The best Restaurants in Middletown ranking of March 2025
977 restaurant menus in Middletown, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"Saw all the great reviews online and decided I had to try this place out. I wasn't disappointed. The food was great especially the artisan meat and..."
Sean Cyr
"Very friendly staff. Food for everyone - vegan, gluten free and carnivores - and all was delicious. Plenty of selection of beer, on tap and in..."
Caron Dodson
"First visit at “Celtic Cavern” 45 Melilli Plaza, Middletown, CT 06457. A gastropub specializing in seasonal American fare (not Irish fare, as the..."
Len Hahn
"Great place to grab a bite and a beer! Service was wonderful. Everything the staff suggested was great! Highly recommend the Brussel..."
mandy turpin
"We got take out and the food was very flavorful and good! When we went to pick up the food, the people were nice and the place looked very cool, I..."
Alexis B
"Lively and fun atmosphere. The best wait staff we've ever seen! EVERY single person was extremely friendly. Food was very good! Pork chops were huge..."
Sue Mcq
"1st time visit. Varied menu. Not pub food. Surely not classic Irish fare. Upscale menu but reasonable priced. Chef prepared. 19 taps, great staff...."
"I’ve brewed with Starbucks, dunkin, kona (variety of brands) and more other whole bean and ground coffees than I care to list and I must say..."
Ryan Kitchel
"Great coffee! Can't get enough of it! Would highly recommend buying..."
Jonathan Bonfiglio
"Tried a cup of Perkatory Coffee the other day from a local place in Wallingford. Then I bought a pound for home. Both the hubby and I love the taste..."
Lisa Howard Liptak
"Just made a pot of the Papua New Guinea from Perkatory Coffee Roasters in Middletown. Great roast!! Can't wait for more from these..."
Dave Lanata
"Perkatory coffee is fantastic, I love it hot and cold brew, either way is delicious. I would recommend it to..."
Adam Bradley
"Just brewed up some Paua New Guinea and it is amazing!!! Highly recommend getting some! I'll deffinaly be back for some..."
Zachary Craig
"I have faith that, when this coffee is released, it will be..."
Erik Higgens
"Awesome Fresh roasted beans make the perfect cup of joe, owners are some of the nicest people around! Highly..."
Scott Gordon
"This coffee is excellent simply put. The taste is phenomenal and it is super smooth you will not regret buying this. Definitely going to be getting..."
Brent Jacobs
"Klekolo who? Dunkin what? Best cuppa I’ve had in a long..."
Mitchell Westcott II
"This coffee is going to be the tits. Trust me, I'm a..."
"My husband and I have been wanting to try the Spinning Fork for awhile now. and on Saturday, we finally made it there. The food was phenominal!! ..."
Sara Martin Faulkner
"Katie was our server and she was great! We are so glad we found Spinning Fork! We have looked for a great Italian restaurant all over Dayton and..."
Tonya Crider Truran
"We found this restaurant by googling Italian food one day. It's a hidden gem. We have been back many times. We recommend it to those who love..."
Kassy Cotterman
"great service and great food. Very nice atmosphere. The calamari was fresh and some of the best I've ever had also had a ribeye steak that was cooked..."
Cheryl Minnich
"We were very impressed with the atmosphere, ambience, and EXCEPTIONAL staff AND best Italian we’ve ever..."
Danielle Boone
"Great food and service. They usually have a special sangria they make which is always good! Also love their house salad dressing. Good food + good..."
Karen Keister Massey
"This place, the food and staff are amazing!!! The food is always great and you definitely get big..."
Carol Dunn
"My wife took me there for my birthday yesterday. I can honestly say I have never seen a staff work together so well. There was no fighting over..."
Keith Pendergrass
"First visit. Outstanding food and the staff was fantastic. Beautiful ladies serving up delicious Italian..."
Matt Leaman
"We had a large group of 15. Our food was hot and delicious and our server was excellent! She was kind and you could tell she enjoyed her job. We will..."
Dan Schaub
"Amazing place, amazing food, and great service!!
But miss your Mom seating us😔!!
She was a friend to all who..."
Shelley Mathews Pisula
"We stopped in tonight for dinner. Tried the sausage & ricotta mushrooms for the 1st time and they were delicious. They have alfredo sauce on them..."
Tammy Hunt (Muff)
"Best Italian place around. If you can’t find it, sorry about your luck. Great portions, great food & drinks and great service!!! Rare to see the..."
Mike Brasel
"A wonderful Italian restaurant located in Middletown Ohio. Always great service. The daily specials encourage frequent visits. We love the..."
Matthew Heller
"Usually food is food. Just something you need. But today, I can assertively say I really ENJOYED my food. The special was steak with asparagus and..."
Lawson Ott
"The service was extremely fast and our server and extremely polite and friendly. I ordered the fetuccini alfredo and it was a bit watery and the..."
Emily
"It's food has really improved! The before, spinning fork food, was not as good. I gave it another whirl since the name changed. Everthing was fresh..."
Amy York
"I was very pleasantly surprised by this place. Food was excellent, prices are reasonable. I would highly..."
Anna Simmons
"My family and I ate there for an early mothers day dinner. I have not been to the spinning fork since I was a kid. My family and I were very pleased..."
Misty Bland
"Food was good. Service OK. WARNING! The EVOO on the table is heavily infused with the garlic! Luckily I caught it before my 82 year old mom dipped..."
William Teager
"We loved the service we received. The atmosphere was exactly what we were looking for, as it was quiet and quaint. The food was awesome and we were..."
"My husband gets the zombie killer he loves it! I get an iced latte and baked goods. All of the baked goods I have tried are good. The set up is nice..."
Elizabeth Vassallo
"My husband and I found this place by accident. We recently moved to the area and often meet up for lunch. The GPS took us here and although I had a..."
Amy Smith
"Great Chai Tea Latte's, very nice spice and flavor! the dirty chai and zombie killer are awesome..."
Cynthia J Lam
"Cool venue. Sandwiches were delicious. But the coffee, some of the best I have had. Great staff. Coffee was better than..."
Della Freedman
"Excellent coffee and the custom coffees benefiting Vet’s totally sold me. I only wish we lived closer so I could visit more often. I had the Iced..."
Norm Martineau
"Locally owned, friendly staff, awesome coffee. What more do you need? I'll take a Red..."
John C. Farley
"Absolutely love this place!!! The coffee is amazingly delish and the staff are super..."
Ash Gonsalves
"Love everone, never unpleasent people behind the counter! Great place and great people all..."
Edith Torres
"Half price for military on Mondays and 10% off the rest of the week. These guys are awesome and so is their..."
Gordon Bellinger
"This place is extraordinary.
Freshly roasted, great cold brew, great barista's.....you'd be missing out if ya don't drop..."
Karen Robinson
"Really great people. .. really great coffee. .. great..."
Elaine Miller Summerhill
"Love this little gem of a coffee shop!! Clam Jamb was fun..."
Brian Trapp
"Amazing coffee..will return again this week for our lb of..."
Saraya Irvin
"I'm in love with Organic Columbian French/Dark Roast
thank..."
Jenny Rebecca
"This has probably become my favorite coffee shop in the Newport area lately. A basic building with some covered outdoor seating gives way to a rustic..."
Rob Purdy
"I absolutely love this place. I drive pass it on my way to work and I'm so grateful I decided to try it out! Their iced spiced chai is amazing and..."
Kaitlyn de Melo
"Very good coffee and the breakfast is also above average. Definitely recommend this place for a quick good breakfast and coffee. Definitely among the..."
MM M
"I feel lucky to live so close to this great coffee shop! Their specialty drinks are always amazing, like the pumpkin sweet cream cold brew in the..."
Nicole Francis
"Great spot, local coffee shop with great coffee. Staff is always very nice and attentive. Often get iced decaf and iced coffee and they make sure to..."
"My husband and I order a lot, after we moved into Middletown we were on the hunt for our new delivery spot! We have FINALLY found it with..."
Katie Egenrieder
"Awesome cheese fries and LOVE the taco pizza! Good steak hoagies as well! Very prompt delivery! Beats Midtown hands..."
Mary Jo Stewart
"Great local pizza place. We can walk there and food is always great. Staff is super nice and it’s clean! Come to middletown and..."
Leigh Hurst
"Food is always delicious. Great coupons online. Order online I love this fast easy process food always delivered HOT and delicious. Thanks for great..."
Renai Roy
"Half way around the world and I still can't wait till my next robertos meal mane order of hot wings extra crispy sauce on the side with a slice mane..."
Anthony Chambers
"We use Roberto's Pizza for our Birthday parties here at Let's Pretend! Their pizza is superb and they always give us top notch service. We LOVE..."
Kerri Doyle Meyer
"Roberto's is always our break n eat when I take my granddaughter Leah walking around..."
Cathy Meise
"My first visit here, and I ordered a large steak stromboli with fried onions. Being a native to Philly of 40 years, I am Leary to steak anything as I..."
MemoryDieppa
"Loved the subs...seemed to be pizza dough used as the bread...loved it! Great portions especially for the prices. Nice guy behind the..."
Jamie Ott
"Excellent pizza. The sausage in particular is wonderful. The sides were delicious, as well. They didn't have one particular item we ordered but staff..."
Daniel Taulbee
"Very good taste of the sauce and great texture of the bread..."
Y Z
"The tuna salad with veggies was delicious. I brought some..."
"Awesome place to come eat, have a drink or just Chill. The food was great, atmosphere was perfect and the owner was very friendly. Ill be back for..."
Rudy Bolivar
"Awesome to find an East Coast Wahoo's. One of our favorites from Southern California, it was great and this one did not disappoint. Service was very..."
Beach Pig
"From the fantastic food to the great bar. You really can’t go wrong! If you are a tequila fan this is a must stop. Kid friendly..."
Toby Stark
"First time ever hearing of Wahoo's and I'm glad I did! Food was delicious and the service was courteous. The manager even came out to make sure we..."
Titus
"I love Wahoo’s. When I lived out west I went to the one in Costa Mesa all the time. The food here is great and reminds me of the original, but..."
Britt
"Outstanding experience. Had the SPM burrito smother in green enchilada sauce and cheese. Absolutely delicious. Also had a Wahoo taco which was..."
"The family and I went to celebrate my 12 year old son's birthday. Our server was a lady named, Jamie. The food was good and the service was great!..."
Joanna Michelle
"The food is good, along with the service. Not a bad place to have a..."
Danny Couch
"Our service was great! The waitress was on the spot and got everything right. My steak was cooked perfectly and only 1 steak of the 13 in my party..."
Michael Brown
"The best dad burn steaks of all time! Excellent cook! Our waiter was Louis and he is the most personable absolutely awesome. Salads were fresh and..."
Nancy Medacco
"The steak was cooked and seasoned to perfection and the wait staff were very prompt and friendly. The bread is delicious if you are not on a carb..."
Guy Clark
"My steak was cooked just the way I like it. The broccoli side was nicely steamed. They got the order a tad wrong and didn't put my dressing on the..."
Connie Crum
"Was seated immediately in a booth as requested. We like that our entree came with salad and 2 sides. I had the Sidewinder grilled chicken and I..."
Clifford Johnson
"Restaurants in the area are really rough, but this is a local gem. By far the nicest, cleanest, best service in the area. Sure if your driving..."
Brooks Fiesinger
"Had a decent dining experience, one hiccup with an item. Sent it back, and it was replaced. Manager stopped by the table to see if the second..."
Aaron Hoyt
"Lone Star Steakhouse sets the standard for Steak & Roadhouse food, service & tradition. You can always expect an excellent meal from Lone Star hands..."
Lucky
"Our waiter Zach was awesome. My husband asked for fried mushrooms which was not on the menu but he made it happen!. It was a nice gesture for my..."
Stacey West
"My husband and I came into your restaurant last night Dec 27 2013 needless to say after all our previous experiences my family never wanted to come..."
Mark Welch
"The service is always excellent! I recently was there and my steak was not to my liking. I was not going to complain but when the waitress asked I..."
"Their combo menu is worth the money. It’s like 10 bucks for a person. I heard they had a buffet. Due to covid they no longer have it. But soon..."
Denuwan Vithanage
"The most delicious soup I have ever tasted in my life. Please try the tomato soup with naan. Very pleased and I love this soup. Perfect combo. I hope..."
Amaya Dignazio
"Lovely delicious food, very friendly staff not much..."
Mario Nakandala
"The food and ambience is wonderful. Everyone should definitely give it a try. The mango lassi is a must. Thankyou..."
aastha limbu
"We have dined in and used Uber Eats. The Chicken Tikka masala is yummy but lately the Chicken Tikka had been a go to; the lemon wedge really helps..."
"Absolutely the most amazing breakfast sandwich I've had in a really long time! Definitely going to be coming back here when I'm in the..."
Lyz Heldewig
"I have nothing but good things to say about the bagel shop & deli. The customer service is really amazing. I like the fact that they take time to..."
Paulette
"The bagels ( and all other foods) are delicious... the owner is awesome. And the customer service is on point. Probably the best bagel joint around...."
Angie Rojas
"Very good food. Extremely friendly..."
Charles
"Best deli in town. Amazing food and great service. Kate is the..."
Stephen Scherrer
"Best place to grab sandwich in Middletown. This was absolutely incredible. The seasonings within the SEC were on point. Only eating here from now..."
Henry Bonilla Jr
"Order from Connecticut for my mom in New York surprise birthday sandwich she enjoyed the sandwich very much and the delivery driver was excellent..."
"I’ve been here twice now. These are the best empanadas I’ve had out of middletown maybe even my whole life. The presentation is top notch. When..."
Terrence Martin
"Such a cute place and super friendly quick service! The food was amazing!! Definitely recommend and will definitely be coming back when I visit..."
Gissele Del Rosario
"I love this place so much, the staff is very kind and accommodating!! don’t get me started on the food, because it hits the spot on so many..."
Dana Almasaeid
"I have tried this restaurant twice and both times even though it has ben a while since I tried ordered they were both good. They haven't changed a..."
lui- g
"Delicious empanadas, arepas, mofongo and other plantain dishes plus some extra sides. Vegetarian and vegan options as well! We had great service and..."
K C
"Delicious, fresh food with an attentive staff. The interior has a cute, bright interior that reminds you of a cozy cafe. Reasonably priced and..."
Odessa Denby
"My daughter and I loved the food. Very tasty and will be back. I had the beef with cheese and without cheese empanadas, yellow rice, beans and..."
"Fusion made a custom pumpkin shaped cake for my son's 1st birthday party (pumpkin theme). The cake was absolutely beautiful!! I was 100% pleased with..."
Samantha Trudeau
"New management brings a smile to any face! Such a delightful crew here! We found the same yummy bakery items, but with lots of new lunch items.
My..."
Marian Carrillo
"The decor may not be all that alluring, but the treats inside certainly are. The service was excellent and the owner is very knowledgeable and..."
Albert Oyegun
"This is probably my favorite bakery. Steve makes the most incredible croissants and pastries I can think of. The cheese Danishes are out of this..."
Dan Labbe
"I was the crazy lady who had no clue what to really order. I called a few times and each time who ever I talked to on the phone was really helpful. I..."
Monz E
"I am impressed how good their cakes are and the craftsmanship of their decorator. The cake was moist and tasty and the frosting is just sweet enough...."
Rich Sylvester
"Very good bakery. There are plenty of grab and go baked good if you stop in and want to grab something. They will make special order caked with a..."
"Best pizza we have had by far and we've tried a lot of pizza! The garlic Parmesan crust is a must and the cheesy garlic bread is..."
Brittni Vella
"Love love love everything about this place fromthe food to the owner to the staff everything is..."
Danielle Ray
"Absolutely amazing pizza. Great service and very clean. You have to try the French fries made in the oven. Omg!!!!!! A must have when around..."
Robert Mailhiot
"I've never had a bad meal or experience here!!! Simply..."
Jessica Lynn
"Pizza & meatball sub. RIDICULOUS! ..."
Pete Donnelly
"We are new to the area and finding this gem was a pleasant surprise. Hands down the best pizza on Aquidneck Island. The dining area is a bit..."
Scott Lamprides
"Love..."
David Brown
"Best pizza in town..."
Richard Ford
"Best pizza in rhode..."
Thomas Caltagirone Jr.
"Yum yum..."
Lisa Wild Cornell
"This place has amazing pizza for many, many years! I highly recommend the white pizzas such as Buffalo chicken, rosemary chicken, steak bomb etc...."
The Take Professor
"Carmella's is the only place I have to make sure I eat at when I'm in the area. Great food, very friendly staff who seem to know everyone who comes..."
Bob K
"Awesome local pizza and pasta. The angel hair spaghetti with homemade meatballs was delicious. Decent sized meatballs packed with flavor. Homemade..."
"I ordered 2 eggs over easy, they were over medium, hash browns are sliced potatoes with the skin a few onions and no seasoning. 2 English muffins..."
Dan Herrick
"I have been here before. What a great little spot. Food is wonderful, service is amazing, and the prices are fair.
I would not hesitate to..."
James Fetta
"Pretty good! Perfect for when you have just enough time to sit down and eat on your way to school. Also the lady working there was super nice...."
Jeannie Johnson
"Small family diner. Wasn't bad. It was the only thing open early for breakfast. I had the meat lovers omelet. Quite tasty. I would go here again for..."
Russell Cook
"Haven't been here since before I got my license. Still as good as I remembered. The friendly excellent service and a cozy atmosphere tie this place..."
Nick “Big Nick”
"What a great little cafe. Food was awesome & the waitress was wonderful & so friendly. Will definitely be..."
Sharon Case
"A hidden gem! I never would have known it was there if it wasn't the only place close by and open on Google Maps. So glad it was though, because it's..."
Ryan Stetson
"It's a diner not much to write home about staff is friendly and food is decent
I would..."
"First pizza I met in the town, and it was awesome. Love the..."
전형진
"This pizza is absolutely amazing,I recommend to anyone looking for something to eat,it's all fresh and delicious, the only trouble I have is the..."
Whiny ThePoo
"I always eat here when in town! Love the pizza and..."
Christina Taulbee
"I'd like to say thank you to all the workers at the Jackson lane cassanos in middletown.in all my years of ordering i have only had 1 time that I..."
matt beatty
"Had a great experience!! The food was excellent and the service was the..."
Nicole Lane-Simonson
"Pizza is really Good and with the house made garlic butter that you can use on anything even bagels. There cheezy garlic bread is the bomb. The price..."
Pink Haze
"Love this place! When we are in town, this is where we're..."
J D
"I really like there pizza. It's a thin crust pizza. They also have subs. The restraunt was clean and service was..."
Sheri A
"This pizza is great. It's known as a St Louis style pizza crust. This is a thin crust. The toppings are finely chopped instead of big chunks. It has..."
Paul K
"Literally the best pizza around. Thin crust with pepperoni and sausage...."
Mindy Baker
"Great customer service restaurant was clean. When I picked up my pizza it wasn't quite ready so he told he would bring it to me at my car he did an..."
Ginny Jones
"My daughter moved to SC and misses Cassanos she always has to get her fix. Always to our..."
Joan Carpenter
"Family loves this pizza! Can't get enough of it it's by far the best choice compared to the others. Our only thing is we prefer to order it well..."
"I liked the atmosphere and sitting outside listening to music was nice with a cool breeze and 77° at around 7pm. I wasn't impressed with the menu or..."
Dan Herrick
"Great place to go for live music! Delicious food and drinks as well. Our server was fantastic, and all the staff was friendly. Big public parking..."
Kevin Mackowski
"There is something about their steak seasoning.... pretty authentic. I am impressed with how well our table server took care of us. Politely asked us..."
F R
"Had a great time at Mezzo's the other night! It was a good atmosphere and the music was awesome, it definitely felt nostalgic! Bartenders were great,..."
Oliwia Bragiel
"Had a fun night out with my friend for her birthday. Mezzos is huge, very clean, they have an outdoor area, live music last night. Our server/..."
T R
"Large outside patio for dining. Bar outside was busy when we had dinner. Good selection on the menu, both my wife and I found items we enjoyed. ..."
"The Hop Knot has tapped into my two favorite things in the world... pretzels and beer. There is truly nothing better in my world. Add in good..."
Rachael Quinn
"Love the place, a great selection of beer on tap. I never thought pretzels could be so versatile. Pretzels, pretzel bites, stuffed pretzels, pretzel..."
Steven Pawson
"Food waa great, beer was tasty, happy hour specials and Groupon saved us some money, and the staff was really personable and fun to chat with this..."
Jessica Marie Glasser
"I am not a beer drinker yet I LOVED the pumpkin beer with the cinnamon sugar rim!! and the food was to die for, all home made pretzel breads, cozy..."
Joanne Arena
"Great service, selection and the menu was great the filled pretzels with dipping sauce are just what you need to pair with your choice of beer......."
Kiki Michalek
"Love going to the HopKnot!! Friendly staff great stuffed pretzels!! Remember to bring a hoodie or sweater.. it’s always cold winter or summer..."
Patty O'Brien
"Great beer selection and really nice staff. The Italian (pepperoni and cheese) stuffed pretzel was our favorite, but all were tasty and freshly..."
Amy Young
"We LOVED our first time there. Great atmosphere and selections. Our service was awesome, the bartender was super helpful and she was totally invested..."
Charity Kuchyt
"We loved it! Roberta was an excellent server and made great recommendations. Everything we ordered was..."
"I have not been to Chipotle's in a while and oh my goodness I'm so glad that I went. My food was amazing. The staff there were very nice. Very..."
Vicki Jones
"Food tastes amazing as always however their soda fountain is always out of the drink syrup and today was out of ice again. Not the biggest deal but..."
"Family Farm is always Family friendly as has been like an oasis for us during this time. The owners are super nice and everyone who works is always..."
Suphora Newsome
"Nice place! Very friendly staff. Like most icecream places, cash only and equally priced. We liked the fact that there were simple board games..."
Michelle ThiesCochran
"DEEEEELISH!! Portions were 👏!!! With so many different flavors. My kids had a blast. Oh, prices are..."
Francisca Marasciulo
"Great food. Great service. New owners are very nice people. Support local..."
Martin Nowak
"It is definately a place you can bring the family. I like the fact you can sample the icecream before you buy. I am always trying something..."
Priestly Canty
"I've been going here for about 25 yrs! My favorite ice cream spot in town. Their customer service is exceptional and the ice cream is to melt for!!!..."
Yohana Gonzalez
"Delicious ice cream. Incredible..."
Zach Farrell
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes