meals were..."
Debbie Lowry
"I thought the service was great and the bartender was very knowledgeable and..."
Peter Thomas
"Butter Smoked Chicken was AMAZING! Everybody in our group of 9 loved their food. Not a crumb left on anybody's plate. 5 STARS ALL THE..."
Mark DeBruler
"The food was AMAZING. We went because Google recommended it to my friend and it was absolutely on point. Food came fast, selection was good. They..."
Hannah Banana
"The food here was so phenomenal. And the drinks were amazing. The ‘Sometimes it Snows in April’ drink comes with its own smoke. And the staff is..."
Romily Bridges
"We finally made it to Vanguard, and we were not disappointed. In fact I think my boyfriend said "this was even better than I expected" at least half..."
Carma Ketterman
"The venue hosted my wife and I’s baby shower and it was a great experience from start to finish. Kayla was great, communication was consistent and..."
Dominique Boyd
"Great food and so much flavor! Portions sizes were plenty for all with the devour menu! Wait time to be seated with a reservation was a bit longer..."
Rachel Davidson
"Delicious food! Crazy good service!!! For example... I ordered a cocktail and they didn’t have ingredients to make it and the general manger went..."
Joel Scott
"Finally, a farm to table restaurant with generous portion sizes! Celebrating local food should emphasize abundance, and from entree size, to wine..."
Abby Rose
"Loved the food and the atmosphere! The chef is great! We got the Venetian lasagna and shrimp scampi! For dessert we had salted caramel chocolate..."
KKnS1988
"Good food in Broad Ripple. My wife got the fried chicken, which she loved, and I got the ribs. Both are recommended. The service was also solid. ..."
Pat Lynch
"We decided to try Vanguard after reading favorable reviews of the restaurant. Our experience at Vanguard exceeded the positive reviews. Our waiter,..."
G Russell
"Vanguard is becoming one of my fav restaurants in the city! The staff is friendly and attentive. Their drink specials are affordable and diverse. The..."
Nessa Be
"Before I start, want to make sure that I say this was Valentines Day. And it was what you’d expect for a newly-remodeled, higher end, romantic..."
Dan Martin
"It was perfect. The ribeye melted in your mouth, the creamed kale was to die for and the mashed potatoes were real. The cabernet held its own against..."
Karen Tackitt