The best Restaurants in Peaks Island ranking of January 2025
9 restaurant menus in Peaks Island, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"Great low key, cafe and waterfront bar near the Peaks Island ferryport. Great service and atmosphere. Wonderful place to spend a blustery Sunday..."
Chris Quinn
"This little diamond in the ruff is everything I love about Maine! Vacationing with family and they brought me to the island for this wonderful little..."
Amy Hofmann
"On our first trip to Portland my husband and I decided to hop the ferry to Peaks island for dinner at The Cockeyed Gull, on the glowing..."
Carly Jae
"As of right now this place is open 7 days a week. It is absolutely fabulous! We got to watch the Sunset on the Patio while enjoying eachother, drinks..."
Dena Sutton
"My husband came to this place already and he said it was nice so i decided to come this time and I Loved it. The Waitress was so nice, the food was..."
Christiana D'Arceuil
"Great little restaurant on Peaks Island. Very friendly staff and the food was excellent. Lots of options on the menu. My son has celiac and they..."
fred rozell
"We had lunch here and the view is amazing. The food was even better. We had 2 of the daily specials and both were excellent. Potato cakes and crab..."
Zommy NL
"On our trip to Portland we decided to take the ferry to Peak Island (I’ve read recommendations that this is a great experience) The island is small..."
Daria
"We loved the Caesar salad, the tuna tacos, the pork bulgolgi lettuce wraps and the cold beverages. We got to sit outside on the deck on a sunny 4th..."
MH Moto
"Excellent location, great food, pleasant service, and a good beer selection.
Get off the ferry, take a right and it’s on the left towards the crest..."
Chris Webb
"The views were amazing. Service was stellar. The food exceeded my expectations for what I would get on Peaks Island. I had a crusted haddock. The..."
Chris Merrill
"I never expect to much from restaurants in touristy areas. Usually I'm paying for the location, view, and food is so so. Not the case here! The food..."
Rebeçca Pakowski
"Double the stars please! Fantastic experience all the way around. We came here Tuesday evening (8/31/21) Our server was so lovely, gracious and..."
Trigger Hippy
"This little restaurant is EVERYTHING. So cute, SO delicious, such friendly staff and good service, and of course the location is spectacular. We were..."
Taylor Flowe
"We didn’t eat here, as we had already eaten a late lunch, but we did grab a couple drinks on the patio while waiting for the ferry. We spent nearly..."
"Great view, food and service! Very clean. Staff takes Covid precautions..."
Burcay Gurcan
"Pete's island restaurant awesome food good price would love to go back again and eat there..."
Peter Osgood
"Stayed in the outer green room for two nights end of June. Nice room, clean, large enough for four. Right by the ferry terminal. Resteraunt is very..."
Donnie Lesh
"Great little lunch spot right off the ferry; fish tacos were..."
Andrew Chase
"Absolutely great experience! Staff sat us at a great table with a view and was super friendly. Delicious meal and great atmosphere. Highly..."
Icecanburn
"Just a great place to just sit and enjoy the views and have a wonderful meal. Food was great and excellent..."
"You can't beat the location; this is the perfect spot to hang out with a bite to eat and a cold beer after exploring around on Peaks.
We ordered a..."
Tom Szelag
"This place was a great find! Quick service, super friendly staff, family friendly, great food and great beverages. Nice back deck that looks out over..."
Nick Habes
"Just the perfect place after getting off the ferry, walking a short distance, and sitting down at a picnic table with a million dollar view of Casco..."
John Najarian
"Long drive. DONT UBER/LYFT. You’ll never make it back to Portland. Gorgeous place to have lunch or dinner..."
Denise Fyffe
"Great views and great food! Really ready to order - walk in the door and order from the server to the left (menu on the wall to the right). Take a..."
Sarah Carsello
"We had the fried clams with onion rings and the chicken tenders with plain fries. The fried clams cost $40 and contained about eight clams. Those..."
Angus Deighan
"You know you're paying a little extra at a place like this for its location and its views, but it's certainly worth it. Sit out on the patio, enjoy..."
Michael Shen
"Lobster here is cheaper than I expected, pretty good food and the view is..."
Ivy Q
"This restaurant was recommended by a local. Absolutely thee best lobster and shrimp rolls anywhere! The cole slaw has minimal mayonnaise with tart..."
Ilene Lazar
"Really yummy food! Their steamed lobsters are very reasonably priced and all of their fish and chips are gluten free. It was so fun to eat on the..."
Eve S
"Could not ask for a better view to enjoy our meal. I went with the brown butter lobster roll and was not disappointed as it was packed with meat and..."
Nelson Corchado
"The lobster here are sooooo fresh! There are only 4 restaurants on the island, and this one hit the spot. The restaurant is family owned, and they do..."
Karle Lyons
"We had a wonderful time there. They had a live band playing throughout the afternoon. The food were delicious. They have nice sitting area..."
Madame Jeune
"It’s a pretty confusing setup, they really should have a hostess guiding you.
The process is to wander around the establishment until you find a..."
Kyle D
"Beautiful views. Hot fresh seafood. Mostly self serve but food is served..."
Judi Clancy
"Lobster tasted great, portions were big, but the fries were a lil too salty and most of the cheese curds of my poutine were cold, not nice and..."
Santa Fe
"I had the fried fish sandwich. It was so good. Great place with a great vibe. Pulled up on the boat to the dock and had lunch. Great people..."
S A
"Perfect place to stop for a bite. Serving size is perfect. Fresh and..."
"Friendly staff and cozy ambiance. The food was very hearty and savory. I enjoyed breakfast while visiting the island for a few days and sat in the..."
Sarah Carsello
"What a darling little cafe off the ferry dock. If you have patience as usually there could be a small line... you must try this cafe. I had a ..."
Verthosand Photography
"Nice little place. It's right there where you get off the ferry, nice option for breakfast before exploring the island. No restrooms inside but..."
Jonnathan J Rodriguez
"Fun little restaurant. Friendly staff. Lots of options for breakfast, lunch. Variety of coffees, teas, drinks. Nice gifty items. Was only open until..."
Catherine “Katy” Panasiewicz
"Very highly recommended. Excellent food (with great vegetarian options) and a very welcoming and friendly chef/server/owner who was a wealth of..."
Darren MacRae
"I love the atmosphere here. The way it's decorated is so cute and it's really cozy. I got a gluten free bagel, which I find always have a distinctive..."
Melissa Curran
"Delicious sausage, bagel and egg sandwich. Got this as soon as we got off the ferry and gave us the energy to get through a day of hiking, exploring..."
Scott Kerth
"I visited this place while on Peaks Island for the 5 Mile road race. The staff were so friendly and helpful, and the coffee was delicious! I had a..."
Samantha Eaton
"Adorable cafe right off the ferry. Friendly staff. The bagel sandwiches were delicious! Get yourself a spinach and feta pastry. You'll thank me for..."
Jeanine Burdge
"We came here because of their famous cinnamon rolls and they truly delivered. All the pastries here are homemade and delicious, you can't really go..."
Sahnaz Saleem
"I love this place. It's small, can be crowded (after the ferry lets out), and kitschy. But, that's what makes it great. Down to earth staff, great..."
Whitney Baker
"This downstairs cafe can be considered small, especially when there is a long line for the many delicious pastries and coffee. The staff is friendly..."
Jeff Chetkauskas
"I've been here several times since winter and every time I've been greeted in a friendly way. The coffee is hot and the food is delicious. It's..."
Steve Fennell
"Cute little spot. Where the food is excellent and made to liking, regulars have their own mugs, visitors..."
Ronny Contreras
"Stopped by today on a trip to the island. The food is really good! One person was running the place and she was very nice and..."
Adam Lamontagne
"Excellent cream cheese and locks! Fantastic coffee. The vibe was lovely, and they made us feel like we were at home! We'll be..."
Trigger Hippy
"Yes!! Had lunch today after walking around the island. The atmosphere was great. Great service! We had the turkey sandwich and the vegetarian!! Both..."
"I've never seen one person run a kitchen all by themselves and still be so friendly! It was a busy day for Milly's when we came (it seemed like every..."
Yael W
"The food and service here is great! Would recommend the Captain’s Lobster Roll and the truffle..."
Emma Valentine
"Me and my fiancé shared the breakfast tacos and we highly recommend them!
They taste amazing and healthy nice and fresh with a great crunch on the..."
Attaquin Weeden
"Lobster roll prepared fresh on the spot. Don't be in a rush, bc they prepare everything after you order it. Go over to Jones Landing for the bar..."
Douglas Daley
"Awesome veggie burger that only took a couple minutes to grab! Highly..."
Keith Stockless
"Great atmosphere and loved the decor/vibe. The Cajun Chicken Sandwich was pretty good, but I was super disappointed by the Fish Tacos. They really..."
Becca H
"Delicious lobster rolls! Like, slap your mama level of..."
Liz
"Grabbed a quick snack upon arriving at Peaks Island and glad we did. Got a Cheese, Bean, and Avacado taco and some french fries. Both were great and..."
Aaron Renshaw
"I got a lobster roll that was fresh, stuffed with meat, and on a perfectly toasted bun. The fried brussel sprouts are also amazing. Simple..."
Kathy Maxwell
"Surprising find! Some of the best tacos I’ve ever had. The taco shell was made fresh and the chicken was juicy and seasoned perfectly! Took some..."
PJ
"I loved the chicken taco with the shredded cabbage and sriracha aioli sauce. The fries were hot and crisp. Check out this stationary food truck and..."
Jeff Chetkauskas
"Wow, the lobster roll was incredible, pork tacos were also really good. Fresh green tea topped off a perfect..."
"Last minute decision to get ice cream here, and it was good.
Smooth and creamy.
Got the Moose Tracks. Ice cream was creamy, and had good flavor...."
Haylee Jane Monteiro
"Very yummy icecream and conveniently located next to the..."
Ashley Peeples
"Crazy line, but worth it! Really good ice cream options & nice kids working behind the..."
Taylor Flowe
"Yummy. Pretty quick service too considering how many people were here. Highly recommend while waiting for the..."
Nick Kottelenberg
"As someone who is dairy free it made my day to go to a place that is accommodating. Their strawberry lemonade sorbet was delicious! I highly..."
Will S
"The best ice cream on Peaks. Great staff. Right off the ferry when you disembark. Try the Moose Tracks! You can also do all your souvenir shopping..."
John Lee
"Nice for an island ice cream break. Variety of flavors. The team were also able to accommodate for an allergy in the party
Thanks!!
PS… ask for..."
Diane Steele
"Only rating 5 star as a curtesy...As someone who’s been spending summers on peaks island for 26 years since i was 6 months old. I remember my first..."
A Moore
"Favorite ice cream..."
Laurie Macdonald
"Always dependable. Always there. Long lines, but quick..."
"I was talking with the owner and he told me how he wakes up at 4 am daily to check his lobster traps and then gets the lobsters ready for sale. He..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes