The best Restaurants in Sugarloaf Key ranking of January 2025
4 restaurant menus in Sugarloaf Key, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"Everything here was slightly above average, good service as well. Outdoor seating area and live music. Key West prices but big portions. I had some..."
Howie Groves
"Great burgers cooked to order. Three of us each had the burger, husband had fries, they were good, I had the slaw and my fiend had the grilled..."
Becky
"I've been to Mangrove Mamas many times over the years for brunch, happy hour and other evening stops, always been treated well, food has always been..."
Ray S.
"Came here many years ago and it looks the same. Thought we remembered that they had beer and Margaritas. Yep, in a separate building behind the main..."
Chill Travelers
"Very laid back, slow paced restaurant. Had the snapper platter grilled with slaw and potato salad. Food tastes good. Outdoor bar with patio..."
Public B
"The Service was very fast and the food is very..."
Adam
"This is a great spot for breakfast. The food was excellent and Amanda, who looked after us was fun and very efficient and extremely helpful with..."
Peter Harding
"Shrimp St Jaques was delicious and server was attentive and friendly. Cooks even came by table to say..."
Big A
"Stopped in for breakfast, it's was good. Particularly their bacon and homemade bread. Atmosphere was relaxing and island like. Friendly staff. To..."
Jon Z
"Next "new" owner. Our first visit here was more than ten years ago. Thru all the "new" owners we've enjoyed most of our meals here. However, after..."
Traveling Gopher
"Good meal. I think the new owners are doing a great job, the food has really got better. And the fact that they now serve breakfast is great. All..."
Ron Leder
"Great Keys stop! Our server was extremely nice, and the fish is fresh. The lobster Reuben is insanely tasty and you have to order the conch fritters...."
Alexandria Guerra
"Hurray! Dog friendly! Oh, and the chow is good too. Especially like the Filet Benedict and Bloody Mary on Sunday..."
Fishman
"True keys atmosphere!. This place is a must stop on your way to key west! The black and blue mahi is to die for. And the potato salad is homemade!..."
Louie33
"I LOVED IT!. I love to eat and I know good food! Was it fancy? Nope! But it was on my top 10 best meals ever! The scallops were so juicy you could..."
Stacey
"Stick with the local fare. Relaxed island atmosphere. Good food, reasonably priced if you stick with the local fare, excellent fish sandwiches and..."
Marc
"Relaxed keys atmosphere and a fried grouper sandwich that is second to..."
The Fundamentalist
"Yes yes. Drove for ever found this and..."
Jake Smith
"AMAZING food! Atmosphere was extremely local sand wonderful. Tee's and flips and a really friendly staff. Absolutely love Mangrove..."
Narie Gibson
"Great local feel to this place before you get into the touristy area of Key West. We enjoyed drinks, appetizer (Conch fritters) and dinner. My..."
Kathryn Nobles
"Food is so delicious! Our waitress was fabulous. We don't go out to eat often. This is one of the best places we have eaten at in a very long time. ..."
Brenda Hawks
"New owners, new team and new menu. All I can say is wow. I had the blackened mahi tacos and let me tell you, they were the best I’ve had in quite..."
Dave’s Event Videos
"4.9/5 Stars
I've been coming down here for 25 years and let me say this place has never disappointed. We had the smoked fish dip and the fritters...."
Yalc Kcin
"Amazing experience! Walked in while an artist was playing a Cello! We were on the patio & enjoyed a serene evening. Nice Conch Fritters & Flounder..."
Sandraella Call
"Had an excellent meal here. Service was wonderful and that alone would make it a return trip. Food was very good. Tried the French dip and it is..."
Jerome Liggett
"New ownership has turned thus place around. We had an amazing lunch and can't wait to come back for dinner. The new owners clearly know what they are..."
Senex Crenshaw
"Missi Porter was our server. She was fantastic. We were a big group and she took excellent care of all of us. I am putting her pic in the magazine...."
Connie
"I took my son here 19 years ago and have always wanted to go back. I was worried it would not live up to my memory, but it did! The food was..."
Richelle Ferree
"Glad to hear the good news/ new owners news about Mangrove’s. We seen the changes over about 30 years and look forward to the new “affordable “..."
cayman597
"Great find. Staff was super friendly. Food was really good (would not necessarily expect this from a bar). Homemade key lime pie was to die for! Cool..."
Brian Wallace
"Fantastic!! Great atmosphere. Good food.
If I lived locally, this would be my go to place. Friendly folks all around. They also have live music and..."
Joshua Hupp
"Have gone there multiple times and love the place! There food is always great and staff is wonderful! Photos are of two different times I've gone...."
Shaylee Crawford
"Really neat venue, daily live music, lots of indoor and outdoor seating.
Really enjoyed the music, cocktails were great and large, and the shrimp..."
dylan murphy
"We all had great tasty meals! The staff were friendly and we all loved the fun atmosphere! What a history after being wiped out by a hurricane. A..."
Adventuring Through Life with the Whits
"We heard it was under new management so we just went to give it a try. They really cleaned the place up, the food was amazing and our waitress was..."
Barb Kenna
"Nice little hole in the wall. Very easy to get to if you're staying at the campground across the street. Food was good but the drinks were weak. If..."
"The restaurant is feet away from our room, so it is very convenient. The servers were amazing and very attentive. They brought us out a sample taste..."
Shannon O
"Remarkable dinner experience. Charming 70’s style building nestled between a small hotel and marina. The marquis sign is not prominent so drive..."
Scott Andrews
"Amazing experience start to finish. We are not ones for writing reviews but we were just reminiscing about how wonderful this place was during our..."
Laurie Laxton
"Exclusive dinning experience outside of Key West. On June 9, 2023 we celebrated our Anniversary dinner here. 630pm reservation. Two very delicious..."
yvonne valla meeks
"Deserving of more than five stars. Have you ever been to a restaurant that you could not believe it took you so long to visit? This was that place..."
Boondocking Nomads
"Great service our server was enthusiastic and very descriptive . The food was delicious and presented..."
Frederick Waldo
"We have driven past so many times and always wonder if this odd little property circa 1970 is even open. It always makes me think of the Brady Bunch..."
key lime
"The Thai Fish was exceptional. My wife and I split the meal and were very satisfied with our choice. Our waitress (Chris) was very accommodating and..."
Stephen Carter
"We walked in on a Friday evening and didn't realize they closed at 9 pm. The chef greeted us at the door, and we apologized for coming in after they..."
Heather Fenton
"When we have something to commemorate/celebrate, we eat! Tonight was at South of the Seven in Sugarloaf Key. We traveled less than a 5 min drive from..."
"We have been ordering pizza from here for months now, at least twice a month. The pizza is by far the best up the Keys, the crust is always crispy..."
Saundra Kielborn
"We live close by and we order the pizza and salads frequently. The pizza reminds me of a traditional brick oven NY style pizza, I have yet to be..."
Theresa Bass
"Solid local pizza joint. You can get beer in the Tiki on a back of property. Inexpansive but..."
Serge Mashtakov
"Best pizza you will find anywhere go to the Tiki Bar order a pizza after 4..."
Shannon Coleson
"I love their white pizza. I order it with pepperoni, mushrooms and red bell..."
Pegs Drewry
"The food is pretty good,, I wish they open earlier then 7:00am like at least..."
Larry Moore
"a for sure stop on the way to key west great fresh ingredients and hands down good..."
k g
"1st time..Way better than expected! ! Good blackened chicken... :))
2nd time.. Inconsistent food quality......"
Ariah James
"DELICIOUS meat pizza! And they deliver for..."
Ashlin Miron
"Good food at reasonable prices. Very..."
Cameron Moser
"Best pizza in the..."
Eric Styles
"Great..."
hballparkspm
""
W
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes