Best Chicken Sandwich in Mackinac Island

5 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Kingston Kitchen At The Village Inn
Kingston Kitchen At The Village Inn
85/100 (1480 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Bar
American
Gluten Free Options
Seafood
American
Bar
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Beef
Nachos
Alfredo
Corned Beef
Chicken Sandwich
Club Sandwich
Salad
Fish
Wings
Pork
Calamari
Calamares
Fish & chips
Fish & Chips
Sandwiches
Ribs
Burger
Fish Sandwich
Curry
Shrimp
Sit down
American
Seafood
Bar
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Live Music
Reservations
Seating
Serves Alcohol
Table Service
Highchairs Available
Wheelchair Accessible
Full Bar
Drinks
Late Night
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Wonderful planked whitefish meal is the same as always. So large it can easily be shared. Fish is fresh and must be local. Now called Kingston..."
Dean Reyburn
"Very tasty food. Nice quantities. Loved their chicken Parmigiana with pasta. Chicken wings was crispy and yummy. Their cherry lemonade was refreshing..."
Zeba
"My wife and I were attending an annual convention on Mackinac Island, we and some friends went to the Village Inn for lunch.  We found the food to..."
Ancient_breed
"Lunch On the Island. This summer was my first time going to Mackinac Island my husband family has been there several times. We decided on Village Inn..."
Cemorris1911
"Good place to eat but not outstanding, I had the walleye sandwich and my wife had the French onion soup. I was craving Great Lakes fish and the..."
Ghengis
"Good place to eat on Mackinac Island. The 1/4 lb cheeseburger with chips was very good. Nice seating outside makes for nice..."
Steve
"Well, it's the " off season" on the island and choices are very limited but the VI is open and serving with a smile. Good food and reasonable prices..."
Steve Mason
"Best bloody mary's anywhere on the..."
Gus
"Best meal at the village inn! Sat at the bar, friendly bartender, Erin, made us the best rum runners! Recommended fish dip appetizer was the tastiest..."
Twerp
"We had an amazing experience here. Starting with the friendly service, food and atmosphere. We started off with the calamari and were blown away by..."
Nick Mathew
"Amazing! We had a wonderful server and incredible food. The bloody Mary was the best I've ever had. Loved the chicken curry. Sat on the patio with a..."
Kristin
"This is a great place to stop in and have lunch. The food was delicious, and they had a menu that focused on more traditional Jamaican dishes as well..."
Dakota Kauffman
"Wonderful service and excellent food! I have nothing bad to say about this place. Definitely check it out when you’re on the island. The calamari..."
Rebekah Cathey
"A Caribbean restaurant on Mackinac? I was so surprised but not as surprised as I was of the delicious food! I am a Jerk Chicken connoisseur. I am..."
Caralyn Silver
"Sadly disappointed in their Jamaican cuisine. The food was aesthetically pleasing but didn't please our taste buds. I ordered a whitefish sandwich..."
C Allen
"My husband and I loved this spot. We went for the Whitefish Sandwich which was flakey with a great crust. The slaw was flavorful and excellent. The..."
Melanie Riederer
"Very soft and joyful ambiance, servers are very friendly and make you feel welcome. Food tastes great, and portions are quite large, which is good,..."
Viktoria G.
"Excellent food. Friendly service. Plenty of food choices with a few vegetarian dishes as well. Don't skip the fried plantain! The portion sizes are..."
S Rao
"My friend and I didn’t intend to eat Jamaican food, but we’re looking for something other than burgers on the Island. Right away the staff was..."
Kara Kristina
The Gate House
The Gate House
84/100 (1265 ratings)
Restaurants
Pub
Vegan Options
American
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Pub
Bar
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Fish & chips
Gate House Nachos
Fish Sandwich
Shrimp
The Moscow Mule
Smoked Whitefish and Clam Chowder
Beef
Limeade and Home Made Root Beer
Nachos
Buffalo Chicken Wings
Lamb Burger Patty
Pretzel
Fruit Cup
Chicken Sandwich
Brisket Chili
French Dip
Apple and Walnut Salad
Salad
Cobb Salad
Saki
Wings
Fish
Sashimi
Scallops
Paninis
California Roll
Ceasar salad
Sushi Grand
Sandwiches
Plath's Bacon Grilled Cheese
Virgin Mango Mule
Chowder
Burger
Hamburgers
Grilled Flat Iron Steak
Fish & Chips
Grilled Lamb Burger
Tapas
Warm Crab Dip
Tacos
Grand Pecan Ball
Ribs
Sit down
American
Bar
Pub
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Reservations
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Late Night
Dinner
Drinks
Mid-range
"We’ve eaten at The Gate House each time we have visited Mackinac Island. We are always impressed with the wonderful service, and lovely outdoor..."
Erica M.
"We had a great meal here! The outdoor area is bustling and makes for great people watching as people go up and down the large hill by the Grand..."
Meagan
"This place was one of the highlights on our trip to Mackinac Island. We'd love the food the place looked awesome sat by the fireplace patio was..."
Michael Greene
"The grilled lamb burger was fantastic. Besides the food I'd say my favorite thing about The Gate House was the lack of chaos you find closer to the..."
Taylor Hunt
"I split a bacon grilled cheese with my daughter ( I had a Michigan mule. Both were delicious! Not a long wait..."
Amanda Jurish
"The Gate House restaurant located on Mackinac Island, Michigan is a very good restaurant. It is located on the grounds of The Grand Hotel. It’s a..."
Richard Mullens
"The food here was absolutely delicious. Everyone from our party of 6 enjoyed everything from the cocktails to the main course and then desserts. It..."
mary orozco
"This place was very nice and the food was pretty fancy. We sat out on the patio to eat lunch and we could see the Grand Hotel from our seat. I would..."
Ryan Soles
"We were immediately greeted with a smile! Our sever was attentive and worked with our large group perfectly! Thank you Adan! Nachos, draft beer,..."
Martina D
"They have an excellent bar serving a remarkable Old Fashion. The bartender made one for me “Her way”. I cant forget to mention the..."
Mark Schneider
"We came in after a long day of discovering the island. We ordered the fried pickle and chicken tender basket which was delicious. The chicken was..."
Jesse Locklear
"Erica has a great personality and a commitment to great service. Thank You! We stopped in for lunch outside. The food was excellent and reasonably..."
Don Jr
"All in all ok. Short Rib was kind of dry. Needed the braising sauce and nice sear. The pretzel kielbasa was awesome. Cherry mule was also fantastic...."
Jake Gordon
"Loved it. I feel like this place flies under the radar a bit because it's away from Main Street. The food is delicious and high-quality. In my..."
Matthew
"We just stopped for drinks after walking around Mackinac Island. we were able to get a seat right away as they were unusually not busy. The drinks..."
Topcatjack
"We went here on a whim while walking back from The Grand Hotel and I’m so glad we did! The food was delicious, my drink was amazing and our..."
Theresegoesgrey
"First time dinning here. Food was good and reasonably priced for the island. Enjoyed sitting out on the..."
Evelyn Jenkins
The Broken Spoke
The Broken Spoke
82/100 (1099 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Bar
Pub
American
American
Bar
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Breakfast
Shrimp
Reuben sandwich
Fish
Pork
Lobster
Salad
Wings
Salmon
Crab Cake
Chowder
Burger
Ribs
Hamburgers
Fish Sandwich
Toasts
Corned Beef
Chicken Sandwich
Sit down
Bar
Pub
American
Live Music
Seating
Table Service
Highchairs Available
Wheelchair Accessible
Full Bar
Takeout
Serves Alcohol
Television
Late Night
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Loved the atmosphere, and the music was awesome. Service was super kind and talkative, and we had our drinks and food right quick. All together..."
Borko Man (Borkoman)
"For tourist food on the island, it's competitively priced and very tasty. Seating is first-come, first-served. Reservations are only allowed for..."
Shone Brooks
"One of only three places open this early in the season. Decorated with old bicycles and wagon wheels, it has a rustic charm. Lobster Mac and Cheese..."
Michael Gibson
"Got the duck wontons and brisket gouda mac. Both were really good, and they give you pretty decent serving sizes. The server I had was absolutely..."
Oliver Truman
"Our meal was delicious 😋 Food was served hot...the Prime Rib sandwich was served with an aujous type dip and a pickle!!! The French fries were..."
Amy A.
"We had a couple of burgers, fish and some other items. I think the fish tacos were great. We also loved the Million Dollar Burger ... it..."
C Thomas
"After biking and walking 18 miles!! Opted for comfort food, chicken pot pie and Ruben with sweet potato fries. Chicken pot pie does not look like..."
jennifer Taylor
"Huge 14 oz ribeye. My husband and I split the plate and had more than enough. Steak was so tender you just about didn't need teeth to eat it. Service..."
April Morton
"Food was good, service was fast, portions were just right. Drinks specials for miles start at $10 Atmosphere is..."
Daniel Roeder
"Best pub on mackinac island. Hands down. This is where the locals go. Fantastic food thats made homemade. Drinks made and shiped in locally or Mitten..."
Amanda Wollet (The Michigan Guru)
"Prepare yourself for the best smoked ribs you will ever experience. Seriously better than some of the stuff I've had in the south!! Deep smokey..."
Vivien Li
"The Broken Spoke makes you feel like you’re home! Great food and tremendous service. Late night drinks and always a full house with room for more!..."
Katie L
"Wonderful staff. Had a chance to sit back and have a few with this local character named Tony Boom. What a riot this fella was, lot's of good local..."
Chad Bennett
"Incredible food, the staff is always friendly and the beer selection is great. Wide variety of guest taps as well as great beer from them. Bloody..."
Caitlin Chick
"It was so divine. Adorable restaurant with best food we’ve had here. Will be back! Caprese salad and add steak….their use of herbs is stellar!..."
Travelore
"Great service and good food! Enjoyed the..."
Erica Hoese
"This went from a one start to 4 star review because of the manager. He quickly corrected a potentially very bad situation caused by an inexperienced..."
B Rodriguez
"We come to the island every year. We finally ate here for first time and I swear I raved about how good the food for hours and even into the next..."
Sarah Ronda
"It's a nice bar and grill on the main street the food was really good had good..."
Kathy Wright
Mustang Lounge
Mustang Lounge
81/100 (2210 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Bar
Pub
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
BBQ Brisket Burger
Reuben sandwich
Fish
Pretzel Bites
Pork
Tater Tots
Beef
caesar salad
blt Dip
Quesadilla
Coney Dogs
Prime rib
Jumbo Shrimp Basket
Crispy Shrimp Basket
Pasta
Porky Mac and Cheese
Salad
Ruben and a Beer
Wings
Mustang Punch
Chili
Pretzel Bite Nachos
Mac and cheese
Fish & chips
Burger
Whitefish Dip
Ribs
Grilled cheese
Tater tots
Mussels Diablo
Fish Sandwich
Patty Melt
Hamburgers
Jumbo Shrimp Fajitas
Nachos
Impossible Burger
Chicken Sandwich
Boneless Wings
BLT
Sit down
American
Bar
Pub
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Serves Alcohol
Seating
Wine and Beer
Table Service
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Drinks
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Mid-range
"It was our first time at Mustang Lounge, heard about it from a recommendation on Reddit. Service was good and very fast, we got the Brisket Burger..."
Nate Weber
"Server was great. Food was delicious. Shrimp was prepared perfectly. Creative for branding the Mustang into the bun of the burgers. Prices were..."
Jason Tucker
"Great food, the patty melt was awesome. I added mushrooms and they were tasty. The ranch was really good. Service was fast and..."
Ryan Zimmerman
"Ambience is great and food is delicious. We ordered crispy chicken sandwich and crispy shrimp basket. Crispy shrimp is amazing!! Staff is friendly..."
Geethika Garikapati
"Amazing late night menu! Changes every night, and food comes out hot and fresh. Staff were super friendly, drinks are cold, food is delicious...."
Zachary Nagourney
"Food was good and the service was excellent. It was kind of down a side street and less busy than some of the other restaurants. There was some..."
Misty W
"This is a really fun joint to eat! Yeah, it's more expensive than McDonalds, and it takes longer too. Put your big boy pants on and enjoy the show...."
Infantry Shooter
"If I had to choose one restaurant to visit while on the island for food and drinks, it will be the Mustang Lounge. The staff are always friendly and..."
Jon Saelee
"Recently visited the island this past weekend and restaurant/bar hopped at night. When we went to Mustang's I had the Mustang Cider and my god it was..."
Laila Jamaleddin
"I loved the delicious food and the staff was very welcoming and very..."
Jimmy King
"Stopped for a cocktail/beer on our walk around the island. Really liked the atmosphere... Oldest bar in..."
Cindy Woolery Anderson
"Food was very good & so we're the drinks. The prices were high, but to be expected on the island. Service was..."
Nikki Bixby
"The wait at this restaurant was pretty short, but the restaurant was pretty busy which was great. The service was great and the food even better. I..."
George Shara
"Food was great, service was exceptional. Our server was helpful, kind and funny! Nice place for dinner on Mackinaw if you're looking for a less..."
Dana Lentz
"After a long day of the exploring the island this place was perfect to refuel. The staff was friendly and fast! The patty melt (add mushrooms) was so..."
Lauren Wolf
"Summer drink menu was excellent! We also had a bloody and it was very good! Loved the inside decor and a plus is the outside is dog friendly! We had..."
Alan
"Nice, laid back atmosphere! Pizza was delicious! One of the more affordable places to eat on the island during spring..."
Elizabeth Dawes
Mighty Mac Hamburgers
Mighty Mac Hamburgers
78/100 (1305 ratings)
Quick Bites
Fast food
American
American
Fast Food
Dinner
Lunch
Chili
Fish Sandwich
Poutine
Chicken Sandwich
Fish
Sandwiches
Cheeseburger
Burger
Hamburgers
Salad
Sit down
Fast food
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"It was a wonderful experience! We had the kids meal and also the 1/4 Mighty Mac. It was definitely one of the most affordable food options on the..."
Gabriella Gomez
"I really enjoyed this meal. First time trying poutine - it was really yummy. The service is quick, friendly, and helpful. The nuggets were really..."
Ashleigh New
"One of the more affordable food options on the island. Outdoor patio by the water is a great, quiet spot to sit and eat. Hamburger was fine. Meat..."
Jeffrey Mckeon
"After a cycle ride of the island we were starving and looking for options for a quick lunch… decided to go to the Mighty Mac. It was a good..."
Amit Jain
"It's on Mackinac Island what do you expect it's a very well run hamburger joint. I had the Olive Burger but I like Oliver with mustard on it they..."
Chris Prieto
"Very nice staff, reasonably priced food, and not very long wait time for food. Overall, they have a great place to sit down and eat. Whether you're a..."
paige Kinsman
"Food was tasty and very affordable compared to other restaurants on the island. Service was friendly and extremely fast. This will be our go-to lunch..."
Jonathan Hopkins
"Food was pretty good. We got poutine and a 1/4 pound Mighty Mac Burger. Got our food out pretty quick and got to sit by the back window in a booth..."
Darren Demis
"Nice little cafe that we stopped at for lunch. Burgers were good. Paper straws were frustrating... Prices were reasonable considering the tourist..."
Andrew Beadles
"We wanted a quick bite to eat to get us through till dinner. They weren't very busy yet and went in. Its a nice place, clean and for the most part,..."
Steve Buero
"Great little burger joint right off the main drag. Prices were good, did was ready quick and the staff was super helpful. The dining room has a great..."
Jeremy Dalton
"Pretty loud and cramped in there. Everyone was polite. The food was great. For a cheap style burger they dressed it up in a good way. Pepper Jack..."
Miss Honesty
"Great burgers! Great prices! Friendly service! Wonderful..."
Tina Harvey
"Husband and I stopped in for a quick bite right when they open, staff was so nice and friendly and the food was cheap and filling for the island...."
Mackenzie Whitlock
"Delicious food very reasonably priced. Dining room is also reasonably quiet and has windows looking out on the harbor. We'll definitely keep this..."
Eric Schipper
"The food was really good, the staff very friendly, and the place was clean with a view to the lake; also, prices were very affordable. I highly..."
Patricia Luna
"Stopped in for a lunch. spicy chicken sandwich was good, fries aren’t bad but are very salty. Plenty of seating inside and a few seats..."
Mike Simon