The best Restaurants in Tilghman ranking of January 2025
9 restaurant menus in Tilghman, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"I came over by water for breakfast on a Sunday morning. I tied up and walked up. What a treat! I sat at the counter and had a wonderful conversation..."
Brian Sharman
"Small town feel with an open heart and amazing fresh food. Fig tree and herbs and vegetables growing out the window. Helpful staff who understand the..."
Craig “Food Monk” Carter
"Ending a romantic weekend on the eastern shore, my wife and I stopped at Two if by Sea in search of something to fill our stomachs for the long drive..."
Aaron Simpson
"Great brunch. The pancakes were fluffy and delicious. And the bacon was sooo crispy. Sat outside and devoured everything. Plus the server was the..."
Rachel L
"Lovely breakfast spot if you’re in the area! Tons of crab features. Fabulous service. They also have a dog friendly garden in the..."
Lucy Ruderman
"Great restaurant on Tilghman Island MD. Out of the way, but worth the drive. We recently attended a cooking session at the restaurant where the..."
William Lieberman
"What a find. This place is quaint. So old school. Comfy, inside and outside dining. Decor makes you smile and reminisce about when you were younger,..."
Darlene Weatherbee
"Fun authentically local restaurant. We had breakfast here two days in a row (not many other places around) and had good food each day. I really liked..."
david reichenthal
"One of the BEST breakfast spots on the island!
The Crabbie Eggs Benedict and the Ultimate Breakfast sandwich were the perfect start to our Tilghman..."
Ron Santram
"A Fantastic Find! Stopped in for late breakfast/brunch after a couple nights stay in Saint Michaels.
The menu is big so be prepared to make hard..."
Matthew Temba
"Kitschy place in a small town that has lots of charm. Amazing creations, perfectly seasoned dishes, ridiculously friendly staff who clearly enjoy..."
Sean Wilkerson
"Only been there for breakfast a couple times but not disappointed. Awesome food, great friendly service! Will keep coming..."
Sean Rogan
"Love this place! Whenever we have company visiting, we like to bring them to Two If by Sea for breakfast. The food is amazing, the staff is very..."
Joyce
"Very friendly service. Good portion size. The homefries are a must get. They even sell bottles of the potato..."
Rob Boucek
"Today was my 3rd visit to Two if by Sea and each visit is even better than the last! The Tilghman Cubano may be the best sandwich I’ve ever had...."
"While enjoying a sister’s weekend on the Eastern Shore we decided to stop at Marker 5 for lunch. It’s not an obvious find from the street, but my..."
Karla Trout
"Frickin great! Fun and friendly staff, my shrimp wrap was super, amazing fries, girlfriend loved the gazpacho and shrimp-avocado toast.
Everything I..."
Geoff McIntyre
"Absolutely amazing, fresh, made with love food! Great views! Exceptionally clean! This is my new favorite restaurant on the eastern shore. Will be..."
Vincent Knoepfel
"Marker 5 has the best wings in Talbot County, and a plethora of other very fine dishes. It is a family friendly location, and has a very nice..."
Strewn Valdez
"My new favorite restaurant on the shore! My folks live around the corner and I get to enjoy this awesome joint whenever I visit! So lucky! I highly..."
daniel morris
"It was relaxing! Sat by the water, ordered shaved ribeye with seasoned fries. I was with my daughter and grandkids. All the food was delicious!!! The..."
Sheri Rodriquez
"This is at Mrker 5 restaurant before crossing Tillman Island Bridge.
Great sunsets view outdoor dining
I would recommend everyone to go..."
Paki 007
"Wonderful service and courteous staff! The food is all scratch and fresh. The on site smoker and wood fire pizza oven constantly provide delicious..."
Amy Gunzelman
"Among our favorite places on eastern shore! Food is always really great with the freshest of fish imported directly from Whittmans. Great place for..."
John Oliver
"We dine here weekly and consider ourselves lucky! Talk about a farm to table experience, if you want to sample their most popular dishes, get there..."
Sandra McCulley
"We celebrated our anniversary here and it did not disappointment. They were out of a few items. I assume due to being out of tourism season. They had..."
Kelly-Marie Sullivan
"Love Marker5! The food is AMAZING! Everything is so fresh and delicious! Beautiful view, great food and amazing drinks! Awesome..."
Sophie Mikula
"Ate here on a Friday night in mid-May. Finally no more mask wear mandates! A bit of a wait for table, but they handled it well, used phone to text..."
Kitchen Boy
"My husband and I enjoyed a wonderful lunch of fish and chips l with their homemade tartar sauce....so good.
Everything here is freshly made...."
sereda aston
"Very nice Restaurant on Tillman Island's, the food is Delicious, I had a Cheeseburger. with fries with salt and pepper, with lettuce and tomatoes,..."
Derrick Davidson
"The wife and I went to Tilghman Island for the very first time yesterday afternoon, and decided to go to both of the restaurants by the drawbridge to..."
Chris Slavens
"PERFECTION in every way. The Colonel and I adore this crown jewel in Talbot County's wonderful restaurant venues! yes, the view is glorious but so..."
LEANDER STARR7
"Great food and service. Felt so welcoming and inviting. Will be..."
"We visited Knapps Narrows by boat for the weekend of 9/9 and dined at Characters. The food was delicious- I had Rockfish Tacos and they were..."
Will Robinson
"Such an awesome little place on the waterfront. We ate outside which I highly recommend doing. Loved seeing the the bridge open and close and the..."
Sarah Braxton
"The place was quite dirty (crusty juicers, dirty blenders with flies...) and it was pretty slow but I swear it was the best half and half soup I have..."
Lucy Nothing
"We were told that they just served pub food. Everything we ordered was delicious, well seasoned and cooked perfectly. Don't miss the long list of..."
R B
"While there is a limited selection of options my softshell crab sandwich was the best I have had. The other people in my party food was more..."
Trey Muller-Thym
"Got the prime rib sandwich. I thought it would be a small piece of meat on a bun but it was a large cut of meat with white bread hidden underneath...."
Bill Abbott
"Excellent meal and very pleasant service, will definitely return any time we're in the..."
Jason Saville
"Landed here after a day of fishing the Chesapeake, what a wonderful surprise! Food was great, they make a great grapefruit crush, and the staff was..."
Robin Frank
"Characters Bridge is your great Eastern Shore restaurant. There's the crabs, the tiki bar on the dock, the draw bridge, the great service and you can..."
Jess Berndt
"Quaint town and restaurant. Love sitting on the waterfront. Great food. Relaxing. Loved watching the busy..."
Shari Kain
"Excellent crab dip and maryland crab soup. The orange crushes were..."
Alexandra Walker
"Good food and service. We had ribs and rockfish recommend..."
Nina Mcquillan
"Delicious seafood fresh out of the Chesapeake Bay. Great location and outstanding service. The crab soup is awesome as well as the..."
phil marvel
"Awesome location and we loved our waiter. (Thanks, James!) The crab dip is excellent--in season--with big chunks of lump crab meat. I had fish tacos..."
"While enjoying a sister’s weekend on the Eastern Shore we decided to stop at Marker 5 for lunch. It’s not an obvious find from the street, but my..."
Karla Trout
"Frickin great! Fun and friendly staff, my shrimp wrap was super, amazing fries, girlfriend loved the gazpacho and shrimp-avocado toast.
Everything I..."
Geoff McIntyre
"Absolutely amazing, fresh, made with love food! Great views! Exceptionally clean! This is my new favorite restaurant on the eastern shore. Will be..."
Vincent Knoepfel
"Marker 5 has the best wings in Talbot County, and a plethora of other very fine dishes. It is a family friendly location, and has a very nice..."
Strewn Valdez
"My new favorite restaurant on the shore! My folks live around the corner and I get to enjoy this awesome joint whenever I visit! So lucky! I highly..."
daniel morris
"It was relaxing! Sat by the water, ordered shaved ribeye with seasoned fries. I was with my daughter and grandkids. All the food was delicious!!! The..."
Sheri Rodriquez
"This is at Mrker 5 restaurant before crossing Tillman Island Bridge.
Great sunsets view outdoor dining
I would recommend everyone to go..."
Paki 007
"Wonderful service and courteous staff! The food is all scratch and fresh. The on site smoker and wood fire pizza oven constantly provide delicious..."
Amy Gunzelman
"Among our favorite places on eastern shore! Food is always really great with the freshest of fish imported directly from Whittmans. Great place for..."
John Oliver
"We dine here weekly and consider ourselves lucky! Talk about a farm to table experience, if you want to sample their most popular dishes, get there..."
Sandra McCulley
"We celebrated our anniversary here and it did not disappointment. They were out of a few items. I assume due to being out of tourism season. They had..."
Kelly-Marie Sullivan
"Love Marker5! The food is AMAZING! Everything is so fresh and delicious! Beautiful view, great food and amazing drinks! Awesome..."
Sophie Mikula
"Ate here on a Friday night in mid-May. Finally no more mask wear mandates! A bit of a wait for table, but they handled it well, used phone to text..."
Kitchen Boy
"My husband and I enjoyed a wonderful lunch of fish and chips l with their homemade tartar sauce....so good.
Everything here is freshly made...."
sereda aston
"Very nice Restaurant on Tillman Island's, the food is Delicious, I had a Cheeseburger. with fries with salt and pepper, with lettuce and tomatoes,..."
Derrick Davidson
"The wife and I went to Tilghman Island for the very first time yesterday afternoon, and decided to go to both of the restaurants by the drawbridge to..."
Chris Slavens
"PERFECTION in every way. The Colonel and I adore this crown jewel in Talbot County's wonderful restaurant venues! yes, the view is glorious but so..."
LEANDER STARR7
"Great food and service. Felt so welcoming and inviting. Will be..."
"Absolutely the nicest people you'll ever meet.
We came in and were immediately greeted, the owner was so warm and gracious chatted with us as if she..."
Melissa Bozeman
"Awesome little store that back a lot of essentials (and not-so-essentials) under their roof. The made-to-order food was excellent (try the..."
Dan Schaffer
"Staying up the road, we happened upon this place while taking a stroll around the area. Aptly named country store, it has a little bit of everything..."
Kitchen Boy
"Great little Country store. Now have Scottish Highland Creamery Ice Cream. Yummy..."
Chris Murphy
"This is a little gem tucked away on Tilghman Island. Took a walk down here after dropping off my vehicle at another wonderful local establishment..."
Curtis Foy
"Stopped in to pick up a late lunch. What a step back in time to the small country town stores, wooden floors and all! Tasty burgers and oyster..."
Sheila Kintz
"This place is phenomenal. We had our wedding a short distance away from the store and our guests and family stopped there for food and supplies..."
Eboni Lance
"I love everything about this wonderful store. From the beautiful wine selections to the amazing food and deli items.
The Gibsontown Garden..."
Lori B
"This place is a true gem on Tilghman Island! They have everything you may need or perhaps forgot for your visit, along with a great menu for carry..."
Ian Smith
"Always have what you need. Recently started serving home cooked dinners which are fantastic. On top of the beer, wine, and liquor selection they..."
"Great drinks and food. Menu has nice variety and the clams were steamed to perfection. Oysters we’re also excellently shucked. Loved the burger..."
Rachel L
"Really cool spot with can’t miss views of the water. Service was great and they have a large menu filled with fresh seafood. We ordered a half..."
Dylan Denslow
"Wow! Food was as great as the view! No pic of the Key Lime Pie but you need..."
Geoff McIntyre
"Staying up the street and decided to check it out. Despite some of the roasting reviews below, this place was wonderful. Keith couldn’t have been a..."
Nick Beirne
"Had lunch there a few weeks ago. We ate outside which was really enjoyable. Outside on the water at picnic tables. We had steamers, clams and shrimp...."
Karebear
"This is the best crab shack on the Chesapeake bay. You can do all the steamed crabs and seafood you’d like, they have raw Oysters, and the entrees..."
Patrick Burgwinkle
"They def are working on updating the space but as always the food, drinks, and service were amazing, such a..."
Abby Haycraft
"Would recommend!! Ate here twice while staying in town for vacation and was pleased each time. We stopped in for drinks throughout the weekend too..."
Dave Kerwood
"Oyster pot pie was unforgettable! Great service, they went out of their way to accommodate us.
Oyster selection was great. Drinks and bartender..."
Paige Pape
"One word: YUMMY! and delicious. Sorry three words! Crab cakes were awesome - full of meat and remarkable flavoring! Crab dip and crab soup were just..."
Timothy Jackson
"We love this place for a boating destination. The crab deck is great and so much fun! Please support these folks. Good..."
Charles Fowler
"I have a lot of trouble finding restaurants that I feel safe eating at with celiac disease. I was glad to see a "we accommodate allergies" type..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes