The best Restaurants in Oil City ranking of February 2025
33 restaurant menus in Oil City, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"I don't like subs. My girlfriend works here so I know about the place. It's under a new manager and he does a much better job at keeping the place..."
Brady Walker
"I love this subway! Always clean, super nice staff, great food. I go there weekly and never have an..."
Josh Reddinger
"The service was good!. I have been to a lot of subways and this is one I would visit again. Only wish the tables had been kept up with a little..."
"Great place to go to meet family!! Love it!!!! Reasonable prices and the quality of food is the..."
Patty Powers Feroz
"Bezt Subs, soups, chicken (broiled), omelette, appetizers, and a wonderful staff� I have never left u happy
The Villa is by far #1 for Oil..."
Michele Elkins-Stuckwish
"As travelers coming through your town we were so very pleased to find you open late at night. What we ordered was delicious and we will be stopping..."
Cindy Berger
"Some of the best broasted chicken I've had in years. Loved the sweet potato fries as well. Definitely a local gem. Just wish they took..."
Cory
"I've been coming here for a majority of my life. Incredible edibles and the subs they make are just the best things in the world! They've stayed..."
Josh Fogarty
"I've been coming to this restaurant for a little over 20 years and I love every bit of it. Subs and milkshakes are their..."
Darkhonor 21
"Dinner time on a Friday. Had our appetizers in under 10 minutes. Entrees in 15. All meals were beyond expectations and the service was polite and..."
Brian Baker
"Food is always amazing. Fast and friendly service. I love going here with the entire..."
Brittany Chrispen
"Always a must when in Oil City! The tortellini and meatballs with garlic bread is a favorite, as are the perogies. Honestly not had a bad meal here!..."
"Best all you can eat crab legs we've had in 15 yrs. My wife n I were so excited and so stuffed by the time we left...."
Tam N Tab Griffen
"I met a group of friends at Casey's for lunch today. We sat in the outside dining area, and the atmosphere was pleasant. The servers were very..."
bbrock
"The meals were put together in good order and the portions were plenty, the staff was friendly, polite, and..."
herb brickner
"It's wonderful to see this establishment grow consistently. The food is wonderful and the environment is nice and quiet. I've had breakfast a few..."
riverbleu 9
"Casey's is the place to be if you want real home cooked food. it tastes as good as it looks, the service is always outstanding and Jami has always..."
Sonny G
"We ate burgers and they were delicious. The waitress/bartender was extremely friendly. Unfortunately she was a little overworked. I will definitely..."
Shawn Lewis
"Seriously good food with excellent..."
Aly Murrell
"The all you can eat crab today was amazing. Quick service, friendly servers, and great..."
"On a day such as this, my Birthday, I get to choose where I go out for lunch. The choices are few and far between for dining out so I don't get this..."
Karla Hartzell
"We went there for dinner on our 20th Wedding Anniversary for the first time. The staff were very nice, greeting you upon arrival and explaining the..."
Marie Shebeck
"This place hands down is amazing better food than taco bell and better prices never leave hungry I'm gonna try and eat here once a week the staff is..."
Lacey Dewitt
"Best fish tacos I have ever had in my life. Hands down.
The staff was friendly and professional, is highly recommend this place to..."
Barrett Holcomb
"Loved it! The staff were super friendly and helpful, anticipating my needs as a first time visitor. The menu had so much to choose from, and my..."
Marcella Kalling Dill
"The fish tacos were the absolute best they should be on the every day menu haha.... I was told by alot of people that your prices were expensive but..."
Courtnie Winters
"I've eaten here a couple times now. The first time right when they opened...the chicken was a little dry. But the next couple times it was perfect!..."
Jessica Kennedy
"Great customer service. Friendly attentive staff. Fresh homemade meals. I had the Surf n Turf bowl today. Amazing! The beef was so tender and..."
Katie May
"Great food. The burrito was humongous. The meal deal was a great deal. Highly..."
Ryan Smith
"My family and I had an excellent experience at the Taco Shack last weekend. Between all of us, we were able to to try the chicken, shrimp, filet and..."
Amanda Orsi
"Food was amazing, its what chipotle tried to be. If you get a rice bowl be sure to get a large to go box, as it will be needed. Highly recommend..."
Darren Fennell
"This was our second trip ordering food for take out, at least 3 years or more apart. We don’t typically visit this town, but made a trip to try the..."
Christian
"I saw an online recommendation for The Taco Shack. I happened to be in the area and decided to give it a try..I had the fried shrimp tacos and they..."
Chris Schrecengost
"It's a very good place to get a quick bite from ... the food is delicious....just like I was told when I first went by another customer "you wont be..."
Mommy and Munchkin mukbang
"The manager greeted us as soon as we walked in and was super friendly with everyone. The ordering kiosks were easy to navigate. The food was amazing...."
Reji Lashinsky
"Restaurant is perfectly described as a hidden treasure. My friend who lives in oil city suggested we go here because I love Mexican food. I got the..."
Nicole Wright
"Honestly has the best food in Oil City! Is a small town Chipotle but WAYYY better!! Had a streak burrito with the fixings and was just about the best..."
"Best Pizza Hut we've ever patronized. Love the lunch..."
Trisha Balmer
"Love the Supreme Pan Pizza. I also like that I can order online and look & choose my toppings & drizzles. Can't wait for them to be open..."
Lynn Fink
"Love Pizza Hut and the Oil City store is newly remodeled and the place was clean and bright! The wait staff was pleasant and attentive. The wait..."
Vicky Doeright
"Stopped in on the way home from the mountains. Got some dinner togo. Chicken Alfredo and wings. They where very good and ready right on..."
Barry Reeher
"It's overpriced but I like the pan crust, I've ordered twice since I've been visiting my parents and both orders were wrong, whoever is taking the..."
Chris Brumbaugh
"Food was good and fast service.. Our waitress was outstanding.. Very nice and quiet atmosphere. Will definitely be..."
"Wings were excellent and fresh cut fries are like going to the county fair (be sure to ask about adding bacon and nacho cheese to them!) Our server..."
Nathan Wrhen
"Excellent food for a reasonable price. Sandwiches and appetizer were delicious and perfectly cooked. Fresh cut fries were a tasty bonus. Waitress was..."
c brand
"Good fresh cut fries and fresh potato skins! Very friendly bartender. Pittsburgh memorabilia..."
Melissa W Cook
"Good food , good friends and good time are to be had there. Wonderful patrons and staff as well as the owner. Always polite and friendly to..."
Wayne Smith
"My husband and I got burgers, they were awesome. Good fries, jalapeño poppers, and the ranch dressing was..."
Kim Wilson
"Great food
Great service
The chef is awesome a great friend of..."
Cy Gaines-Colon
"Service was good, fried fish dinner was good, prices were good. Worth a stop if you're in the..."
"This is the best place in Oil City. Shaun always has interesting specials. The staff is always..."
Andrew Hunter-Tate
"I've never been disappointed. I eat here at least once a month. Great steaks and Prime Rib. Conner is the best waiter around. Excellent food and..."
Jarrod Hamlin Horter
"I love this place. Great food, service and atmosphere. I've owned a cabin nearby for nearly 50 years, I'm sorry it took us so long to discover this..."
Karen Seman
"The best place in town to eat and it just keeps getting better! Thanks Shaun and Marie for making the place..."
Jim Marshall
"All six of us loved our food! Service was great! Prime rib was second to none! This place is a gem in downtown Oil City's North side. Chef Shaun..."
Jeremy Stec
"Great food, great options, and friendly service. I'd definitely..."
Mish Plants
"This is THE best place to eat in Oil City! Great food, great cocktails, great..."
Josh Botts
"My favorite place to eat when I’m in..."
Stephanie Mg Woods
"Awesome food! Everything tasted good, even down to the sauces! So so..."
Dana Hayes Szympruch
"The food is very good with a lot of variety to choose from. The wine menu is also pretty..."
Ryan Smith
"From appetizers to dessert we had an amazing meal at the Yellow Dog Lantern. Wonderful, personable service and a classy atmosphere as well. We will..."
Melissa Kelsch
"Had the chicken cordon bleu and it was amazing. Great food and..."
Sandra Baker
"I took my love, Robin Riddle out for her birthday. Not only was the food fabulous, the atmosphere was outstanding. We will be going..."
Bodie Riddle
"Great place, great food and even better..."
Casey Davis
"Great food great service the prime rib was delicious as always. Glad to see SOMEONE investing in oil city. What a great way to keep an old..."
John Crump
"The food here is very well prepared and wonderful presentation. We had a large group and the service was very good - unobtrusive yet attentive. A..."
Theresa Wiggins Weldon
"Party of 6. We didn't have to wait. Good was great. I had to bring a doggy bag home. That it was that good. I would love to go..."
Ginger Connor
"The shrimp and scallop dinner is absolutely..."
Ashley Zaccari Smith
"Delicious is all I can say!!!! We will definitely go..."
Peggy Hartzell Alsop
"Dinner with Dan & the boys tonight! We all left super satisfied. Food and service are second to none! We'll definitely be back..."
Lori English Hauptman
"The food was excellent. The staff is very friendly and gave good..."
Miss65Stang
"This place was great. Hope it..."
Robert Nebel
"Fabulous food! More than worth the..."
Michele Pratt
"A wonderful dining environment with amazing food and huge portions.
You will satisfy your appetite and still have enough leftovers for a meal later...."
Hyper Flexx
"Excellent food and service! The steak salad was more steak (perfectly done) than salad, and delicious with fresh greens and onion rings. The haddock..."
Kristin L. Wiebe
"I love the food, it is definitely 5 star. The service is always great. The only reason I give it 4 vs. 5 stars is the atmosphere. The restaurant..."
James Burris
"Attentive service, excellent food. Large portion California shrimp and crab salad appetizer was tasty and plenty for two. Garlic toast accompanying..."
William Dickson
"I love this place to dine in. The food of course, as mentioned by most other reviews, is nothing short of the best in Oil City. The staff is very..."
"Shout out to Billy and his staff. There was no wait on the wings and fries. The wings were delicious and the fries were tasty. GREAT EXPERIENCE. We..."
Marci Jo Harkless
"Absolutely best bar in Northwest Pennsylvania with the best people in the..."
Summer Brickner
"Had a great time playing pool, listening to jams & partially viewing Steelers..."
Toshia Marie Nicholson
"Billy's is my favorite bar in the area. It is clean and doesn't smell like an ash tray. I loved the 90s Night this past..."
Danielle Karg Wright
"Absolutely amazing!!! Will definitely be back!!!..."
Diane Jaehn
"5 stars all the way! Great atmosphere and great..."
Bert McClellan
"I'm really impressed! New restaurant style dining, wing buffet every Wednesday with many flavors to pick from, and a giant deep fried pretzel. Staff..."
Darkhonor 21
"I have to give credit when credit is due.
I ordered a dozen wings and some cheeseballs for take out today,
The wings were awesome and everything was..."
Joe Baby
"Honestly, one of the nicest bar/restaurants I've ever been in. OH TOWN is lucky to have it. Love going in there and looking..."
Matt Ames
"The place is spotless. Unbelievably clean. Most of all great tasting food, and great service. We will most definitely be..."
Murf Kuhls
"Super duper clean environment, and very nice atmosphere with very nice bartenders. I will definitely be coming back again...."
Kirstie Fitzgerald
"I've heard that the food at Billy's is great, the owner's very kind and helped me out with some issues as soon as he could. I haven't tried it yet,..."
Brandon Stevenson
"Great place for wings and food! We went for wings for the first time tonight since they reopened and had a slight wait in getting our food since they..."
Nicole Garich
"We go on Wednesdays for the wing buffet. Billy's has great flavors, good fries and sides, and the wings are cooked great. The only downfall is that..."
"Place was easy to find. I like how when you call they have your name and number saved to decrease info gathering time. Staff was courteous. Food was..."
rt yates
"Killer Italian subs, worked at 4 star when I was a kid so they've been around awhile..."
Chris Brumbaugh
"Close to home and much faster to order take out than delivery these days but the food I..."
Wayne Smith
"We got a small pizza and half a sub. Pizza was bigger than what we thought which was nice. My sub was warm and I wanted a cold sub, I went in and the..."
"We just happened to see this while Driving on June 3.2022. We stop in i saw they had Ice Cream. But saw they had burgers to so we both got the meal..."
Kam’s Travels
"Been going here since I was a kid. They have plenty of options for ice cream and other food. Lovely workers and good food. Awesome local..."
Kyndall
"Very nice roadside stand, one of the few places I've seen were you can get flavored soft serve in a bunch of flavors. Crunch coat with jimmies are..."
Steve Churchill
"Wonderful, happy, kind people working there and they bring the order out while we were sitting in their chairs outside in the beauty of spring. ..."
Mary Caratelli
"Good service, friendly staff, and enjoyed the ice cream and..."
Sonny Colvin
"Best pizza burger ever and services was great and friendly, plus milkshake are the..."
"Nice pizza and I'm a philly boy, going back for seconds,lol. I was told by my new friend here that sent me in I should have had the pasta. I'm..."
Bob Steiger
"Absolutely the best pizza in the world. Love the homey atmosphere employees are so nice welcoming. I refuse to eat anywhere else. Thanks for always..."
Greg North
"Very welcoming, friendly atmosphere! Excellent food! I loved the marinara dipping sauce so much, i brought some home. The cheesey bread sticks had..."
Tara Casanta
"The "Meaty" pizza was great. Crust was thin and cooked to perfection! Definitely would go..."
Dolores Girdwood
"I like this place alot but also feel like it's hit or miss. Sometimes the food is perfect and other times a little less then. Im gonna chalk it up to..."
hollie kimes
"Fantastic service and delicious pizza. I really loved the sauce and crust. Definitely will go again if in the..."
Jenny Trowbridge
"Probably my favorite pizza place in the area. Very friendly staff. Has a family vibe to it which is..."
"I'll be walking here to still one of the best bars in Oil City, PA good food great..."
Sadat Bey
"Great staff, and I absolutely love their Rueben..."
Brandi McCracken
"First impression was this is a strange location for a bar in what I perceived as a neighborhood setting and a bit rowdy but after a few minutes you..."
Elissa Deible
"Shots are pricey but nice bar to have some brews. It is a good bar food buddies, not taking the parents out for the..."
Josh Reddinger
"I cant go any where..without running in2 some1..i just dont want to talk to....but that waz not the case here...maybe...it was fine...
The patrons..."
Michael Fedora
"Great atmosphere with a quiet..."
Cody Latchaw
"Very nice and friendly staff! Very good place to go to have food or a drink, or play..."
"Extremely good food, amazing management, and has a hometown feel, You only get in a small town! I've been eating and visiting McNerney's throughout..."
Jesse Chrispen
"Great little local bar. Great wings and..."
Renee Irwin
"Such a friendly place, great food and service. Chris has a great group of local people that come in. Will visit again next time I'm in..."
joe G
"Awesome wings! Great..."
Nicole Snyder
"Great food and a Great Time and You now can Get Your HipB HairZ There !!! Thanks Again..."
barb rossman
"Serve bar food,quarter machine, gambling machines,plus..."
Thomas J. Kelly Jr.
"The burgers are huge, juicy and delicious. Fries are crispy and yummy. The people arw so friendly. Love this..."
Theresa Zlotnicki
"My wife's family are natives of Oil City, and whenever we visit from Maryland, I look forward to our times at McNerney's. Breakfasts are great, and..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes