Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Staten Island
100 restaurant menus in Staten Island, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
"Pretty good soup didn't have pizza though the owner was ..."
mister G
"I’ve ordered from here on 3 separate occasions and every time the food was excellent. I’m especially a fan of the grilled chicken. It’s fresh..."
alex grushko
"Was there Sunday night and the food was terrific. The margarita slice was delicious and oh man those cheese steak enrolls. Not to mention the mac and..."
Itz “Jenn” _Jenny the fnaf lover
"The best Grandma pizza on the island ! Excellent Customer Service . Highly..."
Tonianne Avolio
"Came to eat here after a paintball session with my family, looked for a quick bite before heading back home and we are glad we did. The food was..."
Stephanie Gomez
"Great pizza , Awesome sandwiches. Best in Staten Island . Had a little issue with a few missing wings but the owner replaced it with a cheesesteak..."
Robert Garofalo
"Amazing pizza. Always on time and the best customer service. I honestly think this is the best pizzeria on Staten Island. I will never order from..."
"If you want some of the best pizza you will ever eat in your life then this is the place to go! The chicken parm is amazing and I suggest you order..."
Joseph Faiella
"First visit to Paulie's we ordered two pies for pickup. First one a Margarita pie that was outstanding and second pie was a calamari pie that was..."
Private D
"If you enjoy thin crust, then this your place! Love the pizza,especially the vodka pie! My favorite! I also like to frequent their next door..."
Steveo Roy
"I've have now ordered from them a couple of times and seen much improvement in their home delivery. My girl, my brother, and myself all agree that..."
Phil Sentry
"Great regular pizza, prompt delivery. But their Sicilian pizza stinks. It's either burnt or way under cooked on the crust. And I ordered it more than..."
Jimmy Mango
"Went to a party there and had a variety of dishes. There wasn't anything that I didn't love!
A variety of pasta which were all deliciously seasoned...."
Jeanne Savarese
"I'm gonna start by saying kudos to Paulie, nothing greater than seeing a young professional create a great place to eat!! Paulie's has two entrances,..."
"This place has outstanding pizza with a wide variety of specialty types. We had a sampling of the slices and we recommend the Big Boy Mac pizza,..."
Suzanne Alexandra Ascher
"Delicious Pizza. We really like the taste and the size was huge. Definitely if we come back for vacations we won't miss to visit this..."
Haydee Romani Ramos
"Have to say, I had not had anything from here I didn't like. Vodka sauce is delicious, pizza's are great and food is delicious! Way to go..."
CarlaAnn Volpe
"Calamari squared was amazing! Ordered for the first time tonight and I think we've found our new pizza..."
Maria Vicinanza
"I'm there 1-2 times a week food is great � never had anything that I didn't..."
Anthony Colon
"Amazing service, food was a hit straight out the park, new guys in town, they have a bright future ahead of them. Keep it up guys! Will definitely be..."
Novenia Sohail
"The people are so super nice, especially the cashier girl with dark hair. The even customized a weird order for my keto diet. The food is AWESOME..."
Deena Ann
"This pizza place was awesome!!! We passed by before heading to the beach and this pizza place came up the closest. The staff were nice and the foods..."
Rm Diwa
"Best pizza on Staten Island. No joke. It’s so embarrassing of me for not visiting this joint sooner. Amazing customer experience and most..."
The Cryptotainer
"This pizza shop is so good. They have different varieties of pizza and everything tastes so fresh. I've eaten a little bit of everything off of the..."
J Gee
"This place is amazing the food is incredible the people make you feel like family and the prices are almost unreal if you have not tried it please..."
"We were searching for great pizza in Staten Island and we found it!! Delicious!! Even though we unknowingly stopped in shortly before closing the..."
Whitney Shupe
"Food and service is outstanding. Recently catered a party for my office and the guests couldn’t stop raving about the food.
Thanks again!
Hometime..."
Lauren Goldstein
"They make everything fresh!!! Everything I have ordered from here is always delicious no complaints. I have had the pene vodka with chicken, the..."
Adelaide Adames
"Excellent pie! Sauce is really good. Their vodka pie with chicken cutlet is the best I’ve..."
Michael Palmieri
"Our friend recommended Paesano's for a family celebration and we had several trays of food catered. The food arrived on time as promised and piping..."
Jean Antoniazzi
"They are a bunch of good guys who are professional and really nice. As a regular their prices are good and I personally like their rolls as others I..."
Jonathan Mercado
"We have been regulars, going to Paesanos for years and especially love their grandma pie. We like this pie done a specific way and the owners, real..."
Jarne C
"My family loves the Buffalo pizza and the White pies with spinach they are the BEST pies on Staten Island. Everyone should try them. My family is..."
"Great NYC style Sicilian pie.
Bright, clean sauce. A little on the wet side. Crust was plain. Slices are limp, need both hands. Have some napkins..."
Pete Breza
"We are moving to Florida and wanted to get some good NY pizza before we go and my boyfriend found this place he grabbed a quick slice and came home..."
Nancy Fasolino
"Tiny, but amazing pizzeria/restaurant. Our first time eating here and Justine’s service was phenomenal. She was very polite, professional and..."
Ye Aung
"Excellent Pizza. We have ordered a bunch of times and just the other day we ordered the family special. Great deal, the definitely don't skimp and..."
Michael G
"We went to a Communion party there and the atmosphere was great, staff was on top of everything and the FOOD WAS AMAZING! Delicious food and great..."
Lisa Ratner
"I placed an order last week at your Annandale location with Taylor Smith and she was FANTASTIC!!! she took her time, repeated the order back to me..."
"The workers were so friendly from the get go no sour pusses here,food was amazing,the owner came over with shots on the house and a nutella pie that..."
Mary Jo Reynolds Penkower
"My first time here was for lunch with my best friend and her son. The food was amazing, the freshness and quality was excellent and so delicious! ..."
Danielle Bartow-Demarest
"I threw my daughters graduation party here yesterday. A little pricey, but well worth it. The food was delicious, the service was outstanding. We..."
Karen Anne
"The place is a gold mine!!! We had reservations on a Saturday night and still had to wait about 40 minutes for a table! That has to tell you..."
Tonya Lisa Reyes
"This is one of the best restaurants I’ve ever been to...the food is second to none and the staff are extremely courteous and friendly. We were a..."
Brad Kubis
"My family and I absolutely love Patrizia's! The food is outrageous the atmosphere is outrageous , the staff is professional and courteous! Giacomo..."
John Brullo
"It’s a mini Italian vacation. Every waiter is from Italy. Every waiter speaks Italian. They are too happy to share Italy with you. Love..."
Susan Conlon
"Always an excellent experience! The service was great our waiter was very attentive and we wanted for nothing!! food was delicious..can’t wait to..."
Julie Kraftsman
"Very friendly staff, you can’t beat the food and of course his delicious..."
"A new favorite spot for me, super under rated place. Excellent vodka sauce I get the grandpa pie aka "old school" margarita Sicilian but with vodka..."
Beyond Honest
"Love this place. Made the mistake of trying a different pizzeria tonight due to seeing a hyped up FB post, well I will not make that mistake again...."
Leeann DeVito
"Great food,great staff i love it.
Domenicos pizzeria on Bay Terrace is my favorite pizzeria, i been ordering for a while from them and i allways will..."
Zek Zeka
"Very good pizza. My kids are picky about pizza. They always love it and Im ordering from here almost 3 times a week. They never..."
Christopher McGrath
"This place is great. Ive tried all the places in the area and I can comfortably say this is the best pizzaria in the area. Try our their buffalo..."
J Salerno
"Wonderful food, certainly more that just a pizzeria. Salads of all kinds and all dishes are generous servings. Guaranteed to enjoy the food and the..."
PeterJ Romano
"Really good food!!! The vodka slices and paninis are my..."
"This is the best pizzeria in new york city forget just staten island. The best service, the best prices, and the best taste! Just because they dont..."
Steven Thomas
"My family & I have been going to classic for as long as I can..."
Alex Mahoney
"By far my favorite pizzeria on Staten Island!!! The kitchen is awesome as..."
"Not far from the Staten Island Ferry! Great Pizza! Walk up the hill right past the Police Station und you ll find it on the left! 100% recommended by..."
Oli “OlidayTours” Grieb
"Actually, for $2, this is a pretty decent slice.
Decent size, generous cheese and sauce. Cheese well cooked.
Crust is chewy, crispy and very tasty...."
Gary Wilson
"My wife liked this pizza so much she bought slices to take back to..."
Craig Foster
"It's been 6 days of adventuring through Manhatten.. 6 days since we had A&S pizza and chicken Parm. Nothing in Manhattan even comes close. Every day..."
Tyfanie W
"Best pizza you can find in Staten Island. Incredibly fresh and flavorful pizza with a perfectly crunchy crust. I highly recommend the BBQ slices...."
Frankie Cos.
"This place is so good from the employees down to the delivery driver... They are so professional and the food is so good... when I say this place..."
Lakisha L.
"This might be the best pizza I've ever had the spinach and chicken pizza was delicious so was the Buffalo chicken pizza would recommend 10 out of..."
"The food here is amazing. You can never go wrong with anything at Village..."
Joby Kuriakose
"The best in Staten..."
VinjoSarah Dela Rosa
"Pizza one of the best in IS & Great Authentic Italian Food! I recommend this..."
Joe Ayala
"This people making delicious pizza. So many verities. I did oder half chicken and half calamari pie.It was delicious. Place is very clean. Very good..."
yakkhanadha
"Pretty good pizza, well priced, great window variety for specialty slices, a regular..."
IG_at onetwojongo
"The food is quality everything I have ordered from them is better then most restaurants. Once in a while it might not be what expected but..."
Jo Ann Silva
"I’m always searching for a new pizza place for delivery. Usually, the particular specials of a place, plus recommendations from friends, will draw..."
Jonathan Rossi
"Amazing food, customer service, and was very clean. This was my first time ordering, but definitely not my..."
Benjamin Kazani
"Nice friendly neighborhood pizzeria!! A superb Sicilian slice at this joint. I have yet to try another other of their offerings but that's only..."
"Awesome pizza!!! I used to get my pizza in Brooklyn, then we found Krispy Pizza - my girls won't eat anything else!!! Very nice owners and very..."
Dora Live Laugh Love
"Best pizza on Staten Island!! Excellent service!! Try the wraps and dinner specials!! The place is spotless and they even have outdoor..."
Gianvito Re
"Best Pizzeria In Staten Island , Thank you Brooklyn for setting up shop on the island.Ive been eating at Krispys for 27 years and could'nt be..."
Kurt Dunlap
"BUONISSIMA :) :p COMPLIMENTI :) A PRESTO NON VEDO L'ORA AMICO MIO :) TI RACCOMANDO IL CAFFE..."
Sonia Spiritolibero Vella
"Review update- from 3 star to 5. Food is delicious and every delivery has been on time. I’m happy they are doing..."
Omar Khan
"This is a good pizza. Small size but good amount of cheese and sauce for the money ($2.50). Good taste. Good crust composition as far as chewy /..."
Gary Wilson
"Great pizza! Crispy crust, thin slices, yummy and delicious. Very fresh. We are from Brooklyn and are hard to please when it comes to pizza. We love..."
Irene Limongelli-Rosiello
"John the owner is the real deal! had eggplant parm and it was the only eggplant parm that was made correctly, mariannas is the ONLY pizza place i..."
Halfbakedd69
"some of the very best pizza on staten island. i laugh at some of these reviews. i have been going there for years the new ownership is friendly..."
Anderson Greylock
"Stopped in to let my 6yr old use the bathroom and grab a quick order of garlic knots. Didn’t realize the credit card minimum was $10 and had no..."
Mike C
"Ordered via Uber eats and didn’t know what to expect but WOW the chicken parm and eggplant parm heros we ordered were soooo goood !!! Bread was..."
"Excellent food, excellent service! I would recommend this place to..."
Denise Melito Eaton
"Excellent love it there the food is delish..."
Josephine Ricci
"My husband And I went over the winter, Tina and Vinny sing on fridays, Food is good service is excellent, We enjoyed our meal and had great..."
Geri An Cosmo DiOrio
"Great pasta special on Tuesday. LOVE their bolognese! Staff is..."
Suzanne Pampinella-Morelli
"I have only been here once since I am not from the area but Fratelli Pizzeria was very good. I had a veal cutlet grinder and it was excellent. The..."
Brandon Stafford
"Fratelli's is outstanding! Both the food and service. The entrees are always fresh and delicious. I'm Like the old Al Deppes and Vals Pizza of the..."
John Esposito
"The pizza in this place is great. I have no idea what that guy is talking about. He must not know good pizza. Everyone is friendly and food is great...."
John Smith
"We order a pie to go all the time. The pizza is consistently good. The order is always ready when they say it'll be ready. We've had zero issues. ..."
"Well worth the 2.5 hour trip from East New York,..."
Daniel Alexander Alberty
"Best Sicilian Pizza on Staten Island. Try the..."
Sal Finocchiaro
"*****'s Great service,reliability & the best Sicilian pie!! Mangiare il loro quadrato o essere un..."
Michael Anthony
"As a Brooklynite finding a good pizzeria on the Island was challenging, to say the least, So glad we finally found Il Forno!!! The food is always..."
Joyann Marinelli
"Excellent place, nice staff,Amazing Owner,by far Best Pizzeria on the Island,make sure to try there Upside down pie(..."
Albert Casiano
"ordered a chicken Parm hero w garlic on the bread and extra cheese.
damn, it was good!! very friendly lady answered the phone, and was quite..."
Cat
"One of my favorite Pizzeria's in Staten Island. The only time in my life I can order a plain pie and not put any toppings. Delicious. Crust is..."
DRITA
"Best pizza on Staten Island, got to get the upside down pie, it’s 10x better than L&B in..."
Joseph Cassara
"The food and service are Excellent - whether it be pasta or pizza! This restaurant uses their own delivery people - they are timely, professional,..."
"This place is a gold mine for our stomachs! We order something new EVERYDAY for lunch and we're NEVER disappointed! We also order for dinner! YUM!..."
Stephanie Saunders Primavera
"Excelent food. Staff is very friendly owner is very nice. Real Italian food not like other pizzeria like vilmonte or crappy Rossville pizzeria or..."
Chris Primavera
"I have been using Mona Lisa for every personal catering party for over 5 years and also started using them for my school functions at Hungerford for..."
Angela Esposito
"I'm born and raised on Staten Island and Staten Island has always been known for their food and pizzia but Mona Lisa exceeded those expectations and..."
Joe Bernard
"I cater from Mona Lisa for all my family gatherings and big parties. most recently for a New Years party. The food is always great, always plenty for..."
Nat Tartamella
"Its the best pizza and food ever. We go a few times a week. See ya later. ..."
Josephine Moore
"Whatever you're in the mood for you will find it at Mona Lisa...never fails to amaze w such different and creative pies! Food is amazing too! Always..."
Nicole Tierney
"What can I say, it's the best. I love all of their pizza and their menu is excellent, just had there calamari pizza it was over the..."
John D. Russino
"The food, speaks for itself. The staff and the service are absolutely the..."
Douglas Spinosa
"It's the real deal. You can't find better pizza. ..."
Rudy Waldner
"un commento. su questo ristotante?non saprei cosa dire. visto che vivo in Italia . ma sarà sicuramente un bel posto. visto che lo frequenti. tu..."
Anna Adragna
"One of the BEST Pizza I have ever..."
Concetta Anna
"Just got our fresh mozzarella and pepperoni pies delivered and they were OUTSTANDING! The freshest ingredients and best flavor ever! Been a customer..."
Leeya C
"Honestly, I wasn’t able to tell the difference between pizza before I started eating here. The difference is it’s not just pizza, every single..."
Saruh
"People wandering aimlessly to find the perfect slice of pizza. Others around the store are blinded considering that this special joint is right under..."
John Gorski
"Solid pizza. Nice and garlicky and full of tomato..."
Josemon Raju
"I'm here to change my review my negative review to an EXTREMLY POSITIVE write up. Last week there was an error made on the pizzeria's behalf, but the..."
Frank Dinovic
"The absolute best veal marsala anywhere! So tender so delicious. The staff at Mona Lisa have mastered their craft. Having dinner? Mona Lisa. Having a..."
"Really nice restaurant. Never been here before I was a little skeptical because it's so called a pizzeria but I decided to give a try and I am so..."
Liz Aung
"Dimly-lit restaurant that's connected to a small pizzeria. I did not try the pizza, however the lobster bisque was phenomenal. The vodka sauce is..."
Ye Aung
"First time trying this place out and it was def worth it. The fiocchi and pear pasta with brown butter sauce and goat cheese was absolutely amazing...."
Jennifer
"Food was perfection. I love pier 76 so I knew I'd love Molo. I had the tortellini alfredo with broccoli and grilled chicken. It was cooked to..."
"Awesome pizza! From Detroit and this was the first New York pizza I had and is was..."
John Bon
"One of the best pizza in Staten Island they are different than anyone else you better try this and you find out..."
Atnan Lina Abdushi
"Amazing..."
Blerim Billy Marku
"Great pizza and decent priced! Got the white clam pizza.. love thr flaky crust and the white clam sauce was well made. Not as salty as others I..."
Allan Vinluan
"Tried the regular, margarita, and chicken roll.. Pizza is..meh, pretty good. Crust is definitely dry. Cheese tastes a little on the low quality..."
Nicholas Minutillo
"Delicious pizza fast delivery great service thank you Ti Amo team..."
Valmir Fishta
"Best pizza spot on Staten Island by far!! The food is excellent, The workers are amazing. Always polite and respectful and really make you feel like..."
ali dib
"We come to staten island from Florida for work once a month, the pizza here is amazing!!! I left the upper part if this review 2 years ago. We..."
"The place looks very cute, very clean can definitely use an air freshener in the bathroom but clean. The pizza was good bit spicy but I knew it will..."
Yanina Cher
"The best pizza place on Staten Island.It’s extremely clean,delicious pizza,very friendly employees and such a beautiful girls behind the counter.I..."
Rachael Sullivan
"Loved the pizza slices(had both the meat and veggie option) and the employees were great! Patient and courteous, very professional. Definitely..."
Eshan Mahale
"Love the selection of dishes here. The staff here also polite and the place is..."
Inga Russell
"I thought the pizza was pretty good friendly service and a Soda machine. Comfortable..."
"Great place with such a great variety of specialty slices!!!!!! Awesome and friendly staff as well!!!! ..."
Albert Rotunno
"Good food nice place what ever happened to that Gotti blue eyed hunk?? He was the..."
Sean Cordero
"Every time I'm in Staten Island it's a must to go eat..."
Jack Matoske
"Great..."
Anthony Pirulli
"Mostly good... lately the delivery guys been hard on the product. Still taste the same though. 😂 Really good sauce.. awesome crust. My go to..."
Jr C
"Excellent food! Great atmosphere and very friendly workers!!!! I love it! Thank..."
Alan M
"La Piazza is THE BEST! I’ve been coming here for years and loveeee it here — the pizza, rolls, the penne vodka (a must), salads.. the list goes..."
Brittany Lynn
"I absolutely love this place and have loved it since i first walked in years ago. Can't beat the lunch specials and their rolls are awesome. Haters..."
Amanda Cardona
"Went for lunch. Very affordable, very thin pizza. Crust wasn't soggy but wasn't crispy either. If I had not ordered pick up I suspect the crust would..."
JAI
"The food selection and price for lunch is..."
rob perez
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes