The best Restaurants in Mill Hall ranking of March 2025
23 restaurant menus in Mill Hall, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"I had no clue there was a Denny's over near
I 80. In Lamar PA. If I did I never remembered. I was so happy to be in Denny's again and it's close to..."
Robin Marnati Bartges
"Always delicious but my husband always orders t bone and we were told they ran out....also discontinuing shrimp with the steak....but food was great..."
Michelle Anderson
"Thank you to the two staff members who helped my mother with a medical emergency on March 4, 2018 around 8pm. They went out of their way to help her..."
DeDra Sagerstrand
"Amazing as always!!! The staff work extra hard to ensure everyone is seated and attended to quickly and with genuine smiles. The Berry Vanilla Crepes..."
John Jack
"Very clean, great food, friendly service. This was a great place to stop for breakfast on our..."
Samantha Heffner
"Good denny's overall. Thanks for staying open, unlike your competition across the street. Good coffee and great lumber jack breakfast. First time I..."
Michael Lewis
"I stopped at this location on Friday, June 3, 2022 at around 9:40 PM only to be told once again that it would be at least 45 minutes until we could..."
Jenny
"I enjoyed it. My waiter was very attentive. Gratefully appreciated. The menu could use an upgrade. Maybe it's because I'm a trucker. A pilot..."
"As someone who was raised in Oklahoma, I can say Curt’s has the best and most authentic southern BBQ I have ever had in the whole state of PA. The..."
Kaitlyn Durda
"Very good bbq joint. Like an old time southern place, Curt bought the old dairy queen that sat empty and started selling bbq. Nothing fancy here..."
Matthew Coll
"Ate here for the first time this past weekend while visiting my daughter at Lock Haven University. I had the BBQ Trio (Pulled Pork, Pulled Chicken &..."
Vincent Rissler
"We had the Bacon cheeseburger Wood fired pizza and it was the best pizza we have ever had! It was loaded with cheese, burger, tomato, bacon, pickles,..."
Angela M. Matthew
"Phenomenal ribs! The sauce is excellent and the meat is tender and juicy, perfectly cooked. The pulled pork and brisket sandwiches are also awesome -..."
Mary Katherine Dyczko Riglin
"Delicious food! The BBQ is very yummy, and my wife appreciated the gluten free pizza. The staff was quite friendly, too. Will come back..."
Nathan Sanders
"Amazing food and friendly people recommend to try this place for..."
Dawn Good
"Simple store front, but excellent food. Definitely a well hidden gem in central PA. The brisket was savory, the portions were great, and all at a..."
Tom Summerson
"I have yet to order anything that was not excellent. A year ago today They catered our wedding and the brisket, wings and pulled pork were all..."
Brian Rhoades
"Love this place- anytime we’re driving I-80 we stop. Get the baked beans (has smoke pork added..."
Beth Becker
"Came super late at night and the food was still so amazing. Friendly staff. First time ever there, but will definitely not be the..."
Silver Geyer
"Brisket is melt in your mouth tender. Definitely worth the trip..."
Jamie Grubb
""Pizza is 100% italian approved!"
-Nicola Avella - italian coworker visiting the..."
Kyle Heimbach
"A new favorite when in the area. Visiting family in the area and was looking for a local place and found Curt's. This place was great. I'm from the..."
Terrie Bass
"Oh. My. Gawd! This place is pure awesomeness! We don't get to come often, but when we do it is so worth the wait. 3 lbs of brisket gone in 10..."
JoAnn Buck Davis
"First time stopping here. The brisket was amazing and pulled pork was..."
Brandy Mason
"The absolute best BBQ along with bangin’ beans... cannot beat the honey habanero..."
Brandon Best
"I ordered food and all was great. The food was ready when I arrived. Check out was quick. We really enjoyed the pizza we purchased. I got it half..."
Reed Mellinger
"Some of the best barbecue I have ever had! Also, who would have guessed some of the best pizza in the area comes from a barbecue place?!
I have..."
Anthony Radle
"I had the brisket sandwich platter
and my wife had the pulled pork sandwich platter. We had fries, baked beans, and Cole slaw as sides. The BBQ was..."
Larry Dyett
"This place was kickass. The food was hot and delicious. The wings and ribs were stellar. I especially enjoyed the Mac n cheese. The staff were..."
Dan P
"Amaizing BBQ > truckers there's Parking available in front of the store. I will definitely stop again everytime I pass through..."
Adrian P
"The best ribs I ever ate. Who ever said there was no good BBQ north or the Mason-Dixon line has never been to Curt's! This cat smokes them..."
ed lezerp
"Had been there before. Tried a smattering of things this time. The ribs and briscuit really stand out.
There's not much seating. Take out is fast..."
"Great homemade food with very good prices. I had liver and onions which were excellent. They make their own pies and ice cream. Well worth the stop..."
Bruce Bair
"This place may not seem like much on the outside but the food is completely homemade and so delicious I am sitting here astonished. So good I had to..."
Kitty Queen cutey
"Awesome local spot to get some good food. Lots of things to choose from. Wish I had gotten some dessert because MAAAN that selection. Staff is super..."
Kionney
"We had the Cottage cater our wedding in May, including cocktail hour and a dessert bar as well. The whole staff was outstanding with customizing our..."
Stephen and Jamie
"I went tonight for dinner and had spaghetti with meatballs, Clam chowder And coconut cream pie for dessert.
Needless to say everything was..."
Nick Hadoulis
"ALRIGHT Y’ALL, this quaint fantastic restaurant is a must stop if you’re traveling through PA on 80 !!! The home cooked style food is delicious..."
Mr G
"Great local restaurant. Good food, really fresh. Make sure to get a side of fries! And the homemade ice cream sandwiches are tops. Friendly, fast..."
"Good place for icecream!Food is good also!Best ice cream..."
Spike Cross
"Best pretzels and ice cream around. Definitely a must if your in mill hall..."
Erica Lynn
"I’m in LOVE with the turkey and bacon sandwich..."
Mary Virginia
"Love the Ice Shack! Great prices and you get a lot for your money. Friendly staff. Worth the..."
Kimberlee Welshans Schreiber
"Toasted coconut ice cream was like eating coconut cream pie......."
Doug Lamey Sr
"I love the peanut butter milkshakes! I'll go get them more..."
Jason Cody Young
"Great food at great prices.The pretzels are really good and my husband loves their..."
Mark Kelly Leavitt
"great place to go to get some sweet things to..."
Donna Ruth Geyer Marshall
"Great pretzels and ice cream. Amish or Mennonite owned and very pleasant. Place was packed but we got our order within 5 minutes. Tons of parking, a..."
BlackRose 570
"Love the ice cream and pretzels. The service was slow. They had a gal at the walk up window and a gal at the counter, and other people in the..."
Sharon Bitner
"Always sooooo good. Such sweet staff and the proceeds benefit a non-profit. All kinds of ice cream/ frozen treats and pretzel items. CASH ONLY. ..."
Steven Walters
"Visiting family and the area, so my fiancé and I stopped by the Ice Shack while we were at Mill Hall. This was absolutely worth the stop. They had..."
Ben Wenner
"Very polite staff, always smiling and friendly! I would recommend to anyone in the area to stop by. Very fair pricing and the flavors of ice are..."
Micayla Mac
"First and second time having their soft pretzels ❤️ plan on going back multiple times this summer..."
Seth Reeder
"The ice cream is great and there's a large variety of flavors but for me it's their sandwiches and pretzels that are the..."
Connor Winslow
"They have the best tasting ice cream and home-made pretzels..I would recommend this place to..."
"Very nice and authentic place. The style of interior design and table arrangement clearly hints at the intended content of the menu. Excellent..."
Anton Alalaev
"I go to this Ruby Tuesday quite often and have become a regular there. The staff is always super friendly and I especially enjoy Mandy the waitress,..."
Sydney Glossner
"Food was fantastic, atmosphere was also. Waiter seemed unsure of himself, but was great with customer service. Just had a few issues with our..."
Galene Smith
"I took a team of athletes from Special Olympics PA here in our way to a competing. Manager, Jodey, went above and beyond to help us make this an easy..."
Rebecca Roof
"I order dinner every Thursday. Today was the exception being Monday. She always makes sure that everything is ok and I leave with her saying “have..."
michael radford
"The manager went out of his way for my nana when her oxygen machine died. He offered to go to Walmart and buy an extension cord so she can charge her..."
lifes greatest adventures
"Ruby Tuesday is one of my favorite places to eat. I absolutely love the salad bar :) they have the best in town! I always order the classic..."
"Stopped here on the way home from a day of fishing at Bald Eagle state park. Staff was friendly, food was great, and prices were fine. Nice place to..."
Mark Simmons
"Stopped here last month while traveling from NY to Altoona for my daughter's wedding. Friendly atmosphere, great service and the steak salad is..."
Deb Stanton
"We were a large party of 15 people. The food was great and the service was excellent. My grilled chicken salad was the size that could feed a small..."
Duane Miller
"My wife and I don't go out for breakfast often and decided to try the Creek Side Restaurant. We were pleasantly surprised. The staff was very..."
Large Stromboli with Cheese Steak Meat Grilled Onions and Mushrooms Added In
Loaded Garlic Bread with Cheese Ham and Banana Peppers
Canadian Bacon Sub with Cheese
French Fries or Tossed Salad
Veggie Pizza
Calzone
Meat Lover's Pizza
Italian Sub
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I worked at OIP when I went to college at Lock Haven University 15 years ago. Every now and then I stop by on my way north. I can honestly say that..."
joseph borovich
"I love it here! Only get back to Lock Haven about once a year, but when I do... this is a must stop! Please don't ever stop being..."
deanna bennett
"OIP is an original classic that continues to serve the community with delicious foods such as steaks and hoagies. They also have many other dishes..."
Donald Jackson
"I have been there twice last Wednesday a meat spaghetti and meatballs or wonderful today is the cheese ravioli great again I definitely recommend..."
Stanley J Williams
"Love the food. Server was..."
Kristie Strope
"Amazing food and even better Waitresses very friendly and helpful. Plus the owners are supper friendly and easy to talk to when..."
"I brought my family from an hour and 45 minutes away just to try the food I'd heard so much about from an employee. We decided on the fried fish and..."
Amy Abbotts
"We had just traveled 9 hours and were starving. This little place was next door to our hotel so we walked over. What a find ... the service was..."
Joy Guelli Gerken
"Tracy is a great bartender, could not ask for better service and company. Food is delicious and prices are great. Could not recommend a better place..."
Tj Ryerson
"We went there as a class there was 19 of us and we all got our food about the same. Servers were friendly and took great care of us. big portion. ..."
Elaine Sterrett
"Always a great place to eat. Wait staff are friendly and remember you and your likings. Family friendly atmosphere, and food is always great..."
Prella Ann Smith
"Wonderful staff, spectacular homemade food, nice atmosphere, would definitely recommend..."
Carrie Morris-Major
"Accommodated 30 of us! Staff was remarkable- friendly and very helpful! Food was awesome! Highly recommend the fried pepper rings and Pittsburgh..."
Jen Murnane Borger
"Nice atmosphere,friendly waitress.
The haddock was delicious and
as big as my arm!
The deep fried mushrooms were
tasty and the coleslaw was the best..."
Joseph Wilson
"Amazing food and great staff. Was a little loud due to party when we first arrived but was worth it all when we left with full bellies!..."
Stacey Bellerdine
"Ate at the Tavern tonight with Family before they move to NC. Food was amazingly delicious � �����and our waitress Lisa was..."
Susan Boksan Rapone
"We had a beautiful night for myself and family. The staff is remarkable. The owner is a perfect to all who visit there. I will be going back soon...."
Betty Motter
"Best place to eat in the Hublersburg area !!!!! Great food....reasonable prices....great service..."
"Great place to eat go there every Tuesday they have a Great Buffet great staff Pizza is always very..."
Teresa Osborne
"Great Service and Great Food!! Manager even brought pizza that I like from the buffet out to..."
Scott Vid Andrus
"Great Staff !! Great Food !! The long time Manger Sandy has retired good miss my friend !! Enjoy Retirement !! We..."
Joy Embick
"Pizza was really good. Our waitress was very nice even though I don't know her..."
Jason Cody Young
"It was easy to order online and was ready for pick up no wait time when arrived to pick up very friendly..."
Misty Frank
"The timing was perfect and the food was great. Great amount of meat on the pizza! Not stingy at..."
Shelby Foltz
"My order was made quickly & accurately. When I picked it up, I used the drive through window & the guy who gave me my food was kind & got my food out..."
Keara Weaver
"Pizza was ready on time...food was hot and..."
Brenda Sholly
"Food quality as good as ever, and delivered faster than expected by great..."
Mike Dougherty
"Stopped there yesterday while traveling home. We honestly stopped to go to Arby's but they only had the drive thru open. Talked with the staff here..."
Carrie Shovestull
"The small pan pizza boxes were crushed but amazingly not the pizza inside... otherwise..."
"I was very impressed with the food. The owner came to make sure everything was okay. Nice place will be back..."
Renee Rafter
"Really good food at good prices. Wait staff is..."
Gloria Horner
"Haven't been there in months. The last time I was there the food was..."
Kristie Strope
"GREAT SERVICE!!!
The food was hot & fresh and our server was..."
Sheri Loveland
"Food very good and the prices are pretty good..."
Jay Martin
"Great food and company. Love the..."
Pill745
"We went for the famous fish dinners on Friday night, it was the first time ever going to this establishment. It was very good,the beer battered fish..."
"Best subs around.........been eating them since the late 60's. I live near Pittsburgh now, but when I'm in town, I stop and get their subs. Worth the..."
Karen Hilliard
"Literally a hole in the wall sandwich shop. Hands down the best sandwich I have ever had east of the Mississippi. Give them a try you wont be..."
bigairtrix2
"Hands down probably the best subs in the..."
nick nagle
"Been eating them all my life and plan on continuing til I can't anymore..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes