96 restaurant menus in New Milford, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"We've been "regulars" ever since we moved to the area 10 years ago and love the place! Whether it's a signature pasta or meat dish, or a hamburger,..."
Alicia Sakal
"I miss a good Pizza Miss the owners too great place to have good..."
Gigi Vlamis
"I love the Holiday Restaurant........Have enjoyed many times going there.....Hope for many..."
Judy Swanberg
"Always been, always will be my #1 choice. Best calzones I've ever..."
Chantel Nicole
"Best food ever and speedy delivery thank you for delivering every friday night. Never had an issue with..."
Kyle Sheaffer
"Love the Chicken Danielle. Lots of cheese on the Baked Ravioli..."
Loriann Ickrath Chiarito
"It's great have been going there over 15..."
Joann Holbrook
"We have been eating at holiday restaurant for a few months now and every time it is a perfect experience. Their supreme pizza is amazing. Seriously,..."
TG SS
"We were vacationing on Candlewood Lake and were looking to go out for Italian food. There were 9 of us so we were worried about having to wait to be..."
Jennifer Welles
"Solid thick crust pizza. Just the right amount of topping unlike some other pizza places in the area. Ingredients taste good. They deliver. ..."
Colby Turner
"This is a nice little restaurant, I haven't had the pizza but the seated dining is great. The food comes quickly and they use lots of fresh..."
Ashley Van Tassel
"Had a lasagna from there. It was delicious. 1 meal serves 2 for sure!
The place isn't the clean kind. We never know what's going behind walls in..."
Marianna Camisão de Oliveira
"We had a Christmas geocaching event here in mid-December, which is how I know about the restaurant. I thought the food and service were good. We went..."
"Fall season makes me want Thanksgiving dinner. So the turkey dinner special was everything I needed! Delicious! It’s a huge amount of food and I..."
K OZ
"I've been going to the Windmill steadily for the past 35+ years and have no complaints. The diner is always very clean and the food arrives fast and..."
PK
"So many memories of eating at The Windmill as a kid. I love bringing my own kids there now! The food is always consistent, and it's very clean. Great..."
Kristina
"Well worth getting off the beaten path to come and enjoy this place! Looks recently remodeled yet still retains that quaint hometown diner feel, and..."
ron moore
"My wife and I met with a friend at the Windmill for a nice breakfast before delving into moving furniture. It had been a while since my last visit..."
Karl Hallecks
"Nice place, listening to Bob Sieger 😁. The pancakes were great and the coffee always hot and perfect. The service is really friendly and fast..."
Diol
"Great food worth the trip from nearby rt.84 Clean
really nice..."
Chris Look III
"Fantastic classic diner that serves breakfast, lunch and dinner all day long. One of the very best in the area. I have been going to Windmill for..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes