The best Restaurants in Old Bethpage ranking of January 2025
11 restaurant menus in Old Bethpage, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"Everyone meet Pete the Greek! This spot has really good food & they have better portions than most greek..."
michael lapadula
"Title: A Unique Dining Experience at Pete the Greek
On a quiet Sunday in late October, my wife and I visited Pete the Greek in Old Bethpage. Our..."
Digital Hassan
"some of the best food in the area! I'm definitely a repeat customer although I need to try some other dishes. I have no doubt that it will all be as..."
Larina N
"We ordered the family meal. Lamb/beef gyro and chicken š solvouki. There was a ton of food . Ordered a piece of spinach pie also which also was..."
Fred Potter
"Great food - an absolute local gem. Owned by a local family, so eating here supports our neighborhood. It also is not extremely expensive, and the..."
Brett K
"I've been coming here for 3 years now and it is always fresh and delicious. More than reasonable prices for the portions and freshness. Service is..."
Nick Laurino
"This place is definitely a hidden gem!! Friendly staff. Super fresh delicious food. Diverse menu fairly priced. Great..."
Machew Veltman
"Called Pete The Greek and ordered my sisterās family food from here. Gus was beyond friendly and helpful and food arrived literally the minute it..."
Scott Handelman
"Pete the Greek was fantastic. I visited here a few weeks ago for lunch around 11:30. The food was fresh, prepared well and tasty. We discovered it..."
Arnold Murray
"I live in south Wantagh and I will drive to Old Bethpage for gyros from Pete the Greek! Best gyro I ever had while at a friend's house in Plainview...."
"Please, please support this establishment. Not only is the food absolutely amazing, but it was also so reasonably priced. The portions are huge!!! I..."
Tara Braun
"Good combo platter with two choices of meat, salad and a choice of a side. I picked the pork gyro meat along with the lamb beef gyro. I choose the..."
Maverick
"Consistently great food and service. The team at this location always goes above and beyond. Thank you for all the great..."
Michael Garfinkel
"I've been raving about Pete the Greek since Sunday 10/11/2020. I haven't had the liberty of having an authentic Gyro since the 80's. ( Souvlaki on..."
Joy J
"Really good take out, been to a number of their locations and will be back in thw..."
frank saracino
"I never write reviews. Wow this was great food. We picked up. Ordered a chicken gyro, a beef/lamb gyro and falafels. It was all amazing with..."
Coach Coffin
"The food is just amazing. I wrote a great review a few months ago and have ordered since then but need to tell you this is the place to go or order..."
"This place is a great lunch spot. Amazing pizza. Great service too. The Sweet and Savory Chicken and the Pepperoni is to die for. Go get em and tell..."
"For lunch, a friend and I ran over to Villa Monte in bethpage. He had never been so I thought today would be a perfect day to show him what specialty..."
Kenny Tax (Long Island Foodies)
"Villa Monte Pizzeria: A Flavorful Delight in Plainview
If you're a pizza aficionado in Plainview, New York, Villa Monte Pizzeria is a place you..."
Nirtz Pierre
"I moved out to Long Island over 30 years ago. Villa Monte is by far and away the place I have been searching for over 3 decades. This place is..."
Howard Winston
"I travel for work (full time) and eat most meals out. This place is hands down, the BEST and most memorable restaurant I have ever visited. Not..."
Kevin M.
"The interior of this store is beautiful! I wish we could have actually sat down to eat, but we walked in closer to when they were preparing to close,..."
Iman Gareeboo
"The pizza was good. 6.8 on the One Bite scale. They had a wide variety of specialty slices available. This was my first..."
Thomas Chopard
"Recently discovered this place right in my backyard. Loved the pizza the 3 times I've been. Been telling people about it so that it's not forgotten!..."
Nicholas R
"Very clean!!
Incredible food!!
Very reasonable pricingā¦
Owners SUPER friendly & niceā¦
Very family atmosphere & feel to it
A++++
Def be..."
Artie Verdi
"This is the only local pizza worth eating. The sauce is always fresh and delicious. I prefer their Sicilian Pizza but everything is..."
Joe Z
"They have the biggest selection of specialty slices I've ever seen. So many great..."
Bobby Abrams
"Best pizza place Iāve ever been to and Iāve been to a lot! They have a wide variety of slices to choose from. If you like sweet and spicy, I..."
Victoria L'Hommedieu
"This is definitely the best pizza shop on Long Island though I haven't been to all of them. Best selection of slices, friendly staff. Only negative..."
Al Berg
"Thicker pizza which Iām personally not a fan of, but the Lasagna slice was top notch. They must have 30 different types of pizza in here. You will..."
Martin Donovan
"The pizza was very good..the veal parmesan hero was lacking in veal. Plenty of cheese. Taste was very good. Just needed more..."
Michael Messer
"Absolutely amazing. You must try this place. Everything is made from scratch and it shows...."
CJ Constable
"Their pizza is the best in Long Island. I always go for their slices and my favorites are the chipotle chicken and bacon and buffalo..."
"Lovely new Korean restaurant in the neighborhood. Generous portion sizes. Efficient service. Flavorful, freshly prepared meals. We tried the pork..."
Kundan Sen
"The servers were very attentive and nice. All the side dishes were great. We went for lunch and got tofu stew. The lunch deal is pretty inexpensive!..."
Lily
"This place is very good. I went here for lunch here on a date. This spot has a nice little family feel to it. When you come here I recommend trying..."
anthony giardina
"All the others are right. Amazing food and people. If you are in the area be sure to stop in. I had the hot stone bibimbap and it was so good. So..."
Mathew Brauer
"Fantastic place super friendly and feels like home. Definitely get the Korean food it is amazing even though the sushi is also great. Highly..."
DivPMP
"Wonderful Korean food here! I had a dolsot bibimbap for lunch which was wonderfully seasoned! It came within 5 minutes after ordering which was..."
Kimiko
"Wow! An actual authentic korean place on Long..."
Ivy Tse
"Foods are Perfectššš
Aunties (servers) are so..."
Jd
"All the side dishes were delicious, main dish as well. Very price. Will come..."
Yugyeong Kim
"Good Korean food for Nassau LI and east of Flushing. Can't comment on the sushi, but may be back for it next..."
Wil Yumz
"Didnāt think Iād find decent Korean this (relatively) far from Queens, but Dake is legitimately good Korean food and when I went the restaurant..."
Benjamin R
"Delicious takeout, fast friendly and fair price! We will be..."
Wendy Cohen
"Solid food, big portions. My squid bibimbop came with a good amount of squid. Donāt be confused by the āDake Sushiā sign on the storefront ā..."
Leslie Teng
"Great food! Great service! Great hospitality.. I love Dake..."
Carlos M Taveras
"One of my favorite Korean restaurants this..."
Timothy OH
"Just ordered their chefās special sushi and sashimi and it was AMAZING! I have ordered from many places around the area but none have come even..."
"The staff is super friendly. I'll go out of my way to get my order here because they always make my orders right and if they don't they are kind to..."
Sonia V
"The angels themselves would be unable to sing praises pertaining the efficacy of their pastry and caffeinated drink crafting and sheer enjoyment this..."
Steve Roshan
"I came to this Dunkin Donuts instead of the one on 203 Broadhollow road(which is closer but the service is prison quality) I usually get a matcha..."
Mina
"Toasted everything bagel with cream cheese was..."
Suzan Klivansky
"Coffee and bagels are always fresh the staff here is the absolute best. Once I pull up to the front they start making the coffee for me and I really..."
Jason Guthrie
"My fave Dunkinā spot. Always gets my order right and great customer service. To go orders are always ready...I never have to wait around unlike..."
M Kor
"Best Dunkin in town (maybe the nation)! Staff is..."
V. Ring
"My iced coffee and mini bagels tasted great. The mobile order wasn't working but they got my order correct and friendly..."
Jeanelle Adams
"Staff was super friendly and welcoming. Just the way I like it, in and out with my latte..."
Winston Gonzalez
"Good service. Very polite young fellas. I'll be back for more cappuccino. š..."
Bill Clinton
"Shout out for the guy working here Sundays during COVID-19. Very..."
Irene
"Love my dunkin! Quick in and out and order always made..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes