The best Restaurants in Milltown ranking of March 2025
49 restaurant menus in Milltown, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"A wonderful place for food with friends and family. We were celebrating my nephews graduation. It was truly a special meal in a wonderful ambience...."
Pratap Dhopte
"Couldn’t believe I have never reviewed one of our favorites….we have been here numerous times and we have never been disappointed. Our last visit..."
Tom Z
"Extremely happy w the service (Adelina was so sweet!). Super knowledgeable about the menu. The food was flavorful and the steak cooked perfectly. ..."
Tahina Reyes
"The BEST steak I've ever had- seriously.
I've come here about 5 times now and I've never been disappointed by their food.
So far everything I've..."
صحارا
"Excellent food and even better excellent service. The managers the waitress everyone was very accommodating and super nice. The steak I got was a..."
jerry
"This place is top of the lines!
Food quality, the appearance, the professionalism of the staff, our server Aaron , he was outstanding!
We had some..."
Ilya Kos
"Overall: Good waitstaff. Excellent food. Good lunch options. Nice old world decor. Negative: We went there on a Friday for lunch and stood in the..."
"I mean it's certainly no five star restaurant but for fast food it seems like the most fresh. I heard claims that the Wendy's on Ryders Lane it's..."
Shawn X
"Food is pretty good along with price but something about it doesn't compare to a place like burger king, maybe just better taste in the food. This..."
"Went for a dinner with friends. Cute traditional Applebees. Food was good, I always like their fried chicken. Our party also had Classic appetizer,..."
L. L.
"We truly enjoyed the meal at Applebees. I ordered a shrimp with sirloin and my husband ordered the black bean quesadillas. The food tasted good and..."
Promiti Ghose
"Carside to go was easy to order online and super fast pick..."
Local Guide NJ
"Carside service is prompt and friendly and the food comes out piping hot...which means it's still warm by the time we get home to eat..."
"Quaint little family owned neighborhood bagel store..you can tell the owner cares about his customers. Very reasonably priced excellent fresh food..."
Todd Reiter
"I'm no expert but I do absolutely love a good bagel. Having lived in NY, Brooklyn, and eating bagels every week for most of my life, I've come to..."
KJK
"Been coming here since I was a kid, 25 years ago. When I am in town visiting my folks I hit it up every day. Great bagels, egg salad, tuna fish and..."
Vanilla and Chocolate Swirl with Rainbow Sprinkles
Medium Soft Serve Vanilla Cone with Sprinkles
Cookie Crumbles on Top of Cookies and Cream Under That Waffle Cone
Pistacho Fresa Cafe
Birthday cake
Local Honey
Cookies & Cream
Ice Cream Sundaes
Cookies and Cream Ice Cream
Ice Cream
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"Great selection of delicious ice-cream. So many different flavors! The portions are big enough, and the prices are fair. I am often visiting this..."
James Reaves
"First time here with my Auntie and the ice cream was amazing and the portions were more than enough. Friendly cashier, I’ll will be..."
Stephanie Stewart
"This was my first time visiting this ice cream shop. This is a new location on Main St. for this store. The portions here a huge. A medium cone will..."
Jaime Brownell
"If you go after dinner on the weekends in the summer, expect a line. However they have a good variety, friendly service and good portions..."
Paul S
"You get a lot for a little here. Just a baby size ice cream would be a medium at other places. This place can be very busy at times but the staff..."
Scott Harrigan
"They're awesome. Portions are large. Ice cream and sundaes are..."
Elvira Espada
"First time going after hearing about it and I ordered the medium size banana split. My wife ordered a sundae and we were pleasantly surprised and NO..."
Life Lessons
"I have not been to Ice Cream Depot in ages...but now with MCDs fourth increase in a short time - I'm wondering if people go back to retail Ice Cream..."
"I'm so glad we found Pasquale's. The Pizza, the Baked Ziti and the Broccoli were all bursting with unique flavors. Everything was fresh, and even the..."
Eric Cortese
"Best ever Pizza!!! Especially buffalo chicken is BEST absolutely. I think best taste comes from fire pot(oven). Actually I am not enjoy pizza. Cuz..."
Leo Kang
"The Grandma slice, pictured on the left had a delicious thin crust. The crust was a combination of crispy and dense. The sauce was extremely fresh..."
Cody Obropta
"Brick oven pizza is amazing! Garlic knots is amazing! Make sure you get the pesto on the side. You can do custom made stuff, will try the pasta next..."
Sarang Mulchandani
"We love the food here. Garlic knots are killer! Calzones and pizzas are excellent. Love the salads. Desserts are terrific. We've had many different..."
"Best Chinese food I've had in a while. All the food tasted good and order was prepared accurately. Chicken in the sesame and General Tso was tender..."
Juan Swist (Mike)
"No matter what day of the week I go, the food always has a consistently good taste and never mess up my..."
tony maisonet
"Great food! Take out Service is..."
Cathy Marino
"Smells amazing, food was decent - not AMAZING - not terrible. Like regular American..."
Philip Andrango
"Phenomenal experience! Top notch food, atmosphere, and friendly staff. Have been here multiple times, and every time is an amazing experience all..."
"Came back twice in one month for the Whole Fried Red Snapper with sweet and sour sauce. So delicious!
Tried the Papaya salad with Shrimp, and..."
Lovely Lovely
"Probably the BEST THAI RESTAURANT I have ever been too!! The place is so neat, clean, and the managers as well as the employees were so nice and..."
Aviation Force
"Food is amazing and so is the staff. We've been going here since they've opened and always have great food. The staff is always courteous and very..."
Kim Czachur
"This place has the best Thai food in NJ, hands down. Service is excellent, staff is knowledgeable and friendly, despite always being busy. Ive had..."
Doreen West
"I can't believe I waited years to ever come here. The place is lovely, staff is super friendly and accommodating and the food was AMAZING! I'm coming..."
WeX Majors
"Great place, wonderful Thai food. You definitely should give it a try.
Service is great, nice atmosphere as..."
Nicki N
"I was excited about this place because they have tofu larb! Being a vegetarian and only ever seeing larb made with meat, I was intrigued and not..."
"Lox, Stock & Deli catered our Temple Gala on 6/26/22 for 170 people. All the food was delicious. Toni and her entire staff did a great job. They..."
Arthur Rosenfield
"My go to source for Kosher Catering. Toni is awesome and very easy to work with. They always go the extra..."
Scott Fink
"I have tried almost everything on the menu at this establishment & I can describe it in only 1 word…
DELICIOUS!!!!
What makes things even better is..."
"Excellent service post a 6 + miler hash run through crazy conditions. Attentive service and delectable bar food. Met the owner...superb gentleman and..."
Matthew PT Casserly
"Yes the wings are really that good. Crunchy as great Korean wings... I get the sauce on the side to keep them crunchy. Great prices for the drinks..."
sean burns
"The owner Chuck is very friendly and makes everyone feel so welcomed. The staff is all very nice. Good drinks, great food, music is on point, clean,..."
Jazmin Rodriguez
"Reasonably priced food and drinks. Clean. Not sure about distancing of tables. Hubby enjoyed his birthday wings and the fries are plentiful, tasty..."
Rena Strool
"Love the food, especially the wings and fries. Bartenders are very attentive! Cash only though so come..."
"Excellent Illy coffee, in fact the only Illy place around within about an hour driving radius. Major positive here is the place's size and number of..."
Berele
"Open later than most other cafes around Rutgers - if you’re a student, they have loyalty punchcards! The barista was very kind and conversational...."
Alyssa Tanchoco
"Fantastic customer service and great coffee! Definitely worth a try and I will be..."
Judaya Vasquez
"Great addition to the Milltown area, located in the Target shopping center on Ryders Lane. Lots of excellent coffee options both hot and iced...."
"It's the home of the "Happy Waitress Sandwich"! Large portions, very fast service. This is a great neighborhood place. The menu is very large and..."
Joe Zuccarelli
"Visiting the small town of Milltown for a pool service, we came across this gem.. Great service, clean tables and floors.. and the food was great...."
KB Joseph
"Very good food and service at this long established small local diner. Family owned and operated with a clean and friendly..."
Jack Wagner
"Wanted to try a new place to eat with the family. The food was delicious I got the chicken pesto panini and my husband got the chicken cheesesteak..."
Jennifer Smith
"This was our first time at Milltown Diner.
It's a very small local diner. Nothing fancy but quaint. Not an extensive menu, but the usual expected..."
Jaime Brownell
"Such a great little spot. Happy to have found this on our road trip. The French toast bacon egg and cheese is a must try..."
"It's a nice store. Their Signature brand of food is usually pretty good for most things. As several reviews mentioned I like that the store usually..."
Dan Thomas
"This supermarket offers an impressive selection of vegtables, fruits and other products. This store is so clean you can practically eat off the..."
Mike R
"Great selection Fully stocked shelves and fair prices. Too bad this location is scheduled to close. Best market..."
Linda Winer
"I absolutely love the Milltown store its never overly crowded which makes it so much nicer to shop in. I can always find what i need. All the people..."
JoAnn Sanservino
"Got to love the bathrooms right up front, and this store is never too..."
"Great food and low prices, quick and friendly..."
Peter Carney
"Great food, hometown feel !..."
Julie Howard
"Food and service are always..."
Cheryl Sieg
"Great food and friendly country..."
Stephanie Shannon
"a friend of mine told me about this place we stop by after we got her taxes done and ate the food was delicious the portions was great that you just..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes