The best Restaurants in Rexburg ranking of April 2025
115 restaurant menus in Rexburg, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"I remember my first time stopping at this strange yet fascinating location. I walked inside and was met by the most friendly staff I had ever seen...."
Matthew Stockwell
"Normally when I visit I don't have any issues, this time I walked in when they were overwhelmed with a flood of people, the drive through was over..."
Tim McGraw
"The food was good although the bun was burnt and the ketchup was very watery, but other than that it was..."
Cohen Baggerly
"Great experience. Super customer service.
This last week Mc Donald's supported a teachers night. This raises funds for my daughter's school which..."
"Tried the new (or at least returning) Pretzel crust pizza. Superior to the standard pizza, rate this Caesars as cleaner than most, non-interesting..."
Daniel Bagley
"The pizza here is great! This may be my favorite pizza place in Rexburg! The only disappointing part is they don’t have pretzel crust as a..."
Beck Thueson (ThatOneGuyNamedBeck)
"I ordered a pepperoni cheeser cheeser pizza. But where is most of my pizza? This is absolutely horrible. I was not very impressed with how little was..."
"Huge shoutout to Rexburg Panda! They helped us with a HUGE catering order at Christmas and it was delivered hot, on time and with great..."
Danika Hamm
"The only reason I give this a 4 instead of a 5 is because the drive through is slow. If you're looking to get food from this place faster always go..."
"The servers were attentive and got all of our orders correct. The food was delicious and full of wonderful flavor. It's a wonderful spot that is out..."
Colton Iverson
"Ordered the 1lb burger (with fries/tots) and had food for my wife and I for an entire day. It was delicious and easy to reheat in the oven. My wife..."
David Alkire
"How I love coming back to the original Big Jud’s !!!
High quality food! Burgers and chicken sandwiches are..."
Nathan Duce
"You wanna support a mom and pop shop local greasy spoon, then this is the place to bring the whole family! We come here for big family events and..."
Destinee Speas
"Delicious! Their burgers have that classic small town perfection that makes people come from far away to have!
My husband and I shared the Big Jud..."
sammi estrada
"Burgers here are overrated in my opinion. I think it was OK! The patties can be more flavorful. It is also really busy, needed a little wait time..."
Charise Chua
"I didn't realize that Jud's is not really located in Rexburg; however, it was worth the short drive southward. We arrived at the rather odd time of..."
Bryan Andersen
"This is exactly what I wanted. A great little local mom and pop shop that is delicious (yet simple menu) and the staff was really sweet and..."
"Great slice of pizza for the price. I ordered the “Praise the Lard” and honestly was impressed. 5/5. I originally reviewed this restaurant and..."
Brandon Loder
"You can’t get much better than Righteous Slice. They appeal to their target market (college students) brilliantly.
The atmosphere is fun, unique,..."
Noah Kelsch
"The best pizza in town, no doubt! Every pizza I've tried is unique and so delicious! My favourite is the Bee Sting; the hint of honey is amazing!!..."
Brittany Henry
"Definitely a favorite! Not your typical pizza place, this one has unusually flavored pizzas and fresher ingredients. The crust reminds me of the..."
krista Simkins
"The pizza was amazing! The Godfather pizza is a great choice! However, the lack of unsecured windows on the second floor was, frankly,..."
Joseph Hansen
"Staff is always so fun and courteous. The shakes are SO good! And the pizza tastes delicious, like it actually has real ingredients. Seriously love..."
Jonnae Ogden
"We loved everything about this place! Our food was delicious and was ready and served to us just as we made it to our table to sit down! The..."
Jessica Zaugg
"Customer service is great! Every time I come to righteous slice, employees are always so sweet and happy! Overall, I’d rate my experience..."
"The dessert pizza pies were AWESOME!!! I loveee them!! All the sweet ones were done great! Definitely highly recommending people trying the oreo pie..."
Charise Chua
"I normally don’t write reviews but I loved my experience here on Saturday! From the second I walk in the door the staff were very friendly and..."
Kathryn Hankins
"Best pizza in town! You could definitely eat the crust if you want to ☺️ There are so many different flavors and unique options. The restaurant..."
Chelsea Nerdin
"Pizza Pie is hands down one of my favorite places to go. The staff is ALWAYS helpful and kind. The last time I went I was helped by a girl named..."
sydney risser
"A good pizza buffet. There are some fun combos there. I especially loved the hillbilly pizza and the potato pizza. I'd like to see some thin crust..."
"SUPERB sushi and entrees. We have been frequent customers at Da Pineapple Grill for over five years now, and continue to love their food. We are so..."
Sl_cannon
"Definitely a family restaurant, friendly noise level. Not licensed so no Saki to go with dinner. Good selection of..."
Kate
"Amazing Food and an "Island Pace". I will start by saying this definately one of my favorite restaurants in the entire southeast Idaho area. The..."
Tyson Nielsen
"Sushi in Idaho. I know it sounds a little weird, eating raw fish in "no-where" Idaho. But this place can be surprising. Much higher quality sushi..."
Anton Chigurh
"The teriyaki chicken is so so goooood!! Loved the flavors of the chicken as well as the sauce!!! (I had it taken out once and the fries was soft,..."
Charise Chua
"Seriously so good here! We don't eat sushi hardly ever but we were in the mood for something different and it did not disappoint!
Our favorites were..."
Jared Hawkes
"I rarely ever give 5 stars. Maybe 5% or less of the time. This place is five stars. I didn't expect much from any restaurant way out in the country..."
David Valderrama (Early Christian Life)
"Great food, great service, great ambiance. You will feel like you're in Hawaii! Definitely try their specialty drinks and their Mango Guava..."
Meghan L Hunt Nelson
"After moving from Texas I have been in utter despair over the lack of quality food present in rexburg Idaho, thankfully after months of searching I..."
Laura Campas
"I wish my stomach was bigger!! This is some of the best sushi I have had. I’m actually taking it home and I don’t usually do leftovers. Our..."
Brynn Blevins
"I haven’t tried much aside from the sushi, but I think it’s the BEST in Rexburg! The fried sushi is the bomb! Landon was a great waiter..."
Celeste Popoca
"Really good food! The portions were really big and it is worth the price! I would definitely be back here! Make sure to order their chicken..."
"Late lunch and they weren't crowded at all, service was friendly and the food was pretty fast. I tried the French Onion soup and it was not to my..."
Melanie KRD
"Great Applebee's and servers. Very nice and attentive. Good experience and good food. Would come..."
Logan Flynn
"Went with my husband around 10pm to have late dinner , had the Southwest chicken 🐔 bowl and it was very filling and yummy. I couldn’t finished..."
Sethrina Ng
"If you're looking for a nice, sit-down meal but don't want to spend a lot of money, Applebee's is a great option. The portions are medium sized but..."
"I’m going to be honest and say skip the steak on this one and just get the pizza instead. The restaurant is clean and has a very attentive staff...."
maryroselol
"Great food, amazing lemonade!
Glad to see a gluten free crust on the menu! It was a little doughy, but loved the fresh jalapeños on my spicy..."
Alicia Mackno
"Great place with great service. This is probably one of the better sit down restaurants I’ve eaten at in rexburg. The food tasted delicious and..."
Kayden Lamb
"I have been to Frescos many times now with the wife and we have had a good experience every time. We normally order a pizza each and half and half..."
Marcus Helgesen
"Fresco is a very good spot in Rexburg with some good food. It would be great if they had the full liquor license for the bar because the canned..."
Bobbie Loy
"Living here for 4 years but first time came here. Really nice restaurant and the food is really great. Both quantity and quality and decent. Not..."
Cheng En Yang
"This place was so accommodating with our large group after a graduation. The food was served quickly, even though we came in late. The servers were..."
Susan Young
"Delicious strawberry beet salad and margherita pizza. Classy environment and lots of big..."
"I never thought I'd say this about fast food but man is arbys GOOD! It was my first time going to an Arby's and i got the beef n cheddar sandwich,..."
melissa baggett
"This place has some great food! They really stack on the meat for their sandwiches, and the happy hour sliders are great! I do wish they still had..."
Sam McHan
"Updated review: I’ve been the Arby’s twice since the past review and have been very pleased with the customer service. I came in one time for a..."
Miriam Butts
"The staff was amazing and the food was delicious. This is definitely one of the better..."
"*The service is great and the food is hot, but the attitude/management could be better.*
For over a year I've been visiting this BK for a quick meal..."
Matthew Sailors
"Today I ordered in the drive thru before I realized I didn't have my wallet with me. My order was $10 the manager was going to give me my order..."
Blake and Sarah Galbraith
"It's just your regular average Burger king. I've been here about a dozen times or so and never had any..."
"As a chain I enjoy these resturaunts, especially with their range of menu items. I once ordered shakes from most of the fast food places and Jack's..."
GetReadyGo
"I have a lot of children.. Yesterday my husband and son in law and all my children went to your store to get something to eat. The employee that took..."
Kristyn vandyke
"Food came out pretty quick and was hot. Tasted great! Prices are a little higher than I like, but what can you do when your out of town needing to..."
Brandon Garner
"Second time in my 31 year existence I’ve had Jack-In-The-Box. No complaints from me... staff was friendly & the food was..."
"The general manager is so personable!!! He recognizes my husband each time he comes in because he also works in the fast food industry. The food here..."
Megan Gamber
"Overall nice experience! The scoops of sour cream and guacamole were a little on the small side especially since their guacamole is chunky which I..."
Kameron Nicole
"I love this location. The food is always great and the employees are amazing. To address the concerns of the people below me though, they probably..."
Mike P
"Went in recently and had a great experience. Food was bomb and they got it out super quick. They happened to get my quesadilla order wrong (I totally..."
"I purchased the Crisp Meat Burritos, 4 for $8.99. It was a lot of food, I couldn’t even finish all 4 of them. They are large and are full of..."
Ben M
"Always great service, fresh ingredients, good portion sizes and friendly staff. I don't like the new menu boards as they offer a complete list of..."
Diane Perry
"Actually decent food. The prices are reasonable and the food is filling. The burritos don't taste all that impressive till you use some of their..."
Dick Grayson
"This place operates with military precision. I waited inside for my food during a busy rush so for about 5-6 minutes I watched the employees fill..."
Todd Beck
"great restaurant. they really care about their customers, and want to do the job right. They have many secret old menu items that are unavailable..."
Bryan Seare
"You've got to love the rolled bean burrito and cherry empanada. For a quick bite to eat, this is definitely an option. Bonus: these are simple to eat..."
Ryan Smith
"I've been coming here more than 10 years and have never been disappointed. The staff are wonderfully friendly and the food is always fresh and fast...."
"First time here tonight and it did not disappoint!! I originally wanted the cheese steak sandwich but they ran out so I got a brisket one instead...."
Ilaisaane Takai
"What a transcendent experience. YES, this is a Gas Station.YES, it is called “blisters”. YES, it is right off the freeway. YES, there is no sign..."
Chad Fredman
"This place is unassuming as it shares space with a gas station convenience store, however, it serves really good BBQ as evidenced by its popularity...."
Kalvan H
"Everyone was raving about this place and how good the food is, I order a 3 meat plate and a Buffalo chicken sandwich. The meet plate and frys were..."
john preston
"YES! I love this place. Our FHE group went and filled up the room on a Monday night and they pumped out all of our food really quickly. The Cuban was..."
Julia Farr
"I have eaten here several times now and it does not disappoint. Tonight I had the turkey and tri-tip. Both were juicy with amazing flavor. To top it..."
"The milkshake here is AMAZING!!! I love the flavors of the strawberries!!! It’s my Number 1 place to get drinks now.
The pistachio ice cream is..."
Charise Chua
"Nice little restaraunt with two of my favorite foods, sandwiches and fro-yo. Place was clean and the army of staff kept things moving at a fast pace...."
Joey Charboneau
"This is the best sandwich restaurant that I've been to in town! I stop by every couple of weeks to grab a sandwich for me and a coworker. They..."
Matt Huber
"Best sandwich in town! Such a great environment inside and outside. If they make a mistake, they correct it immediately. It's a bit pricey, but..."
Joey B
"Good food, great service, it was a fun stop for a crew of us. I wasn’t that excited about the sandwich, but honestly it could have been my..."
Marsha Keller
"Millhollow is the best sandwich shop this side of the Snake River. This is where I took my wife on our first date. I’ve probably eaten over 30..."
Keaton Ballard
"I always get a turkey blt on sourdough with a vanilla frozen yogurt and cookie dough on top. I have gotten this combo for about four years now. Yup...."
"Made my food quickly and didn't mess anything up at all. Sandwich was high quality and workers were friendly. Good customer service. This location..."
Rachel Lau
"I always love Jimmy John's. Great quality, super fresh, always tasty not to mention how freaky fast they are ;)
They have a lot of add-ons that are..."
sammi estrada
"Always yummy sandwiches. They accidentally got part of our order incorrect, but were very gracious in making us some new sandwiches that corrected..."
"The pies here are amazing. The food is exactly what you expect from a hometown resturant. It's all very good and great prices. The chilli is a hit..."
Jacob Wells
"Chicken Hawaiian w/ teriyaki sauce on side
Vegetables
Mashed potatoes w/ gravy on side
Corn bread (not in photo; served ahead which was great because..."
Y G
"Great quality meals with generous portions! Our server, Amanda, was courteous, knowledgeable, sweet, and quick. I highly recommend Frontier..."
Lillian Egan
"Great, fast service and the waitress was pleasant and helpful. I got the breakfast country fried steak and not only was it wonderful, but it was as..."
Michael Fay
"The taste of the food was great, the freshness not so much. I don't think they are busy enough to keep it fresh. I ordered chicken pot pie, like I..."
Mary Fernelius
"I went here while I was traveling. I got the Quiche Lorraine, and the strawberry Rhubarb pie. It was pretty basic just your everyday town Diner. It..."
Aaron Mac
"I love the decorations and the feel of home and getting a home cooked meal! The food is pretty good and the cornbread they provide with each meal is..."
Ariel Beals
"The food came out very quickly and was pretty good but not great. The service was good. Overall good..."
"I feel like all chain restaurants let me down eventually. Once that happens, the only thing that brings me back is if someone I want to eat with..."
Chris Smith
"Normally this place is super good but for some reason today, I picked up my online order and I had a different experience. My tortilla shell is..."
Mady Cavaness
"Been here a few times with friends. Honestly no complaints! The restaurant feels authentic and has that similar vibe with all of the other Cafe Rio..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes