Best Porterhouse Steak for 2 in New York City

2 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Club A Steakhouse
Club A Steakhouse
84/100 (14925 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Steakhouse
American
Gluten Free Options
Steakhouse
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Filet Mignon
Shrimp
Red wine
Ribs
Manhattan
Beef
Bread
Fried calamari
Tiramisu
Broccoli
Lobster
Oysters on the Half Shell
Pasta
Bass
Dessert Platter
Salad
Cheesecakes
Mushroom Ravioli
Mac and cheese
Carrot Cake
NY Strip
Crab
Porterhouse Steak
Sirloin Steak Tartare
Oyster
Hanger steak
Lamb Chops
Calamari
Cakes
Filet Mignon
Profiteroles
Lamb
Dessert Plate
Calamares
Pesto
Crab Cake
Salmon
Fish
Porterhouse Steak for 2
caesar salad
Broiled Ribeye Steak
Crab Cake
seafood platter
Tomato & Bufala Mozzarella
Cheesecake
Desert
Sit down
American
Steakhouse
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Private Dining
Accepts American Express
Reservations
Live Music
Jazz Bar
Seating
Table Service
Accepts Discover
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Dinner
Fine Dining
"Everything was great! We booked a reservation from 5:45pm and there only a couple of parties in the restaurant when we got there, which made us feel..."
Kaito K
"Enjoyed this New York steak house with our son and his wife. Service started out a little lackluster, mostly due to it bring the holiday season..."
Reed
"Where do I start? This place is so good on so many levels, and given that it’s in the neighborhood and I’ve walked by it so many times, I can’t..."
ReedH
"First time here. Found it on location search for best steakhouses in Midtown East. It ranked #1 at 4.5 stars, so we booked it. Met friends from..."
Bill Flagg
"Yum yum 🤤 we got to experience this place with a Groupon! And while options were limited, it was absolutely worthy!!!! Our server name as Tony,..."
S C
"I recently had the pleasure of dining at Club A Steakhouse, and it was nothing short of an exceptional experience. From the moment I stepped inside,..."
Neici
"Celebrated a milestone birthday here on 9-28. We arrived earlier than our reserved time. From the moment we walked in, we were welcomed and seated..."
Sharon Dowery
"Booked the restaurant based on reviews, and we weren't disappointed. The management team and the serving team are top notch. The steak is amazing, ..."
Paul McElligott
"Club A Steakhouse makes you feel like an A-Lister from the moment you walk through the door. Friendly faces greet you, from the manager and/or owner..."
Lloyd Loganathan
"Celebrated a birthday dinner last night. Food is amazing and also the service. Staff and owner make your visit feel extra special. We would..."
Lucy Diaz
"From the moment we walked into Club A, our experience was nothing short of extraordinary. We took advantage of a Groupon deal, and were treated to a..."
Geova Love Prints
"We had the hanger steak and filet mignon, with the bacon appetizer. The filet mignon was slightly overcooked and not medium rare as we asked, but..."
Diego Diaz
"We made reservations for 8:30pm and were seating quickly. Our waiter was very attentive and kept us hydrated and even brought us bread with butter...."
Zelaya
"Bruno and his family were hospitable and absolutely lovely. We cannot wait to go back and see them again. Next time. We are in New York City. The..."
Leslie Lemm
"5 stars all around!! Service, food, and atmosphere were incredible! We are from Ohio, planned a trip to NYC and, in doing so, spent much time..."
Jodi Roszman
"I am looking on TripAdvisor for the #1 restaurant in New York City. This location was ranked at #1. Traveled about 40 minutes to get here, in the..."
Greg Gowens
"Great services. Been here 2 times. First time was amazing, 2nd time was also good but not as good as first time. Steak was solid but I always order..."
Don Lui
"If you are looking for a steak in NYC, I would highly recommend this place.📍Club A has this red wall and ceiling that makes the whole dining..."
Bill Lee
"My family and I had an incredible experience at Club A Steakhouse that I simply had to share. From the moment we walked through the door, we were..."
Yansy Chiang
Smith & Wollensky
Smith & Wollensky
82/100 (19182 ratings)
Restaurants
Steakhouse
American
Steakhouse
American
Gluten Free Options
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Chowder
Mashed Potatoes
Beer
Cheesecake
Salmon Steak
Shrimp
Mac & cheese
Coconut cake
Lobster Roll
Strawberry Shortcake
Beef
Filet Mignon
Bread Basket
Lobster
Lamb chops
New England Clam Chowder
Pasta
Surf And Turf
Creamed Spinach
Salad
Roast Beef
La Sauce Barbecue Maison
Clam Chowder
Porterhouse Steak for 2
Mac and cheese
Red wine
Torte
Jumbo Asparagus
Crab
Cheesecakes
Maryland Crab Cake
Oyster
Carrot Cake
Housemade Cheesecake
Calamari
Porterhouse Steak
Thick Cut Bacon
Tuna
Cakes
Smash Potatoes
Calamares
Lamb
Manhattan
Burger
Fish
Crab Cake
Cabernet
caesar salad
Sit down
American
Steakhouse
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Full Bar
Digital Payments
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Private Dining
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Dinner
Late Night
Fine Dining
"When I first had the pleasure of dining at Smith and Wollensky in NYC, I never imagined how delicious the food would be. I was a teenager and my..."
James R
"Stopped in for a drink and dessert late in the evening. The chocolate peanut butter cake was just what I needed to fill my chocolate craving that..."
Rebekah Bouch (The Nifty Nerdarella)
"I ate here a few years ago when I came to NYC, i am so happy to find back still some of the best meat I ever ate. Well done to the kitchen, you guys..."
Geoff Oswald
"The meat lovers pilgrimage should include this bastion of old world tastes and style. Heavily wooded and with supple furniture, it feels as if this..."
Aditya Dhillon
"A unique dining experience. Old world charm in the 21st century. The name was chosen by taking two surnames from random out of the telephone..."
Mij 'Casper' Duran
"The grill located in the same building but with its own entrance around the corner is open up to I believe 2am. If you find yourself looking for..."
PCP
"La atención de este lugar es muy buena, y el salón muy acogedor. La carne es de calidad pero los precios un poco altos. Un acompañamiento que..."
Francisca Arancibia
"One of the many NYC Steakhouses!. I have been dining at this Steakhouse for years mostly for business engagements. The Steakhouse decor has the look..."
Acava
"The old reliable. For a late nite supper, the grill and bar is hopping and open until 2am while still serving a perfectly done ribeye. The hash..."
Charliehound
"Twice a Year. Two times every year we have a sales conference at our NYC location. The first night in, before the others arrive, a friend and I..."
Abyss4Nappetite
"Absolutely great steak and seafood. I cannot say enough about the great steak and lobster I had. Peter Mcguire my waiter was top drawer. My family..."
Earl Hope
"Old school charm!. Old school steakhouse! Really like S&W! Very good quality food! Get the potatoes! Service is old school and..."
ODawg
"I have been eating here for 20 years. I no longer work in NYC but whenever I visit I try to eat at S& W. I took my son here last month and he was..."
VC
"B+ orrrrr C?. It was tasty.... pricey see & be seen crowd..."
Wheezy
"Great Steaks. Service is one of the best anywhere. Ambiance is worthy of any great steak house. Everything is of course ala carte, bring a hefty..."
Grumble Bunny
"Got to visit while in NYC. A little more pricey than some other steak houses but I have to say they have the most amazing steaks and amazing sides...."
Mark Berry
"This sets the standard-all else are..."
Epinew
"A New York Must. For steak, in manhattan there is no other. Just smashing. Super wine list, Great service, and will amaze for that special moment or..."
Peter Gilson
"Steaks are excellent, but expect a crowd. The steaks here are second to none, but do expect it to be packed, don't be late, and the volume level..."
Defilm
"Great steak. The meat is high quality and the service is fantastic. Any place that gets their stone crab from Joe's in Miami is a winner in my..."
The Philosophist
"Almost Perfect. The steak and wine selections are fantastic, but why can't I get a mashed potato? So..."
Andy L.
"Good times. Great steaks and wines. This is one of those places that you go to be pampered. The servers are a little old and cranky, but..."
Scotty
" Now my husband had built this place up and although my eyes watered at the cost of our New Yorker steak it was incredibly delicious, cooked how we'd..."
Corinna
""One of the most trafficked restaurants in New York and among the most celebrated steakhouses in the world" - so says Smith + Wollensky's website. I..."
Lardbutty
"Porterhouse for two is my turf of choice, the cut has a bit of everything which I love. Juicy and the beef flavors are prominent. Not as amazing as..."
ChubbyChineseGirl
"Porterhouse was cooked just right, Fried calamari was lightly battered, cream spinach was light and smooth and hash brown was crispy crust and soft..."
Dirk ondago
"The steaks were superb and cooked to order. The staff were super friendly and efficient! Well worth the price you pay..."
Simon Lee
"One of the best steak houses in NYC!! Everything was incredibly delicious!! I especially enjoyed the Prime Rib and Carrot Cake. The service was also..."
Pata
"Amazing dinner celebrating my friend's engagement without him. The atmosphere, the food and and staff really completed the experience. Thick..."
Miguel Lazo
"We always love smith and wollensky. The filet mignon was great! Perfectly cooked. The sides and dessert are always the best part though. I love their..."
Carter Walsh
"Had the Cajun rib steak and normal fillet. Meats were of high standards but the Cajun was too over powering for me, where as the fillet felt a little..."
D. A
"Porter steak was delicious as per our request of medium but it could use a bit more of seasoning. Seafood plater for two was fresh and delicious. Our..."
Alex W.
"All the dishes we have ordered were excellent. the highest quality meats and perfect cooking points. The exceptional atmosphere as well as the..."
Lucas Lazaro
"I can’t recommend this place enough!!! The service was out of this world. We visited from California to celebrate a friends bday and they gave us..."
Caroline Roberts
"It felt like a New York steak house - go to the bar when you arrive to have a drink, they know your table so they put the drinks straight on your..."
Alexander Fong
"As soon as we arrived for our reservation, the staff was quick and very attentive. They were amazing at helping my husband pick out a wine to go with..."
Megan Crawford
"I have read about this restaurant for years. This classic restaurant lived up to its billing. The steaks were perfect. The side’s spinach, mash..."
Sanford Peisner
"This is my favorite S&W. Tonight we we very fortunate to have Cammie as a server. Is old school charm and attention to detail made our dinning..."
Russell Black
"We absolutely loved our food: ribeye, crab cakes, Mac & cheese shells, Asparagus, wine. I do not recommend the creamed spinach tho. We sent it back &..."
Donna Shelton
"I love the Wollensky Grill, the atmospheric, sometimes damned noisy but fantastic , bar and grill just next door to the main restaurant. You can't..."
Steve Dunthorne