The best Restaurants in Stillwater ranking of February 2025
307 restaurant menus in Stillwater, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"Love it. Seems like everytime I go there I meet someone cool. Bartenders are always nice and mix a good..."
Devin
"Not a bad little local spot! Demographic seems to be late 20's to late 30's. Decent prices on drinks and a fun back area with Jenga..."
Stellar Kruize
"Went early evening, quiet older crowd super job Steph, making sure we always had what we needed and let us know when she was leaving and who would be..."
Darlene Brooks
"Extremely laid back crowd. The bar is a no smoking joint that serves beer specials on certain days and at times. Prices are fairly average for a bar..."
"I was greeted well by the host. The server was great too. The wings were great. If you are heat lover and don’t mind lil trouble down the line in..."
Saurav Shrestha
"Amazing experience at this location. My server Nate was very nice, antentive, and swift with everything. He also answered any questions I had. 10/10..."
"Amazing ,fresh sandwiches. Cinnamon rolls are by far the best in town. This is a must..."
Tamra Hartman
"Delicious breads and other goodies made fresh! Tasty varieties that you don’t find elsewhere.
Exceptional service..."
Stacie Jensen
"They have the most amazing pretzels, fresh bread, and natural ingredients for a healthy..."
Robert Olszewski
"Great bread, great people, great Harvey rocks! Thank you for the amazing..."
Melody Fox
"The cinnamon swirl bread from Great Harvest is yummy! The densest bread ever! Toasted, Lathered with butter and a layer of skippy peanut butter -..."
Chris Lynskey Clark
"friendly staff and wonderfull service, i'd stop her again when get the..."
Edward M Nardone
"I love the Dakota wheat bread. It makes wonderful toast and..."
Linda Orsted
"If you guys need a Woodbury location let me know - 651-283-8607. James Brooks Remax Results and Woodbury resident since..."
James Brooks
"You don’t have to buy bread anywhere else! Everything they have here is as natural as it gets. Plus you get to sample what they have baked fresh..."
Brad
"Great cookies and bread is ok, pretzels are delish ! Good..."
Gianna Ianos
"My absolute favorite cookie is the salted caramel. They are at the Woodbury and Saint Paul Aldrich Arena Farmers Market and my sister and I go there..."
Monica Ortez
"Very helpful and professional staff! Great..."
Mary Anderson
"Fantastic variety of fresh baked bread daily and not to forget the array of delicious cookies hot out of the oven! Aside from their breads and..."
Cassie Hatella
"We love the variety of breads that they..."
Steven Glaser
"As I was about to make bread one day I thought “why not just go to great harvest?!” They use better ingredients than I can get at a regular..."
Nonnie Kleinstick
"Friendly on site bakery. Ask questions about just about anything and the baker's share conversation and amazing breads and scruffins! Muffin style..."
"The food itself was pretty decent. Nothing spectacular. It’s a charming little eatery, but not the kind of place I’d go often. Maybe only when..."
Michael Teicheira
"My only complaint about this restaurant is that I can’t eat here 3 times a day! I don’t know what sort of magic Sarah & her staff use to produce..."
Jessica Lynn
"Sweet lil hole in wall in downtown area (I think). Food was amazing, just the right amount of everything, fresh, well done homemade everything,..."
Suzanna Thomas
"They have a rotating menu of all homemade items, always made with quality ingredients. They also have baked goods and frozen take home..."
kristen josey
"We always love the Good Little Eater!! Even when there's a ln ingredient I don't typically like, I love it in their dishes. High quality, gourmet..."
b Hinesley
"SUPPORT LOCAL!! This restaurant is amazing!! Their menu changes out I think every week or two weeks. They have freezer items like baked goods,..."
Miriam Moran
"I really enjoy how easy it is to eat here. Food is really great and its not the same ol' you get everywhere else. Sarah and her entire team does a..."
Absolute Carpet & Tile Restoration
"Always friendly and always a unique menu selection for the month. The dining area is small so be prepared to share one of the large tables with other..."
"The service here was phenomenal. The calamari reminded me of the fried squid I had in the Philippines, and I couldn't stop eating it. The shrimp..."
Taco Cookie
"We had our pre-graduation dinner here and it was very busy the time we went with family and their graduates. But we were served efficiently and..."
Donna Dawson
"We ate there for lunch on Monday, everyone greeted us when we walked in, short wait for table, waiter was very attentive and the food arrived..."
Jan Hamen
"Had a party of ten. The staff was simply superb. Very efficient and courteous. Everyone was extremely happy with the service and hot food. The server..."
Ivan De Tevis
"Our food was amazing, and the waiter was so nice and friendly! There was no wait to be seated, and our food arrived quickly. Best restaurant..."
Crystal Lowder
"These guys are a great place for the drinks they have a very experienced bar crew I can tell you that the food was just a little above good better..."
"Fun place to get a coffee drink and muffin or cookie and shop for fun and unique gifts. Warm and friendly..."
Barb Miller
"My daughter and I found your place while exploring Stillwater today. Great gifts (I made most of my purchases gifts for myself!) I love my new blush..."
Shawn McLaughlin
"I have a love/hate relationship with this place.
Well, I love it, my husbands hates it :-)
Maybe it's because I pop over for a coffee a few times a..."
Kelly Costa-Daly
"Coffee, ice cream and cupcakes - all superb! Thank you!! We will be..."
Kelsey Meehan
"When will or do you have the Don't Kill My Vibe coffee mug that I can..."
Denise HoneyHipzz Holder
"So many neat items to keep the lost art of writing a letter, journal, or thank you card personal. Love..."
"I give the sandwich artist's a thumbs up. They were busy and doing pretty good keeping up.very friendly. Made myself and family of 4 a great..."
Mark Dion
"Service was very good. I always love friendly people. Makes you feel good. They were..."
Andrea Koczur
"Thank you Eli for making my bomb sandwich today! I had a very good experience and bonus points for eye contact! I can't get that at my other Subway...."
Christina
"Did not remember the name of the person who assisted us, yet he was very friendly, patient with my 84 yo mother, helpful with suggestions,..."
Mary Griffith
"Food was great havnt had subway in quite awhile! Crossing the highway was easy as well..."
"Exactly as I ordered, ready when I arrived (probably earlier than promised). "Hot and Ready". Good stuff... well, not stuffed crust as I ordered..."
matxdad
"They remember us! Plus our pizza is never wrong. The team here at this establishment truly enjoys us as customers and take great care in all the food..."
Marlene Isaac
"I think that Pizza Hut is my favorite over the other pizza places..."
"Food and service was great. A must go to place in Stillwater,..."
Patricia Runnels
"Amazing chips, queso, and salsa. Love their mango margarita - great price for the size! Their chicken is good and so are their burritos. All in all I..."
Maddie
"We started with the white queso and after inquiring about other salsas, our server brought out 2 other spicier salsas. Mrs. Flip Out had the..."
"Best shop downtown Stillwater by far! The interior design and cheerful workers make the experience very delightful, and keeps you coming back for..."
Theo Falkenberg
"Every time I go to Stillwater I make it a point to visit Mai little Cup cake. I love the atmosphere and decor of the shop. The staff was quick to..."
Chrissy Her
"The best cupcakes I ever had! It wasn't super sweet like the store bought ones, it was just perfect! My favorite is the carrot cupcake it's so..."
Kathy Vang
"My first time inside, everyone was super nice. Greeted me and talked with me while I looked around, beautiful shop with top class cakes and cupcakes!..."
Nick Robertson
"Best cupcakes ever! Blue velvet with chocolate filling is to die for! The raspberry champagne cupcakes are my fave..."
Smile Queen
"Tasty cupcakes and delicious boba tea. Simply design but the cupcakes are anything but that. Reccommend the watermelon boba tea and the German..."
Alexander Jovan Piletich
"We were so happy to try Mai Little Cakes! The cupcakes lemon/blueberry and mocha were just perfect!
Can't wait to try other flavors and check..."
Joyce Enright
"I love this new shop on Main Street! The cupcakes are seriously DELICIOUS!! I know they do custom cakes - and I can't wait to order one for my..."
Meg Anderson Brownson
"I bring cupcakes to clients regularly (at least once a week) and this cute little shop is hands down the best! Great service, and amazing flavors- I..."
Courtney Novosad
"Adorable little bakery! They have the best boba tea around! The lady working today was super sweet. The cupcakes are also outstanding! This is..."
Samantha Burke
"I've never enjoy eating cupcakes or cake but these cupcake are just wonderful and not too sweet, just perfect to my liking! Everyone should give it a..."
Tswb Jody
"The bubble tea!!!! Wonderful staff!!!!!! Great decor!!!! Amazing..."
Bretta Chaplinski
"Really cute and delicious cupcakes. We tried the lemon, chocolate raspberry and vanilla with sprinkles. All three types of frosting were very..."
Alex Jordan Noel
"My sister bought a variety of cupcakes for a baby shower; they were a big hit! I would definitely recommend them- very..."
Melonie Wheeler
"We visited on a soft opening and got a variety of cupcakes. AALLL of them were amazing. I tried a mocha cupcake and a raspberry chocolate kind. Let..."
Maggie Chandler
"Mai made my son's 1st birthday cake and it was perfect! Thanks for making our day that much more special! She even made a small matching one for him..."
Joe Berg
"Had their bubble tea here!
Was pretty good! And great for the price. Definitely some of the best boba I have had under 5$
Had a lychee black tea...."
Nicholas Willette
"Stopped in randomly in this gorgeous bakery with my partner. As soon as we stepped in we were greeted with a clean, classy, pink and white bakery. We..."
Brady Burton
"I love the atmosphere! The inside is so cute and the staff is so nice. The cupcakes are very cute & tasty. The boba is very good..."
Ranna Marie
"Enjoyed a large cup of rolled ice cream. Well served in a beautiful presentation! Simple but nicely decorated establishment! Their bubble tea was..."
Josep Cors
"Adorable little place with cupcakes, bubble tea, and ice cream. I’ve been here a few times now, and it never fails to disappoint. Such a fun..."
Lysha_Marie
"Beautiful and yummy cup cakes! And I loves the ice cream rolls. It was fun to watch how they make it and mixing in stuff and such a cute..."
Emily Lu
"We love Mai Litte Cakes!!! Love how cute the place is and how friendly the staff always smiling!:) I have brought my 5 year old daughter there twice..."
"Amazing dining experience last night. Thanks chefs, bartenders and servers for an evening of unique, beautifully balanced dishes. We had the..."
Betsy Houck May
"I never review restaurants...people have different tastes and likes, but I can't resist. The remodel is beautiful, bright and inviting. Had a small..."
Tracy Lynn Picha
"Outstanding. The minute you walk through the door, you are transported by the chic, coastal vibe, but the fun is just beginning. There is serious..."
Traci Lambrecht
"Another great addition to downtown Stillwater! The space looks amazing and the service was great. We tried the Oysters, Chicken and Waffles, and Fish..."
Erin Gardner
"One of the best restaurants along the river!! Amazing cocktails, food and staff!! Can’t wait to come back and try the dinner menu—worth every..."
Amanda Solie
"For this Southern girl it was the perfect menu! The food was awesome, we ordered (several things since we couldn’t make up our mind)from the lunch..."
Neeley Berry
"Delicious. The depth of flavor was amazing. Had the Octopus, crab risotto, diner burger and shrimp..."
Jenny Beastmode Hofferber
"Everything was honestly perfect. Cocktails? Funny names and delicious flavors. Prawns and grilled oysters to start? A perfect appetizer to our meal...."
Megan Virginia
"Just go. Really great atmosphere, beautiful room, phenomenal, friendly service and excellent food. We stopped in for lunch and had a load of oysters..."
Jason Holmgren
"Fantastic cocktails, fantastic food & fantastic bartender! I highly recommend the Fried Chicken Sandwich and All the Boys to the Yard..."
Angela Mackenthun Berres
"Met a friend for lunch to check out the spot....I’ll be returning many times! The food was outstanding! I had oysters and the fried catfish, prawns..."
Victoria Asauskas
"The food was nothing like I’ve had. Our group made sure to order different entrees so we could try them. The ox tail ravioli and chicken & waffles..."
Heidi Gilde
"Beautiful furniture and lighting. The food and cocktails are also outstanding but I was disappointed in the french fries. The shrimp and grits were..."
Rebecca Mazza
"What a great restaurant. From awesome decor that changes from chic to romantic from 1sr floor to the second floor. Staff is exceptionall. The food..."
Greg Klein
"This place made our night! Totally turned our unfortunate events around during our 1 year anniversary. We came in for late night drinks. I had an old..."
Ariana Larson
"Honestly, the best food I have ever eaten. I would give 10 stars if I could. Hubby & I shared smoked crab risotto, hot octopus and oxtail spinach..."
Tracy Martinson
"Amazing!
I love this fresh Southern Coastal flair! Great service, wonderful food selection, and the drinks were spot on! The atmosphere is..."
Brenda Weber
"We stopped in for happy hour and are so glad that we did. The oysters were amazing and the Pearl Salad with the Green Tomato Vinaigrette was just..."
Mary Jo Wiseman
"Lovely space with great flavors. Just came in for a light bite and the savor waffle, crawfish bisque and corn bread were perfect. Nice, surprising..."
"MANGIARE! MEANING FROM THAT OH SO ITALIAN WORDS: LET EAT ! (My Dad) Mr. Karl Schu Birthday Dinner On Sat: 1/4/2020 That I Treated Him To At The Old..."
Kyle Schu
"The atmosphere is an old farm house that has a very warm feeling. The waitress was very pleasant and courteous. The food was very good. Be aware this..."
Matt Yeastedt
"A fantastic Italian experience! If your able to get a table you won't regret it! Its BYOB and everything is organic and fresh. Justin and his wife..."
Jeanean Freeland
"If I could afford it I would eat here every weekend. Well worth getting on their list! Hard to find a better meal in central..."
Anon #1
"Wow, we had an absolutely amazing evening at Old Tioga Farm! Incredibly delicious food and a great atmosphere. I highly recommend..."
Wendy Odams
"Absolutely the best food for 100 miles. Wonderfully prepared and presented prix fixe menu that always delights. BYOB means you can bring what you..."
Matthew Prosseda
"The best food and best dining experience! The hospitality is second to none. The combination of flavor is truly wonderful. Go with an open mind,..."
andrew caflisch
"The best food in northeastern PA, hands down. Extremely authentic Italian cuisine lovingly and thoughtfully prepared. It’s a relaxing, enjoyable..."
"Late at night after game day, can’t be beat! Line takes a little while, but just be..."
John Warren
"3/5 if you just come here to eat randomly. 5/5 after a night of spending quality time out on the Strip. The pizza is great too! Be prepared to wait..."
Michael Teicheira
"Miss this place when I got trashed. The best finish after hitting the..."
DoWon Kim
"Delight for thr stoner and the drunkard alike. If you aren't under the influence of something, you aren't pregnant, and you don't have a strange..."
Alasdair Hill
"Best food in town. Try the Curty dog and the..."
Richard Rodriquez
"Greatest food ever. Especially, after a couple of drinks!! It's totally worth waiting in line..."
Abigail VanSteenwyk
"Great food if you want a hotdog with a twist it's a must try you won't regret..."
"Wow, what a crew! I placed a massive catering order for the volunteers at Mopars in the Park and our volunteers absolutely devoured them. I actually..."
Bud Kleppe
"Sandwiches were amazing. They had a lot of taste and flavor. Prices are also fair and not too expensive. Would definitely..."
"This Subway, located at 6th and Washington in Stillwater, is by far, one of the best I have been to. The store was nice and clean, and the lady..."
Loretta Schaub
"Always been a good lunch stop. They are typically pretty busy during lunch hours (11am - 1pm) due to their accessibility, but the staff is pretty..."
Jordan Madden
"Attendant was nice and helpful. He made a great salad and an equally great sandwich. The grilled chicken is always the best for me personally. All..."
Amanda Meddley
"Very polite employees and made a wonderful sub. Thanks..."
Lady Bug
"Clean venue and one of the workers were friendly and excited to be working. The gentleman that was there looked like he was absolutely miserable. I..."
John Berry
"Nice people.. good..."
Mark Mann
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes