The best Restaurants in Phoenicia ranking of January 2025
10 restaurant menus in Phoenicia, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"Came well recommend and didn’t disappoint. Good food, great service. On a motorcycle and waited out the rain, not rushed to leave, even though..."
Chris Blackwell
"First visit was with the guys. Wait was over an hour for table of 6 but the food was totally worth it. In fact I loved the food so much that I had to..."
Atul Pai
"Feeling nostalgic and / or adventurous? Missing old school Americana? Craving amazing food while up in the Catskills? There is a place, right off..."
Ekaterina Gosparovich
"Perfect as always. Food was on point staff even though they were beyond busy were..."
Jason M Logan
"Worth the drive, great food, wonderful old time feel to the place, great views of the mountains! Spend the extra few minutes to drive up Route..."
Mark Duerr
"Best food. Best ingredients. Best staff. An owner who is present and cares. Truly local.
I can't wait for the summer hours to start! Duck confit..."
Antonia Schreiber
"Omg! Excellent food and service! An extra - the Bloody Mary’s are best..."
Tory Lynn Scarfone
"A must stop on route 28. We always sit at the counter. The pancakes and French toast are delicious! Cool vibe and great service...."
Lauren Dez
"Cool vibe, great eats, very kid friendly. As others said, very long wait but we were there primetime on Sunday with a large party. Had fun playing..."
Wendy Klein Keane
"Only good things to say about this place! The staff is warm and welcoming. The pancakes were some of the best I’ve had. They’re pretty filling..."
Rylan Gordon
"So, I've been driving past this diner since April of 2022 as I work on the high peaks. The lots always full without fail. Today I hit #29 and decided..."
Tom Hoos
"Super overhyped, place been around for years but need to pay attention to food temperature (Chicken Tortilla soup was barely warm), Meatloaf sandwich..."
Marcin Glowacki
"This is a must stop for anyone visiting Mt Tremper, NY. It was unbelievably busy and the hostess was able to find us a table with no waiting while..."
Laura
"My wife and I had a wonderful time at Phoenicia Diner. Be warned that even on a Friday at 11am, it’s going to be quite packed and there will likely..."
Michael Berkowitz
"We had our Welcome Party/Rehearsal Dinner here in early July on a Sunday eve.. it was seriously fantastic. The weather was ominous but we were able..."
Mel Frezados
"This place is a must visit if you are in the area! It's diner food but done with quality local ingredients and creativity. I had a smoked trout egg..."
Sara Lynch
"I had been here a few times a few years ago and I remembered loving the place, but on my most recent visit, not so much. It was very crowded and very..."
Jena Vignola
"If you want stellar food in a somewhat rural and random spot, this is it. The pancakes - oh my. They were the best I’ve had in many years,..."
Adam Orentlicher
"Food was excellent however I do not recommend sitting outside. It wasn’t even that crowded when my family and I went. But we decided to sit outside..."
"Amazing ambience and yummy tasty food.
I had lunch over here after long drive in Catskills mountains..
I got a right spot for car fuel and stomach..."
Rajesh More
"Not sure whether Brio's needs another review. This place is iconic and has been Phoenicia's and, dare I say it, Catskill's fixture since time..."
Yurii Chinenov
"Amazing pizza cooked fresh in a wood fired pizza oven! One of the best pizzas I have ever eaten and I have had many pizzas from all over Italy...."
Matthew Ash
"We were in the area for my daughter’s wedding and I took my relatives to Brio’s for breakfast in the morning on a rainy Saturday. It is a pizza..."
Bonnie Sakow
"Hidden gem! Fantastic food with great prices and excellent personnel! We tried their penne ala vodka and ny style pizza, both were very good ! Check..."
Ewaldo Leitão
"Stumbled upon this gem while exploring the Catskills and will be dreaming about their pizzas back home in SWFL! The sesame crust, pesto drizzle, and..."
Anisley Martinez
"We stop here on our family vacation to grab lunch. I liked to stop in at non-chain restaurants when traveling. We were very impressed with how good..."
Nathan H.
"We were two families of 4 and everyone left happy and full with two large pies, two orders of tater tots and fried calamari. Tater tots were..."
Mei Zhang
"Wow. Just the best pizza I have EVER had.
The thin crust brick oven pizza was the BEST treat after a 10 mile hike to Slide and Cornell Mountain.
We..."
Caroline Vargas
"Went here for breakfast on a Monday morning in August. Food was excellent. Had a breakfast quesadilla and husband had an omelette. Service was just..."
Tisha Paige
"Great quick lunch stop after hiking. Wonderful wide selection of food and good atmosphere sitting in sun room on a nice chilly..."
Ian Colquhoun
"Our meal was great! Our server, can't remember her name but the beautiful one with the scorpion tattoo on her wrist was awesome. I had the fish..."
derreck ferris
"So friendly and accommodating. From unique wood fired pizza to steak delicious. Desserts are dangerously..."
Ralph Merante
"Totally loved this place, it was neat. The bartender was so nice also the serving staff, We enjoyed the food over there .. Ambience was too good also..."
sasidhar uppala
"This is a nice place to have dinner. Friendly staff. We ordered the tilapia, the mac and cheese and the coconut cake! OMG everything was delicious..."
Michele
"This is a great place to visit! Yummy brick oven pizza with a whole lot more!
Pros:
Great service
Yummy pizza
Fast and friendly employees
Incredible..."
Jer Brack
"The staff is friendly but a little slow to react to waiting customers. The inside is spacious and clean the ambiance is sports bar. The place is..."
"Stopped in after a snowboarding day at Plattekill Mountain. We enjoyed ourselves but felt rushed when we were having desert. Waiters and bartenders..."
ANA BANANA
"The food was delicious, we ordered a sea food Mac and cheese and a fish with mango salsa. If I come back to USA, I will definitely go back there, it..."
Nadine Lariviere
"We had the rice ball with marinara sauce appetizer and it was delicious.
Pork chop entree was cooked perfectly to a nice medium. All the sides..."
Nick Duque
"Great service, staff was extremely friendly and knowledgeable, let's not forget great..."
Irma Pimentel
"Visiting the area with my wife for the weekend and I saw this on Yelp. We made a reservation for 7, but we ended up going early as our plans around 6..."
Jonathan McHugh
"Ordered take out and was delicious. Wish the outdoor space was dog friendly but could tell they were trying to maintain an upscale vibe. I understand..."
Geoff Erickson
"Best Filet Mignon I've ever had! We are big steak eaters and have dined at some of the best well known resteraunts and steak houses from Naples FL,..."
Mr. C
"Food was ok, ordered the oysters they were great and a decent price. For main I ordered the Tomahawk steak , says it's supposed to be 40 oz , If the..."
charlie tolmie jr
"Great place... The food was so good. Highly recommended 👌
Customer service is excellent. Everyone greeted me with a smile. They were extremely..."
Norman Hawkins
"We had just finished hiking and arrived about 40 minutes before closing time, but the staff treated us like royalty. The food and the services was..."
Penny Lester
"The location was perfect, atmosphere was a delight. Food was exquisite. Most of all the server Alfredo was so attendentive, hostbilable and..."
Elizabeth Morel
"Buddy and I shared a delicious 40 oz tomahawk ribeye after a big dayhike. Had to force ourselves to finish it. Sides are..."
Christian Lopez
"Love this place drove from from long Island last year only to find them closed for a wedding. This year we made sure. The 2 couples that came with..."
STEVE FORTE
"I was in the area for an extended weekend. The restaurant has a very comfortable atmosphere. Staff are friendly and provide attentive service...."
Christian H.
"Great small town steakhouse! Service was excellent. The 40oz tomahawk was out of this world. Super thick, the dry rub was so good and cooked..."
Lindsey Twist
"I had a delicious strip steak, very rare - couldn't finish it. I had it for dinner the next day, and lunch the next. Excellent to the end.
Side..."
tea bird
"Delicious! A little on the pricey side but definitely enjoyed our meal. Food was cooked to order, no..."
Stacy
"Truly fine dining. Quite expensive, so I'll think of this as a special occasion place. My steak was excellent, the service solid, and the decor..."
"While vacationing in the area, we found Woodstock Brewing. We were seated in the beautiful outside seating area, tried flights and pints, and..."
Shark Man
"Always try to stop by when I’m in the area. The smoked beef sandwich was awesome and so was the selection of IPAs! Staff was great too! Looking..."
Scott Beatty
"Great collection of draft beers. We ordered a couple of flights and some chips; both of which were great. The ambience is great, everything is clean..."
sachin rathi
"We are so happy that we decided to have dinner at Woodstock Brewing after a day exploring the shops and markets of downtown Woodstock. Located about..."
Natalie Fox
"The beer was great! I loved all the ones we got in the flight. The spicy wings were very tasty..."
Erica M
"It's a great place to enjoy the weather, scenery, food and beer at the same time.
The food and beers were..."
perle75nyc
"Loved the vibe of this place! Kids, dogs, locals, non locals. Everyone chilling here on a Saturday afternoon. Menu was unexpectedly wide and..."
Alison Lee
"Nice place. Open seating. The only downside was the bug infestation on the windows. We were allowed to change seats, but there wasn't much they could..."
Gee Parker
"I have passed this establishment a handful of times since I started hiking the Catskill35s and have been itching to check out. I was stoked to meet..."
Greene Dream
"IPAs across the spectrum. Sours galore. Great food and a beautiful tap room. Just get there. Thai fried chicken sandwich and the smoked beef sandwich..."
"Wonderful place while visiting Phoenicia. The portions are huge and you have enough leftovers for the next day or two. The food itself is delicious...."
Malika Baksh
"Best place near Phoenicia. Always had lot of fun there. Best Pizza and lot of choices for draft beers!!!It has become a routine to stop by this place..."
Rajesh Narasimhan
"Great food, humongous portions, friendly and super efficient service.
Nice ambiance overall.
What else one needs? Great selection of local beers..."
Alex
"The food was delicious and the selection enormous. They had three different menus with a whole assortment of food. One of the things that really..."
Imre Beke
"Honestly, I love their meatloaf and struggle to stray away from that comfortable meal that leaves me feeling so good after. 2 beers, maybe 3 and I'm..."
Captain Mike K
"Food is always good and the service is great. There are plenty of choices to eat and drink. The prices are fair and dessert case is a..."
Andrew Wojturski
"Hello Mike I hope this finds the right place and maybe you do remember my family as I do yours my greatest memorys with my uncle Joe from Greenpoint..."
PETER GUCCI
"I went up to NY to visit family. We ended up going here for lunch. We ordered pizza. The pizza was great. We ordered a buffalo chicken and cheese..."
John Pomeroy
"My husband and I were in town just for the weekend, and were looking for dinner on a Sunday night. The location had some changes due to COVID-19..."
Madeline Morris
"Let me start off by saying the food is amazing! My wife and myself hiked Mt Tremper today and looking forward to a good meal and a cold drink. We..."
paul tonkay
"Just a great place to eat, have fun, and enjoy the day with the out door dining. Staff super friendly. Get ready to eat because the portions are..."
TeamTiny Relaxation
"Overall a decent dining experience. I visited with a large group, my wife and I ordered the combo dish of chicken fajitas. We found the food to be..."
"EXCELLENT BREAKFAST! While vacationing in the Catskills for Memorial Day, we stopped at Sweet Sue's. The service was fantastic and the food was..."
Shark Man
"After years of eating at Phoenicia Diner, we decided to try a new brunch spot and I’m SO glad we found Sweet Sue’s! I just had the best pancakes...."
Cole Witter
"Tried the cold brew, which was good and a fine strength. The waffle was good as well. Service was good, and food was a bit slow coming out of the..."
Thomas
"Been an occasional diner the past two decades. Good to see new owners have maintained the delicious Sue’s legacy pancakes along with a larger..."
Steve Smith
"The best pancakes and rancheros we’ve ever had! Latke potato pancakes were amazing and freshest coffee from a local roaster to top it all off. We..."
George
"This place is a hidden gem, we drive nearly 2 hours to check it out. Made a day trip of it and this was a wonderful way to start the morning. They..."
Peter Panagedes (Beast Monkey)
"My daughter is obsessed with their pancakes, but I must say, the Huevos Rancheros were so good I dreamt about them that night. They’re perfect,..."
Christine Fitzsimonds
"Sweet Sue's is phenomenal! Everything we've eaten here has been incredible (strawberry monkey pancakes, chocolate pancakes, chili/labneh eggs, and..."
Jamie Hill
"Our first time to Sweet Sue’s and it did not disappoint. This latest culinary edition to Phoenicia is fantastic! A new/old establishment beloved by..."
Kathleen Ruttan-Daigle
"I came in for breakfast on a beautiful sunny Sunday morning. I ordered a cappuccino that was too strong for me but I added milk to it and it got..."
Caroline Vargas
"Pleasant surprise addition to Phoenicia. Don’t know why I missed it but luckily found this cute cafe on the main retail strip in town. The coffee..."
Victor Jung
"Brisket sandwich on sour dough is to die for! No one is in a rush here… so if you are- take a patience pill or don’t come. No rush to clean off..."
Alexandra Gleason
"Cute breakfast place with a large variety of pancakes, my favorite being the ricotta ones. I also got an omelette with mushrooms and leeks but it was..."
Ukiyo
"Should change its name, this is a shadow of what Sweet Sues used to be.
I had been going to sweet sues regularly for as far back as I remember. It..."
Adam Knuckey
"Always a great breakfast or lunch here. Pancakes are their specialty but I prefer one of their egg sandwiches. Cathy is a great waitress who has been..."
John Boston
"The food was so good at Sweet Sue's that I had to keep ordering a different dish every 10 minutes and everything was spectacular. This is one of the..."
Mr Manigo
"The town of Phoenicia is a hidden gem. Sweet Sue's is known for it's pancakes and they're are plentiful (try the cornmeal type) so don't get the full..."
"The food at Tavern 214 is very good. I got the Cheese and Salumi plate, which consisted of salami, 3 hard kinds of cheese, meat, and 1..."
Basil Moore
"Found this wonderful restaurant while enjoying the fall colors. From preparation to presentation everything was great. The appetizers were some..."
Jeff Gunn
"We had our Wedding Dinner on Nov 1st. Their entire teams was so accommodating and professional. I did everything remotely from NYC and it was all..."
Dayna Dixon
"We have a ski home at Hunter Mountain and eat here frequently. T214 is always consistently great. Pete and Vivian are awesome hosts and restaurant..."
Jay Frischman
"Great staff, lively vibe and most importantly DELICIOUS food. Menu was mix of American classics like steaks and fish, but also included other..."
Max Schweber
"I food run and bus here during the summer. Everyone who works here is great, they all put customers first. The lobster mac and cheese is my favorite,..."
Jordan Milite
"The food was delicious and so was the ambiance. We sat in front of the fire on a cold night and it was perfect. The service was fantastic as well...."
Marsha P
"Best food in Phoenicia. Owners have a great passion for their food and cocktails. Staff is always great and very knowledgeable and accommodating..."
Sean Zapart
"Fantastic atmosphere. Amazing staff. Excellent execution on dishes many MANY places do poorly. Local, well seasoned, cared for..."
JP B
"Absolutely love everything about this place. From the decor to the staff it was perfect. The food was delicious. My husband and I can't wait to go..."
Dawn Kozik
"This place was amazing. The two owners were super nice and very welcoming. Great atmosphere, great sound system with good music, and the food was..."
Scott Newman
"On our first trip to Phoenicia, we were delighted to find such wonderful hospitality and delicious takes on comfort food from Peter and Vivian Diaz,..."
Clayton McGratty
"Delicious burrata and trout tacos. Very Friendly service. My only complaint is they are closed Sundays and I couldn't go..."
Linda Farrish
"Service and food were fantastic. They were able to seat us after a day at Belleayre without a reservation, we got..."
Richard
"Delicious small plates. Fantastic cocktails. Pete the owner and his wife are..."
Alexander Lepes
"We really enjoy the food and the service.
Kind of cold near the door whit only the fireplace working to worm up the place in..."
"This place is amazing!! Perfect lattes and coffee, insanely delicious cupcakes baked fresh every day by the owner, and beautifully crafted sandwiches..."
Shannon Hokanson
"I plan on returning every single time I'm in the area. What an incredible bakery! The women there are great, the Jill's Favorite sandwich was..."
J Brown
"Grabbed coffee and brownie to go. And brownie was extra good. Kids were very..."
Ewa Kubiak-Thornton
"We are visiting from Maine this week- this bakery is right down the road from where we are staying! We have been in each morning to get the most..."
Ashley Lee
"Glad to have stopped in! Will be stopping again before returning home! Great little bakery with excellent sandwiches!
You can tell as soon as you..."
Tom Morey
"This is not just a bakery!!!!!
This is my new favorite place, I think its even better than Brios. Jill is the sweetest and very helpful, I will be a..."
Sabina Cardenas
"Love this bakery! Friendly home town atmosphere. The owner is caring and dedicated to her business. Imaginative and delicious bakery items. Fantastic..."
Carolyn Day
"Great place. Very friendly staff; prices are decent. They treated us like we were at a diner even though all we ordered was a bagel and a cupcake...."
Alexandra Benware
"It was a pleasant stop. The sandwiches that both my husband and I had were amazing. They were some of the best I've had in a long time. It's well..."
Carol Tolive
"Amazing cupcakes! I had the lemon and the Snickers; the cupcakes were moist and so tasty and the icing was perfect. The staff there are super..."
Rachel Huenger
"Friendly, clean and great coffee. Indoor outdoor seating. Family friendly. Good baked..."
Leidy law
"The Cold Brew and the food is always great. The overflowing Pulled Pork Tacos I had today were..."
Alexander Bradley
"Delicious fresh baked goods. Out of this world coffee at an extremely good..."
Heather Wright
"What a lovely place! Amazing coffee and beautiful baked..."
Amy Budd
"Great bakery, breakfast and lunch all day . You must stop and say hi to..."
Walter Johnson
"Best egg sandwich in NY, best place to grab breakfast or lunch on..."
"Didn’t realize “the lot” had a different location, the review written on Phoenicia Diner still holds. Service, food, and ambiance was amazing!..."
Samantha Zapata
"An absolute gem. One of the standout experiences of our family's trip to the Catskills. A perfectly curated blend of wonderful food, idyllic..."
Ash Kimber
"Great option to grab some much needed coffee while waiting for a table at the Phoenicia Diner (literally a few feet away). I went with the "Catskills..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes