The best Restaurants in Sullivan ranking of February 2025
101 restaurant menus in Sullivan, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"Great food and very friendly staff! Tortellini Rosa is my daughters favorite and the meat sauce has amazing flavor! This is a must stop while in..."
Angie Robb
"I had my office holiday dinner here last weekend. We had a great time and the food was excellent. I think we tried a little of everything. The pizza,..."
Michelle Kenworthy-Clothier
"Let me start by saying I’ve never felt compelled to write a review until today. My fiancé and I booked a tasting with Nora on very short notice..."
Marina Fuller
"I’m in town for work. Locals said this is a must go to restaurant, and it was! It’s amazing. I got an Alfredo pesto linguine chicken pasta. It..."
Angie Christensen
"Camping at Shakamak nearby and being out of town, we promised our boys pizza and found Joe's by a map search. So glad we did. Best pizza I've ever..."
Christina Shephard
"Their food is always delicious, I love the atmosphere. The service is great. The Leone's are the heart of the place, all four of them. Definitely..."
Stacy Street
"We love eating here! We love the tasty Sunday meals after church as well as the wonderful menu items. The owners are great, friendly people who are..."
Patty Sue Jett Horn
"A fantastic little place. Highly recommended. We will be going..."
Cheryl Maggard Phelps
"Best place in Sullivan! Love the people that work there always so nice . the food is amazing..."
Samantha Kelley
"Love eating here,best food.recommend it to everyone . Always treated good service is..."
Sherry Brown Smith
"What a great turnout for Luke Jones fundraiser & the Leones are so generous & have a great heart for our..."
Brenda Butler Howard
"Great food and great people. Very family..."
Mary Nickels
"We enjoy eating at Joe's! Their food is always delicious! We love their spaghetti and the atmosphere! Every one is very..."
Dwightandlinda Boyll
"Could go there everyday of the week ! Almost did ! Great food and friendly people..."
Samantha Kester
"Amazing food and great service, the sauce is a taste you will remember and can only find..."
Billy Zellars
"Great food with his homemade..."
Steve Linn
"Huge thick calzones that are perfectly crispy outside with tons of fillings!! Awesome Gluten Free menu to! Husband loved regular menu & I was..."
Sarah Shalloe
"My favorite place to eat. So good and such lovely owners and..."
Tamara Biddle
"Super good food, I'd fight someone for their meatballs 😋 The service is exceptional as..."
Kaitlin Jones
"We celebrated a birthday,11 lady's the food was delicious and are server was amazing, kind, sweetest young lady..."
Alicia Gettler Moseley
"The atmosphere, service, and food were all..."
Bobby Styck
"What a neat local place for good Italian food. Lots of locals eat here, so that says..."
"The staff is very kind. And the only reasons for 4 stars were the old shoes and loud music....we were placed right under the speaker. However, they..."
S R
"It's been over 20 years since I was there last. We had planned to go to a different restaurant, but it was closed. So we went to Patrick's. There was..."
Amy Miller
"It's been years since I've been to Patrick's. Still great food and great..."
"Ordering for a crew can be a pain sometimes, thankfully the fine employees here were able to accommodate my large order and were friendly and didn't..."
Derek Yarno
"Tried out the new crispy chicken sandwich. There were two of us. One was crispy, unfortunately one was not, but still quite tasty. Coleslaw is..."
Maureen O'Connor
"I think that this location does excellent job. The people at the window are friendly and the quality of their chicken is above..."
Earache My Eye
"The food was great, better than the KFC in St. CHARLES, MO. Don't know why the difference..."
Bernard Ross
"I went here for a change from the burgers. I order 3 chicken little, fries and large drink and it was almost $13. I didn't check to see what I was..."
"I've never had a bad experience. The staff is always friendly and the drinks are always amazing. I would most definitely..."
Chelsea Shaw
"Coffee was delicious and service was quick and..."
Amanda Bird
"Nice store and the usual good SB coffee and the staff are nice but.....
They messed up our orders on both visits and the orders were not complicated!..."
Carl O'Neil
"Little disappointed at how often they’re closed and out of stuff. But outside of that the staff is amazing! And they make the best..."
Christina Spence
"Bruno needed his coconut..."
310interiors
"Good service, nice atmosphere, good drinks.
It's Starbucks so hopefully you know what you're getting into. I like to say "Starbucks is supposed to..."
Tyler Harms
"Came here with my wife. Been here before. Nice staff working here. Standard stuff other than that...."
"We had the best service tonight and the waitress Holly did an outstanding job! We appreciate her work ethic! Thank you again, we will be dining with..."
Jamie Elder
"Great service with good food. My travel mate said the Buffalo Chicken thin crust pizza they ordered was delicious. The oven-fresh soft dough..."
Lonnie Perry
"I really want to give a shout out to the crew and management at this location. I had a birthday party with about 35 people at 5 last night. We had..."
Brian Hines
"I hate to admit this, but me and my wife ordered pick up from here like 20 minutes before they closed. They were out of the appetizer we wanted but..."
Sequoia Cornell-conner
"I was visiting from Missouri and stopped to get a pizza. Im not a fan of Supreme but I fell in love with this pizza. Had so many toppings it was..."
"Hardee's sadly left the Chicgoland area years ago so I can only find it when I go north across the Wisconsin border. My wife truly loves the Ham..."
Keith Emrikson
"I was traveling
Stopped a little to later for breakfast
Disappointed
But the shift manager had them make me breakfast
Very nice to..."
steve jerrell
"Order was correct, staff was friendly, bathrooms were clean. We enjoyed our meal..."
Leah Sapphira
"I feel like Hardees is underrated and overlooked a lot by people. This place has always consistently delivered amazing burgers and fries. They are..."
"We are visiting the area and wanted something simple and easy after a busy day. This fit the bill!
Several dishes to choose from and reasonable..."
Dana Shankle
"The food was perfection for a take out restaurant. Although they do offer indoor dining where the service and food are just as superb. If your in the..."
sherry kearns
"Then going there for many years. They are very consistent and very good. If you like spicy food they can make it as spicy as you like. The hot sour..."
Mike
"The food is good. They have plenty of seating since opening up that dining section. No table service, so you get your own refills and clear the table..."
Colleen Barclay
"Food is amazing and the staff are really friendly restraunt is really clean. They are also really fast so you won't have to wait a long time for..."
Stephanie Johnson
"Nice little hole in the wall Chinese place..quiet,but very friendly..good prices$$..soup was great...fried rice was way above normal.. Mongolian beef..."
DH H
"Finally some good Chinese food in the Sullivan area, wish they would deliver. The new remodeled dine in area is very..."
Deborah Kizer
"When we want decent Chinese takeout and our local joint is closed we'll drive 30+ minutes to this location. It's good food and the staff has always..."
"Stopped for convenience to the interstate and so very glad we did! Staff were so polite and welcoming and the food was fantastic! The restrooms were..."
Dorrenna Mullins
"We had Tacos ‘El Sol’ with rice and beans and Al Pastor street tacos. Service was excellent food was..."
Susan Fischer
"Authentic Mexican food! Amazing, Clean, fast fresh and caring. This place is absolutely amazing and the food is delicious! Servers were very polite..."
Leilany Rosa
"So SO good! Food, service, cleanliness all excellent. My husband accidentally ordered the wrong entree & they happily made him a new one. Very..."
Kim Goldin
"I don’t know what’s better…the food or the service!!!!! Y’all I almost hate to leave a five star review…because I want to keep this gem to..."
Athena Daley
"Passing thru Sullivan for a doctor appointment and stop here at El Sol. It was clean and friendly. Was not sure what to get so i had them surprise..."
William Elkins
"We came here last night and it was great!!! All the flavors were there for the food but the service was kind of slow. We waited about 25 minutes..."
"Wow, who would have known this out of the way place (at least for out of towners)had fabulous food. My Jane burger was seasoned sooo good. You'll be..."
Eddy Wilcox
"Great Beer Great..."
Black & White Roofing
"We had a wonderful experience here today. We went to maramac caverns today and wanted something good to eat. We got wings, with the boomer sauce, and..."
kristi clay
"They pulled off a walk in of 35. Thank..."
Rigga M
"Love their wings and Ice cold..."
Tammy Daniel
"Bloomers was great 👍 food was fresh 😋 service was great and we enjoyed it. Definitely be..."
Jane Wagenseller
"Good food and drinks great service i loved being able to play music while i played pool and spent time with family in a good..."
"Love eating here. The food is great. The drinks are great too.. The staff and owners are wonderful. Love that I can watch any game on the TV’s...."
Angela Johnson-Dal Ponte
"Great service, wonderful food, giant portions, especially for the $ A hidden..."
Ellen Grabowski Tish
"I usually have the calzone which is amazing, but last night I switched it up with a basic chicken sandwich. The chicken had great seasoning and..."
Jill Frederick
"You will not be disappointed and once you try Rosati's you will be hooked for life! For a heightened dining experience, take the time to visit and..."
Barb Satterfield
"They have great food and great service! Their food is amazing I love the..."
Ariel Heppe
"We go about once a month. Always great food. Service is great. Love the..."
Cynthia Denton
"Great Pizza!!!! Thanks Josh!!!
And April!!! Your service was exceptional!!!
Very pleasant atmosphere, will be back for a dine in evening..."
Jim Goatley
"This is really the only place you can get a Chicago style pizza within 50 miles of Sullivan, and it's actually comparable to other Chicago pizza..."
Cade Grimm
"Great pizza!! It's definitely worth the 40 mile round trip!! Try the Chicago style pizza!! Yummy..."
Patty Goatley
"Very very good. 1st time visit. We have always wanted to try it and I'm glad we did. Will definitely be..."
Douglas Dukeman
"We are originally from Chicago and now live in Lancaster PA. Our in-laws live in a small town nearby. The whole family misses Chicago thin crust big..."
Sean Kavanaugh
"There is some good pizza in the area and we think this tops them all. Fair price and good service..."
"Great experience. My delivery driver Brianna was very nice and kind. Great food and it was..."
Victoria Hunter
"The guy who deleverd my pizza was an all out great guy got what i paid for with no..."
Crimson Cranky
"Ordering online best experience, I was able to pick the time I wanted to pick up the pizza. Once I got to the Store everyone I had contact with was..."
Kimberly Curley
"I love our local Pizza Hut! The ingredients are always fresh and appropriately placed. The employees seem to really care about getting orders right...."
Jennifer Pippin
"I was given a free order of cinnamon bread sticks with icing on my birthday. They were SO good!
The young man that waited on me was very helpful. I..."
Natalie Tourville
"Tried the Cinnabon minis and they were very good!! They always give us hot and fresh..."
"The people at hole in the wall go above and beyond for their customers. I had my son's rehearsal dinner there tonight and they were amazing! They..."
Angie Clawson
"I've tried the pulled pork, pulled chicken, and brisket, and they've all been juicy and delicious. The mac & cheese has a nice kick to it, and the..."
Nichell Williams
"This was our first visit to Hole In The Wall and it was fabulous. I'll be honest, we had heard mixed reviews when it first opened but wow either..."
Karen Bretz
"Great food at reasonable price. Awesome atmosphere and the staff is super friendly. Was there for my birthday dinner and the owner came out and..."
Nick Houser
"Excellent food!! Very friendly staff we tried almost everything on the menu between our family and would recommend..."
Margaret Palmer Luckenbill
"This is a great place to eat. Not only is the food fantastic, but the staff is also pretty awesome, as well. When they first opened, I visited, and..."
Tricia Binion Sieberns
"We were looking for something different before going to the theatre. Saw your ad in the theatre program and decided to give it a try. Nothing fancy,..."
April Stuemke
"The food @ hole-in-the-wall is awesome. I had their BBQ pulled pork nachos and pulled pork tacos. The nachos were made with deep-fried flour..."
Shane Allen
"Great food always forget about this place when going out to eat will be back for more..."
chris novota
"Good food and prices. Young man behind the counter was super friendly. Interesting decor,..."
Tony S.
"I work here and I eat here all the time. Google asked me to give a review so I decided to write a review. Love this food. Paid 5 dollars for a pony..."
Ethan Schmohe
"Small location with a friendly staff. Food tasted great and was super..."
Michael Orr
"We arrived a little closer to closing than we usually would. We still received great service and amazing food. The pork nachos we're yummy and smoky...."
Ashley Kite
"Ordered take out, the pulled pork was great but the Cole slaw was absolutely awesome! Best Cole slaw I ever had! The young man brought the order to..."
Cristy Phelps
"Great food and service to match! Small town family owned atmosphere. Just what you would expect. I had brisket sandwich with beans and cornbread...."
"They got free WiFi it password is lovecoffee an there coffee if fire like holy moly it's fire and there prices like come..."
Larry Thompson
"Friendly staff that makes great specialty drinks; can’t go wrong there! Their lunch specials are always intriguing and delicious. Their cupcakes..."
Colleen Barclay
"We are regulars at our Story Coffee, the service is great, our drinks are always perfect, and they even know what our favorite drinks are. They are..."
Judy Chandler
"Food was amazing! Definately going to be my go-to for in-town lunch and lattes. Why even go to Starbucks when this exists?
And they have local goods..."
Courtney Hollis
"I'm not a fan of coffee .. and it seems as though that's all they offer ? The cupcakes appear to be "all the rave" but they have filling inside and..."
Jen R
"The gourmet grilled cheese is wonderful! The little shop has some really cute things, and there's a great selection of coffee drinks. I like to..."
Karen Fischer
"This is an amazing place to go for breakfast and coffee. My wife and I have been here several times and every time the staff is so wonderful and..."
"MEAN STREET had the opportunity to play at The Diamond in Sullivan, Indiana and I can honestly say this is by far one of the best places we have ever..."
Danny Stultz
"Great place to grab a drink and amazing food. Perfect atmosphere for parties, hanging with friends and live music. Highly..."
Bob Ainsworth
"Delicious food. I seriously can't stay away from the jalapeño bites..."
Dawn Michelle Sanders
"Great little spot with a great staff. Name may be a little misleading still at times as this is NOT A BBQ RESTAURANT. That being said tho, cheap..."
Chris Wiggins
"Service awesome... food awesome as well and prompt.. owners are very much involved and are nice people to boot.. great highly..."
Ellen Ochsenbein
"Went for my besties birthday 🎂 Bartender was friendly and the drinks were..."
Amber John Lawson
"Food was great bartender very nice and..."
Daniel Hurley
"I always have a good time when I go to the..."
bluesman195545
"Nice stopping for our trip further north. Very good service, we had water. But several in our group had drinks, they said Beer is very cold...."
Randy Scott
"One waitress working and she did a great job. Food was hot and fresh. Prices are reasonable. I will definitely have lunch there more..."
Rod Bennett
"Great food big selection on drinks from beer to liquor good atmosphere fun time. The burgers or whatever the special is that day cause the owner can..."
"Just finished a slice of their white cake with fresh strawberry filling and, I believe, vanilla butter cream frosting. Oh, my. I shall name you..."
Becky Lawson
"I have never had anything but terrific experiences at Sullivan Bakery. The staff is always super friendly and helpful and the baked goods are top..."
Emily Rose Hinks
"We stopped in as part of our weekend at Lake Shelbyville and will be back the next time we are in the area. The owner and the manager and staff were..."
Deb Fritz Monroe
"I ordered a coconut cream pie and it was fantastic! The crust was very flavorful with a sweet coconut cream filling topped with lightly browned..."
Linda McCabe
"The donuts are good, but I also enjoy the friendly staff. The service is..."
Eric Crouse
"We are blessed to have such a great bakery in Sullivan, with owners who care about the community. My favorites here are: blueberry or maple square..."
Grant Wade
"A great and clean place, friendly staff, and the food was awesome!!! Loved my..."
Leah Blomberg
"Amazing!!!! My wife just had a baby a few days ago, and she got up 5:30 and HAD to go wait in line for some donuts. She got chocolate long johns,..."
Ian McDevitt
"I had sent a request in a week ago about a specific kind of pie to have as a gift. Today I Ordered it. I have to tell you how helpful and polite..."
Les Elder
"I was finally able to stop in and was lucky enough to try a cream horn...SO good! Can't wait to come..."
Jordan Stoune
"I love the goodies from the Sullivan Bakery!! The employees are so cheerful & pleasant. A visit there is an all around fun..."
Terry Suzy Edwards
"Delicious. The only thing I would recommend is a wider variety of coffee drinks and a place to sit outside and..."
Julie Click
"Delicious bakery goods and wonderful family. My grandsons love to..."
Jeffand Patty Marlow
"I believe all small towns need a bakery and Sullivan's is spectacular. Girl Scout cookie cupcakes live up to the hype! And me and my wife (both avid..."
Sequoia Cornell-conner
"Hands down the best donuts in the area since Dixie Creme! Go almost every weekend for some maple squares and..."
Calvin McCollom
"Whoever coined the phrase, "Money can't buy happiness," has obviously never shopped at Sullivan Bakery. Their donuts are the best ever. Not overly..."
Michael Loy
"Donuts are so amazing! Nice customer service...."
Amy Day
"Thee cutest doughnut shop ever🍩🍩🍩I bought a whole peach pie and a dozen doughnuts and it was all so yummy! Their coffees are really good..."
Leah Parks
"Fabulous doughnuts, and the best apple fritters..."
Joshua Clark
"Delicious! Fantastic place to grab donuts and treats for the office, or just to treat yourself :) I highly recommend the fried cinnamon rolls, but..."
"If you're tired of the same old fast food/delivery that most places in the area offer, Petty Pit Stop offers an eclectic mix of fusion food that is..."
Silas Armstrong
"I was lucky to be able to participate, in the beginning of Petty Pit Stop, a food tasting. Everything was delicious. Full of lots flavor that blend..."
Alicia Martinez Schwartz
"Great fresh food! My favorite is the Apple BBQ pork panini. I would highly..."
Lacy Knoepfle
"Excellent food! Their Chicago Style Italian Beef sandwich is wonderful and they have multiple gluten free options (I know you like that Stacy and..."
Steve Hollis
"I had the pleasure of tagging along with a friend to a tasting this evening. What a wonderful experience! I was very apprehensive about going, as I..."
Char Lene Thompson Mowery
"We had Texas meatloaf , garlic mashed tators, yummy asparagus. We meet in Sullivan, food was piping hot. Our entire family enjoyed the meal...."
Nita Weinke- Clem
"The food was amazing! We had chicken tikka masala and it was scrumptious! The portion sizes were perfect and we have plenty for lunch tomorrow! I..."
Amber Bowling
"I love this place! Fresh food for dinner that we love! My favorite is the Fairbanks hot chicken and Petty Pit Stop mac and..."
Amy Lambert
"All I can say is Yummo !!! We have eaten at some pretty unique and delicious places and this by far is at the top of the..."
Jody Brown
"Awesome food and service!!! I have to eat gluten free, and there are so many..."
Stacy 'Hammond' Hollis
"I had the Burrito Bowl today and it was fantastic, the atmosphere fun and the staff very friendly. I can't wait to go back and try something..."
Cindy Rotman
"Great food! They will work around diet restrictions and kids who are picky..."
Amanda Nicol
"Ordered lunch today and it soooo good! The loaded whipped cauliflower was delicious! Along with my panini! Also my kids loved the pizza quesadillas!!..."
Michelle Lynn Eslinger
"Delicious take out! We had the Italian beef, whipped cauliflower, and sesame chicken. Great fresh and fast alternative to fast..."
Sarah Shepler
"Fantastic little place! Most unique menu selection I’ve ever seen, my wife and i usually order 3 meals worth of food just to try different..."
The fish Addict
"Enjoyed the whole experience. Breakfast all day... nuff said. Berry Bacon Popper was on point with flavor profile. The atmosphere and staff were..."
Chelsea Perkins
"I'm a HUGE fan of Petty's. They are very accommodating to my dietary requirements. I'm gluten & dairy free, these ladies know how to make my meals..."
Kailee Cloutier
"Unbelievable food for a small town square restaurant. I'd recommend it to everyone who ever visits the area! The lobster nachos are to die for and..."
Cavin Ramsey
"Found the place on a wim and turned out to be pretty good. Nice young ladies were running. Decent variety and breakfast available all..."
Micheal Myers
"First of all, don’t let the menu scare you!! Yes, they have “non traditional” offerings but TRUST them!! They offer food for every lifestyle-..."
Amy Collins
"I haven't tried a lot on the menu, but their cactus chili soup is one of the best new things I have tasted in a long time. Perfect combo of hot and..."
Kallie Gambill
"Petty Pit Stop is a local gem! The menu is unique and incredibly well-executed. The staff provides good service.
If you're looking for something..."
"Love the atmosphere and the wonderful service each time you walk in! Great place to shop and sit and have wine with family and..."
Diane Foster Waggoner
"Absolutely love coming into 5 West, whether it is with my kids playing chess or in the evening enjoying a drink with my wife. Nothing more I can say..."
Kevin Cremeens
"5 West is a fantastic coffee shop. Not only does it have the best coffee around, but the owners are committed to providing a wonderful..."
Rikki McArthur Ray
"Relaxing atmosphere & wonderful owners, who always make sure you're enjoying your drink choice. And, speaking of drink choices..they are plentiful!..."
Jen Crouse
"Relaxing, comfortable enjoyable. Very nice seating outside in the back for lovely summer evenings to sip on a glass of wine or a..."
Linda Waite
"Had the caramel latte. Yummo! Can't wait to try some of their other drinks. Great to have an option of somewhere to get my espresso fix...."
Liz Warf
"Tea was great very flavorful. Clean place to relax. Would definitely go back. Nice..."
Carolyn Lacey
"Went and had an iced latte today and it was amazing! The atmosphere is wonderful, the service is great! Will definitely be back to enjoy a glass of..."
Ryan Hess
"Great espresso, wonderful friendly staff , felt right at home sipping on my drink and reading a book on their comfy couch. Will definitely be back..."
Spencer Taira
"Tres Picos Garnacha was an excellent suggestion at a good price! What an awesome little wine bar..."
Matthew Kracht
"Amazing Coffee, Wine and service! Way better than Starbucks! I'm craving the vanilla Carmel coffee right..."
Danielle Runyon
"Always love coming here for coffee and a visit with a..."
Angela Holliday Carnes
"Friendly staff and amazing coffee! So glad I stopped in!!..."
"Absolutely delicious food, great service, will go back as often as..."
Janelle Watts
"My daughter and I came from out of town and were hungry for Mexican food. We scoped the choices online and picked this restaurant. After eating we..."
Rebecca Lolley
"Employees were cool, Food was..."
Dawn Kruse
"Excellent taco salad!! And service! Glad we stopped on our..."
Sharon Guerber
"Great food at a fair..."
John Pisarsky (Vio1ent jay)
"Delicious Food & Great..."
Dixie Rose
"Fajitas were seasoned... Too many times I go to places and the meat isn't seasoned. Salsa is good. Chips are warm. Guacamole is fresh. Jumbo..."
Laura M
"Great food. Great company with my bestie. Food is great. Very clean. Will come back if in area..."
"Best place in town to eat oh, fair prices good drinks great..."
Terry Biggs
"Great place to have a drink and great people. Thank you for your..."
Dustin d. Anderson
"Best place in town to eat by..."
Liss McQ
"Never had a bad experience here. The food is great and so is the service. They actually have a garden where they grow all their own produce. Outdoor..."
Cade Grimm
"Really good food. One server on a Friday and she really did an amazing job. First experience...will definitely come..."
Tina Eades
"Food is fresh facility could use some lights so dark couldn't nearly read the..."
Mindy Porter
"Always a happy and friendly..."
Evelyn Lunsford
"Very nice facility. The food is always good. While all of their food is reasonably priced their daily specials are even better. Sometimes their..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes