The best Restaurants in Selden ranking of January 2025
95 restaurant menus in Selden, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"Really excited for Riley Fibbers! I love the location as it’s one of the few spots in the area, the food was delicious and the atmosphere is great!..."
Marlene is Key
"Great experience the first time at Riley Fibbers. Had the French onion soup special and Philly cheesesteak sandwich. Both were very flavorful! Nice..."
Bryan Coon
"Good drinks. Amazing food. Went last week, we had pretzels and the french dip. Came back today for more. The service is great, especially Terrence..."
Debra S
"Great spot. Stumbled upon it and have gone two days in a row despite being out of town. Still haven't had it all. Will come back to try some more...."
William Reyes
"Tried the new Riley Fibbers last night and it did not disappoint. Our waitress, Kailee, was attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable. The owner was..."
Vanessa L
"We had such a great time at our Christmas Party! Great food drinks and..."
Fedora Lounge Salon
"Love this place!!! I used to drive to the one in East Islip for the wings, now there's one right in my neighborhood. Woo hoo! Best wings around!!!..."
Heather Clark
"My wife and I lived in Oakdale from 2015-2021. Riley fibbers in East Islip was our go to place for wings, burgers, sandwiches, apps, pretty much..."
JFK35 517
"We went there to check out the new bar. Food was good, but my wife's dish came out 10 minutes before mine. Ordered rye bread but got a roll after..."
Dave Meyers
"Best staff! Best food!
Favorite days are Thursday and Saturday, the bartender Jen is beautiful and sweet and will keep a smile on your face all..."
ClassicComedy
"Highly recommend the the Dip Burger. Been there three times. And each time the food has been..."
Kevin Krauth
"Great fresh tasty food! My family loves the steak sandwich. The waitress Kylee is so sweet and..."
Chris Carballo
"New owners completely redid this neighborhood pub.....great food and service....we shared some killer sliders as an app....my buds devoured their..."
Brian Kearns
"Place looks great. Clean and renovated. Food was great. Kailee our serve was attentive and great. Totally recommend Nice to finally have a nice..."
Patty C
"Food was amazing would go again it was just really cold and the food took some time to come..."
Jordan Agostino
"Great food and easy to order as well. Would recommend to..."
"Fun place with good food. Great to hang out in on a Saturday night with my pretty..."
Coozane
"Great meals and good prices. Try the steaks and..."
Joe
"Wow, that's good.. I stopped in kinda spur of the moment and strolled up to the bar to be greeted promptly, served upon happily, and offered GREAT..."
Doug
"good place. We have our annual Christmas party there and have never been..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes