**EDIT: I went in to the store and spoke with the owner; very kindly listened to my explanation of what had happened. The last time I was in (January), the pizzas were baked properly and definitely looked & tasted better than when I was in 5 months ago! Thanks to Brandon and the Urban Slice staff for the motivation to make things right for their customers!
I went in to order a cheese pizza, and when I got in, they had all these freshly baked pizzas out, but the cheese was the only one stale! Wasn't even warm when I got it, super dry and overall not that great. Who wants to eat a slice of pizza that looks like THAT? I mean really... Would the manager or staff buy and eat that if they had a choice..?
My wife and I had the pleasure of eating at Urban Slice many times since moving to Madison a couple of years ago. We were both born and raised in New York so we know a little bit about authentic New York Style pizza and Urban Slice did not disappoint!
Not only was this the best pizza that we have ever had outside of New York but it was one of the best pizza that we have ever had period! My wife is not a big pizza lover and she loved this pizza. The pizza is thin crusted with just the right amount of spices in the sauce and just the right amount of mozzarella cheese. In addition the meatball topping that we ordered was delicious. It was not just ground beef but a real Italian meatball topping.
We are moving to Madison soon and this will be our regular pizza place. If you value the opinion of two New Yorkers on good New York Pizza then don’t just walk here for their pizza…RUN!!!
1308 W Dayton St - Madison
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes