Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Staten Island
100 restaurant menus in Staten Island, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
"Ive been going here since i was a kid. Best pizza hands down. The Alla Vodka pizza, the calama, the baked clams, all to die..."
Chris Ayala
"AMAZING. Some of the best pizza I ever had. The vodka pizza is worth the trip itself. If you haven’t been here yet you are missing..."
Joseph Arancio
"As a pizza lover, bartender at Deninos, and a Staten Island Local, Goodfellas keeps up with the pack and is a hidden gem like most restaurants in the..."
Tyler Douglas
"This is my favorite pizza on the planet. I found the now closed Amboy rd location many years ago while living in Staten Island, and even though I've..."
Alex Pobuda
"I've had take out from here for the last 20 years and the food is excellent! As a change of pace my husband and I had dinner here last night for the..."
Betty Parrilla
"The food and service are excellent. We live in Brooklyn and go to eat at Goodfella’s when we are in Staten Island..."
Diana DiNatale-Sullivan
"Best pizza and vodka sauce chicken roll was delicious too !! I will be..."
Jo Sephine
"As always service is great. The people that work there are always friendly and courteous.And the food is always good and when you put that all..."
Charlie Benway
"Great service, fantastic food and a welcoming atmosphere. Worth the 2.5 hour drive from..."
Arnold Dennis
"The food was incredible and the service was wonderful. This was my first time here and I will definitely be back. Their fresh mozz pizza was..."
Arthur Cordero
"Fantastic pizza! Any of them! And their french fries are crinkle cut, crispy, and deeelish. Goodfella's definitely has me as a lifetime..."
Jessica Barberry
"Square pie was delicious and the hot antipasto hit the spot. Well worth the trip from..."
Pete Vaz
"Stopped by for some. Baked clams, fried calamari, and a vodka pie..."
Charlie Gentile
"Stacey our waitresses was amazing table of 7 took our order didn't write anything down everything was perfect, so attentive food was outstanding..."
Tacey Hinaman Cullen
"Good Night Caroline ! Our group visits the city a few times a year and always make our way there for the best pizza around !..."
Michael Morris
"Brought my 18m daughter...They’re good and patient with kids, unlike some restaurants. Of course, their food was..."
"Compared to other pizza in the bulls head area, this place takes the cake in regards to pizza quality. They have a great family dinner deal and their..."
Michael Bernstein
"Very good food and service.
We ordered food several times in addition to sitting there. The food was delicious and very fresh. The dishes are large..."
Ayellet Shalom
"Panini cheese steak with peppers, onions, mushroom awsomeeeeee!!!!!!. It was delicious the bread was so soft, fresh and good. I will be ordering from..."
lateesha mcleod
"Fast delivery. Good 🍕 ordered large with extra cheese. Good prices. Will definitely order from here again. Polite delivery..."
"We always make it a point to take the ferry across and visit Staten Island. This was such a great try today and away from the Manhattan tourists..."
Billy Diamond
"Lovely staff and beautiful food! Highly recommend a visit if your visiting staton island..."
Harry Webb
"Eggplant parm is by far the best in NYC! Crunchy and sauced perfectly... Our server Stephanie was absolutely delightful and wonderful! So happy this..."
Esther Lee
"Stumbled into this neat pizza place, it was awesome! Everything was delicious, and fresh. Waitress was very nice. Good prices..."
Rose Rincon Horn
"Wonderful place, friendly environment, and good food ,everything is good, partial to the Chicken Francais, and Filet stuffed with crabmeat , ..."
Ernest Demenna
"We went there for the first time a couple of weeks ago.... it was great! Today I was home with 2 boys looking for a decent delivery....and realized..."
Lisa Chernyak
"Absolutely great place! Thanks for your hospitality and the food was perfect! Great job, guys! Big hugs from the 4..."
Mirela Slowik
"Great small pizza joint! LOVED the Ricotta and Prosciutto..."
David McAtee
"We love Marie's Gourmet and are delighted to have Marie's 2 here now in downtown Staten Island. Great addition to the neighborhood. Excellent food,..."
Eileen Sullivan Christie
"I just went there for lunch, first time... The most amazing salmon bruschetta I've ever had!!! Yum!!! I would give 10 starts but option was only..."
Wioletta Milejska
"Marie's 2 is awesome! It has a beautiful and clean interior, great service, and delicious food. I especially love how accommodating they are to..."
Joanna Shaw
"Other than needing a larger bar area 😝
Everything is always amazing
Fresh, made to order-
Love you can order 1/2 orders of all pasta dishes
I am..."
Ryan Madigan
"A wonderful discovery on our adventure to Staten Island. Fun and..."
Nina Ford Rivera
"Awesome food at a great price. Very cool staff..."
"Some places specialize in 1-2 types of slice, but Justino's is a great all around pizza spot with a crisp crust on just about everything! We got..."
Ryan Fisk
"I’m a regular at this pizzeria, and they never disappoint! Their pizza is mouthwatering and their garlic knots are soooooooooo delicious!..."
Bobby Denton
"The slices are large and the crust is crispy. And there is a variety of toppings. You can't go..."
Desmond Chow
"After moving from bk to si two years ago, i was seriously missing bk style pizza and I swear this place has exactly that! I love their pizza because..."
michelle chmelev
"Service is great, but no A/C in the..."
Craig Lee
"The most delicious lasagna pizza ever! Love this..."
Jody W
"This is a great local pizzeria located at 89 Guyon Avenue on Staten Island. They make a great thin crust pizza that is always piping hot and fresh...."
"Some of the best pizza I've ever had in my life definitely the best on Staten..."
Donald Joseph Resse II
"The pizza was delicious and the plates were even better. The place was clean and not dinghy looking . And the guys behind the counter even..."
Joseph Messina
"Wow! Awesome food and great..."
Joe Fidurko
"The best pizza always fresh and staff is great. Always look forward to stop by for a slice or two or..."
John Roma
"Trucker from Ohio. Great service and great pizza from the Rossvillle location. Thanks..."
Matt Bowling
"The best..."
Manuel Escamilla Escamilla BaltaZar
"Delicious pizza and nice..."
Patty
"Have been ordering from here for the last 6 years, since we moved into the neighborhood. The food is always great. The owner and just all staff in..."
Dave Rivera
"I been ordering from here bi-weekly for years and we are seldom disappointed. If find the food fresh and consistent and the employees seem hard..."
John Rock
"Love this place. I order from
Here both at work and at home and it never disappoints. There are so many lousy pizzerias around here but this one is..."
"They are under a new management They re new everything even the Pizza taste better than..."
nabil MOHAMED
"Affordable whether by the slice or get a full pie. The crust is nice & crispy so it's perfectly done. The pizza has just the right amount of cheese &..."
Lady Raven
"Excellent prices. Remodel, clean and great cooks and chefs. Pizza sells quickly, especially the $2 any slice (yes, with toppings) love the Penne..."
Sydell Mack
"Great pizza great service the owner ray is very friendly..."
Resul Kaja
"Pizza and garlic sticks all day everyday, always fresh and hot , can't get enough of the garlic..."
"Awesome food! Meatballs and pizza are the best I have ever had. Great atmosphere and top notch wait staff. Highly recommend you visit..."
Justin Rivera
"We had such Amazing food and Excellent service at Millie's..Diana our server and everyone else made the dining experience superior! Very authentic..."
Lisa Carvano
"We tried the meatball parm pizza and the vodka pie, both were fantastic. Service was great. Will definitely go..."
Franca Wilson
"Been here multiple times already. Everything about this place is great. Food, service and..."
Michael Pavone
"I love Millie’s!!! Everything is so delicious... especially the vodka meatballs and mashed potato pie😍😍 Can’t wait to go..."
Candice Parlante
"Amazing food, excellent service and fun atmosphere. We’ve been there twice in two..."
Sandra Verity
"Food was delish. Service was..."
Cindy Jo
"Great meatballs & Great pies..."
Michael Major
"WOW, JUST WHAT THE ISLAND..."
Nicholas Racioppo
"Millie's is an absolutely incredible restaurant on so many levels. In fact, from my experience - it is more than a restaurant. It is a dining..."
123 Publish Incorporated
"Excellent Highly recommend. We had 3 of the coal fired pizzas. It was light and crispy, crust was delicious. So good definitely going back..."
Michael G
"Our waitress was very pleasant and the food was delicious! As an Italian Woman I was able to really appreciate the authentic flavor of the vodka..."
Marisa Streppone
"A group of us went on a Sunday, they were running a special $20 all you can eat. We definitely took them on their offer and arrived with an empty..."
Robert Nelson
"I can't believe I never commented about Millie's before. I've eaten here so many times. The food and service and can't be beat. Amir the manager is a..."
Cindy Aliseo
"Went to Millie’s of Staten Island it was amazing got the meatball coal pizza. The owner Brandon came over to see how we liked it and of course told..."
Nicholas Bianchi
"We have been to the Morristown location many times. When we were looking for a place to eat in Staten Island we saw a Millies and could resist..."
Susan Prisco Realtor
"Excellent house red. Pizza is made fresh from scratch- not greasy at all. The meatballs lived up to their reputation- absolutely AMAZING. Antipasto..."
"My brother always orders here and I was in town and decided to try. First impression was very quiet, clean, and welcoming. Very nice breeze with door..."
Elizabeth A
"A small but very personable restaurant. The vodka penne pizza is fantastic. Prices are even a little bit cheaper than other locations. Parking is..."
James Hanrahan
"Excellent pizza. Always crispy and not overloaded with cheese. Dough never too salty. My new pizza spot! Bye bye..."
Bianca R
"A must have pizza very..."
Ceaz G
"I have been going there for years. Everything they make is really..."
adele randazzo
"Pizza is super delicious and the people that work there are super nice. Would highly recommend this place if you are in the..."
Elizabeth K
"Great pizza and amazing..."
Lasal
"Love the food. The owners are warm and friendly. The food is good, my favorite is the carini hero. Excellent rice balls. The pizza is good too! They..."
"Went last night! Amazing food and enormous portions! Loved..."
Melissa Scharf Farinacci
"Best Pizza & Food on the island. Simply put Gino's IS the BEST Pizza & Food on Staten Island! Best Pizza, especially the Bacon pie! Specialty pies..."
FoodFamily
"Great Prices and Pies. Nice small pizzareia that makes great pies, especially the Sicilian. They are atleast 25% cheaper then the..."
AngryCitrus
"Pleasantly surprised. Super affordable.
Great taste. Large portions. Got free bread and water with a penne vodka dish. That is what made this a five..."
opencorners
"Great pizza. Decent delivery time's. Owner speaks English and takes order correctly. I love their olive pie and their sauce is..."
Stephie T
"Food is always good quality here and the customer service is great. This time we tried the Sicilian grandma pie with extra sauce and it was PERFECT...."
Christy Williamson
"Omg this is the best pizzeria on the island!!! Delicious pizza and subs and calzones!!! Very friendly staff. Their pizza 🍕 speaks for themselves...."
Christina Cornacchio
"Every bite was absolutely amazing. These guys were a blast, funny, and friendly. I also saw a NY Knick, NY Giant, and 9x Wrestling World Champion..."
"Just here yesterday for birthday celebration We go here often great restaurant if u are looking for good food this is the place nice casual..."
Teresa Russo Trovello
"Great staff, delicious food. Don't know WTF people are complaining about. The only thing I would tell them is lower the music a bit. The music itself..."
April Lynn
"Best calamari and pizza i had in a long time. Anthony our server was top notch! Will be going again very..."
Randy Gigante-Zimmerman
"It is absolutely fantastic!! From food to beverages, the service and if course my favorite bar tender Brian !! My favorite place for my hubby and I..."
Michele Petrassi Nasca
"The food was delicious. Everything was fresh. Friendly atmosphere. We missed out on the stuffed zucchini flowers because it was all sold out. That..."
JoAnn Calvo Cassese
"Excellent food and the staff and management are wonderful. My favorite pizzas are the Americano, vodka pie, and Funghi with smoked mozzarella. Be..."
John Camp
"Scrumptious food....pizza awesome...also loved the grilled chicken..."
Michael O'Rourke
"Great night and delicious food and great drinks love it their! The service was wonderful too! A must return although not my first time went to all..."
Lisa Scudera Trombetta
"Delicious from appetizers to sandwiches and pizza best on the..."
Loretta Sarnataro Falco
"My husband threw me a small bday surprise here. Service was OUTSTANDING! Food was delicious! Comfortable atmosphere. Would definitely recommend this..."
"I love to eat and I enjoy a good slice of pizza. And one of the best places to go on Staten Island is this place ,the pizza is crispy it's the..."
Frank Giasi
"This is a small Italian restaurant that was a bit out of our way but their pizza was probably one of the best I ever ate and staff couldn't be any ..."
George Sliwa
"We are from out of town and stayed at the Hilton Garden Inn, by luck ordered delivery pizza & garlic knots and they were fantastic , fast delivery..."
Heather Pangborn
"The best vodka pie on the island
There is no..."
John DiScala
"The best pizza and food in the whole Island, I really recommend it if you ever want to stop by and eat or take out your all welcome. It's awesome try..."
Max Desan
"On a recent visit to Staten Island from Upstate NY, we enjoyed one of the best takeout pizzas ever! Generous fresh toppings, declicious sauce &..."
Thomas Acquisto
"The only place on the island I get pizza from now. The mushrooms alone are worth the..."
James C Hamilton
"If you are looking for some great food served by a very friendly staff, this is your..."
Gina Bunch Russo
"The Pizza and Crew ... DA-Bomb!!
Simply Deeeeeelishhhhhh!!! A must try .. You won't be disappointed . 5..."
Darla Darla
"The best Sicilian squares in New York ! Family owned and operated Check it..."
"Thank you for helping to promote our event and Supporting our Veterans.
The Brothers and Sisters of Rolling Thunder 2..."
Nicole Sforza Chati
"Excellent food and great owners very nice..."
Brian Johnstone
"Always stop when I'm in SI. One of my favorite..."
Jason Sampogna
"Great staff, excellent food, fast delivery. 5..."
Frank Smith
"Good food and a pleasant atmosphere
One word..."
Anthony Abbriano
"My favorite takeout and funnier than late night..."
Pat Nangano Sonnenshen
"Great great great..."
Douglas Ferrera
"If 10 stars were available DiLeo's Pizza would get it. Live in VA but had to travel to NY for a funeral. We wanted to eat pizza in " New York" and..."
Jaron Young
"Phenomenal pizza. Had the best experience & LOVE the garlic knots, buffalo wings, vodka sauce with ANYTHING & caesar pie. 11/10 highly..."
Jessica T
"I was in town for a funeral, it was late, DiLeo's was across the street. Didn't think too much of it, but we found one of the gold standards of..."
Nick
"Delivery was super quick and friendly. Ordered online which was very easy. The food was awesome. We got the baked ziti pizza and a chicken parm hero..."
"On the way from JFK to Philadelphia decided to get a bite to eat. Stopped at this quaint little place in Staten Island. I had no expectations but was..."
Michael Lemashov
"Советую. Пиццу кушали вместе с мужем - очень вкусная , нямм..."
Alena Beleevskaya
"This Jersey guy was there for the first time and LOVED it! Can't wait to have the Grandma pie..."
Matt Coughlin
"Via Ponte is our favorite Pizzeria!!! The best in the Island!...I feel bad for anyone that are not able to get your food..."
Diane Marie
"The best buffalo chicken pizza..."
Louise Vigorito Adams
"The best pizza in..."
Maximo M Martinez
"Regular pizza is OK, but the specialty pizzas are the best! The food is amazing, real authentic Italian food. Although small, they have the best..."
Emily Visone
"Great pizza, really enjoyed my vodka pie and pepperoni pie. Delivery didn't take long and pizza was super hot when arrived! Yummy, definitely..."
Bubba1229
"Some of the best pizza I’ve had deadass. Grandmas og pizza bangin af fr. I’m so high I had to ask the beautiful girl who took my order where tf I..."
Fas With the M3
"The best pizza I remember eating.crispy crust .cheese and sauce is just..."
Alaedin Ashaib
"Via Ponte's margherita pie could be the best pizza I have ever eaten in my life. The crust is light, thin and delicious, along with the homemade..."
Joseph Fragoso
"Really good pizza, my favorite ( Margarita), the sauce..."
Yariel Reyes baez
"I visit Staten Island, NY every month. I'm here again. And looking forward to try a next slice in Via Ponte Pizzeria. Loved it!!! Best pizza I have..."
Tatiana Klik
"Our weekend in Staten Island was a delightful time! It wouldn't be the same if we did not stop by in Viaponte for a quick lunch. Ordered "Famous..."
"This place is great! Clean and well managed. The staff is friendly. The food is awesome! THE BUFFALO PIZZA is delicious! Definitely recommend this..."
AnnMarie Venn
"Ordered pizza here for the 1st time, and they let me make 2 specialty orders and they were perfect. My wife ordered a Pan Pie with vodka sauce,..."
Denis Boyle
"This is the best pizzaria I’ve every been too. the staff is amazing and the food is amazing. This is the only food place I order from..."
ETNIK KOSOVRASTI
"Best pizza I ever tried In ny and there rolls are excellent. Always order..."
"It waa the best pizza I've had in a long time. The topping was endless. Every bite was extremely exciting in my mouth and my toes..."
Natosha Kearse
"Best pizza in Staten Island hands down! Always..."
Katya Kolbasko Smith
"Simply..."
Kevin Czifra
"The OWNERS ARE AMAZING THE FOOD IS OUTSTANDING ��TOP ON THIS ISLAND In TASTE OF DIFFERENT FOODS ,,,,,I AM HAPPY I LIVE A FEW BLOCKS AWAY..."
Vivian Costanzo Bonanno
"Slice is on the small side, and a bit on the dry side.
Good mix of cheese and sauce. Good flavor to the cheese and sauce. Medium thin, crispy crust..."
Gary Wilson
"Good pizza. Parking in the area is hard to find though and there is only about 2-3 tables of you want to eat in. During busy times it can get quite..."
Dominick Marciano
"Whenever I'm on that side of Staten Island Even If I'm not Hungry I Get 3 pepperoni sliced warmed up for 10 seconds with my Ice cold sprite and I'm..."
Big Rube
"Been coming here for decades. It's home.
I used to walk here every day and buy a slice for $1.25. They keep the place clean and friendly.
Pretty..."
Ejay Menchavez
"The guys who work super energized and very nice to the customers. Deep dish slices are delicious calzones excellent. Prices on point. The quality..."
K B
"Definitely try buffalo pan slice, buffalo wings! More than Pizza! Chicken franchise hero and buffalo slice is my favorite! They have catering..."
Jordan Berber
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes