The best Restaurants in Montauk ranking of January 2025
132 restaurant menus in Montauk, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"For good reason, this has been a Montauk staple since I can remember. Was here this morning with my daughter and was reminded of why so many of us..."
Kalbaugh Family
"I read reviews that said this store had the worst customer service. I have to say I absolutely disagree. I sent an email to them on a Sunday..."
Debbie Orr
"We got surfboard rentals here and had no issues. They were happy to provide us with cardboard and straps to fasten the boards to the roof of my car...."
Cole von Richthofen
"For bike rentals: a tandem bike is pictured but they do not rent them. The bikes we rented were pretty solid but needed a bit of maintenance. I had a..."
Rebekah Newman
"Located in the center of town, this beachy rental shop made our weekend spectacular. On Friday we rented a moped and on Saturday we rented bikes. The..."
Tyler Wolf
"Great spot to pick up toys for the beach and pool! Huge selection of Montauk gifts and..."
Victoria Graham
"My friend and I rented electric mopeds from here. The attendant was very kind and covered the basics of the vehicle in under 3 mins. I had the time..."
Josiah O
"I saw a hoodie on their website in youth size so I called to see if it could be made in adult. Jill picked up the phone and was so great. She helped..."
Nina Gilden
"Had a problem with a sweatshirt not fitting properly and the staff was more than patient especially since it was a zoo that weekend! They have the..."
MsJennaNY
"I was in Montauk on vacation last year when I stopped by here. They had a huge selection of souvenirs, clothes, toys and more. I Highly recommend to..."
"Upscale buffet style. Chicken Milanese was fantastic. Pastries were out of this world. Vegetables were delicious.
Service was the kindest ever...."
Gabriel Davila
"I was floored by this restaurant. My partner and I were staying at Marram and had dinner our first night at Mostrador. The food was incredible -..."
Kate Marinkovich
"On top of delicious food, high quality ingredients and thoughtful service, the owners, chefs, operators and servers are delightful. We arrived on a..."
Lauren Kurtz
"Best prepared vegetables meals on LI? Desserts and coffee are also spectacular. Super casual but swanky at the same time...."
Robair Reichenstein
"One of the most peaceful, serene resorts I have ever stayed at. Every member of the staff we talked to was incredibly helpful and gracious, by the..."
Eric Amador
"A little too pricey but the food is amazing and the service is great. The views to the ocean are..."
Cristina Perez Cordon
"Absolutely love this place! Me and my husband come to Montauk almost every year but was always a bit disappointed with restaurants.. we finally found..."
Magdalena O.
"Mostrador Marram is a very cute cafe at the Marram Resort. We stopped in to get breakfast overlooking the beach based on a friends recommendation...."
Ajay Mahendra
"The presentation is so beautiful - you can taste it with your eyes and KNOW that it will be AMAZING. Trust me — your tastebuds will NOT be..."
Christina Maloney-Dillon
"Mostrador Marram is a must go for lunch if you're in Montauk! Every meal is fresh that day and the menu changes daily. The grilled vegetables were..."
"Froyo and Gelato is my family's favorite place! We go here everyday, every summer! The kids love it and I love it because there are so many options..."
Ghazala Choudhary
"This is a fun place for a frozen treat. There are always several frozen yogurts to choose from and a wide variety of toppings. Kids love the place. ..."
Barney Simon
"Tons of toppings. If you don't want the yogart you can just buy the toppings. Swedish fish, malted balls, reese's peanut butter cups, you name it...."
mary jo pojawis
"Elegant and chic, this joint has a lot of variety in a small space! Belgian waffles, crepes, candy, doggie treats, quinoa bowls, t-shirts and more -..."
Jeffrey Baez
"Buddaberry is a GREAT place to eat frozen yogurt and had a great and nice design. And is healthy too. But the people are sometimes not..."
Braeden Krzenski
"Best dessert in town. My family comes here every night when we’re in Montauk! Ask them for the Fro-Yo..."
Andy Bolton
"Delicious, delicious froyo and well worth the visit even in the summer crowds. Open fairly late,..."
Matt Ballard (450nm)
"So good! The amount of toppings they have is ridiculous. Will be returning for..."
Michelle Tate
"Favorite place in Montauk! Love going and getting some some froyo..."
Diana Arias
"Really good gelato and prices weren't..."
John
"Love it ,wish they more flavors and..."
NASA1
"Tasty but pricey. understandable for a seasonal..."
"Cute GEM in the middle of Montauk! I love the outdoor, super laid-back vibe. Great variety of coffee, tea and snacks. I recommend you stop..."
Jaime-Lynn Cornell
"Discovered this cute little coffee spot with a beach-town vibe. They serve La Colombe coffee, a nice place to sit outside and enjoy the..."
Sarah Labuda
"Perfect coffee shop. Best espresso & coffee I've had!!! Staff is super friendly too! If you're out in the Hampton's you have to stop at this Sagtown..."
E. M.
"Best coffee on the planet!
Nicest, coolest staff!
Everyone in Montauk needs to get their coffee and tea fixes here. It's the..."
Emma Brannen
"Great coffee. Great service. Cool hidden gem in..."
"Best breakfast and lunch in Montauk in the best..."
Eileen Choron
"Perhaps the best lobster roll I have ever eaten. Flavorful chunks of lobster in Dewan butter on a buttered, grilled bun. Served with salad + balsamic..."
David Laster
"Steve doesn’t just give you the best food in all of Montauk. He also makes you feel like you’re part of his family. He talks to you with an..."
Nike McAllister
"They make the best Lobster Roll!! Homemade Brioche Roll..Lobster cooked perfectly and come with a side salad and French fries..plus if you going..."
Heidi Siciliano
"Steve is so nice, I’m staying at the wave crest and he remembered my name throughout my stay. All the food I had was pretty good, and Steve is NOT..."
Abby _
"Best lobster roll in Montauk. Steve is a gem. I stayed at the Wave Crest and kept coming here every day. The smoothies are fresh and delicious. The..."
Nicole Toussaint
"Wow. Best lobster roll in Montauk. There, I said it. Fresh fries, salad and the brioche roll that makes you moan when you feel the crispy insides..."
Kareem Elbasty
"Stumbled upon this truck at my recent stay at the Wavecrest. The Best Food Truck I’ve ever been to, amazing breakfast, awesome lunch. Best hot..."
Anthony Nigrel
"Awesome food, fast, friendly service and what could be better than breakfast overlooking the..."
Stephen Lee
"Still dreaming of the lobster roll! Fresh large pieces of moist claw with just enough butter and lemon on a delicious buttery..."
"Great location & good vibe! Most importantly, food was delicious!! Oysters were perfection, salad was fresh & generous. Can't say enough about the..."
Cassie Cowman
"Outstanding food and a good experience. A bit more upscale than surrounding restaurants, but well worth..."
Bekim Becaj
"Taking over the former Dave's Grill space, we were happy to hear that the owners of one of our favorite restaurants (Bay Kitchen) had taken over. We..."
Tracy Becker
"Great food and cocktails in a beautiful setting..."
Stephen A. S.
"Service was good and the sea food was fresh and prepared excellent. Did not drink can not say how the drinks..."
Anthony Biondo
"Over the Top on a good way...
Google said it was closed it was OPEN!
The staff the food the ambiance is over the..."
"I have been an owner at the Montauk Manor for over 20 years and I have to say that tonight was by far the best dinner I have ever experienced!
The..."
Robert Vanderhoof
"From the moment we stepped in the door, we were enveloped in the warm, authentic, traditionally Italian atmosphere. We could honestly feel the heart..."
Candace Barry
"So fun to step back in time and enter The Manor, a historic building in Montauk, and dine in an intimate dining room just off the main lobby...."
stephanie pietromonaco
"This place is amazing. We had the Meatballs and the spaghetti with Monte’s sauce. I must say that I can not stop talking about how good these..."
Thomas Raynor
"This place is off the hook delicious. Best place to eat in Montauk hands down. I highly highly..."
James Cruickshank
"Best chicken parm I've ever had. Very casual setting in a beautiful location. Prices are reasonable. We will be back again for..."
New World Health
"I’m a local and wanted to stop by and try the restaurant since it just opened and they have reasonable prices. I was pleasantly surprised on how..."
Kevin D
"The food, service, ambiance, and energy were all top notch. I'm going back as soon as I get back to MTK! Great job..."
Guy Wilson
"We dined in and it was exceptional. Food is amazing and vibe is real. Congrats and thank..."
Tripoli Gallery
"Yes!! Warm, cozy, authentic Italian vibe through and through. Feels old school. Great vibe + will be back..."
Lisa Gallo
"Wow !!! This is A MUST TRY !!! The food is out of this world DELICIOUS 😍😍 Great atmosphere ! Reasonable prices ! HIGHLY RECOMMEND..."
"We had chef and owner Shawn Christman at our home as a private chef for our anniversary and I am speechless. He is professional, friendly, kind and..."
"Now called Rincón del sabor II, this place has freshed squeezed orange juice made to order for $5. They have cafeteria style food plates in 3 sizes...."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes