The best Restaurants in New Albany ranking of April 2025
318 restaurant menus in New Albany, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"This location was very quick. The customer service was pretty good, the food was delicious and the drinks were cold. The drive thru was very busy but..."
Jonathon Myhre
"I deliver for DoorDash later in the evening so frequently go through the drive-thru due to the lobby being closed. The staff is always friendly and..."
Kelly Baxter
"I was very disappointed for the money I spent compared to the food I ordered. Not McDonald's I Used to Know. State Street New Albany Indiana...."
"Celebrated our anniversary with brunch this past Sunday! Beautiful restaurant, perfectly cooked breakfast, the best coffee and pineapple mimosas I..."
Tami Howard Renn
"My husband took me here for my birthday. Our server, Igor, was excellent and made some great suggestions. We both had steaks and they were cooked to..."
"They have always been friendly and professional
And I love going..."
Kwaku Agyemang-Badu
"One of the better McDonald's I've been to. Always quick and friendly. Gets my order correct a majority of the..."
Chelsea Fischer
"Overall, the service was good. I was surprised by how quick they processed the orders. The staff was super friendly and on top of things. The burgers..."
"The Jeffersonville and Clarksville locations should take a field trip to here and take notes. Maybe then they too can understand their assignment...."
OneDa Burns
"It's Little Ceasers. Nothing fancy but the pizza is a good deal when fresh. Don't waste time reheating..."
Chris Lemmel
"I'm talking bout the Charlestown Rd in new Albany. They are a very busy store. Esp when and if they get understaffed. Even still considering that in..."
Derek Hendricks
"Witnessed a boomer (acting like a child) berating young manager over a soda. Manager tried to be helpful and was very professional.
Food was great..."
"A very fast drive thru no matter the time of day. Food is always great and they are very effective at cranking out larger orders with hardly any wait..."
Patrick Durham
"I visited the KFC on Charlestown road on Thursday June 30th around 7pm. I just wanted to say how sweet and kind our cashier Sarah..."
Christie Schroeder
"Food was freshly cooked + delicious. I quit eating KFC for years because the quality went way down. I'm glad y'all found your way..."
Brenda Messer
"Food was good but the wait was to..."
Sha Okeefe
"I work from home and Also live close to this KFC. On my 30 minute lunch I am able to go and order my food and come home and eat. They always are..."
"Our first experience here was as wonderful as I’d hoped. Beer cheese appetizer was spot on. I highly recommend the pork chop.....two bones in and..."
Jennifer Scherzinger
"Service was really good, food was very good, the beet hummus was over the top, anything thing you want to drink nice Atmosphere In a very large..."
Larry Hayes
"Great service at the bar! But Allie Davis is the best waitress ever!!! Great cocktails and great food. Our favorite place to go 4-6 times a month you..."
Guy Plummer
"We got to go Fri, there was a half hour wait which gave us time to check out the bar and try some cocktails and delve into the beer cheese, which was..."
Stephen Emmons
"Wonderful experience as always! Prompt service, delicious dinner & dessert, and these pumpkin martini's that were to die for! Loved our..."
Shawna Warf Fidler
"Highly recommend! Everything was fresh and super yummy. I suggest trying the beer cheese and pretzel baguette. They have friendly staff as..."
Alexis Mattingly
"Great atmosphere with excellent food. The staff was very friendly and made it a point to tell us about the history of the restaurant/bar as well as..."
Jennifer Roberts Justice
"Our table had the burger, pork chop, sweet potato mash, garlic parm frites, smokey mac n cheese, brussel sprouts. Everything was delicious! Our..."
Jennifer Young Posey
"Always a great spot for drinks with friends, a quick lunch, or a date night dinner. Great atmosphere and amazing food. Steak frites are my favorite..."
Kendrick Patton
"Love everything about this place down to food, drink, service and atmosphere. Love that it's right in my..."
"The staff & service was outstanding! The food was very good (onion straws, ribs, pork, brisket, wings & buttermilk crunch)! Will definitely have to..."
Dan Moulder
"Not only is the Brisket extremely delicious, but even every side dish we ordered stood out better than most places we have gone to. Well worth..."
Lowranzo Hackett
"Very original atmosphere. Food was epic. Service was outstanding! Would recommend this joint to..."
Jamie Brown
"Really good barbecue place. We’re visiting and just happened to come across it. Very good! We’ll look for it again when we come back. Try the..."
Eric Varnado
"The best bbq in town and the sweet tea is to die for...I have always had a great service and food there...love..."
Cindy Thomas Summitt
"My server was great,food came up fast and it was hot and fresh.I was impressed with my overall experiance.I deff will be back..."
Tiara Pitman
"It's a great place to eat !! They have the best honey wings an great slaw an fantastic potatoe..."
Debbie Rice Fanning
"Always great food! Zack was a great server!
Always pick up some sauce when we are in..."
Don Richards
"We love this place! We drive an hour just to have it! Today I was blessed to have a surprise 50th there. My family from Tennessee drove to..."
Tina Waggoner Woodall
"It's always good, never disappoints. I have to say the wings seem to have a bit more honey than usual but still delicious. I know it's a BBQ..."
Tom Posz
"They are an overall good place to eat. I love their side dishes. They have great onion straws and potato salad. Their pulled pork is not my favorite,..."
TeardropInn
"The bbq is good, but not as good as Famous Dave's. Their honeywings however are very tasty. Soaked in sweet honey sauce, they're like no other wings...."
Steve
"Good Side Items. MY idea of good bar-b-q is grilled on instead of plain meat with a side of sauce but I am not going to give them a bad review for..."
DLynn
"A little on the expensive side but it's the best BBQ in this..."
The Glutten
"I went to marks feed store it was a group of 4 of us. Our server was outstanding. We did wait long to get in the door. We sit down and was..."
donetta moye
"Exceptional service.The food is always hot, fresh, and Tasty.Never had a bad experience here. Extremely accommodating to my large family of 7. Prices..."
Kyle Sheckell
"Food was good wish they had a better selection of BBQ sauce. Staff was friendly. Place was very busy but staff did a great job keeping..."
Darrell Louden
"Easily competes with the best bbq around. Have been enjoying Mark's since it was on Lewis and Clark Parkway in Clarksville back when I was a kid...."
Patrick Durham
"Excellent server, Yack. No he didn't talk a lot, but our drinks were never empty and dirty dishes were removed promptly. Food was great, loved the..."
Michael Higgs
"Quiet night for a late dinner at Marks. The Wild Salmon Burger was excellent and the chicken BBQ basket fit the bill for my wife. Great job by our..."
"I get something different every time I'm here. Everything & I mean EV-ERY-THING is good. You can't go wrong no matter what you order. My wife has to..."
Adam Phillippe
"Eagles Pizza is a great place to eat! They have a variety of items on their menu. Their sugar cookies and cinnamon dessert pizza are to die for!!!!..."
Sheri DeLong
"This was our first time at Eagles Pizza and not only was the staff friendly, helpful and speedy at getting our pizza ready and out to our table hot,..."
Kimberly Biederman
"There is no other pizza that is as good as Eagles Pizza! I moved to Florida 13 years ago, and you can’t find great pizza. I flew into Columbus..."
Sarah Walker Azbell
"Always the best! Even the same as I remember backnin the..."
Daniel Weaver
"I grew up on this pizza and have been craving it for days. Drove 40 minutes last night to get it. Was worth every second of the stormy drive there...."
Bobbi Jo
"I've been going to Eagles Pizza since they were located in a house that was behind the current location. It's the very best pizza! We've moved 2hrs..."
Theresa Collins Evans
"My favorite place for pizza in the area. We love the trash pie and a..."
Robbie Latta
"I have been going to Eagles pizza for over 30 years. Not much is changed in 30 years except for the exterior of the building. Great pizza every time...."
Ryan Phillips
"This is really good family pizza, nothing fancy. It is definitely our choice when we order pizza for home. They don't deliver and it can be hard to..."
Tiffany Emery
"All The Way Pizza with Anchovies in New Albany, Ohio. It was the perfect day to put the top down and drive through the springtime countryside. We..."
Ilex
"Eagles pizza is by far my favorite pizza I've tried. I wouldn't go bar cdubs review. New Albany isn't Columbus it's a cute small town that has..."
Emily
"Great..."
Elle Green
"Great pizza!. The crust, toppings, and cheese are great! Sauce is a little bland with not much spice, but their ingredients are so good, A very..."
Scott Swesey
"Great pizza, nice atmosphere. They don't accept credit..."
Wcc
"Great Pizza--Ex Culinary Industry Chef giving honest reviews. All I can say is well played. Who would of imagined you could find amazing pizza in..."
Chefp1
"They don't take credit cards... so remember your check book or cash. Oh, and they don't deliver.I usually order the sausage & pepperoni..."
KAK
"I had a chance to try this place out the other day and I absolutely loved it. I am a big fan of this style of pizza which I would call regional to..."
Adam W Nelson
"Fantastic pizza my first trip here was the taco pizza, the third (in the picture the BBQ chicken with extra chicken). The pizza is awesome and the..."
Bryan Ott
"Eagles is a nice family pizza joint with a variety of options I didn’t love the pizza her but my family did it was very saucey but I loved..."
2broz Film
"THIS PLACE HAS IT!! Ya know, that perfect thin crust pizza?? If you're a lover of thin crust pizza(not the chewy kind that you find at those..."
Jessica A
"Having never lived near Eagles, I've only had it here and there, sparingly, over a 30 year span. Every time, the flavor is the same. And it's..."
Ryan Brown
"Now, we all know the Taco Pizza is AMAZING.. but the best kept secret is their sugar cookies from the bake shop of heavenly goodness. If you went to..."
"Good food and beer. Love playing in the Euchre League on..."
Wynston McMartin
"Kayla Chatterton, great server and bartender! Very friendly and..."
Alex Musci
"Great food and drinks and Kayla Chatterton was the..."
Nick Oltman
"This place was pretty great. It's actually located in an apartment community, but open to the public. It has a very nice vibe, there are sand..."
James Roberts
"Great location in New Albany with volleyball and a pool when the weather is warm. The food selection is varied and has a Korean feel to it with pork..."
DK Park
"Very nice place. We were group of 12 people. Service is good. Good food. Serving plates are different and plates are small that what I..."
bhavana udupa
"The Goat is a great Venue. I had my Sons graduation party there and Had Thomas and James help assist with the event. They were both Awesome. I felt..."
"I was immediately greeted by the employees, who were greeting every single customer when they entered and left the store, and the vibe of the store..."
Taylor Lewis
"Wasn’t expecting much out of a subway but this establishment was beyond my expectations I just had to write a review. Remodeling inside but the..."
Megan Crawford
"I came here for lunch today and the customer service was amazing. The couple that was working today (2/15/22) were super friendly , they were so..."
Allie Swaddling
"Absolutely amazing customer care! Most polite workers/owners and made a fantastic sandwich as well...."
Michael Johnson
"Some of the greatest customer service I had received in a while. I highly recommend this Subway because of their customer..."
UlyG
"pretty good food not as good as grandma used to make..."
"Me encanta, todos muy agradables y la comida espectacular, no los cambio por nadie...
Amazing great food, everyone is great. The best mexican..."
Eliezer Lebrón
"Freshly made tortilla, excellent foods, and one of the best drinks I’ve had in a long time! The staff is very friendly and..."
Elaine Ashbrook Robertson
"Been looking for a great Mexican restaurant in Columbus area for a year now, finally found it at Blue Agave. Being from CA i am use to excellent..."
David Lang
"One of the best Mexican restaurants in CBUS. Always great food and stellar service!..."
Jonathan Lipaj
"Best Mexican hands down. Quick, efficient, and excellent food. Been coming to here and the previous Polaris location for quite some time and it is..."
L.j. Hayner
"Excellent, fresh food and awesome atmosphere, great wait staff. One of my..."
Valerie Lynn Hamill
"Excellent food and the server is on it! Be sure to order guacamole. They make it in front of you at the table. You
can find coupons online in the..."
Tammy Gruber
"Best Mexican food I've ever had, hands down!
The queso is delicious! The freshmade tortillas are superb! Good atmosphere.
Just LOVED..."
Elizabeth Wren
"This place NEVER disappoints!! We love coming here with friends and family. Great for all..."
Malia Newberry Jewell
"Great food, fresh guacamole, and..."
Stephen R. Smoot
"Fast, delicious, prices great ! Will definitely come back again and recommend it..."
Susan Bullock
"The best tableside guacamole! Ask for it a little spicy. All the food is really well done. The staff is always so friendly. I've been coming here..."
Larry Hill
"Pretty good corporate Mexican. The floors were all liked by my dining partners, my enchiladas were better than expected as well. The chicken..."
Lorence Sing
"This place has been on my radar for years, but I had never made it over to check it out; I am glad that I finally did. Many restaurants can make very..."
Charles Downs
"Such a great place to go for Mexican food. Guacamole was the best guacamole I've ever had! I got Shrimp Tacos and they were so good. My friend got..."
Caitlin Bowman
"Great place to eat Mexican food..food is fresh. Loved their hot salsa (mix it with normal salsa). Chicken chimichanga is..."
P Gajaananan
"Blue Agave is hands down my favorite place to go. The food is always hot, delicious, and quick. The margarita pitchers are always amazing, and when..."
"This is the cleanest, best smelling Subway I've ever been to! Super friendly staff and the food on the line looks fresh no matter what time of day we..."
Becah Joy
"My sandwich was fine.. I wish they would have asked me if I wanted it toasted. Cause I forgot. Next time hopefully one of us will remember I like my..."
Debbie Shell Hughes
"Great service, also very fast and delicious food, you could say it’s fresh for sure! Friendly employees and overall..."
Marty :P
"So I got a pizza that was absolutely beautiful and tasted as good as it looked. The girls that work here are so nice and so helpful. I really enjoyed..."
Kena Young
"The girls here are always nice. (I've only been to this location about 4..."
"Just a quick walk from the office and happy to visit every time. Deli subs are my go-to and the points card is a MUST for frequent visitors. Clean..."
"Wow! Came in definitely at its busiest time, there were about three baristas in a tiny area that were making the drinks, what seemed like 20..."
Derk Morgan
"What can i say? Great coffee and great service. Go here at least 4 times a week. Love..."
CinderyPuppet
"Fast and super friendly service, Hannah was wonderful and clearly very educated on the menu. I was unsure of what I wanted and she gave me a few..."
Michael Ross
"The baristas are always very friendly, which is awesome since we tend to order custom drinks. Many times baristas aren’t all that friendly when you..."
"Very disappointing this location is permanently closed and is now up for sale the next closest one is the one in Walmart and I absolutely HATE
that..."
jackie huber
"Me and my boyfriend just left here and the service from Deonte was absolutely amazing!! He went above and beyond. I've never in my life of going to..."
Heather Basham
"I started at this store, and I've moved to the owners newest store on Eastern Blvd. We make sure our food is as fresh as possible, and the manager..."
"I ordered a somewhat large breakfast order on Christmas Eve (about 8:20am). It took awhile, maybe 15 minutes, but that was expected on my end with a..."
J Evans
"Wendy's breakfast does some things right such as their sandwiches and potato wedges. Don't get the sausage gravy. Weak.
They need to pave the..."
Jeff Kraus
"My fast food love. Being out and about a lot this ol lady loves the fact that Wendy's is almost everywhere. I absolutely love the new crispy fries..."
"I enjoy Roosters wing a lot, especially on game days or special events. I ordered for carry out and was pleasantly surprised to still have my order..."
Carver Ealy
"Another great Rooster's location. They have a very nice patio and a great bar area. The food is, as always, very good, and our server was very..."
Tod Bowen
"Definitely in my top two wing restaurants to go to. There's always great service whether you set a table or at the bar like I did tonight. The staff..."
Joshua Clark
"They are always super consistent, great food and very large portions. This location is typically slammed but knowing that I make sure I place my..."
Jessica R
"Very attractive wait staff!!! And polite too!!! My brother took me here, they changed their hours and we got here 10 min from closing.and the staff..."
Johnnyrev1 Out
"Rooster wings are great, the only thing is the long waits. Even if you call ahead, you will most likely need to wait for your pick up when you get..."
"Food was great! Service and atmosphere was wonderful.Did not wait long. Great..."
Dayna Wade
"I've been to several different locations, but this one was different. The side portions were much larger and the service was fast and friendly and..."
Joseph “Tatersa Lad” Sanchez
"Food is amazing and fast service every time I’m there. Servers are friendly and not too prices about 50 with tip for dinner for..."
Kenny Baker
"The food was amazing and the portion sizes were HUGE. My husband and I will likely be frequenting this..."
"Fast & friendly service. If you've never tried their breakfast, you've got to! There's nothing else I can say about the rest of their menu, I mean..."
Matt Grant
"I mean, it's Wendy's. This is my go to $5 dollar Biggie Bag. I actually haven't evolved past that🤭. If it's not broken, why fix it.? In other..."
Mary Conner
"I felt like some Chili today so I stopped at Wendy’s. The staff was so very friendly and accommodating!!! They made you feel Special!! The Chili..."
Linda Green
"MY first job was at a Wendy's in Tennessee!!! 1978, 79. The food is always fresh and very..."
"I was greeted and told I could have a seat in dinning room then I never got my food by the time I waited for 20 minutes my fries where cold the..."
Johnny Brown
"Went in today and they were short staffed (literally only two workers and they were SLAMMED with customers). I just want to commend the two workers..."
"Nice place, clean, good food, friendly. Was in town on business - good place to..."
Pat McCon
"We were in town from Buffalo, New York and came here for dinner since it was close to our hotel. It was busy and we had a wait but we were able to..."
Chelsea Seufert
"Great food, great server. Had a nice lunch and will definitely go..."
Janet Markham Stephens
"Visiting from out of town-good experience-sat at the bar-clean, service was fast and efficient-typical tavern with a decent array of beers on tap..."
Mary Beth Freshwater
"Amazing shrimp buckets, drinks!!!! The menu has a great selection. Bartenders were..."
Rachael Elizabeth
"Really enjoyed my meal..loved the atmosphere and especially the double nickel salad....will definitely go back if I get a chance next time I'm in..."
Janie Terwilliger
"Great Fish & Chips with lobster bisque to start. Yummy! One of my favorite places in Upper Arlington or where ever I am in Central Ohio. We will be..."
Kathy Kiely Horvath
"Clayton did a wonderful job taking care of us at the bar. I will definitely be..."
Sara Baker
"It's refreshing to go to a chain restaurant that focuses on the local beer scene. Great food and great people always mean a lot to me. but, I guess..."
Joe Wilson
"1st time here, was in from out of town for a graduation, food and service was outstanding! Wish we had one closer to our..."
Rhonda C. Arnold
"30something. To the person who wrote the last review...who goes to Rusty Bucket with the expectation of fine dining, getting upset about a greasy..."
Nedshoehorn
"Very good fun to be at and great..."
Food Lover
"Best fried pickles..."
Try New Food
"Well, yeah, a bit expensive, but you get what you pay for. The pork tacos were..."
"Stopped with my son for a celebratory lunch and was highly impressed. Love the decor and vibe. Service was outstanding, our server even gave us a..."
Lori Payne
"I have to extend a huge thank you to the staff tonight. Our server did a great job as usual. But one guy in the kitchen noticed my three babes..."
Sara 'Heyder' Cook
"We were just there. Atmosphere was really nice for the holidays. Walked right in, waitress came over got our drinks and appetizer. Then took our..."
DiAnna N Joe Pavich
"The holy shiitake pizza was one of the best pizza's i have ever had great place to..."
Jason Miller
"The tortilla soup was excellent! Crust on the pizza plus the toppings were super as well. Great service, we sat at the..."
Betsy Morrison
"Our second time there, this time decided to try the pizza. It was amazing. We are definitely coming back to try different toppings. First time..."
Crystal Uretsky
"One of the coolest places I've been to there is so much to look at on the walls and the service was amazing food was also..."
Justin Bagent
"Love this establishment. Great for a family lunch or an evening of craft flights & music. The service is outstanding. Everyone on staff seems to..."
Mrs. H.L. G-B
"We went to a family lunch here for the first time for all of us. We ordered two appetizers, the Cloud Nine wings and the avocado smash with..."
G Faustus
"Mellow Mushroom has a fantastic selection of pizza to choose from. I got Might Meaty, Pacific Rim, and Koenig Karma and all were delicious. Buffalo..."
Joshua Fields
"I love mellow mushroom pizza! This restaurant is very clean inside and the staff is extremely nice. The restrooms are also clean. Mellow mushroom..."
Adam W Nelson
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes