The best Restaurants in Old Lyme ranking of January 2025
34 restaurant menus in Old Lyme, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"Great Greek Pizza Diner. The owner and staff here are really great folks. Easy to talk to. The meat lovers pie was chock full of goods. The Greek..."
Steve Powell
"The pepper steak grinder is so..."
pat vickers
"Been there twice, both times great grinders, will go..."
Jason Labrecque
"Great pizza and friendly..."
Bill V
"polite, fast and friendly.....burger was ok but there hot dog was amazing grinder roll was fresh, full of goodies and I cant wait to go back and try..."
Jon Doolittle
"Tuna fish grinder w/hot..."
Aqua Jet-Irrigation
"Teddy's has the best rice pudding in the USA. I have traveled all over the US and I have not found a recipe that even comes close. Teddy's also has..."
"Very cozy. Personable service! The seafood dishes are very good. Seems to be an unknown spot. Not busy, but should be! Clean and comfortable..."
DONALD COLLINS
"Food was great!
However I felt bad for bartender who had to do many jobs.
We waited for awhile as did many others because bartender was doing..."
Josie Tuttle
"Great food at Hideaway 😋,it was our Anniversary enjoyed the time together ❤ with my wife.
Thanks to the Chef for making the Seafood jambalaya..."
Elijah Glover
"Good eatery, decent beer selection.
50 cent wings on Thursday night....and they come out quick!
Turkey club was excellent.
No wi fi..."
pete B
"It was our first time here and it was a wonderful find! It was cozy, and the food appealing to your eye!! It was very good and we'll definitely..."
K C
"Went in the afternoon for lunch. The bartender/waiter/busboy worked very hard and provided GREAT service. I spilled my beer and without asking, he..."
"Thought it would be a great idea to head to the beach on the beautiful Friday. I was right! Walked right on the beach with a table in the sand and..."
Big Nick
"Beautiful day! One of the perfect spots in this area for sitting on the beach and enjoying a drink.
We did not order any food, however we did order..."
Michailah Williams
"Great time here.. no money needed, they take only credit cards and debit cards.. right on the Beach, better make reservations.!!! For 35.00..."
Carol Bono
"My friend and I were in the area and had heard great things about Kokomo’s, so we decided to stop in! We were sad that there was no open table for..."
"Great summer spot to eat lunch in between visiting the..."
Morgan DiBacco
"Amazing Amazing. Amazing!!!! Staff is super polite live music good fresh food drinks are made to perfection this is my spot I would recommend anyone..."
Sara Peay
"Went today on a whim, live band and drinks were amazing! Highly..."
Jelani Gilbert
"Had a good..."
henry rosado
"Love love love this spot!! Get your girls and have some..."
Black Raspberry and Cherry Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
Burger
Lobster Roll
Ice Cream
Fish
Philly Cheese Steak
Cheeseburger Combo
Sit down
American
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Seating
Dinner
Mid-range
"My chocolate chip ice cream sugar cone was simply delicious!! Well worth the $5 price for a small cone. The staff were extremely helpful..."
Robin von Raab
"fantastic ice cream & fantastic service. i accidentally came after closing, but elle, renee, emily, and molly were still very willing to serve me! an..."
Eleanor Dushin
"Solid spot for burgers, fried seafood, and ice cream. I tried a lobster roll CT style for the first time ... enjoyed..."
Matthew Dawson
"I just stopped at the Hallmark Drive-In and absolutely loved it! I got ice cream for the whole family for a great price especially being on the..."
"Nicest dunkin building ever. The cashier was friendly but hands down the most awkward person ever. Nothing against it the experience but walked out..."
Ben Dubiel
"I went there this morning around 5:30 and was greeted by the friendly worker who is usually there. She apologized profusely that coworkers who were..."
Jennifer
"My husband and I had a few really bad experiences at our two local dunkins so we had stopped going. Decided to try this one since it’s an area we..."
Black Raspberry and Cherry Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
Philly Cheese Steak
Cheeseburger Combo
Banana Milkshake
Raspberry Sorbet
Grilled Chicken Sandwich Meal
Crispy Chicken Sandwich Meal
Fast food
"Whenever I visit my Dad in Old Lyme, a stop at this place is a must. Lobster Roll is on point (I prefer the cold one but the hot buttered one is..."
Doug Marcks
"Great place. The food and ice cream are great. Always friendly..."
Dan Mcpherson
"Best lobster roll ever... ice cream was great..."
Jim O'Toole
"Always stop here whenever we head to the beach. Portions of ice cream seemed larger than usual but the Pumpkin Spice was surprisingly..."
Sabra Ionno
"I had black raspberry yogurt in waffle cone!! So good!! Huge servings. Small size cup was more like a large. Always fresh and delicious. Can't wait..."
Bonnie Marquez
"Excellent ice cream. Fun food! Super cocos..."
eileen lemontagne
"Convenient. Lots of ice cream flavors to pick from. I used to go when I was a kid and it had different owners, I believe. Very nicely..."
"Have tried three apps & three entrees so far all delicious. They have a prepared meal case as well. Highly recommend the beef stroganoff, the..."
Donna K
"Excellent food, clean rustic atmosphere. Staff are friendly. Great mix of musical guests. Would love to enjoy the patio on a summer night. Well lit,..."
Anne Howley
"Nice atmosphere and great food! I had the scallops which were done just perfectly! They have various entree and drink specials most times and have a..."
Ken Panetta
"Went to the first annual clam bake! I got the $15 boil bag and it was definitely worth it! It came with clams, mussels, shrimp, crawdads, potatoes,..."
Andrew Cusson
"Nice atmosphere. Food was very good. Pricing was reasonable. Location convenient to accessing I-95.
Oddly, they couldn't find any sugar for our..."
Lou
"Great place for a casual dinner, the people were friendly, great chicken wings and homemade chips and the mudslide was good too. Highly..."
"Great food. Sad to see multuple employees inside without masks. Wont be returning anytime..."
Pete Jacobson
"Coffees is the Best! Great food, friendly staff and always..."
Alex
"Couldn't have been more pleased with the service and quality of food I received at Coffees Country Market! Teresa and Ken really came through in a..."
Nicola Alexander
"This place is awesome, I used to go there everyday for lunch when I worked at all pro! Great grinders and soup, good..."
Noah Schroeder
"Very good coffee and amazing sandwiches. Very..."
Cecilia Montero
"Awesome grinders very good..."
Ron Hathaway
"I've been going there for 27 years. Yum
You won't be disappointed. The salads are..."
Dana Lasky
"Coffee's catered the after-gathering for my father's funeral. They were kind, flexible, helping us tease out exactly what we needed and wanted. The..."
"We made an unscheduled dinner stop off I-95. Good selection of wines. Menu simple but tasty. Prices NYC comparable. Cozy atmosphere. Staff helpful..."
Victor Nowicki
"My husband and I recently enjoyed a quiet dinner and cocktails at the Chestnut Grille. If you've never tried one of the Chestnut Grille's..."
Nory Oakes
"Great food, with live music in the bar some evenings. Beautiful old inn with a mix of fresh..."
"Originally a Da Vinci Pizzeria, La Mia is exactly what you hope for in a local pizza shop.
I order a *scallop and bacon pizza* exactly as it comes:..."
Bokks87
"Holy cow... that was one incredibly delicious chicken cutlet bacon grinder!! Definitely was not expecting that!! As a chef, I’m very critical of..."
Chef Chrissie Lapidow
"really great pizza, but my only complaint is the online ordering/delivery. the delivery itself seems a little expensive and not all their menu items..."
gilla syko
"Pizza is my favorite food- and I love the creativity, crust, and passion for pizza at La Mia Pizzeria! I love the daily specials and their 2 slices..."
Rachel Postovoit
"Local fave. I live around the corner and am so grateful to have a celiac-friendly option that is even more delicious (i think) than regular..."
"My favorite Subway by far, they know my regular order after a few visits and keep a very clean..."
Brian Noland
"Clean store and friendly staff! Just disappointed that they don't take coupons, that we actually get in the mail for this..."
Patty B
"Yummy subs very tasty but disappointed in the short..."
Caroline Cote
"Excellent Experience. Stopped at that Subway to buy myself and 2 workers lunch on the way back from a job. The 2 ladies working were very friendly,..."
Tait Transportation
"Cleanest most friendly Subway I have ever been in!
Excellent staff when I went during the..."
"Absolutely the best Chinese food you can get in eastern ct. Friendly, fast and accurate service, portions given are generous compared to price...."
Liam Whatofit
"The chicken and broccoli here tasted great! Would definitely go here..."
Macy Wong
"This restaurant is home to one of the BEST Chinese food I have ever eaten! Especially the General Tso's Chicken, garlic chicken, pork lo mein, and..."
Rina L.
"I ordered General Tso's Chicken and I just absolutely loved it! The texture of the chicken was crispy and seasoned well on the outside, yet when I..."
Wendy Weng
"The broccoli and garlic sauce is cooked to perfection, the onion fried soft and tender. Polite and friendly service, clean establishment. Definitely..."
"I loooove really this place in old lyme, my salad was delicious and also my husband..."
Virginia Urbina
"Fish tacos out of this world! My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed our meal.Only complaint was portion size for price. Definitely recommend and not..."
Maureen Coogan
"Happy hour at the Public House is amazing. Their food is definitely worth their usual price, but at half price it is a must try. For the price of a..."
Tommy Seda
"Great service, food, and an excellent drink menu. Live music on some nights is also very..."
Holly Johnson
"Great place for delicious drinks and tasty food! Will absolutely be going..."
Ashley Hobbs
"Food was delicious and perfect portion size. Nice casual..."
"Love this shop, the owner is wonderful, and everything is always fresh as can be. They also have great tips on cooking ideas and ways to make your..."
Red Crow
"I have known this family for generation's and Dawn has surpassed her parent's today as a great purveyer of a seafood and very helpful.....can..."
Christopher Hall
"Never bought bad fish here. Clean and friendly, always willing to help with receipes for the..."
Julie Cameron
"Excellent quality fresh fish pricier than the grocery..."
Kathy Jennings
"The BEST place to get a lobster roll on the..."
Caitlyn Cody
"Lobster roll was fantastic!! Friendly people definitely will go..."
Michelle Valenti
"We've gotten the lobster bisque, and clams - both are..."
"An excellent spot for sweet or savory crepes, gourmet coffee, and smoothies. Service is quick and cheerful. The crepe I had wasn't exactly like being..."
"An excellent spot for sweet or savory crepes, gourmet coffee, and smoothies. Service is quick and cheerful. The crepe I had wasn't exactly like being..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes