Sluurpy
Reset

There is only one restaurant

Best Pizza Slice in Maui

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Prison St Pizza
85/100 (1851 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Wings
Bikini Blonde
New York Style Pizza
Pesto
Killer Beer
mango
Pepperoni Garlic Bread
Pepperoni Pizza
POG Seltzer
Salad Basalmic Dressing Add Grilled Chicken
Greek salad
Pepperoni and Veggie
Pizza Slice
Spinach Goat Cheese Salad
Garlic Cheese Bread
Primo Beer
Pasta
Cheese Calzone
Coconut Porter
Salad
Big Swell IPA
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Lunch
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"This is the exact type of pizza I'm always looking for. Crispy crust, great sauce or cheese ratio and delicious flavor. Reasonable prices, cute place..."
Tiffany Pershall
"We ate here last night on 4th of July which I have to assume was the busiest night of the year in Lahaina. This is where Maui has their firework..."
Kyle Sela
"Great place to grab a quick pizza and salad. We came for a late dinner and enjoyed a salad, garlic bread and pizza. The salad was amazing with..."
Robert Artelt
"Delicious! So much flavor and perfect texture! My wife and I got the Old World Pizza with pepperoni. It went well with a couple of Maui beers and a..."
Michael Viart
"Pizza is good. They have quite a selection of toppings to choose from with build your own options available. Calzones are also on the menu. I think..."
Justin Antonietti
"Pizza was yummy, just not a fan of the crust but their toppings were pretty good. Nice ambiance and very friendly staff. They close pretty early so..."
Marianne Alonso
"Needed a quick bite to eat before a boat ride, and Prison Street Pizza was the perfect option for us! Being from the East Coast originally, I was..."
Alex Studd
"I was definitely ready to try pizza again on this trip back to Maui. This time we were looking for a good thin crust. Prison Street Pizza the..."
Temple Thomas
"Super friendly and fast service. We were there after a lunch rush so was easy finding a table. I highly recommend their Pizza. We tried a medium..."
Celine Marie
"Fun pizza combos with a meal well priced. I ordered 2 slices with extra toppings and a water for less than $10! Great..."
Rock Jocelyn
"We ate here three separate times and happy each time. Definitely one of the cheaper options and a non greasy thin pizza is never a bad idea. I just..."
David Ditta
"Best pizza ever. The crust is simply superb and the cheese is somehow amazing! Don’t go anywhere else for pizza. Oh. And the calzone is the best..."
Jennie Spendlove
"This is our go-to pizza place on Maui. Even if we’re not hungry we have to stop by at least once every trip. So worth it! You won’t be..."
Jen M
"Great pizza! Only place in town where you can get just a slice if you want! Super friendly people too! Highly recommend if you’re in Lahaina and..."
Brook Y.
"You know it’s gonna be a good pizza when the box doesn’t close all the way cuz crust is blocking it. And oh boy is it good. This is New York..."
Scott Kerr
"Full disclosure, if you are from the Mainland, the prices will be a little shocking at first (I paid over $60 for 2 pizzas). Let's just say that at..."
Zahra Kardos
"Great off the beaten path relaxing environment with the best pizza and service. On a whim heading north took a left on a side street “Prison St”..."
76 Power Wagon