"The Chocolate Coffee cake is to die for. I have made the trip from Coram to get just that half a dozen times. The Jelly Donut is also..."
custom eyes
"I love this bakery... always a delight. Cinnamon cake donuts crispy even when you buy them at 2:00, my favorite are the raspberry filled butter..."
grace park
"One of the last authentic hometown bakeries.
From basic breads and cookies to display worthy cakes you get fresh homemade deliciousness.
For out of..."
David Toomey
"Better than Alpine so don't waste your time on lines there, come here! It's a non-popular place but they have the best cookies and pastries! The..."
Grace Muller
"Absolutely incredible - I connect most with bakeries that can seamlessly blend a homey comfort with tasty, professional baked goods. You will..."
Christina Ventura
"One of the few great, traditional bakeries..."
Leila McGrath
"Do any Italian bakeries make Italian bread anymore? I've been looking for prosciutto & Foccaci breads? Or even Semolina !! That's why I Loved Authur..."
Robert Torres
"I can’t believe I only discovered this place for the first time today …. This is a top-notch bakery with excellent customer service. I will most..."
Chris Cirillo
"St. James couldn't ask for a better bakery. Everything is always fresh, delicious and the staff goes above and beyond. The owners appreciate the..."
Celina Murphy
"Love this place, we had Mike do our wedding cake for our opulent wedding and it was BEYOND our expectations!! Beautiful four tier buttercream cake..."
Beth Taylor
"Fantastic family run bakery. The pies are exceptional. You can order any pie with a lattice top if you give them a day notice. I did and what a pie!..."
Kym Mirabella
"I ordered a last minute sugar free cherry pie. They were able to make it on a nights notice. It was incredibly delicious and fresh! Thanks..."
elena rodriguez
"Rainbow cookies to die for. Never had store bought this good. Mini pastries were also TERRIFIC. Little pricey, but what isn't anymore. Worth the..."
Valerie Radocy
"Always friendly service. Amazing and always delicious baked goods. Definitely one of the best tradtiional Italian bakeries on Long..."
Philip Armand
"Lived in Nissequogue for years, and remember when Garguilo’s first opened. Finally an old time Bakery in town.
Now I’m retired in Loveland..."
Bob Massaro
"Staff are super nice and helped me find some cookies I could eat that didn't have any ingredients I'm allergic to. Huge selection. Highly..."
Rebecca Leah
"Whatever they bake is great. I always have their egg rolls. They serve coffee as well. There are two or three table to sit; it's a plus for a walk-in..."
Abdullah Basaran
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes