American cuisine: the best places to taste it in Lake Mary
55 restaurant menus in Lake Mary, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"So let me tell you great service great food definitely a must go bagels were on point pancakes were delicious ! Ladies that were there serving people..."
Isaac Aguilar
"What great service and food!! Highly recommended to anyone in the area. Best flavored coffee I’ve ever had (hawaiana..."
Angie Cruz
"Came After church with a big crowd. The service was phenomenal. The waitress was great and very personable. The the manager, along with the chef,..."
Tucker
"Great place friendly staff and amazing service!! Best place I have ever been to in Florida. The food was super fast to get out nice and hot. I would..."
R C
"Had a few minutes before work and wanted a bagel with cream cheese. Quick and easy, no fuss, friendly staff, and the bagel was delicious. Will..."
Justin Santiago
"The day old bargain bagels I got were delicious. Gave 4 stars and not 5 because the bacon egg and cheese bagel sandwich I got was bland. I'd..."
Belle Williams
"I've eaten the Neo (eggs, nova lox, and onions scrambled together), repeatedly at the Winter Park and Lake Mary Bagel King. Today's Neo was the best!..."
"Absolutely loved this restaurant. From the ambiance, to the decor, the setting is very welcoming upon entering. The service was good and the cuisine..."
G's mail
"Delicious, beautifully plated food, great wine selection and very attentive, friendly service provided by Ramon. My husband also loved his..."
Kimary Carrero
"Worth another visit. We went here for my wife's birthday dinner. She had the fried olives appetizer, a grouper and risotto special, and the creme..."
Andy S
"The service and food was very good spinach artichoke appetizer was excellent and the pork chop dinner I had was very good would highly recommend this..."
Louis Hernandez
"Family dinner-tried the olives appetizer, the lobster flaky dough appetizer, truffle fries, salmon salad, steak salad, pancetta pasta and shrimp and..."
Dessie Hristov
"I’ve never almost cried from the delicious taste of food before, let alone on each course!
The staff was extremely kind and helpful, and later on..."
Jake Hajek
"Greatest selection of wines and fantastic pairing opportunities with amazing food. The owner knows wines and has an amazing and awe-inspiring..."
"If I could give this place 100 stars, I would. 1st and foremost- the place has one of the most unique set ups I've ever seen. Individual rooms, salt..."
Sabrina Bush
"Bungalow Retreat has quickly become a favorite spot for my family and friends. We've enjoyed Sunday brunch with mimosas, happy hour and special..."
Adrian Valentin
"Fantastic find!!! Great spot combining speakeasy, nice outdoor patio, tapas and great small bites, and private massage chairs, lounge and bar. ..."
Scotty Bryan
"Burgers are excellent. Decorated really nice. Service by Dixie was amazing. We will be..."
B R
"Great food! The B E S T burgers and fries hands..."
T R
"I found this place on google and the decor really caught my eye so I decided that we should try it for date night. I love unique places. I’m so..."
Fall Formytype
"Wow, wow, wow! First time here. Great service, great food! Try it, you'll like..."
"Fantastic place to eat breakfast or lunch. Staff is friendly and helpful. Food is 'to die for', and there is plenty of food on your plate! Super..."
Barbara Kelly Simboli
"Great food with a variety of healthy options. Great service and very kind, courteous and respectful servers. My server Tom (or Tim lol sorry bad..."
Tony Lozada
"I 1st time experience was awesome. Colby was a great server. He point out on the menu what he thought was good and also recommended many different..."
Monisha Robinson-Wynn Carter
"Nice place, good service, highly recommended. It is the perfect place to eat brunch,..."
Victoria De Los Angeles Paez
"Excellent service. From the hostess to the waiters/waitresses, everyone is very pleasant and accommodating. The portions are more than we could eat..."
Vickie L. Lowery Perez
"Never a long wait to be seated. Service is excellent . They are always coming around to make sure your drinks are full. The food is excellent. You..."
Fred L. Davis
"I will definitely recommend this place! Service was excellent and the food was really..."
Jana Menendez
"Great food!!! Best breakfast place there is! And not bad prices..."
Kayla McCormack
"I wish I could remember our waiter’s name. Not only was the food great but the service..."
Marlene Good
"We love kekes! We were on vacation and celebrating an amazing engagement; service was wonderful and attentive, food was delicious and filling as..."
"The soft ice cream was super creamy and fresh . Best place so far that I have found in Lake..."
Aaron Canning
"Love this place, should have found it sooner. I just wanted ice cream but ended up with a brownie sundae and it was delicious! Bring your family to..."
Zully Gomez
"Definitely a true ice cream shop! Ice cream is so thick and..."
Jeff N Darbi Peterson-Sprague
"The best gelati's in the area. We have been here twice and both times it has been great. Make that 3 nights in a row...."
Joan Degroat Finigan
"Versini's is the best. It reminds me of when I used to get Italian ice in New..."
Raquel Cifuentes
"Best in town..Their gelatis are my favorite! I recommended mango ice and either chocolate or vanilla ice..."
Yasmeen Virji
"Have the best..."
Giselle Martinez
"The Lake Mary location is the BEST! I came on Friday with the 2 little girls I Nanny for. We all got small cones, & the cashier was nice enough to..."
Aimee Patnaude
"So I'm not really into sweets but my family wanted to give Jeremiah's a try and OMGEEE I'm so glad they did!! Who would've thought an icee and ice..."
Amy Santangelo
"The sugar free cherry Italian ice is an amazing thing for those of us who are diabetic or on keto. It honestly doesn't taste sugar free. I'm..."
Patrick Dearman
"Always an easy win! Great desert option and they do puppy..."
"I'm following a low carb eating style. I asked for the turkey sausage egg white & spinach power sandwich without the bread. They did it perfect in a..."
Shannon Brannock Green
"Always an awesome place to go. Great service and..."
Laura Ramsey
"Delicious souffles, hot coffee and big selection of freash bagels with a great view to start the..."
Vic Berger
"enjoyed your back patio with nature..."
Anita Einarsson
"Nice mid-sized Panera Bread. Easy on-off access from I-4. The staff are friendly, efficient and professional. There is a large sitting area if you..."
Akira Sora
"I have been in this area for 3 years and I have never been to this Panera.. what so special about this place is there is a very famous trial right..."
KarthikKumar Somasundaram
"Visited Panera Bread after a nice long bike ride. Excellent choice we both had the 1/2 chicken frontega panini sandwich and 1/2 Asian chicken salad,..."
Beverly Darden
"This was our first veto this Panera. The food was as good as we expected. The restrooms were clean. The staff was little less cordial than I..."
"Early dinner, place not full. Server gave full attention and food seemed fresh. Very tasty and cooked..."
Eric Lee
"We had such a wonderful time at this location. They accommodated us, a party of 20 with a smile. Our waitress were the best! Meghan and Alyssa..."
eyhr1os
"This has finally did a major turn around in service and food. We were very hesitant to come back, but some one gave us a gift card so we came back. ..."
J. L.
"Warm atmosphere, great service, great pricing and no wait, food cook well, medium rare steak, perfecto, NY strip and 3 other steaks were served :) ..."
Summer Snow
"Longhorn to me has the best steaks of any place and went to all the steakhouses longhorn beats all of them, I had the fire grill T-Bone I still taste..."
Anthony Vitale
"Matthew P. was our waiter at the Sanford fl location. He went above and beyond always checking on us to make sure we had a great experience. He was..."
Linda Sanders
"Great food, great service and a warm atmosphere makes this a great place for dinner. Prices are fair and I was actually pleasantly surprised when I..."
John Lesko
"Ordered a Rib eye wanted it medium & my sister ordered rare. So my rib eye was rare. Still was great, can't complain. The taste was excellent. The..."
"Wow, what a great experience! The all you can eat brunch and all you can drink Mimosas was fantastic! So many small dishes to try and we tried them..."
Frank Kuebler
"I’ve been here several times for brunch, and it never disappoints. Nice location with plenty of parking; clean, indoor & outdoor seating, upscale..."
Lauren Bortnem
"Thanks Dawn for the excellent service and your pleasant attitude, you've made brunch a pleasant experience. Service was not rushed.
Bottomless..."
Lenny Leger
"Such a yummy brunch experience today. The customer service was exceptional from the hostess welcoming you and throughout the meal from management,..."
Lisa Pompa
"I took a friend out for her birthday dinner and we selected F&D, she had never been before and I had only been once before but this time I would be..."
Let's Talk About Da Food
"Always great food and service! We ordered the grouper and shrimp & grits this time. Loved the flavors and presentation. It's a nice ambiance and..."
Denise Diaz
"The food and service was amazing ! Would definitely be back and highly recommend. The management was also outstanding checking on us every step of..."
"Although I am a huge fan of their beef & veggie burgers, we stopped in last Friday night to try the new Chicken Avocado BLT in Lake Mary...."
Sharon Caruthers Delgado
"I love burger fi! This place is great .. burgers are really good! The service is quick & good! If you want grass fed burgers this is the..."
Jeff Lopez
"My favorite burger place! I take my family there all the time! Staff is always on point & their fries are my..."
Rudy Lopez
"Absolutely the best burger I’ve had in years. The onion rings were fantastic but could usless salt for my taste, but I’ll still get them..."
Roger Merrett
"I was hesitant about buying a burger from here because it’s so expensive but from the moment I walked in the atmosphere was great, I ordered a CEO..."
Imari Holifield
"The best juicy burgers! The fries are like homemade. Freshly cut and cooked just right. Soft with a slight crunch. The staff is always..."
Rosetta Jackson Adams
"This place is delicious! Great atmosphere and exceptional service. The manager is very attentive to the customers. We always love going to..."
Casey Sliger
"Phenom burger and aoli fries are the bomb! Everytime my wife are on vaca we stop here from..."
Richard Donald Siam Jr
"Love that I can have a garden style burger. No more tossing always buns. So..."
Kristine Fisher Boyce
"KARA WAS AMAZING AT THE FRONT!!! she knew immediately when I asked what vegan options they had and she helped my indecisive bf choose what burger to..."
Mackenzie Matthews
"Had a wonderful time at my local Burger-Fi this evening. Great time in the outside seating with great music, drinks, and most important GREAT food. I..."
Irania Morales
"I had a plesant experience with my wife and mother-in-law at BurgerFi in Lake Mary, Florida. The restaurant is really clean and the food was great!..."
DJoumbarey Moreau
"Best burger in lake Mary area 🍔 it’s so delicious and fresh with crispy onion rings I love it 😻 I like that they have a stamp on the bread..."
Razan Mohamed
"This was my first time here and it definitely won't be the last. The inside was spotless as well as the bathroom. Cheyenne was very patient with me..."
Paul
"Very nice establishment. Cool laid back atmosphere. Very busy with a rather confusing ordering procedure. It tends to be a bit loud in there also...."
"Clean restaurant, good service and friendly staff!
The subs are made to order, alway fresh and hot 🔥
Spacious interior with ample..."
Ruben Orozco
"the charming and talented young man who took my order simply made my day! he is by far the greatest employee i’ve ever interacted with in my whole..."
Joe
"The only reason I’m not giving you guys a five star rating is because you gave me the complete wrong sandwich. However, the sandwich I got is a..."
Cyrus Nally
"This is one the best Firehouse Subs around. I have dined here several times in the last 10 years. The restaurant is always clean and the staff are..."
Frank Carr
"Updated; LOVE THEIR VEGGIE SUB WITH SAUTEED VEGETABLES!
Love firehouse, especially their Lemon cookies which this location does not have! Still great..."
Kristina Dixon
"Always the best customer service. Fresh and hot when promised. Love the sweet and spicy..."
"Went here for the first time with a friend for lunch. We loved it! Love that you can sample anything on the menu first and you will not be..."
J. L.
"First time here and definitely not the last. I ordered the Fancy Nancy on wheat bread. Delicious food. The watermelon tea is so good too! Friendly..."
Kerri Payne
"We love the fresh food and have never been disappointed! We were there at lunch today and we had the great pleasure of meeting a team member named..."
Jennifer Metzger
"I really like the buffalo chicken salad on the croissant, as well as the mac and cheese. The pickle and cookie are a nice touch. My only constructive..."
Angela Carter
"Enjoyed the chicken salad, they make a number of styles and I had the one with egg and pickle added and it was so good. The broccoli salad was..."
George Booras
"I like that they let you sample the scope salad before you commit to it. My food was..."
Vernette Cole
"A welcome addition, Classic Nancy favorite, Cranberry Kelli and Fancy Nancy are family favorites. The store is so..."
"Founded by Dexter Richardson and John Hoffmeister, Dexter's is a local and established contemporary restaurant where you can enjoy great food and..."
Tastes Of Orlando
"Great dinner spot. Both the fancy menu and the regular offer tasty dishes whether you want a chicken sandwich or expertly cooked mahi on a bed of mac..."
Mama Likes To Eat
"Amazing food! They have the best food in the area except for Ruth's Chris but dinner here will cost you half as much. The standard menu is not as..."
Sam Moss
"Love Dexters! We go the the.... Love Dexters!We go the the LM and WP locations somewhat often. The food is ALWAYS great. Casual atmosphere,..."
BMcGraw
"I love the daily..."
IknoGdfood
"My favorite place for Sunday brunch! The Dexter's Benedict is delicious and their Bloody Mary is..."
Amanda
"The food and service was excellent. On our server's recommendation (Tim) I got the eggplant Napoleon, and it was terrific - on of the best entree..."
Brent Garvey
"Go for brunch, avoid night time. I have been to Dexters twice, and they were exact opposites in experience! When I went out at night, with several..."
Dinner 4 Four
"Music is often wayyy too loud and the drinks are expensive but what else would u expect at colonial. But the food is really good and fresh, the..."
TrueFoodie
"Excellent!!! Great atmosphere and great..."
Jessica Ziebarth
"Lake Mary Gets Culinarily Intriguing. Having been afforded the opportunity to visit the Lake Mary location of Dexter's the other evening I am happy..."
Robert Maddrey
"Great Brunch. Enjoyed a great brunch on Sunday, thumbs..."
Emma
"A favorite lunch destination. The first thing I request is a basket of homemade mixed chips. This combo of sweet and salty is delish. My favorite..."
La Cosmopolitana
"Great food and terrific service!. Fourteen people on a Friday night ... and we had a great time. The service was fantastic ... the food was terrific...."
Bev
"Excellent options! Driving through from out of town and Dexter's was a great find. Awesome sauces for their sandwiches and dressings for..."
Kathryn
"Pretty Good. Pretty good food in a nice atmosphere. Went here with some folks from work. The beer selection is a bit skimpy, but we had good service..."
Lake Mary Food Critic
"A little bit of everything. Dexters is a good catch-all restaurant for those wanting to escape the torture of Applebee's, TGI-Fridays, or other such..."
Edward Or Eddie
"Dexter's of Lake Mary is almost always busy, and there is a reason why. Good location, decent food, and nice atmosphere. My friend Tommy and I went..."
Lake Mary Food Critic
"The food was very good, the calamari I can say I’m not a big fan of but overhear it was very good. I also got the southern nuggets, and the pie...."
Stania Paul
"Kind service, decent amount of outdoor seating. Variety of food isn’t extensive but what they serve is very fresh and tasty. Not much is gluten..."
Jessica Martin
"They never disappoint!! Anytime me and my cousin decide to do brunch we never have to speak on..."
Dee Yng
"We had brunch and enjoyed it. The country chicken with gravy was delicious 🤤. The banana bread shot was deliciously sweet just the fridge slight..."
Nagu
"Dexter's is a bar, that serves brunch. There were lots of people having a good time with unlimited Mimosas on the table. The food was good. But the..."
John Catiller
"The staff is always positive and attentive. I've sampled several different items and have never been disappointed. attention to quality and..."
* bYte
"My food was delicious. Couldn't finish it all. Everyone was nice and super friendly..."
"Amazing neighborhood local restaurant .... the menu is excellent .... service on point and always consistent!
Vanessa was awesome and our meal..."
Tina Hackett Craft
"Absolutely love this bar! It has a nice neighborhood feel to it. Reminds me of a Northern Tavern when I was growing up. The food is really good, best..."
Harry Gordon
"This place has great food and great service, their sweet potato fries are to die for. I would highly recommend to friends as well as family. They..."
Kathleen Oliveri-Dorn
"Going to make this a regular stop on my trips to Lake Mary! The staff were awesome, very personable and attentive. Zack and Lane were great. The..."
Jeff Ahsinger
"My favorite fun place in Lake Mary. Love the staff, food, the crowd, and the..."
JoAnn LaForte
"I ordered the Vodka Shrimp Pasta, it was delicious, hot and seasoned to perfection. I also had the pimento cheese dip w house fries as an appetizer...."
Jean Nelson-Haynes
"I love this place! The food and service are always great and the atmosphere is comfortable and familiar....just like your favorite neighborhood..."
Kitra Weaver
"Excellent service and tasty variety of food. What else could you ask for.
Walking distance from Sun Rail station?
Yes it has that..."
Tom M. Carlson
"Just had a delicious meal here with our family. We'll definitely be back..."
Aaron Ludin
"Awsome food and atmosphere. Reasonabley priced drinks. Terrific wait staff! Try the Chicken..."
"The food is flavorful and the chicken is tender. Good portion sizes. Decent prices and friendly employees. The only downfall is that just about..."
Alisha Morris
"Just WOW! Delicious meal and such amazing staff! I got 5 tenders and I’m glad I did, this is a must..."
Josh Altice
"WOW! We have lived here for a while, but just never got around to trying this place. On a whim, we ordered online for dinner and it stated 10 minute..."
Jennifer Copas
"The food and service was amazing! Zoee took my order at the register and was very kind and greeted me with the biggest smile on her face. She was..."
Amber Glass
"Had a hiccup in terms of their menu on the Uber eats app. Called the restaurant, spoke to the manager directly and explained to him the situation at..."
Ricardo Gil
"The food and service was spectacular. Zoee was a huge help when deciding which flavor to put on my tenders. She was patient, kind, and..."
"TooJay's is celebrating 35 years in business and it's no wonder they've been so successful. Almost no other restaurant in the Orlando area has such..."
James Emerson
"Really enjoyed it!! The loaded latkes were good! Love the fact they put muenster (my fave) cheese on their items. Their desserts looked soo good i..."
Melissa H
"I love their chicken salad. I usually have to get a fix of it. I also enjoy the kids meals available. They have a chicken salad that is wonderful. I..."
Dinner 4 Four
"Not Jewish or Kosher: Too good food.. One reason I live here is I'm a 5 minute walk from a NY Diner. I lived with other Jews like me in Queens and LI..."
Andrew I. Lerner
"A great jewish deli. With plenty of choices to choose from, its no surprise that you can find both great, good and so-so on their menu. However, hold..."
Richard Riga
"Good Deli. Good deli sandwiches, service can be slow during peak..."
TX Connection
"Home-Style Cooking. I really enjoy their foods and I frequent the place but I must say, there is nothing "Kosher" about it and should not be..."
Connie Standish
"Good Deli Food. Good deli food here. The sandwiches are great with ample portions. The desserts are to "die for." A great place for lunch or to meet..."
Lake Mary Food Critic
"Huge menu, huge sandwich. This is one of those restaurants that I forget about until I go in, order a sandwich, and think, "Why don't I come here..."
Edward Or Eddie
"I had lunch at TooJay's yesterday. I have to admit that they generally have consistently pretty good food there, I've eaten there quite a few times..."
"Subway by far is the most healthiest option when it comes to sandwiches. This also depends on what you add to your sub. I prefer Turkey only,..."
Frank Jovine
"Great place. The staff has always been super nice and fast. They always have a smile and talk to you so it's never like being served by..."
Ainara Nieves
"The place is very clean and the staff is quite efficient and quick. Great sandwiches and friendly service, couldn't ask for..."
ABDELRAHMAN AbuEbied
"this is the only subway within this area unless you go down to lake mary blvd. love this place, never busy and they always have everything stocked..."
Luis Valdes
"Thank you for my $4 sub! You took my order quickly over the phone and had my sandwich and a smile waiting when I arrived. And the sandwich was..."
John Doe
"Disappointing to see this location is now closed. Rent was probably too high in that plaza. What a shame. It was my favorite subway I've ever been..."
"This place was awesome!!! For our first time they made it unforgettable! Food and drinks were great.. desert was phenomenal!!! Not an everyday place..."
Gina Kotara
"I waited to visit this restaurant because I didn’t believe the quality was as good as everyone raves about. Many dine restaurants are lucrative..."
Fatima Boyd
"Excellent service. Great food. I had the crab cakes, shrimp cocktail, lump crab avocado salad and cowboy cut steak. All delicious. The best if the..."
Lily Leung
"One of the best restaurants we have been to. The service is over the top and the food..."
CherinBob Bell
"We live close by and eat there 4 Times a year. The service is always top notch and the food is always excellent! David the manager has a great staff..."
Craig Peterson
"We had a very nice romantic dinner for our anniversary. We were sat promptly, food came out at a good pacing. Our server was amazing, and kept our..."
Amanda Jones
"This was my first time dining experience and I must say I loved everything about it, the wait staff was very friendly and out going, beautiful..."
Agnes Saam
"We had a great meal! It was our anniversary so they had rose petals on the table. It was great. My steak was so yummy! And they gave us a..."
Brenda Currie
"I like the place but my food was nine dollars it was happy hour had four drinks my bill was $67 drinks are way too..."
James McNabb
"The food was excellent and the service was exceptional! For the price you pay, the level of customer service from the moment you drive on the..."
Aisha Rodney Ruiz
"We had some appetizers on happy hour and everything was tasty especially the spicy shrimp. The wine I chose was nice. We also had dinner. My 6oz...."
Aaliyah Marie Freeman
"Steaks.... salads .... dessert were all perfect! Shout out to our assistant server Conner you were outstanding! Well done! Great night. Thank you..."
"the two people on shift today were really chill and we had genuine laughs and conversations. food was very good as well. get those two a raise..."
Anderson Wrench
"Tuna wrap was very tasty. Friendly..."
Yinka
"Standard brand experience with fast service and good..."
Jayaram Srinivasan Brindala
"Beth was very accommodating and helpful in preparing sandwiches for our soccer team during a busy tournament weekend. After having multiple places..."
Braeden Frenette
"The employees here are really fun. They remember my child’s order and always make her feel special. Best Subway..."
Megan Mingie
"Excellent service, portions, and quality. (Much better than the store near me in Winter Garden.) Also, the fun banter from behind the counter..."
Steve Luke
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes