18 restaurant menus in %{citta}, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
The best Restaurants in St James ranking of December 2024
18 restaurant menus in St James, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Roasted Beets with Baby Arugula Pickled Cherries Toasted Almonds & Blue Cheese
Black Spaghetti with Calamari
Meatballs Braised in Tomato over Polenta
Table Service
BYOB
Reservations
Seating
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Amazingggggg!! Best polenta on the planet. Highly recommend this restaurant. You need a reservation and it's very tiny but you will not be..."
Leah Marie
"My favorite place to eat. Prix fixe makes great tasting food with fresh ingredients affordable. Country Italian with a contemporary touch always..."
Hohjudy
"Best kept BYOB secret. Unexpectedly remarkable food. This place will inspire even the most sophisticated of palettes, and leaves mouths watering for..."
ShutupandEAT
"The preparations are simple, focused, authentic, flavorful, and on-point American interpretations of Italy's best soul..."
WineZag
"This place is a hidden gem. Small seating capacity without feeling tight. Call for a reservation. The food and service are excellent. Our server last..."
Alex Stubberfield
"One of Suffolk County’s best! Small, intimate space pushing out BIG flavor! Menu consists of regular staples like bucatini carbonara and eggplant..."
Matt Mantone
"secret gem..... love this place! food always fresh and delicious! Chef comes out and checks on the tables love hows its an open kitchen..."
Jackie Bon
"Plain and simple, one of the best restaurants on Long Island. Chef Stephen and the staff are incredibly kind and welcoming. Anything made in that..."
Chris Montalbano
"Don't even know where to begin how wonderful this place is. Between the food, service, and intimate atmosphere, this restaurant is fantastic! You..."
Edward Hartung
"Intimate atmosphere. Server was really nice and the chef too. Great food (especially seafood & pasta). Definitely want to come..."
Dayoung Gong
"Great price fixe menu, lots of choices. Cash only and BYOB (no charge). Huge portions and some of the best Italian food I have ever had. The place is..."
Elizabeth Turk
"This was first dining experience at The Trattoria and it won't be my last! The food and service were both excellent. However, what stood out for me..."
Stella Heun
"It took a long time to get a reservation , but in the end it was worth it. Very good food tasty and cooked well we were 2 couples and we all liked..."
Gappsi Giuseppe Abbrancati
"Absolutely love coming here. The meal was cooked to perfection and everything is like an amazing flavor explosion!!! Our waitress Jenny was amazing...."
"Veal Chop Parm was of Orangutan proportion!
Excellent, I brought home another meal basically. Pietro is very accommodating.
Haven’t been here since..."
EXP Smith
"We sat outside in the garden, which was really nice. The food, drinks, and service were all top-notch. The grilled octopus and mussels were amazing,..."
PJB
"This is a Beautiful Place Inside and Outside.
Will be Open in November 16
For Dinner Only.
Amazing Food. You Gonna Love it.
Very Professional..."
Noe Sura
"The perfect place if you want delicious, authentic Italian food. The service was incredible, from the moment we arrived. We sat outside, and the area..."
Cindy Romero
"This restaurant consistently delivers on every level! Meeting the owner every time at the door to be shown your table with a welcoming smile is..."
Jim D
"Absolutely amazing food, drinks, and service! Your best bet is to make a reservation as tables go quick. The place can be a tight squeeze, but it is..."
James Carr
"It was busy but the service was spot on, no issues. The food food was good but overwhelming great. The roasted potatoes were delicious. The lemon..."
Anthony DeBiase
"We initially had reservations elsewhere for a special occasion, but that place seated us in an outdoor seating enclosure that was ice cold. Pietro..."
Christopher Bowen
"Always a great meal. I can never decide what I want because everything on the menu is great . I usually get the octopus for an app for myself and a..."
Scott Birke
"The patio and service were great. The Buratta and lamb pasta was fantastic but the rice balls were just..."
Kelly Pereyra
"Surprise destination for Valentines Day dinner! This was out first time and will not be our last! Food was exceptional! The owner is amazingly hands..."
Jenn Ciralli
"Pietro has a nice quaint atmosphere, not too fancy. It is separated into different rooms. There is also an outside bar and seating area with a fire..."
John Amato
"We took the outdoor dining. Love sunshine and the taste for the appetizer. My friend ordered pork chop, it is great. I ordered swordfish but the..."
Yimin Zhu
"The food is amazing .. authentic feel. The service was a little slow . The staff loves to talk to people and make it a personal experience but it..."
Sal Verdi
"The food is outstanding! The atmosphere is outstanding! The only issue I had was you must order all your food at once. I love to start with a..."
Lisa young
"This restaurant was so authentic and delicious. The atmosphere was chic. I absolutely loved the our evening here so much. An excellent dining..."
Dani DeLongis
"We had an amazing meal this past weekend at Pietros! Every single dish was cooked perfectly and plated beautifully. With each course we couldn’t..."
Kris NYC - Viera - Spacecoast
"Pietro and his amazing staff hosted our son's communion this past weekend. Upon booking, Pietro sat with me and planned out a beautiful menu, no..."
"I've been wanting to go here since moving to St James and finally got the chance. Very nice interior and the menu is kind of like a large portion..."
Paul K McGinniss
"We loved that the menu changes every Wednesday with inventive items added and some old favorite retained. The Sea Bass Tacos and Lemon Toast were..."
Janice F
"The food was good! The four of us shared seven different dishes. Everything was delicious! We brought the leftovers home:) yummy! Played trivia..."
holly murtha
"Food was good. Service was friendly but we had a conversation about food allergies and the chef didn't listen to our concerns and one of our party..."
Anthony Tassone
"Got to visit Husk and vine 2x last week. Once for their incredible Happy Hour and once for a private party in their back room. Both times I..."
Jason Nabel
"Great apps. Good drinks. Burger was a disappointment especially for $27. Wagyu meatballs were good. Fried chicken biscuit gravy sliders were great...."
John Halter
"I've been wanting to try them for a while. They have so many specials during the week and the food looks amazing. Finally made it there. It was..."
Sunita Sukhu
"Definitely one of the best places to dine in the area. My wife and I have been coming here since they first opened and they never dissappoint. ..."
Patrick A
"Busy restaurant with a huge bar, parking can be a problem.
However, the food is fantastic. The menu has something amazing for everyone and..."
JV Young
"This place rules. It's tough to say whether the atmosphere or the food is better because they're both incredible. It's the perfect place for dinner..."
Matt Lindsay
"Quality food and drinks!
Everything we ordered was delicious, surprising flavors and textures. Tried pear cider here for the first time and it was..."
Ani
"I would give Husk and Vine Restaurant 5 Stars as well, but this review is for Husk & Vine Catering & Events at Blueblinds Mansion.
I can not say..."
Francine Ingoglia
"Went out to Nesconset to visit a friend and we started looking for places to eat. Was looking for small plates or shareable items. Found tgis place..."
Claudio Woolley
"Burnt Brussels and cauliflower steak were amazing. Staff was super nice.
Wings! Wings! Wings! Perfectly fire roasted wings! A great kick of spice..."
Kristen Slevin
"Been here a couple of times and it is now my favorite place in the area. Large drink selection, great food, even better service.
Don’t forget to..."
Amir Rahmati
"Their drinks are delicious and the food is even better! I love that they have alot of "small plates" so you can order a bunch of different things. We..."
Jennifer O'Keefe
"Went in here for a quick bite and ended up with an amazing experience. Our server Angelina was amazing and explained that most menu items come as..."
Christopher “Superman” Saldana
"Always looking forward to enjoying their weekly rotating menu. Their Seasonal Cocktails are always a..."
"A total hidden gem!
Have been coming here for quite some time and they never miss. The food, the ambiance, every single detail is perfection! Ray and..."
Alyson Fitzpatrick
"Service: very friendly, social, and attentive.
Atmosphere: small dining room with visible kitchen. Classic drawings on wall, cozy. Amazing patio out..."
Kevin Tower
"Just to say... BABABOOM place ! The ambient is awesome. The service is excellent always attended to our table with a beautiful smile! Her name, I..."
Lulu Bundra
"This was my first time here. I absolutely love it. The staff an owner are amazing. The food is fresh is fresh could be I love the fact that you can..."
Sarah
"Amazing little cute restaurant with delicious food. They only have a few tables so definitely make your reservations beforehand. We paid about $50..."
Fangzhi Z.
"A great restaurant with amazing food, great atmosphere and attentive wait staff. We have eaten there numerous times and every dish was always..."
Vinnie Linarello
"Great food .Gluten free options. No alcohol, You can bring your own wine. They have a New England clam chowder that's pretty good.
Try the pear and..."
john Schmaeling
"I had my daughter’s bridal shower at Basil. The outdoor deck was the perfect venue. People raved about the food and the service was excellent.
Chef..."
Mary Ann Chidichimo
"Lovely restaurant at Saint James main Street with backyard garden for outdoor dining.
Recommendation: watermelon salad, honey
Food: Their..."
Yimin Zhu
"Pictured is the Caesar salad, Soltani and apple blossom. All 3 delicious, excellent food presentation. I've had my fair share of Persian food and..."
"My wife and I had dinner last night at NOCO in St James. I had dined there previously for a work event but this was her first visit.
We started at..."
Alan Devries
"We went to NOCO for our first time for our wedding anniversary dinner. I highly recommend this restaurant. The unique menu and food served are..."
Lo
"I like the decor and delicacy of the food. I like the oyster which is quite delicious. You should try them raw with no sauce and then with lemon. The..."
Ke Hu (Kevin)
"We went here for my mom's birthday dinner and it was phenomenal. Expect to pay top dollar, but it is actually worth it. I have never had roast..."
Amanda Morris
"We had an assortment of delicious and fresh appetizers: clams, oysters, octopus, shrimp, some raw, and others cooked with innovative imagination. Our..."
Georgia Poulianos
"Unbelievable experience for dinner yesterday. First of all, the atmosphere was terrific and the restaurant was beautiful on the inside. For appetizer..."
greg sanderson
"Had a wonderful Friday (2/18) night dinner at NOCO. Service was stellar - shout-out Liv - for taking care of my little girl's needs! The food here is..."
Trav Ramkissoon
"We tried Noco on a whim, and we couldn’t be more pleased! From the service (our waitress was Kala) and the food… we were thrilled. I ordered..."
Elda Semitekolos
"Recently had a meal here for my grandmother’s 90th birthday. All of us enjoyed our appetizers meals and desserts. The mussels & shrimp appetizer..."
Alicia Stevens
"Went to noco with my husband last night to kick off the labor day weekend! We ordered several small plates...they were all delicious! Service was..."
Nicholas Theodosiou
"Great experience. Came here on a tuesday night with a reservation for 6. Service was nice and also quick!! Finished dinner by 7:15. It wasn't very..."
Lisa Lam
"Gott he filet, perfectly cooked medium rare the way I ordered. Apps and side also top notch. It was the 1st time I was there and definitely will be..."
frank saracino
"Went for restaurant week and it was a great meal. Shared the apps (not shown-mussels, potato & crab croquettes) and desserts (pictured)-pistachio..."
Blanca
"We went there last night with my husband for my birthday🌸 we love the service and food, especially duck, it was phenomenal! ❤️🔥 Thank..."
Ezgi Dereli
"Great evening with friends. Caesar took good care of us. Drinks were top notch and everything we ate was..."
David Singer
"Best restaurant in Saint James! Make a reservation as it is often booked. Casual but professional service makes for a relaxing experience. Great..."
Nadine Wilches
"We went during restaurant week. So many great options to choose from! Each course was delicious! Service was just as great. Rosie was really sweet..."
Candi Walls
"Dinner for 2 couples with apps and drinks was 397 dollars. Food quality justified the price, service too. I had the lamb and it was cooked..."
"The Chocolate Coffee cake is to die for. I have made the trip from Coram to get just that half a dozen times. The Jelly Donut is also..."
custom eyes
"I love this bakery... always a delight. Cinnamon cake donuts crispy even when you buy them at 2:00, my favorite are the raspberry filled butter..."
grace park
"One of the last authentic hometown bakeries.
From basic breads and cookies to display worthy cakes you get fresh homemade deliciousness.
For out of..."
David Toomey
"Better than Alpine so don't waste your time on lines there, come here! It's a non-popular place but they have the best cookies and pastries! The..."
Grace Muller
"Absolutely incredible - I connect most with bakeries that can seamlessly blend a homey comfort with tasty, professional baked goods. You will..."
Christina Ventura
"One of the few great, traditional bakeries..."
Leila McGrath
"Do any Italian bakeries make Italian bread anymore? I've been looking for prosciutto & Foccaci breads? Or even Semolina !! That's why I Loved Authur..."
Robert Torres
"I can’t believe I only discovered this place for the first time today …. This is a top-notch bakery with excellent customer service. I will most..."
Chris Cirillo
"St. James couldn't ask for a better bakery. Everything is always fresh, delicious and the staff goes above and beyond. The owners appreciate the..."
Celina Murphy
"Love this place, we had Mike do our wedding cake for our opulent wedding and it was BEYOND our expectations!! Beautiful four tier buttercream cake..."
Beth Taylor
"Fantastic family run bakery. The pies are exceptional. You can order any pie with a lattice top if you give them a day notice. I did and what a pie!..."
Kym Mirabella
"I ordered a last minute sugar free cherry pie. They were able to make it on a nights notice. It was incredibly delicious and fresh! Thanks..."
elena rodriguez
"Rainbow cookies to die for. Never had store bought this good. Mini pastries were also TERRIFIC. Little pricey, but what isn't anymore. Worth the..."
Valerie Radocy
"Always friendly service. Amazing and always delicious baked goods. Definitely one of the best tradtiional Italian bakeries on Long..."
Philip Armand
"Lived in Nissequogue for years, and remember when Garguilo’s first opened. Finally an old time Bakery in town.
Now I’m retired in Loveland..."
Bob Massaro
"Staff are super nice and helped me find some cookies I could eat that didn't have any ingredients I'm allergic to. Huge selection. Highly..."
Rebecca Leah
"Whatever they bake is great. I always have their egg rolls. They serve coffee as well. There are two or three table to sit; it's a plus for a walk-in..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes