The best Restaurants in Nantucket ranking of February 2025
123 restaurant menus in Nantucket, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"Food is expensive but you're paying for the view and convenience of being very close to the beach. The staff was super friendly and thoughtfully..."
Nanci Pham
"We are here at the Cottages for an extended staycation, and so dining at the Bistro for many meals. The staff, ambiance, and experience of the Bistro..."
Stuart Malin
"Great food had the Margherita pizza. Read some reviews about management and business hours. Opened right in time for us and is a beautiful spot to..."
"Stopped here for the first time this morning. The walk up take out window service is easy and fast. The very homemade beef, barley, veggie soup was..."
Peter Ferri
"Pretty good coffee if you’re out near the airport or the bakery. Their definition of some of the drinks is different than what you might be used to..."
Stephen Ogden
"When you have cravings for one of this big Starbuck crazy coffee and you can't find it no where on Nantucket that is your place !!!!
The best place..."
Stacey McKenzie
"Excellent coffee and espresso drinks with a very nice outside lawn..."
Ali & Nic
"Favorite caffeine spot on the island! Great selection, friendly service in a nice..."
Augie Harrigan
"One of my favorite places to get..."
Shanroy Nelson
"Plenty of parking, order through the door, pickup outside another door, had chairs and tables to sit and eat. Had a good time here hanging out for a..."
Peter Shatzer
"Excellent hot sandwiches, cold sandwiches and pasta salads. They have different sandwiches reach day off the week. I'm here like clockwork every..."
"If I could give six stars, this is probably the only place on the planet I would award it.
Yes, they are busy. Yes, patience is absolutely..."
Dave Kenyon
"The best baked goods on the island; we had an assortment and they were all delicious! I didn’t try their coffee but it’s probably good as long as..."
Ali & Nic
"Selection of fresh brewed coffee, hot & cold sandwiches, pastries and cookies. The egg bites (or was it egg cup?!) were delicious! Also fresh pizza..."
Sherm Sherm
"The sailors knots are buttery, sweet, and heavenly. Yummy coffee, morning buns, croissants, and toads in the hole are also..."
D M
"Hangover is short list of best breakfast sandwiches on island, confections are pretty good..."
Jerico Mele
"The morning buns are amazing! It’s a croissant cinnamon roll. Must..."
Timothy Torres
"Fantastic! Fresh, high quality ingredients.
They sell out of many things early in the day, but I got my almond croissant later in the day and was..."
"My husband and I had our wedding on Nantucket last weekend. Being from out of state, we did not get to taste test the strawberry grand marnier cake..."
S S
"This place is delicious. If you live on Nantucket you probably already go here, if you’re visiting, this is the food place you were looking for..."
Sonny Ratcliff
"Possibly the most chill breakfast nook in Nantucket. Many of their breakfast burritos have been demolished, and many a conversation about partying..."
Chris Riba
"Last-minute cake does not disappoint! Forgot to order a cake for my husband's birthday. I did a search on "best cakes in Nantucket" in a Facebook..."
Anastasia O'Connor
"Best Buffalo chicken wrap I’ve ever had and excellent açaí bowl to finish off the meal. Would highly..."
dontworry boutit
"My fiance (now husband) and I chose 45 Surfside to make our wedding cake and it was one of the best decisions we made! The cake was absolutely..."
Caroline Prior
"The mango passionfruit spritzer is delicious. Very reasonably priced food and drink items..."
Jamie Potter
"I want to give this spot 5 stars because they have eggcellent egg sandwiches and great coffee. The staff is also nice. However, only offering small..."
"I absolutely love coming here when I’m in a hurry for work! The staff is very welcoming, and accommodating! The line is intimidating but it’s..."
Lois Vigue
"I hd the Big Mean Green in taco form and it was amazing! So was my fresh juice! Wish I found this place..."
Nicole Alcantara
"Great vegan and vegetarian options! I have had the bfast burrito, bfast sandwich, and the vegan bfast sandwich. Amazing food and fast..."
McKenzie Altman
"My favorite place for a fresh juice and wrap/ sandwich while on..."
Nate DeMontigny
"One of my favorite place for breakfast and I love the pick up and go..."
Raquel Nunez
"BEST PLACE EVER!! Having celiac - (and being vegetarian) - it is really difficult to find food, let alone freshly baked delicious muffins, breakfast..."
Meg Harvey
"Awesome lil gem!!! Tawny and the staff are so friendly and upbeat...love love..."
Shannon Hobson
"Love it! Breakfast after 6 am beach run! See you this summer..."
Alex Grano
"Arrived fresh off a plane and just in time for closing! We we’re able to grab some of the to-go salads and chips: the orzo, roasted chickpea, and..."
Madalyn Peterson
"Good selection of coffees - had chai late with almond milk! Fresh green juices..."
Lexi E
"Awesome place for a quick healthy bite! They have a great selection of sandwiches, salads, wraps, and smoothies. They are fast even if you are..."
Joe Hutson
"Good and healthy burritos except they didn’t omit sour cream when specifically asked, had to eat it anyway. Mistakes happen, but Make sure to..."
Millie Smith
"Beautiful food, handcrafted and able to handle all levels of food priorities for the individual or the masses... No matter your genre.
Take out,..."
Victoria Ewing
"Such good fish..."
Kaylyn Meadows
"Lots of fresh healthy….sandwiches, wraps, salads, smoothie and juices. Very robust..."
"Quick stop before we JET off the island!! All around, Stubby’s was a good stop! I went with the impossible burger! All 8 of us tried something..."
Logan Schooley
"Every time I travel to Nantucket this is the best spot to go. Great service, food is fantastic and open late night. If you haven't tried the Full..."
Brian O'Halloran
"Stubbys truly is the best place to grab some food and hangout. My favorite spot of all time. The employees are well trained and have a passion for..."
Brockston Masseth
"Get the Jerk Chicken and rice! It's really tasty and the hot sauce is quite fine. It's been on their menu for ages. I alwayse get an order before..."
John Dewey
"Legendary little stop for breakfast or late night food! We stopped for bagels before going to the beach but it's also next to all the bike rentals as..."
Matt S
"Best, fastest, clean, good eats at Fair price for this island! Cheesestake not Philly but yummy, great breakfast sandwiches yummy..."
Brooklyn Girl New York
"The best steak and cheese I have ever had! My husband also got the clam chowder and loved it! You can also call ahead and order to make it even..."
Kyla Simpson
"Amazing experience! Workers are very friendly, food is excellent, vibes are unreal..highly..."
"Delicious pizzas and fast, friendly service!
I didn’t get pictures of the whole pies (everyone dug in before I could get a chance 😀,) but we had..."
Nikki Montgomery
"This is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. If you eat meat, their sausage is so perfect on the potato/rosemary pizza (I also added Gorgonzola)...."
Jonathan McEuen
"Shared the prosciutto pizza for lunch on a bench, so fresh, ready in 5 minutes and hand delivered to us outside by the friendly staff. Perfectly..."
D M
"Very good pizza! Just wish they had..."
Grace Gherman
"Great pizza made really quickly, plus homemade gelato, cannoli, and a nice Aperol Spritz! Perfect meal. My favorite pizza so far is the Capricciosa,..."
Lisa
"This is the best pizza on Nantucket. Great ingredients, great crust, great..."
Brian Robles
"Great new spot for neopolitan Pizza on the island. Prices are reasonable and the food was great. As with all wood fired pizza make sure to order it..."
Alexander Moschella
"Delicious pizza with fresh toppings! Service is also..."
"Simple, perfectly executed seafood sandwiches. Incredibly warm and friendly staff. Astonishing harbor views. Not exaggerating when I say this is one..."
Dave H
"Straight Wharf features some of the freshest fish of any market on the island, and as a bonus has the best lobster rolls that I've ever..."
Stephen
"best lobster roll on the planet. mix of tail and claw meat. celery crunch and warm brioche..."
Lucia Mijares
"They have amazing lobster rolls and the seafood hear is very..."
Nicólas C
"Epic Swordfish and Tuna here..best place for that fresh..."
"This food is sooo good. Clam Chowder, Shrimp tempura and Shrimp Scampi were on our menu. everything was so flavorful and the ambiance was great. A..."
Ruben Sandoval
"Went on Saturday night and sat at the bar. The drinks where great, the food was really good, we had the sushi special and it was delicious as where..."
Paula Jaros
"Beautiful place and excellent service. The drinks and selection of beers local and import are great. Try the sushi!..."
barry gilliland
"Local town people great outdoor court yard and fresh menu. Great drinks and wine..."
"Beautiful store!!! Everything looks so good I could buy one of everything!! Marinated meats are the best, tastiest steaks I've ever tasted and the..."
Susan Amour
"I'm so excited that there is an amazing meat and fish market so close to Naushop!! Starbucks coffee is a plus for me..."
"The Gaslight restaurant on Nantucket is a new permutation of an old restaurant on Nantucket. This was most recently The Starlight, a restaurant with..."
Wendell Jones
"A small Asian-fusion restaurant we tried on the island. Overall it was pretty good, and the steak 🥩 tips were delicious..."
Joey Allen
"Every plate was delicious! We stuck to raw and small plates, split almost everything, and enjoyed it all! Only 1 dessert option (carrot cake) but it..."
Kathy Fritz
"Tasty asian fusion in the heart of Nantucket town. Get the king salmon and the Japanese BBQ..."
Taylor Yates
"Great apps and drinks. Professional friendly..."
David Friess
"The most charmingly hip atmosphere with stellar music on island, plus they have some of my favorite island food. I take all my foodie friends there..."
Val Dorf
"all around great spot on-island and a must visit for locals and tourists alike. drinks are delicious, the food is amazing, and the staff and..."
Alexandria Penta
"The proprietors of the Gaslight are a gift to this island. They creatively resurrected a beloved island establishment making it better than ever with..."
"London fog doesn’t have enough vanilla in it. Price is much better than the corner cafe place. Chocolate “croissant” is barely recognizable,..."
Jane Pan
"Best coffee shop on Nantucket! Great staff ( reminds me of a refined stubbys crew without the loud music) Really nice workers and great snacks. I..."
Kyle Mcmanus
"Good coffee, great Danish. Not sure 100% if folks working were having an off day, just a bit dry on presentation. But still a good..."
Jake Lee
"Hands down the best coffee on the Island. They brew using beans from Nantucket Coffee Roasters - Nantucket's only coffee roaster. Using the freshest..."
Pete Steixner
"Always get a Latte at 6am. Only coffee ☕️ shop open at that..."
"Their pizza was so yummy, thin and a little crisp... really delicious. I don’t know why they have such a low rating. I also eat a lot of pizza in..."
Wednesday Adams
"really good pizza - took a while to get our order though. apart from that no..."
Kasia GT
"If you love CLAMS you will LOVE this Pizza!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! LOTS OF CLAMMSSSS!!!..."
Scrogy Johnson
"The pizza was very good, as a man married to a women from Brooklyn and a frequent visitor of Brooklyn I can say it is the most like Brooklyn style..."
"I went to Nantucket the day after Christmas. Almost everything was closed. I heard someone say the pharmacy had a lunch counter. They had sandwiches,..."
Billie
"The best pharmacy on-island hands down. Amazing staff, who will help you with everything you need. They have everything you might have forgot plus..."
Liz Skokan
"One of the best places to grab a bite to eat in the morning. I eat the Elvis at least 3 times a week! Also the breakfast sandwiches are the best! The..."
Ethan Bayzack
"Nantucket Pharmacy is the only pharmacy in downtown Nantucket and they do a GREAT job providing a variety of products and brands so there is..."
Emma Knutti
"A community conscious business. When out of Covid 19 masks, they gave them out at no charge.
Always friendly, informative and customer focused. Their..."
Kevin Davidson
"A great neighborhood pharmacy with Ken the owner who makes it a very special..."
"Fantastic little cafe with tasty treats and good coffee. The friendly staff showed personal care to my unique order (coffee to go so I could take it..."
Robin R Johnson
"Yummy is great! Have been multiple times are tried a few different things, and everything has been great! It is a nice place to stop going to or from..."
Joe Hutson
"Aleah was the best, beautiful smile, beautiful heart, can't wait to go back..food and service was..."
Marie Valero
"Yammy is always yammy!!!!
Great stop for a quick bite on your way to the beach.
Great sandwich options also this year they have many more - shakes,..."
Stacey McKenzie
"Amazing place to come eat with friends. The price it not bad as for parking space not much space. The service is great food is amazing and sitting..."
"I met up with a friend for dinner. We had a very fun waitress who made a fantastic recommendation for a glass of wine. For dinner we tried the Steak..."
Leigh Topham
"Raw bar was excellent and white sangria was the best. Staff is attentive and ambience is light and airy. Great spot for a few hours of summer..."
Susan Lynn Ryan
"Overall a great place to have dinner and drinks. Service is phenomenal and so is the menu. A true hidden..."
Maaks Caren
"Great new spot. Scallop dish yummy! Chicken and waffles very good but only savory option. Wanted some maple syrup! Will def go..."
Kathy Molloy
"Food, staff & atmosphere are amazing! A must..."
Erin Coffin
"Hey Nantucket peeps and EVERYONE who's planning on coming to the Island! You'll need to get here! Food and atmosphere are..."
Melody Johnson
"Awesome atmosphere and great..."
Meghan Bernazzani
"..."
Roger Levesque
"I am Mexican and I can say this restaurant has great tacos! Drinks where amazing too!..."
Elissa AK
"Newly renovated space looks great. Every corner give you different Mexican style vybz.
Happy to see something different at Nantucket.
New menu is..."
Stacey McKenzie
"Mussels ,Beef Tostada and Margarita very nice this time Adios Pantolenes better then Margarita Thank you..."
Bulut Mutlu
"Absolutely fantastic experience. Excellent, attentive service along with delicious food. Only thing I wish is that I could have partaken in a couple..."
Lorcan Kelly
"Great New Spot on the island, staff is fantastic with great energy, has indoor and out door seating. Plenty of Parking, a rarity on Nantucket. Food..."
Charlie Polachi
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes